Haji Bibi case

Last updated

Haji Bibi v. His Highness Sir Sultan Mohamed Shah, the Aga Khan, often referred to as the Haji Bibi Case, was a 1908 court case in the Bombay High Court heard by Justice Russell. The case was fundamentally a dispute over the inheritance of the estate of Hasan Ali Shah, a Persian nobleman with the title Aga Khan I and the hereditary leader (46th Imam) of the Nizari Ismailis. A number of the properties and other monetary assets had been passed down to Aqa Ali Shah, Aga Khan II and then to his grandson, Sir Sultan Muhammad Shah, Aga Khan III. [1] The plaintiffs included Haji Bibi who was a widowed granddaughter of Aga Khan I and a few other members of the family that all claimed rights to the wealth. [2] [3] The decision is notable as it confirmed the Aga Khan III's exclusive rights to the assets of his grandfather and to the continued religious offerings by his followers, including some Khojas, as the 48th Imam of the Nizaris. [4]

Contents

As part of the adjudication, the British judge extensively examined the religious identity of the Khoja community in India. The plaintiffs argued that the family was Ithnā‘ashari (Twelver), and under the corresponding Muhammadan customs of inheritance, they were obligated to shares. However, after considering the religious customs of the Khojas including the ginans, Justice Russell concluded that the community was Shia Imami Ismaili Muslims, now known as Nizari Ismailis. [1] Furthering the 1866 decision in the Aga Khan case, this tradition was differentiated from both Sunnis and Ithnā‘asharis. [5]

Historical background

Before the arrival of the British in the Indian subcontinent, the Khojas had a pluralistic character and used multilingual discourses to address their faith. The community had been converted by a number of Nizari Ismaili pirs and sayyids since the 11th century, of whom Pir Sadruddin and his son Pir Hasan Kabiruddin are often seen as the most influential and successful missionaries. [1] However, the collection of their teachings was referred to as satpanth , ‘the true path,’ and the group did not self-identify as Ismaili, Muslim, or even Hindu. Rather, traditions were adopted from all three, and the Khjoas expressed their beliefs in terms of concepts and formulations. For example, the satpanth tradition venerated `A True Guide` that lived in the West that could have been interpreted as either the Nizari Imams or the 10th incarnation of Vishnu. [6] [7] This unique set of beliefs not only baffled outsiders such as the British legislature, but it also led to internal confusion within the community. [5]

Since the Alamut period, the Nizari Imams had been settled within Persia. Although they often received religious offerings from their followers in the Indian subcontinent, there was little done to label the satpanth as Ismailis / Nizaris or unify the community under the Imam's authority. [8] Aga Khan I was similarly born in Persia, but due to conflict with the ruling Qajar government, was forced to flee in 1841. He eventually settled in Bombay in 1848 where he proceeded to assert his authority on all sorts of issues related to the large Khoja population, including controlling the communally owned property. [5] [9] While a number of the Khojas accepted the Aga Khan I as their new leader, a number of dissenters challenged his authority in what is now known as the Aga Khan case of 1866. The decision by Sir Joseph Arnould concluded that the Khoja were Shia Muslim and not Sunni, with the hereditary line leading to Aga Khan I as their rightful leaders. [5] [4]

It is also important to note that the Aga Khan I's move to India did not just involve one individual. Rather, the movement involved thousands of persons affiliated with his institution, including extended family, servants, scribes, and private military forces. [10] Upon moving, he used his property, allowances from the government of Rs 3000, and continued religious dues from the Khoja community to establish a presence in Bombay through a number of properties and care for his extended family. This would become one of the central issues in the Haji Bibi case. Did the Aga Khan care for his extended family out of his personal goodwill or out of some other obligation? [1]

Arguments and evidence

Justice Russell's decision in The Bombay Law Reporter notes that as many as 128 claims were brought up by the prosecution. Generally, these issues fell under 4 umbrellas. Below we analyze both the plaintiffs and defendants arguments:

