European contract law

Last updated

European contract law represents a strategy working towards a common set of legal principles operating in the field of contract law across the European Union, with minimal differentiation between the national contract laws which apply within the member states. Contract law represents one of the areas of private law harmonisation being pursued and progressed by the European Commission, while the Principles of European Contract Law are a set of model rules drawn up by leading contract law academics in Europe, which attempt to elucidate the basic rules of contract law, and more generally the law of obligations, which most legal systems of the member states of the European Union hold in common. The Principles of European Contract Law (PECL) are based on the concept of a uniform European contract law system and were created by the self-styled Commission on European Contract Law set up by the late Ole Lando ("Lando Commission"). The PECL take into account the requirements of the European domestic trade.

Contents

History

In a broad sense the principles offer a "set of general rules ... designed to provide maximum flexibility and thus accommodate future development in legal thinking in the field of contract law". [1] The impetus for the work on the PECL were resolutions of the European Parliament of 26 May 1989 "on action to bring into line the private law of the Member States", [2] and 25 July 1994, [3] which expressed the desire to establish a common European civil law. As an initial foundation, a common contract law was to be first created.

Probably the first response was Harvey McGregor's 1993 "Contract Code", which was produced in response to a request from the English and Scots Law Commissions for proposals for the possible codification of a combined law of contract for England and Scotland. McGregor made this work available to the EU, who seemingly ignored it.

Instead, the Commission on European Contract Law (an organisation independent of any national obligations) started work in 1982 under the chairmanship of the late Ole Lando, a lawyer and professor from Denmark who died in April 2019. [4] The Commission consisted of 22 members from all member states of the European Union and was partly financed by the EU. The first part of the PECL was published in 1995; the second part has been available since 1999, and the third part was completed in 2002.

A symposium on "a European Civil Code" took place at The Hague in 1997, organised by the Dutch Ministry of Justice during the January-June 1997 Dutch presidency of the European Council. [5]

The European Commission published a "communication" concerning "a more coherent European Contract Law" on 15 March 2003. [6] The Commission's Action Plan set out within this communication proposed adopting "a mixture of regulatory and non-regulatory measures" to address the problems resulting from national diversity within the contract law field. [5] The Commission and the legal experts in this field have pointed out the extensive research which needs to be undertaken (and financed) to take this agenda forward. Schulze and Ebers, in a "joint response", see the agenda as having three stages:

Today, the work of the Commission on European Contract Law is continued by the Study Group on a European Civil Code. The Group is managed by Christian von Bar, a German law professor. The Group was founded in 2005.

Principles of European Contract Law

The Principles of European Contract Law (PECL) were inspired by the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) from 1980; however, they are a so-called soft law. Therefore, the PECL do not represent a legally enforceable regulation: "The term 'soft law' is a blanket term for all sorts of rules which are not enforced on behalf of the state, but are seen, for example, as goals to be achieved." [7]

Thus, the PECL are very similar to the Principles of International Commercial Contracts of UNIDROIT – International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (Unidroit Principles) which were already published in 1994. As is the case with the PECL, the Unidroit Principles are a "private codification" prepared by top-class jurists without any national or supranational order or authorisation. Their main goal of both the PECL and the Unidroit Principles was the compilation of uniform legal principles for reference, and, if necessary, the development of national legal systems.

In the compilation of the PECL, the law of the EU member states, and thus common and civil law, as well as non-European law were taken into consideration. In the PECL regulations are available which in this form have not been included so far in any legal system. The authors of the PECL also pursued the long-term goal of influencing the development of laws in Europe.

The PECL as common core of the European systems

In the formulation of the PECL the Lando Commission also used various European legal systems. In comparing these legal systems, there are often considerable differences with regard to certain regulations. [8]

To make available to the concerned parties a fair legal construct for their business dealings that do not prefer a party from a particular jurisdiction, the differing national law in question was, more or less, merged to form a common core.

This approach is intended to eliminate insecurity in international transactions. Each party can be assured not to have disadvantages due to unfavorable aspects of particular national law after the parties have agreed to the application of the Principles: "... the only way to a really unified market was and is that of having a common set of rules in order to overcome the traditional barriers of each national legal order having a distinct and disparate regulation on the subject." [9]

The disadvantageous effects of differing national laws on the behaviour of the market participants will thus be avoided, trade will be promoted, as will a legally uniform European market.

