Hoarding (economics)

Last updated
1894 Poster articulating an aspect of hoarding. Coin's Financial School - Hoarding Gold.png
1894 Poster articulating an aspect of hoarding.

Hoarding in economics refers to the concept of purchasing and storing a large amount of product belonging to a particular market, creating scarcity of that product, and ultimately driving the price of that product up. Commonly hoarded products include assets such as money, gold and public securities, [1] as well as vital goods such as fuel and medicine. [2] Consumers are primarily hoarding resources so that they can maintain their current consumption rate in the event of a shortage (real or perceived). [3] Hoarding resources can prevent or slow products or commodities from traveling through the economy. [4] Subsequently, this may cause the product or commodity to become scarce, causing the value of the resource to rise.

Contents

A common intention of economic hoarding is to generate a profit by selling the product once the price has increased. Hence, economic speculators tend to hoard products that are inelastic in price so that when the price of the product does increase, the demand for that product is maintained. [5] [2] Unlike investing, hoarded goods are excluded from an economy’s flow of money [6] and generally occurs in markets operating under a non-competitive structure. [7] The practice of hoarding can have varied effects in the economy and is legal in most cases, however price controls and other regulatory laws are often enforced to prevent negative market implications. [8] Under Islamic jurisprudence, intentional acts of economic hoarding are regarded as a highly sinful and unlawful. [2]

Artificial scarcity

The term "hoarding" may include the practice of obtaining and holding resources to create artificial scarcity, thus reducing the supply, thereby increasing the price, so that resource can be sold for profit. Artificial scarcity may also be used to help corner a market, by reducing competition via the creation of a barrier to entry. This reduction in competition could allow a monopoly or oligopoly to form. [9]

Hoarding versus investing

Investing refers to the act of temporarily allocating funds in an entity such as stocks, property, and other financial schemes with the intention of generating a profit as the value of the investment appreciates over time. [6] Unlike investing, which commonly involves providing corporations with money to be spent on manufacturing goods and services, hoarded stockpiles are not active in the economy. Economist Mathias Binswanger [10] classifies economic hoarding as the resources that are withdrawn from and not reinjected into the circular flow of money, being all the money flows that are connected to active events occurring in the economy. Hoarding and investing can be made distinguishable by the notion that investing produces resources of value within the economy, whereas hoarding suspends resources of value from being active in the economy. Economist Seyed Sadr differentiates between the speculative intentions of hoarding and general intentions of investing using the following criteria:

“If the market share price of a unit of investment in a project is higher than the production and marketing cost of that unit, the share should be offered for sale. If it is held off the market to create artificial scarcity of the shares, the behaviour is speculative in nature.” [2]

Environments that allow for hoarding

For the act of hoarding to occur, certain conditions must be met to allow speculators to successfully manipulate of the price of goods. The main condition granting the ability for speculators to manipulate prices is that the goods being hoarded belong to a non-competitive market. A non-competitive market occurs when the agents acting in the marketplace of question are limited, have little or weak competition, and are not controlled entirely by market forces, unlike markets which operate under perfect competition. [11] [7] Resultantly, agents acting in these imperfect markets have amplified power and a greater ability to influence the price of a product both directly and indirectly. In the situation where an external force disrupts the supply chain involved in producing a product, there may be shortages causing demand to increase and the market price of the product to increase correspondingly. [12] A non-competitive market condition may provide agents with the opportunity to exploit situations where shortages may be occurring by imposing restrictions on the quantity of product in shortage that enters the market, maintaining high demand and increased prices. [2] Conversely, in competitive markets, market prices tend to adjust in response to the authentic abundancy or scarcity of a good. Agents attempting to curtail a product in such competitive market conditions will most likely not succeed at driving up prices, as competing firms will inevitably supply the product to the marketplace to earn profit. [13]

Fear-based hoarding

Hoarding behavior is a common response to fear, whether fear of imminent societal collapse or a simple fear of a shortage of some good. Civil unrest or natural disasters may lead people to collect foodstuffs, water, gasoline, generators, and other essentials which they believe, rightly or wrongly, may soon be in short supply. There is often an implication that hoarding occurs because individuals do not believe that the market will operate efficiently in current or expected conditions.