1. Intention of religious offerings

2. Inheritance and religion of the Khojas

3. Release of the estate

4. Murder of Hassan Shah and Jungi Shah

One issue with the current primary source literature is that the Aga Khan III's defense is not fully available due to the public. Arguing that the testimony would lead to conflict within the community, the defense counsel asked for the judge to clear the court. Justice Russell permitted this request, and although the private evidence was used in the adjudication, it was expunged from all public records. [1]

  1. Justice Russell found that the religious offerings were made out of “deep vernation and reverence” for the Imam and were made for him to use as he saw fit.
  2. The Khoja followers of Aga Khan III were defined to be Shia Imami Ismailis, a group different from both the Sunnis and Ithnasharias.
  3. Justice Russell sides with the defense and argued that Sir Sultan Muhammad Shah had been generous to his extended family and did not commit fraudulent activity to claim the assets of the Aga Khan family.
  4. The judge found these accusations to have no foundation and concluded that they should have never been made. [1]

Impact

As a case generally around inheritance within the Aga Khan family, the decision by Justice Russell immediately concluded the rights of the Sir Sultan Muhammad Shah, Aga Khan III to the assets of family assets accrued by his grandfather and father. More broadly, the Haji Bibi case furthered defined the religious identity of the Khoja followers of the Aga Khan as Shia Imami Ismailis, distinct from both the Sunnis and Ithna’asharis. This label would become a primary marker of identity, and over time, many of the practices of the Khojas would change to remove some of the Hindu or Indic elements to better match the Muslim community. [5]

A response given by the Aga Khan during this case regarding the origin of his followers is significant. In addition to enumerating his followers in Iran, Russia, Afghanistan, Central Asia, Syria and other places, he also noted that “In Hindustan and Africa there are many Guptis who believe in me…I consider them Shi’i Imami Ismailis; by caste they are Hindus”. This serves as an important example where the Imam recognizes the Gupti community, who were practicing pious circumspection (taqiyya) at the time, as his Ismaili followers. [11]

During the Imamate of Aga Khan III, the Nizaris would grow in prominence and followers. The Imam would play a significant role in the independence movement from Britain as well as the formation of Pakistan.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aga Khan I</span> Politician

Hasan Ali Shah, known as Aga Khan I, was the 46th imam of the Nizari Isma'ilis. He served as the governor of Kirman and a prominent leader in Iran and later in the Indian subcontinent. He was the first Nizari imam to hold the title Aga Khan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aga Khan III</span> 48th imam of the Nizari Ismaili community

Sir Sultan Mahomed Shah, known as Aga Khan III, was the 48th imam of the Nizari Ism'aili branch of Shia Islam. He was one of the founders and the first permanent president of the All-India Muslim League (AIML). His goal was the advancement of Muslim agendas and the protection of Muslim rights in British India. The League, until the late 1930s, was not a large organisation but represented landed and commercial Muslim interests as well as advocating for British education during the British Raj. There were similarities in Aga Khan's views on education with those of other Muslim social reformers, but the scholar Shenila Khoja-Moolji argues that he also expressed a distinct interest in advancing women's education for women themselves. Aga Khan called on the British Raj to consider Muslims to be a separate nation within India, the famous 'Two Nation Theory'. Even after he resigned as president of the AIML in 1912, he still exerted a major influence on its policies and agendas. He was nominated to represent India at the League of Nations in 1932 and served as President of the League of Nations from 1937 to 1938.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Isma'ilism</span> Branch of Shia Islam

Isma'ilism is a branch or sect of Shia Islam. The Isma'ili get their name from their acceptance of Imam Isma'il ibn Jafar as the appointed spiritual successor (imām) to Ja'far al-Sadiq, wherein they differ from the Twelver Shia, who accept Musa al-Kadhim, the younger brother of Isma'il, as the true Imām.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aga Khan</span> Imām of the Nizari Ismāʿīli Shias

Aga Khan is a title held by the Imām of the Nizari Ismāʿīli Shias. Since 1957, the holder of the title has been the 49th Imām, Prince Shah Karim al-Husseini, Aga Khan IV. Aga Khan claims to be a direct descendant of Muhammad, the last prophet according to the religion of Islam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aga Khan IV</span> 49th Imam of the Ismaili (born 1936)

