Hasanlu Lovers

Last updated

Hasanlu Lovers
Hasanlu Lovers.jpg
Born
Birth names unknown

Teppe Hasanlu – Iran
DiedAround 800 BCE
Teppe Hasanlu – Iran
Other names'Hasanlu Lovers'
Known forExcavated from the Hasanlu archaeological site by a team from Pennsylvania Museum led by Director Robert H. Dyson Jr in 1973
Notable workThe “lovers” were on display at the Penn Museum from the mid-1970s until the mid-1980s.

The Hasanlu Lovers are a pair of human remains found at the Teppe Hasanlu archaeological site, located in the Naqadeh in the West Azerbaijan Province of Iran. Around 800 BCE, the city of Hasanlu, located in north-western Iran, was destroyed by an unknown invader. Inhabitants were slain and left where they fell. In 1973, the lovers were discovered by a team of archaeologists from the University of Pennsylvania led by Robert H. Dyson. [1] [2]

Contents

The two human skeletons were found together in a bin during excavations, seemingly embracing at the time of death, [3] with no other objects except a stone slab under the head of one skeleton. They died together around 800 BCE, during the last destruction of the Hasanlu. [3] Approximately 246 skeletons were found at the site altogether. [4] How the lovers died and ended up in the bin is still under speculation but both skeletons lack evidence of injury near the time of death and possibly died of asphyxiation. [5] They were exhibited at the Penn Museum from 1974 until the mid-1980s. [6]

The right skeleton, referred to as HAS 73-5-799 (SK 335), is lying on its back and the left skeleton, referred to as HAS 73-5-800 (SK 336), is lying on its left side facing SK 335. [3] When excavated, the skeletons were tested to determine various characteristics. Dental evidence suggest SK 335 was a young adult, possibly 19–22 years of age. Researchers identified the skeleton as male largely based on the pelvis. The skeleton had no apparent evidence of disease or healed lifetime injuries. [1] [2] [3] Skeleton SK 336 appeared to have been healthy in life; the skeleton had no apparent evidence of healed lifetimes injuries, and was estimated to have been aged to about 30–35 years. [1] [2] [3] Sex determination of the left skeleton was less definitive. Evidence suggests SK 336 was also male [7] after being originally identified as female. [4] The skeletons have been a subject of debate since they were first excavated. [3] [5]

Archaeological record of Hasanlu

Map of Ancient Near East including Hasanlu MapofHasanlu2.jpg
Map of Ancient Near East including Hasanlu

Hasanlu is an ancient Near Eastern site located in the Qadar River valley, on the southern shore of Lake Urmia in northwest Iran. [8] [9] The city of Hasanlu was occupied consistently from the sixth millennium BCE to around 800 BCE, when the site was invaded and destroyed by fire. [9] In 1934–1936 Hasanlu was commercially dug by Sir Aurel Stein, a British archaeologist. [10] Then, in 1956, the Hasanlu Project was launched by the sponsorship of the University Museum of Pennsylvania, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the Archaeological Service of Iran. [9] Following the launch of the Hasanlu Project, a team of archaeologists from Penn Museum led by Director Robert H. Dyson excavated the site from 1957 to 1974. [10] This team completed nine excavation campaigns, and the excavation of the site ended more than 40 years ago (as of in 2022).

Excavation of the site revealed burnt remains of huge mudbrick walls, thick layers of ash, skeletons, vessels, and more. Excavation exposed extensive destruction – evidence of the city’s invasion and arson. Archaeologists explain that the nature of the destruction resulted in the city being frozen in time, preserving buildings, artefacts, and skeletal remains. [8] Approximately 246 skeletons, [4] of a variety of ages and genders were found. The bodies were left where they were killed in the streets and in buildings. Some victims were found in groups, with head lacerations, and dismembered limbs which suggested mass executions had taken place. [8] Among the 246 skeletons found, two of them were the remains of the Hasanlu Lovers.

Who attacked Hasanlu is still unknown; the general academic consensus is that the Iranian Empire were the invaders, but the Assyrian Empire was also very prominent in the region. There is no indication from the skeletons themselves or from the artefacts exactly who the invaders were. The city of Hasanlu itself is considered protohistoric: there was no writing around the site, unlike sites in neighboring regions. [7] Because of this, archaeologists do not know how the people of Hasanlu would have identified themselves, who they were, or the language they would have spoken.