Market implications of hoarding

Hoarding can theoretically provoke the arising of a non-consumption economy, as the products being hoarded by speculators are not available or too expensive for potential consumers to benefit from. [14] [15] If the producer or industry that manufactures a product has a low long-term responsiveness to changes in demand, economic hoarding is likely to cause demand to sharply increase, as producers are unable to produce enough units of said product to recover it from a state of scarcity due to its low elasticity of supply. As demand for the product increases, the products value increases, often resulting in accelerated inflation. [3] [16] Resultantly, economic hoarding is often considered to be detrimental as it can isolate commodities from the economy.

Due to the complexity of the economy and the flows of resources occurring within it, critics argue that the effect economic hoarding has on the economy is abstracted and the results of economic hoarding can be highly varied. In some instances, where the profit generated from the act of hoarding is reinjected into the economy, the economy may benefit from economic growth that the act of economic hoarding has provided. Conversely, economic hoarding may compromise the initiative to invest in active agents in the economy, especially when the hoarded asset promises higher returns, resulting in reduced economic growth. [10]

Similarly, hoarding money in savings can theoretically both benefit and disadvantage the economy. While there is low risk of currency oversupply and accelerated inflation when hoarding money, financial hoarding may distort the value of assets and commodities and intensify the risk of losing money in investments or business ventures, as less money circulates through active economic instruments such listed companies. [17]

Government regulation

Poster promoting the idea that price controls maintain affordability in times of scarcity. Domestic Price Control - NARA - 195924.jpg
Poster promoting the idea that price controls maintain affordability in times of scarcity.

Not all hoarding is illegal; legal prohibitions often target behavior that could destabilize a market. A common procedure used to prevent speculators intending to hoard commodities is implementing price controls, in which limitations on the price that can be charged for a good or service is enforced. [8] Price controls intend to maintain the affordability of a product even in times of scarcity, limiting the extent to which a products price can increase, hence constraining the potential profit generated from economic hoarding acts. [18] Governments may also create agencies to monitor entities for hoarding behaviours, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission in the U.S., responsible for identifying and tracking potential speculators storing excessive commodities with intentions of manipulating a marketplace. [19]

However, it is often difficult for regulators to distinguish when an act of hoarding is provoked by the intention to manipulate prices or by fearfulness of future events. Additionally, in some instances government intervention may lead to further instability in the market. The price limit set for products in price control roll outs are often lower than the predominant market price, which may result in suppliers being unwilling to sell their products. The subsequent decrease in supply will tend to an increase in demand, which can lead to the formation of underground markets where the product is illegally sold for a higher price. [20] [2]

Price gouging is typically illegal, often defined by raising the prices of necessary goods after the declaration of a state of emergency.

Prohibition of hoarding in Islamic jurisprudence

The practice of economic hoarding and price gouging is prohibited in Islam, a major world religion whose followers practice the principles laid out in the Quran, Islam’s central religious text. [21] There are multiple Islamic hadiths, being the recorded traditions of the prophet Muhammed, [22] deeming practices of hoarding and profit maximisation as an exploitation of society in times of need. [23] Such verses command followers of Islam to spend their money in a way in which pleases Allah, directing for followers to allow their money and assets to circulate through the economy. For example, in one verse farmers are directed to market their produce for sale and purchase their supplies every day at the market, intending to protect farmers from the temptation to hoard their produce. [2] The practice of hoarding, denoted as ‘Kanz’, which roughly translates to ‘the unproductive hoarding of wealth’ [24] [2] was prohibited in the Quran ensuing an event where businessmen hoarded gold and silver coins, which were the main medium of exchange in Arabia during the rise of Islam. This hoarding instance inhibited the flow of money throughout the economy, depreciating the value of tradable goods and assets at the time. [2] The prohibition of economic hoarding, or ‘Kanz’, rules against speculators withholding assets from the market with intentions of reselling the good at a higher price. Additionally, circulating false information about price and/or demand changes of a good is also prohibited in Islam, as it is considered to be a sinful act of deception. [2] [25] Conversely, expenditure of money toward value-creating activities, such as seen in practices such as investing are praised in Islam. [26]