Shah Karim al-Husayni (Arabic: شاه كريم الحسيني, romanized: Shāh Karīm al-Ḥusaynī; born 13 December 1936; known as Aga Khan IV, is the 49th and current imam of Nizari Isma'ilis. He has held the position of Imam and the title of Aga Khan since 11 July, 1957, when, at the age of 20, he succeeded his grandfather, Aga Khan III. The Aga Khan claims direct lineal descent from the Islamic prophet Muhammad through Muhammad's cousin and son-in-law, Ali, who is considered an Imam by Nizari Isma'ilis, and Ali's wife Fatima, Muhammad's daughter from his first marriage. Aga Khan IV is also known by the religious title Mawlānā Hazar Imam by his Isma'ili followers.

The Nizaris are the largest segment of the Ismaili Muslims, who are the second-largest branch of Shia Islam after the Twelvers. Nizari teachings emphasize independent reasoning or ijtihad; pluralism—the acceptance of racial, ethnic, cultural and inter-religious differences; and social justice. Nizaris, along with Twelvers, adhere to the Jaʽfari school of jurisprudence. The Aga Khan, currently Aga Khan IV, is the spiritual leader and Imam of the Nizaris. The global seat of the Ismaili Imamate is in Lisbon, Portugal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jama'at Khana</span> Term used by some Muslim communities for a place of gathering

Jamatkhana or Jamat Khana is an amalgamation derived from the Arabic word jama‘a (gathering) and the Persian word khana. It is a term used by some Muslim communities around the world, particularly sufi ones, to a place of gathering. Among some communities of Muslims, the term is often used interchangeably with the Arabic word musallah. The Nizārī Ismā'īlī community uses the term Jama'at Khana to denote their places of worship.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Khoja</span> Nizari Ismaili Shia Islamic community in India

The Khoja are a mainly Nizari Isma'ili Shia community of people from the western Indian subcontinent. Khojas predominantly reside in India, Pakistan and eastern Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aga Khan II</span> Member of the Iranian royal family (1830–1885)

Aqa Ali Shah, known as Aga Khan II, was the 47th imam of the Nizari Isma'ili Muslims. A member of the Iranian royal family, he became the Imam in 1881. During his lifetime, he helped to better not only his own community, but also the larger Muslim community of India. He was the second Nizari Imam to hold the title Aga Khan.

Pir Sadar ad-Din (Sadardin) or Pir Sadruddin was a fourteenth-century Nizari Ismaili da'i and is regarded as the founder of the Khoja Nizari Ismaili community, also called Satpanth.

Ginans are devotional hymns or poems recited by Shia Ismaili Muslims.

Satpanth is a Sanskrit term used initially by Nizari Isma'ilis and Ismaili Sufis to identify their faith formed over 700 years ago by Pir Sadardin. Although the term is today used mainly by its subgroup formed in the 15th century by his grandson Pir Imam Shah which itself consists of various sub-sects, and differs from the mainstream Nizari Khojas in that they reject the Aga Khan as their leader and are known more commonly as Imamshahi. Uniquely, the term Satpanth has been historically used by Ismaili, as well as by adherents of subgroups. There are villages in Gujarat which are totally Satpanthi such as Pirana near Ahmedabad where Imam Shah is buried. Satpanthi dargahs are known to be venerated with a stark contrast in the devotees, with outward Muslims who may wear a hijab, and outward Hindus wearing traditional garb such as the sari.

The Nizari Isma'ilis around the globe are governed by one universal constitution known as "The World Constitution".

The History of Nizari Isma'ilism from the founding of Islam covers a period of over 1400 years. It begins with Muhammad's mission to restore to humanity the universality and knowledge of the oneness of the divine within the Abrahamic tradition, through the final message and what the Shia believe was the appointment of Ali as successor and guardian of that message with both the spiritual and temporal authority of Muhammad through the institution of the Imamate.