Rediscovery and excavation

Archaeological Site of Hasanlu: Figure 23.2. (Adapted) Plan of Hasanlu with the Hasanlu Lovers indicated by an arrow. ArchaeologicalsiteofHasanlu.png
Archaeological Site of Hasanlu: Figure 23.2. (Adapted) Plan of Hasanlu with the Hasanlu Lovers indicated by an arrow.

The skeletal remains of the Hasanlu Lovers were found together in a plaster-lined brick bin with no other objects except a stone slab under the head of one skeleton. [3] [11] The excavation took place in 1973, directed by Robert H. Dyson, Jr. Dr. Selinsky stated that the lovers perished together during the invasion of the site, around 800 BCE, during the last destruction of the Hasanlu, [3] but did not have any lethal wounds. [3] Archaeologist Oscar Muscarella suggests that the hole in the right skeleton's skull is not due to an injury, but the result of a blow created by a workman's pickaxe. [5] When discovered, the two skeletons were facing and embracing each other. [3] The skeleton on the left is lying on their left side, reaching with their right hand towards the skeleton on the right.

There is no definitive explanation as to how the two skeletons ended up in the bin only assumptions. One assumption is that "they must have crawled into this bin, which was probably covered at the time, and escaped detection." [5] Since cause of death was not due to injury, archaeologists have concluded that the probable cause of death was asphyxiation, [5] when debris fell from the burning building, and sealed them in.

Scientific analysis

Anthropologists Page Selinsky and Janet Monge go into extensive detail about the DNA testing of the Hasanlu lovers and how the DNA testing [7] compares to the skeletal assessment of their biological sex.

The lovers were first sampled for specific isotopes to see if there were any differences in the skeletal series and the diets that they consumed. What the isotopic testing revealed was that the diets of the individuals were quite varied, but they were not patterned in any particular way. Isotopic signatures indicate that the diets of the residents of Hasanlu were varied, including wheat, barley, sheep and goats. [12] Isotopic signatures coming from oxygen revealed the lovers' settlement patterns; these oxygen isotopic signatures revealed that the lovers, and the other Hasanlu people, were all born and raised in the Hasanlu area. [7]

It was concluded by Selinsky and Monge that both individuals were male. [3] [7] They came to this conclusion when comparing both the DNA analysis and skeletal assessment. Dr Selinsky stated that the pelvis was the single best criterion for estimating the sex of the skeletons as there are distinctive features between a female and a male pelvis. [7]

The skeleton on the right (referred to as SK 335) is lying on its back. The front portion of his pelvis was lost but when examining his sciatic notch, it was evident he was a male due to the very narrow gap which is a distinctive feature of the male pelvis. [7] As such, researchers identified the skeleton as male largely based on the pelvis. The skeleton had no apparent evidence of disease or healed lifetime injuries. [1] [2] [3]

For the left skeleton (SK 336), lying on its left side facing SK 335, the sex estimation was less clear, but overall research suggests a male: the cranium is distinctively male, while the pelvis is more mixed in its morphology. [3] At the time of excavation, this skeleton was originally identified as female. [5] This was because his sciatic notch was quite wide, a characteristic of a female pelvis, but the front portion of his pelvis which was retrieved from the site, had an acute angle in the front and was less pulled out than a female’s, which suggested the skeleton was a male. [7] The individual appeared to have been healthy in life, and the skeleton had no apparent evidence of healed lifetime injuries. [1] [2] [3] The sex of the lovers was confirmed from a bone sample for an ancient DNA analysis. The genetic determination of the Hasanlu lovers was male. [7]

The age of the two skeletons was also determined. Dental evidence suggests that the right skeleton was a young adult or subadult, estimated to be aged 19–22 years old, [3] as he has third molars, and his wisdom teeth recently grew. His skull was less developed, which was attributable to the young age of the individual. [7] The left skeleton was estimated to be an older adult 30–35 years old; his skull had fully developed, and the cranium was distinctively male. [3]

Controversy

Some researchers argue sensationalism about the Hasanlu Lovers, and other potential examples of non-heteronormative behaviours in the past are problematic. [13] [14] The two skeletons received their sobriquet 'Hasanlu Lovers' due to the intimate position they were found in. Before the skeletons were subjected to DNA analysis one skeleton was thought to be male and the other female. Muscarella, an archaeologist who was heavily invested in the discoveries made at Hasanlu, states, "I knew at first sight who was the female," [15] in reference to the two skeletons. However, the team from the University of Pennsylvania, assessed that the right skeleton was likely male due to its morphology. The left skeleton had less clear osteological indicators, but was later identified to be male through DNA analysis. [3] Limitations of osteological sex assessments as noted by one author is that there are many times when the biological sex can not be certain, and that these tests do not reveal anything about the culturally-constructed gender. [14]