In this manner, the PECL succeed in bridging the gap between the civil law of the European continent and the common law of the Anglo-American system by offering regulations which were created to reconcile the divergent views of two systems. [10]

At the same time, the PECL provide assistance to judges in national courts and arbitrators in arbitration proceedings deciding cross-border issues. Should there not result any satisfactory solution from the national laws, "the Court [...] may adopt the solution provided by the Principles knowing that it represents the common core of the European systems." [11]

Written in a language known to all parties and using a uniform terminology, the PECL also serve as a "basis for any future European Code of Contracts", [12] consistent with the above-mentioned EU resolutions, which may eventually replace separate national laws.

The PECL as part of a European Lex Mercatoria

Often, parties to international sales contracts do not agree on a national law governing their contractual agreement. Instead, they sometimes agree on the validity of internationally approved legal principles, the so-called "general principles of law".

These law principles, the Lex mercatoria, on which a court can then make its decision to settle the disputes of the parties, are composed of the "laws of several systems, the work of the legal writers and the published arbitral awards", [13] [14] and thus the entirety of the international legal practices in a special field of law. Thus, the PECL are, like the Unidroit Principles or the CISG, also part of the Lex Mercatoria.

Whether Lex Mercatoria is subject to choice of law by the parties, is, however, actively disputed in international private law. This is also true for its legal nature per se. The PECL do not play a significant role in drafting of international sales contracts, or as a law governing such contracts. The possibility of including the PECL in such contracts – either expressly or by reference to "general trade principles" or similar – is indeed expressly mentioned in the PECL.

In practice, however, the PECL are rarely agreed upon as applicable law. Within the trade between the member states of the European Union, the PECL nevertheless have a certain influence, since they were precisely created for such trade. The PECL enable the court, should it make use of them, to reach a balanced decision. Further, it is possible that national legislative bodies will consult the PECL in connection with possible reforms to obtain a view of the current European consensus on contract law, without having to analyse the law of the individual states in detail.

The PECL were created, as was the case with the CISG and the Unidroit Principles, with the intention to be an example for existing and future national legal systems.

Regulations under these soft laws were integrated in the new laws of various Central European and East European states. For example, parts of regulations of the PECL became part of the German Civil Code (BGB) in the course of the reform of the law of obligations in 2002.

Influence on a European civil code

There is an ongoing legal dispute as to whether an independent European civil code beyond the existing substantial EU regulatory framework is needed. If it is determined that a European civil code is needed, the PECL provides important steps toward the establishment of such a code.

The Study Group on a European Civil Code (SGECC), based on the PECL and, respectively, the Lando-Commission, presented in 2009 a draft Common Frame of Reference (DCFR) in co-operation with other institutions. It is a draft for the codification of the whole European contract law and related fields of law.

Amongst its efforts regarding a coherent European legal framework, the European Commission published a green paper on European contract law policy options in July 2010, [15] where it put forward seven options for the further handling with the prepared Draft Common Frame of Reference up for discussion. [16] These options range from the fully non-binding presentation of the results as a "toolbox" and a "facultative European contract law instrument" up to an EU Directive or Regulation establishing a binding European civil code. [15] : 7–11  Although the European Commission affirms that the options would be put up for an open-ended discussion, it is already preparing concrete regulations for an optional instrument by an "Expert Group" and a "Stakeholder Sounding Board".

Actually, the solution of an optional European contract law seems to be favoured (so-called 28th regime, [17] alongside the 27 contract law systems of the member states) for which the users and companies within the European Union could use at their will (opt-in rule). This optional regulation would be offered as an alternative to the existing individual-state contract law systems of the member states in all official languages. It could optionally be used for transnational contracts only or also for domestic contractual relationships.

However, the concept of the prepared Draft Common Frame of Reference has met with strong criticism in the European member states. There are fears that a reliable application of law is not possible without a thorough revision of the draft. [18] Further developments remain to be seen.[ needs update ]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">English law</span>

English law is the common law legal system of England and Wales, comprising mainly criminal law and civil law, each branch having its own courts and procedures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Directive (European Union)</span> Legislative act of the European Union

A directive is a legal act of the European Union that requires member states to achieve particular goals without dictating how the member states achieve those goals. A directive's goals have to be made the goals of one or more new or changed national laws by the member states before this legislation applies to individuals residing in the member states. Directives normally leave member states with a certain amount of leeway as to the exact rules to be adopted. Directives can be adopted by means of a variety of legislative procedures depending on their subject matter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Civil code</span> Codification of the civil law

A civil code is a codification of private law relating to property, family, and obligations.