Classifying Hoarding Practices in Islamic Jurisprudence

Seyed Kazem Sadr, a professor of Islamic finance, [27] highlights the different levels of extremity regarding hoarding practices in his book “Handbook of Ethics of Islamic Economics and Finance”. [25] Sadr defines such levels in phases. In the first phase, the act of hoarding is non-speculative, rather the agent hoarding the good has no intentions to affect the price nor supply of the good being stockpiled and are simply collecting such goods to maintain their livelihood. In the second phase, agents stockpile products that are easily accessible and abundant in the market. Although the good is not being stored for immediate use, if the good is easily accessible such stockpiling activities will not negatively impact the price nor supply of the good and therefore is viewed as saving rather than hoarding in Islamic jurisprudence. [28] In the third phase, the practice of hoarding causes the price of a good to increase, although is still available in the market. With intentions to create shortages and influence prices, the third phase of hoarding is considered unethical under Islamic jurisprudence as consumers may be burdened by having to pay for products at a greater price and possibly having to go to greater efforts to source products they may need. In these cases, the government has the authority to seize and auction off the hoarded goods to consumers. [29] [2] In the fourth and final phase, the practice of hoarding is deemed to be extremely harmful as the goods being hoarded become scarce and inaccessible, causing extensive adverse effects on the stability of the economy. With consumers struggling to obtain the goods required to maintain their livelihoods, society becomes vulnerable to collapse, hence such instances of hoarding are ‘haram’, meaning forbidden by Islamic law. [23]

Examples of hoarding

Silver Thursday
Silver price in USD.png
Silver price history in 1960–2020 showing the Silver Thursday event in 1980
Convicted Nelson Bunker Hunt, William Herbert Hunt and Lamar Hunt
VerdictFound guilty of violating fraud, commodities and antitrust laws
Sentencelifetime bans from trading in commodities futures and a $10m penalty

Silver Thursday

There have been many instances of economic hoarding throughout history, with an example being the silver collapse of 1980, coined ‘Silver Thursday’. [30] In this case, brothers Herbert and Nelson Hunt speculated that inflation would result in the value of paper currency to diminish, whilst metal assets, such as silver would maintain value and subsequently face an increase in demand. The brothers began to bulk purchase silver, including physical silver and future contracts that would allow them to buy or sell silver at a predetermined price, accumulating an estimated 100 million ounces of precious metals. [31] By 1980, this hoarding event resulted in silver prices spiking to 50 U.S. dollars per ounce from the original 1.50 U.S dollars per ounce the Hunt brothers had paid for 10 years prior. Ensuing this surge in silver prices, the Federal Reserve intervened, suspending all trades in silver and ultimately resulting in the market crashing on March 27, 1980, when silver stock prices plummeted back down to $10.80 U.S dollars per ounce.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supply and demand</span> Economic model of price determination in a market

In microeconomics, supply and demand is an economic model of price determination in a market. It postulates that, holding all else equal, in a competitive market, the unit price for a particular good or other traded item such as labor or liquid financial assets, will vary until it settles at a point where the quantity demanded will equal the quantity supplied, resulting in an economic equilibrium for price and quantity transacted. The concept of supply and demand forms the theoretical basis of modern economics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Inflation</span> Devaluation of currency over a period of time

In economics, inflation is a general increase in the prices of goods and services in an economy. This is usually measured using the consumer price index (CPI). When the general price level rises, each unit of currency buys fewer goods and services; consequently, inflation corresponds to a reduction in the purchasing power of money. The opposite of CPI inflation is deflation, a decrease in the general price level of goods and services. The common measure of inflation is the inflation rate, the annualized percentage change in a general price index. As prices faced by households do not all increase at the same rate, the consumer price index (CPI) is often used for this purpose.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Commodity</span> Fungible item produced to satisfy wants or needs

In economics, a commodity is an economic good, usually a resource, that specifically has full or substantial fungibility: that is, the market treats instances of the good as equivalent or nearly so with no regard to who produced them.