Shah Khalil Allah III was the 45th Imam of the Nizari Ismaili Shia Islam community. Khalilullah Ali III was born in 1740 in the city of Kirman. His upbringing in Mahallat began under the care of his uncle, Mirza Muhammad Bakir at the age of two years, and got rudiments of his formal education at home. In 1792, he succeeded his father Abū-l-Ḥasan ‘Alī ibn Qāsim ‘Alī, for whom he was his eldest son. He moved the seat of the Imamate from Kirman to Kahak, from where he led for 20 years. His name of Shah Khalil Allah was a Ni'matullāhī Sufi name, which reflected the close relationship between the Nizaris and Ni'matullāhīs. In 1815, Shāh Khalīlullāh moved to Yazd in order to be closer to his Indian followers.

The Imamate in Nizari Isma'ili doctrine is a concept in Nizari Isma'ilism which defines the political, religious and spiritual dimensions of authority concerning Islamic leadership over the nation of believers. The primary function of the Imamate is to establish an institution between an Imam who is present and living in the world and his following whereby each are granted rights and responsibilities.

Pir Wazir Ismail Gangji / Varas Ismail Gangji (1788-1883) was an Ismaili Pir, religious leader, Ismaili missionary and social worker from Junagadh, who is also noted for beautiful explanations of some often recited Ginans of Ismaili faith.

The Aga Khan Case was an 1866 court decision in the High Court of Bombay by Justice Sir Joseph Arnould that established the authority of the first Aga Khan, Hasan Ali Shah, as the head of the Khoja community of Bombay.

Women of the Ismaili sect are part of Shia Islam. Some subsects have women's rights issues, others observe a relatively progressive environment within their sects, which is also dependent on the laws in the countries practicing this sect.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Russell, Justice (1908). "Haji Bibi v. H.H. Sir Sultan Mohamed Shah, The Aga Khan". The Bombay Law Reporter via First Ismaili Electronic Library and Database.
  2. Mukherjee, Soumen (2017). Ismailism and Islam in Modern South Asia. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. p. 114. ISBN   978-1-107-15408-7.
  3. Kassam, Tazim R. (1995). Songs of wisdom and circles of dance : hymns of the Satpanth Ismāì̄lī Muslim saint, Pīr Shams. Albany: State University of New York Press. ISBN   0585045925. OCLC   44961093.
  4. 1 2 "Chapter two. Sectarian Showdown in the Aga Khan Case of 1866", The Aga Khan Case, Harvard University Press, 2012, pp. 35–56, doi:10.4159/harvard.9780674067707.c4, ISBN   9780674067707
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Ali S. Asani, ”From Satpanthi to Ismaili Muslim: The Articulation of Ismaili Khoja Identity in South Asia," in Modern History of the Ismailis, ed. Farhad Daftary (London, New York: IB Tauris in association with the Institute of Ismaili studies, 2010), 95-128.
  6. Asani, Ali S. (2009), "Satpanthi Ismaili Songs to Hazrat Ali and the Imams", Islam in South Asia in Practice, Princeton University Press, pp. 48–62, doi:10.2307/j.ctv301gh6.11, ISBN   9781400831388
  7. Renard, John, 1944- (2009). Tales of God's friends : Islamic hagiography in translation. University of California Press. ISBN   9780520253223. OCLC   262893247.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  8. Poor, Daryoush Mohammad (2014), "The Aga Khan: A Visionary Leader", Authority without Territory, Palgrave Macmillan US, pp. 107–167, doi:10.1057/9781137428806_4, ISBN   9781349491599
  9. Daniel Beben, "Introduction" in The First Aga Khan: Memoirs of the 46th Ismaili Imam, 1-60.
  10. Aga Khan III, 1877-1957. (2005). World enough and time : the memoirs of Sir Sultan Mohammed Shah Aga Khan III. Pakistan Herald Publications. ISBN   9698837116. OCLC   123540044.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  11. Virani, Shafique N. (February 2011). "Taqiyya and Identity in a South Asian Community". The Journal of Asian Studies. 70 (1): 99–139. doi:10.1017/S0021911810002974. ISSN   0021-9118. S2CID   143431047.