In law, codification is the process of collecting and restating the law of a jurisdiction in certain areas, usually by subject, forming a legal code, i.e. a codex (book) of law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Legal history</span> Study of how law has evolved and why it has changed

Legal history or the history of law is the study of how law has evolved and why it has changed. Legal history is closely connected to the development of civilisations and operates in the wider context of social history. Certain jurists and historians of legal process have seen legal history as the recording of the evolution of laws and the technical explanation of how these laws have evolved with the view of better understanding the origins of various legal concepts; some consider legal history a branch of intellectual history. Twentieth-century historians viewed legal history in a more contextualised manner – more in line with the thinking of social historians. They have looked at legal institutions as complex systems of rules, players and symbols and have seen these elements interact with society to change, adapt, resist or promote certain aspects of civil society. Such legal historians have tended to analyse case histories from the parameters of social-science inquiry, using statistical methods, analysing class distinctions among litigants, petitioners and other players in various legal processes. By analyzing case outcomes, transaction costs, and numbers of settled cases, they have begun an analysis of legal institutions, practices, procedures and briefs that gives a more complex picture of law and society than the study of jurisprudence, case law and civil codes can achieve.

Commercial law – body of law that governs business and commercial transactions. It is often considered to be a branch of civil law and deals with issues of both private law and public law. It is also called business law.

The Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, abbreviated BGB, is the civil code of Germany, codifying most generally-applicably private law. In development since 1881, it became effective on 1 January 1900, and was considered a massive and groundbreaking project.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Comitology</span> Process by which European Union law is modified or adjusted

Comitology in the European Union refers to a process by which EU law is implemented or adjusted by the European Commission working in conjunction with committees of national representatives from the EU member states, colloquially called "comitology committees". These are chaired by the European Commission. The official term for the process is committee procedure. Comitology committees are part of the EU's broader system of committees that assist in the making, adoption, and implementation of EU laws.

International trade law includes the appropriate rules and customs for handling trade between countries. However, it is also used in legal writings as trade between private sectors. This branch of law is now an independent field of study as most governments have become part of the world trade, as members of the World Trade Organization (WTO). Since the transaction between private sectors of different countries is an important part of the WTO activities, this latter branch of law is now part of the academic works and is under study in many universities across the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Civil law (legal system)</span> Legal system originating in Western Europe

Civil law is a legal system originating in Italy and France that has been adopted in large parts of the world. Modern civil law stems mainly from the Napoleonic Code of the early 19th century, and it is a continuation of ancient Roman law. Its core principles are codified into a referable system, which serves as the primary source of law.

<i>Contra proferentem</i> Doctrine of contractual interpretation

Contra proferentem, also known as "interpretation against the draftsman", is a doctrine of contractual interpretation providing that, where a promise, agreement or term is ambiguous, the preferred meaning should be the one that works against the interests of the party who provided the wording.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UNIDROIT</span> Intergovernmental legal organization

UNIDROIT is an intergovernmental organization whose objective is to harmonize private international law across countries through uniform rules, international conventions, and the production of model laws, sets of principles, guides and guidelines. Established in 1926 as part of the League of Nations, it was reestablished in 1940 following the League's dissolution through a multilateral agreement, the UNIDROIT Statute. As of 2023 UNIDROIT has 65 member states.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Law of France</span>

French law has a dual jurisdictional system comprising private law, also known as judicial law, and public law.

Lex mercatoria, often referred to as "the Law Merchant" in English, is the body of commercial law used by merchants throughout Europe during the medieval period. It evolved similar to English common law as a system of custom and best practice, which was enforced through a system of merchant courts along the main trade routes. It developed into an integrated body of law that was voluntarily produced, adjudicated and enforced on a voluntary basis, alleviating the friction stemming from the diverse backgrounds and local traditions of the participants. Due to the international background local state law was not always applicable and the merchant law provided a leveled framework to conduct transactions reducing the preliminary of a trusted second party. It emphasized contractual freedom and inalienability of property, while shunning legal technicalities and deciding cases ex aequo et bono. With lex mercatoria professional merchants revitalized the almost nonexistent commercial activities in Europe, which had plummeted after the fall of the Roman Empire.