In economics, deflation is a decrease in the general price level of goods and services. Deflation occurs when the inflation rate falls below 0%. Inflation reduces the value of currency over time, but deflation increases it. This allows more goods and services to be bought than before with the same amount of currency. Deflation is distinct from disinflation, a slowdown in the inflation rate; i.e., when inflation declines to a lower rate but is still positive.

This aims to be a complete article list of economics topics:

In economics, elasticity measures the responsiveness of one economic variable to a change in another. If the price elasticity of the demand of something is -2, a 10% increase in price causes the quantity demanded to fall by 20%. Elasticity in economics provides an understanding of changes in the behavior of the buyers and sellers with price changes. There are two types of elasticity for demand and supply, one is inelastic demand and supply and the other one is elastic demand and supply.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Price</span> Amount of money given in order to purchase a thing or service

A price is the quantity of payment or compensation expected, required, or given by one party to another in return for goods or services. In some situations, especially when the product is a service rather than a physical good, the price for the service may be called something else such as "rent" or "tuition". Prices are influenced by production costs, supply of the desired product, and demand for the product. A price may be determined by a monopolist or may be imposed on the firm by market conditions.

In classical economics, Say's law, or the law of markets, is the claim that the production of a product creates demand for another product by providing something of value which can be exchanged for that other product. So, production is the source of demand. In his principal work, A Treatise on Political Economy, Jean-Baptiste Say wrote: "A product is no sooner created, than it, from that instant, affords a market for other products to the full extent of its own value." And also, "As each of us can only purchase the productions of others with his/her own productions – as the value we can buy is equal to the value we can produce, the more men can produce, the more they will purchase."

<i>Economics in One Lesson</i> Book by Henry Hazlitt

Economics in One Lesson is an introduction to economics written by Henry Hazlitt and first published in 1946. It is based on Frédéric Bastiat's essay Ce qu'on voit et ce qu'on ne voit pas.

In economics, dishoarding is the opposite of hoarding. In the case of hoarding emphasized most by macroeconomics, someone increases his or her holdings of money as an asset rather than using money simply as a tool for buying goods and services. Thus, dishoarding would refer to the reduction of one's asset holdings of money.

In economics, economic value is a measure of the benefit provided by a good or service to an economic agent, and value for money represents an assessment of whether financial or other resources are being used effectively in order to secure such benefit. Economic value is generally measured through units of currency, and the interpretation is therefore "what is the maximum amount of money a person is willing and able to pay for a good or service?” Value for money is often expressed in comparative terms, such as "better", or "best value for money", but may also be expressed in absolute terms, such as where a deal does, or does not, offer value for money.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Competition (economics)</span> Economic scenario

In economics, competition is a scenario where different economic firms are in contention to obtain goods that are limited by varying the elements of the marketing mix: price, product, promotion and place. In classical economic thought, competition causes commercial firms to develop new products, services and technologies, which would give consumers greater selection and better products. The greater the selection of a good is in the market, the lower prices for the products typically are, compared to what the price would be if there was no competition (monopoly) or little competition (oligopoly).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Currency appreciation and depreciation</span> Change of currency values relative to other currencies

Currency depreciation is the loss of value of a country's currency with respect to one or more foreign reference currencies, typically in a floating exchange rate system in which no official currency value is maintained. Currency appreciation in the same context is an increase in the value of the currency. Short-term changes in the value of a currency are reflected in changes in the exchange rate.