Reasons for expecting the skeletons to be a heteronormative couple, as Killgrove and Geller explain, are because modern society is primed by culture to see this representation. [14] [16] Geller states that projecting contemporary assumptions about sex, gender, and sexuality onto the past can be problematic, [16] and that the true relationship between the two skeletons is unknown and remains up to speculation, despite the implications that may be drawn from their apparently intimate pose.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red Lady of Paviland</span> 33,000-year-old human remains in Swansea, Wales

The Red "Lady" of Paviland is an Upper Paleolithic partial male skeleton dyed in red ochre and buried in Wales 33,000 BP. The bones were discovered in 1823 by William Buckland in an archaeological dig at Goat's Hole Cave which is a limestone cave between Port Eynon and Rhossili on the Gower Peninsula, near Swansea in south Wales. Buckland believed the skeleton was a Roman era female. Later, William Solace examined Goat's Cave Paviland in 1912. There, Solace found flint arrow heads and tools and correctly concluded that the skeleton was in fact a male hunter-gatherer or warrior during the last Ice Age.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Puabi</span> Queen of Ur

Puabi, also called Shubad or Shudi-Ad due to a misinterpretation by Sir Charles Leonard Woolley, was an important woman in the Sumerian city of Ur, during the First Dynasty of Ur. Commonly labeled as a "queen", her status is somewhat in dispute, although several cylinder seals in her tomb, labeled grave PG 800 at the Royal Cemetery at Ur, identify her by the title "nin" or "eresh", a Sumerian word denoting a queen or a priestess. Puabi's seal does not place her in relation to any king or husband, possibly indicating that she ruled in her own right. It has been suggested that she was the second wife of king Meskalamdug. Although little is known about Puabi's life, the discovery of Puabi's tomb and its death pit reveals important information as well as raises questions about Mesopotamian society and culture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forensic anthropology</span> Application of the science of anthropology in a legal setting

Forensic anthropology is the application of the anatomical science of anthropology and its various subfields, including forensic archaeology and forensic taphonomy, in a legal setting. A forensic anthropologist can assist in the identification of deceased individuals whose remains are decomposed, burned, mutilated or otherwise unrecognizable, as might happen in a plane crash. Forensic anthropologists are also instrumental in the investigation and documentation of genocide and mass graves. Along with forensic pathologists, forensic dentists, and homicide investigators, forensic anthropologists commonly testify in court as expert witnesses. Using physical markers present on a skeleton, a forensic anthropologist can potentially determine a person's age, sex, stature, and race. In addition to identifying physical characteristics of the individual, forensic anthropologists can use skeletal abnormalities to potentially determine cause of death, past trauma such as broken bones or medical procedures, as well as diseases such as bone cancer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rakhigarhi</span> Archaeological site in Haryana, India

Rakhigarhi or Rakhi Garhi is a village and an archaeological site belonging to the Indus Valley civilisation in the Hisar District of the northern Indian state of Haryana, situated about 150 km northwest of Delhi. It was part of the mature phase of the Indus Valley Civilisation, dating to 2600-1900 BCE. It was among the largest settlements of the ancient civilisation, though most of it remains unexcavated. The site is located in the Ghaggar River plain, some 27 km from the seasonal Ghaggar river. Initial excavations at the site happened in the 1960s, followed by further excavations in the late 1990s, however more sustained excavations have taken place in the past decade.