European tort law, as a term, is not strictly defined and is used to describe a number of various features concerning tort law in Europe. The concept developed alongside other major historic developments of European integration.

The European civil code (ECC) is a proposed harmonisation of private law across the European Union.

International Commercial Law is a body of legal rules, conventions, treaties, domestic legislation and commercial customs or usages, that governs international commercial or business transactions. A transaction will qualify to be international if elements of more than one country are involved.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Contract</span> Legally binding document establishing rights and duties between parties

A contract is an agreement that specifies certain legally enforceable rights and obligations pertaining to two or more parties. A contract typically involves consent to transfer of goods, services, money, or promise to transfer any of those at a future date. The activities and intentions of the parties entering into a contract may be referred to as contracting. In the event of a breach of contract, the injured party may seek judicial remedies such as damages or equitable remedies such as specific performance or rescission. A binding agreement between actors in international law is known as a treaty.

The Principles of International Commercial Contracts 2016 is a set of 211 rules for international contracts. They have been drawn up since 1984 by an international working group of the inter-governmental organization UNIDROIT, and they were ratified by its Council representing 64 governments of member states.

References

  1. ↑ Ole, Lando; Hugh, Beale (2000). Principles of European Contract Law, Parts I and II, prepared by the Commission on European Contract Law. p. XXVII.
  2. ↑ EUR-Lex, RESOLUTION on action to bring into line the private law of the Member States, OJ C 158 of 26 June 1989, 400, voted 26 May 1989, accessed 10 January 2024
  3. ↑ OJ C 205 of 25 July 1994, 518
  4. ↑ Copenhagen Business School, In memory of Ole Lando, accessed 16 September 2023
  5. 1 2 3 Schultze, R. and Ebers, M., Joint Response to the Commission's Action Plan on European Contract Law (COM(2003) 68 final)
  6. ↑ EUR-Lex, Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council: A More Coherent European Contract Law - An Action Plan, 2003/C 63/01, published 15 March 2003, accessed 16 September 2023
  7. ↑ Smits, Jan (1998). "A European Private Law as a Mixed Legal System" (PDF). Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law. 5 (4): 328–340. doi:10.1177/1023263X9800500402. S2CID   145363652.
  8. ↑ Ole, Lando; Hugh, Beale (2000). Principles of European Contract Law, Parts I and II, prepared by the Commission on European Contract Law. p. XXIV.
  9. ↑ Castronovo, Carlo (1997). Contract and the Idea of Codification in The Principles of European Contract Law (in Festskrift til Ole Lando. pp. 109–124.
  10. ↑ Ole, Lando; Hugh, Beale (2000). Principles of European Contract Law, Parts I and II, prepared by the Commission on European Contract Law. p. XXIII.
  11. ↑ Ole, Lando; Hugh, Beale (2000). Principles of European Contract Law, Parts I and II, prepared by the Commission on European Contract Law. p. XXIV.
  12. ↑ Ole, Lando; Hugh, Beale (2000). Principles of European Contract Law, Parts I and II, prepared by the Commission on European Contract Law. p. XXIII.
  13. ↑ Lando, Ole. Some Features of the Law of Contract in the Third Millenium, ch. III 22 A.
  14. ↑ "Lists of literature". cbs.dk. Archived from the original on 19 November 2003. Retrieved 28 June 2011.
  15. 1 2 European Commission, "Green Paper from the Commission on policy options for progress towards a European Contract Law for consumers and businesses", COM(2010)348 final, published on 1 July 2010, accessed on 21 September 2024
  16. ↑ "Consumer contract law". europa.eu.
  17. ↑ Thomson Reuters Practical Law, "Legal FAQs: What is the 28th regime?", accessed 27 April 2024
  18. ↑ "Ein europäisches Vertragsrecht kommt – aber zu welchem Preis?" [A European contract law comes – but at what price?]. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (in German). 1 July 2010. Retrieved 1 September 2017.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.