The term bioarchaeology has been attributed to British archaeologist Grahame Clark who, in 1972, defined it as the study of animal and human bones from archaeological sites. Redefined in 1977 by Jane Buikstra, bioarchaeology in the United States now refers to the scientific study of human remains from archaeological sites, a discipline known in other countries as osteoarchaeology, osteology or palaeo-osteology. Compared to bioarchaeology, osteoarchaeology is the scientific study that solely focus on the human skeleton. The human skeleton is used to tell us about health, lifestyle, diet, mortality and physique of the past. Furthermore, palaeo-osteology is simple the study of ancient bones.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teppe Hasanlu</span>

Teppe Hasanlu or Hasanlu Tepe is an archeological site of an ancient city located in northwest Iran, a short distance south of Lake Urmia. The nature of its destruction at the end of the 9th century BC essentially froze one layer of the city in time, providing researchers with extremely well preserved buildings, artifacts, and skeletal remains from the victims and enemy combatants of the attack. The site was likely associated with the Mannaeans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ziwiye hoard</span> Treasure hoard discovered in Ziwiyeh, Iran

The Ziwiye hoard is a treasure hoard containing gold, silver, and ivory objects, also including a few gold pieces with the shape of human face, that was uncovered on in Ziwiyeh plat near Saqqez city in Kurdistan Province, Iran, in 1947.

The Robert J. Terry Anatomical Skeletal Collection is a collection of some 1,728 human skeletons held by the Department of Anthropology of the National Museum of Natural History of the Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C., United States. The skeletons have been widely used in research for anthropology and forensic science.

The Jiroft culture, also known as the Intercultural style or the Halilrud style, is an early Bronze Age archaeological culture, located in the territory of present-day Sistan and Baluchestan and Kermān Provinces of Iran.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arslan Tash</span> Archaeological site in northern Syria

Arslan Tash, ancient Hadātu, is an archaeological site in Aleppo Governorate in northern Syria, around 30 kilometres (19 mi) east of Carchemish and the Euphrates and nearby the town of Kobanî.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lovers of Valdaro</span> Pair of human skeletons found near Mantua, Italy, in 2007

The Lovers of Valdaro, or Valdaro Lovers, are a pair of human skeletons dated as approximately 6,000 years old. They were discovered by archaeologists at a Neolithic tomb in San Giorgio near Mantua, Italy, in 2007. The two individuals were buried face to face with their arms around each other, in a position reminiscent of a "lovers' embrace".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Skeletonization</span> Remains of an organism after soft tissues have broken down after death

Skeletonization is the state of a dead organism after undergoing decomposition. Skeletonization refers to the final stage of decomposition, during which the last vestiges of the soft tissues of a corpse or carcass have decayed or dried to the point that the skeleton is exposed. By the end of the skeletonization process, all soft tissue will have been eliminated, leaving only disarticulated bones.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oscar White Muscarella</span> American archaeologist (1931–2022)

Oscar White Muscarella was an American archaeologist and former Senior Research Fellow at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where he worked for over 40 years before retiring in 2009. He specialized in the art and archaeology of the Ancient Near East, in particular Ancient Persia and Anatolia. Muscarella was an untiring opponent of the Looting of ancient sites and earned a reputation as the conscience of the discipline. He received his Ph.D. from the University of Pennsylvania in 1965.

Hajji Firuz Tepe is an archaeological site located in West Azarbaijan Province in north-western Iran and lies in the north-western part of the Zagros Mountains. The site was excavated between 1958 and 1968 by archaeologists from the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology. The excavations revealed a Neolithic village that was occupied in the second half of the sixth millennium BC where some of the oldest archaeological evidence of grape-based wine was discovered in the form of organic residue in a pottery jar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gordion</span> Capital city of ancient Phrygia

Gordion was the capital city of ancient Phrygia. It was located at the site of modern Yassıhüyük, about 70–80 km (43–50 mi) southwest of Ankara, in the immediate vicinity of Polatlı district. Gordion's location at the confluence of the Sakarya and Porsuk rivers gave it a strategic location with control over fertile land. Gordion lies where the ancient road between Lydia and Assyria/Babylonia crossed the Sangarius river. Occupation at the site is attested from the Early Bronze Age continuously until the 4th century CE and again in the 13th and 14th centuries CE. The Citadel Mound at Gordion is approximately 13.5 hectares in size, and at its height habitation extended beyond this in an area approximately 100 hectares in size. Gordion is the type site of Phrygian civilization, and its well-preserved destruction level of c. 800 BCE is a chronological linchpin in the region. The long tradition of tumuli at the site is an important record of elite monumentality and burial practice during the Iron Age.

Robert H. Dyson, Jr. was an American archaeologist who served as director of the Penn Museum (1982–1994). He was best known for directing excavations at Teppe Hasanlu between 1956 and 1977.

Mary Virginia Harris (1911-2004) was an American veteran of World War II who served in the Women Accepted for Volunteer Emergency Service (WAVES), which the U.S. Navy created as a program for women following the attack on Pearl Harbor. Harris wrote the manual for WAVES, called Guide Right (1944). Later in her career, she managed materials and records from the University of Pennsylvania’s excavations at the archaeological site of Hasanlu Tepe, in Iran.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dalma culture</span> Prehistoric archaeological culture of north-western Iran

Dalma culture was a prehistoric archaeological culture of north-western Iran dating to early fifth millennium B.C. Later, it spread into the central Zagros region and elsewhere in adjacent areas. Its widespread ceramic remains were excavated in central and northern valleys of the Zagros Mountains in north-western Iran. Dalma assemblages were initially discovered by the excavations carried out at Dalma Tepe and Hasanlu Tepe in south-western parts of Lake Urmia, in the valley of Solduz.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Near Eastern bioarchaeology</span> Archaeological sub-discipline

Near Eastern bioarchaeology covers the study of human skeletal remains from archaeological sites in Cyprus, Egypt, Levantine coast, Jordan, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, Oman, and Yemen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dalma Tepe</span>

Dalma Tepe is an archaeological site about 2km northeast of Naqadeh, Naqadeh County, in the Iranian province of West Azerbaijan. It is the type site of Dalma culture, a prehistoric culture of north-western Iran from the fifth millennium B.C.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Dandamaev, M. A. (1989). The Culture and Social Institutions of Ancient Iran. Cambridge; New York City: Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0521321075.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Dyson, Jr., Robert H. (1973). "Survey of Excavations in Iran 1971–72". Iran: Journal of the British Institute of Persian Studies . 11: 195. doi:10.2307/4300498. JSTOR   4300498.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 "The Lovers – Hasanlu". Penn Museum . Retrieved 31 October 2017.
  4. 1 2 3 Muscarella, Oscar W. "Warfare at Hasanlu in the Late 9th Century B.C." Expedition Magazine 31.23 (1989): Expedition Magazine. Penn Museum, 1989 Web. 31 Jul 2020 http://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/?p=2478
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Muscarella, Oscar White (2013). Koehl, Robert B. (ed.). Amilla: The Quest for Excellence. Studies Presented to Guenter Kopcke in Celebration of His 75th Birthday. Vol. 43. INSTAP Academic Press (Institute for Aegean Prehistory). doi:10.2307/j.ctt5vj90s.30. ISBN   978-1623033132. JSTOR   j.ctt5vj90s.
  6. "Gazette: Changing Times: 1961–1981 (July/August 2002)". www.upenn.edu. Archived from the original on 7 August 2002. Retrieved 3 August 2020.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Expedition – "Hasanlu Lovers" , retrieved 11 May 2022
  8. 1 2 3 "Expedition Magazine – Penn Museum". www.penn.museum. Retrieved 11 May 2022.
  9. 1 2 3 Tedesco, Laura Anne. "Hasanlu in the Iron Age". metmuseum.
  10. 1 2 Muscarella, Oscar White (2006). "The Excavation of Hasanlu: An Archaeological Evaluation". Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research. 342 (342): 69–94. doi:10.1086/BASOR25066953. ISSN   0003-097X. JSTOR   25066953. S2CID   163988676.
  11. Ellsworth, Amy. "Penn Museum Blog". Penn Museum. p. 20. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
  12. Toebbe, Diana Smay (2005). Measurement of inclusion biases in archaeological skeletal collections: A case study of Hasanlu. ISBN   978-0542154126.
  13. Snoddy, Anne Marie E.; Beaumont, Julia; Buckley, Hallie R.; Colombo, Antony; Halcrow, Siân E.; Kinaston, Rebecca L.; Vlok, Melandri (1 March 2020). "Sensationalism and speaking to the public: Scientific rigour and interdisciplinary collaborations in palaeopathology". International Journal of Paleopathology. 28: 88–91. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpp.2020.01.003 . hdl: 10454/17640 . ISSN   1879-9817. PMID   32028057.
  14. 1 2 3 Killgrove, Kristina (8 April 2017). "Is That Skeleton Gay? The Problem With Projecting Modern Ideas Onto The Past". Forbes. Retrieved 31 July 2020.
  15. Muscarella, Oscar White (2013). The Hasanlu Lovers. Institute for Aegean Prehistory Press. pp. 345–350.
  16. 1 2 Geller, Pamela L. (2017). The Bioarchaeology of Socio-Sexual Lives. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-40995-5. ISBN   978-3319409931.

Further reading