Within economics, margin is a concept used to describe the current level of consumption or production of a good or service. Margin also encompasses various concepts within economics, denoted as marginal concepts, which are used to explain the specific change in the quantity of goods and services produced and consumed. These concepts are central to the economic theory of marginalism. This is a theory that states that economic decisions are made in reference to incremental units at the margin, and it further suggests that the decision on whether an individual or entity will obtain additional units of a good or service depending on the marginal utility of the product.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scarcity</span> Concept in economics

In economics, scarcity "refers to the basic fact of life that there exists only a finite amount of human and nonhuman resources which the best technical knowledge is capable of using to produce only limited maximum amounts of each economic good." If the conditions of scarcity didn't exist and an "infinite amount of every good could be produced or human wants fully satisfied ... there would be no economic goods, i.e. goods that are relatively scarce..." Scarcity is the limited availability of a commodity, which may be in demand in the market or by the commons. Scarcity also includes an individual's lack of resources to buy commodities. The opposite of scarcity is abundance. Scarcity plays a key role in economic theory, and it is essential for a "proper definition of economics itself".

"The best example is perhaps Walras' definition of social wealth, i.e., economic goods. 'By social wealth', says Walras, 'I mean all things, material or immaterial, that are scarce, that is to say, on the one hand, useful to us and, on the other hand, only available to us in limited quantity'."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Outline of economics</span> Overview of and topical guide to economics

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to economics:

In economics, an excess supply, economic surplus market surplus or briefly supply is a situation in which the quantity of a good or service supplied is more than the quantity demanded, and the price is above the equilibrium level determined by supply and demand. That is, the quantity of the product that producers wish to sell exceeds the quantity that potential buyers are willing to buy at the prevailing price. It is the opposite of an economic shortage.

Ecoflation is a future scenario in "Rattling Supply Chains", a research report by the World Resources Institute and A.T. Kearney, released in November 2008. It is characterized by natural resources becoming scarcer and sustainability issues become more pressing, leading to an increase in the price of commodities. The effects of the increase in the price of commodities are felt by corporations suffering environmental costs being added to their usual cost of doing business.

Inflation rate in India was 4.83% as of April 2024, as per the Indian Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation. This represents a modest reduction from the previous figure of 5.69% for December 2023. CPI for the months of January, February and March 2024 are 5.10, 5.09 and 4.85 respectively. Inflation rates in India are usually quoted as changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI), for all commodities.

This glossary of economics is a list of definitions of terms and concepts used in economics, its sub-disciplines, and related fields.

References

  1. ↑ "Hoarding". Corporate Finance Institute. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Iqbal, Zamir; Mirakhor, Abbas (2020-04-20), "Chapter 1: Ethics of Risk-Sharing Economics and Finance", Handbook of Ethics of Islamic Economics and Finance, De Gruyter, pp. 1–20, doi:10.1515/9783110593419-001, ISBN   9783110593419, S2CID   240967449 , retrieved 2022-05-09
  3. 1 2 Stiff, Ronald; Johnson, Keith; Tourk, Khairy Ahmed (1975). "Scarcity and Hoarding: Economic and Social Explanations and Marketing Implications". ACR North American Advances. NA-02.
  4. ↑ Emmer, Robert E. (1959). "A Concept of Hoarding". The Review of Economics and Statistics. 41 (2): 162–169. doi:10.2307/1927798. ISSN   0034-6535. JSTOR   1927798.
  5. ↑ "Elasticity vs. Inelasticity of Demand: What's the Difference?". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  6. 1 2 "What Is Investing?". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  7. 1 2 Experimental economics. Volume II, Economic applications. Pablo Brañas-Garza, Antonio Cabrales. Basingstoke, Hampshire [UK]. 2016. ISBN   978-1-137-53816-1. OCLC   936079538.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: others (link)
  8. 1 2 "Fixed Price Definition". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  9. ↑ "9.1 How Monopolies Form: Barriers to Entry - Principles of Economics 2e | OpenStax". openstax.org. 11 October 2017. Retrieved 2022-04-29.
  10. 1 2 Binswanger, Mathias (1999). Stock markets, speculative bubbles and economic growth: new dimensions in the co-evolution of real and financial markets. E. Elgar. ISBN   1-84064-071-5. OCLC   40734977.
  11. ↑ "Perfect vs. Imperfect Competition: What's the Difference?". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  12. ↑ Reinhardt, P. G. (June 1974). "Price Adjustments during Inflation in Non-Competitive Markets". International Economic Review. 15 (2): 431–439. doi:10.2307/2525868. ISSN   0020-6598. JSTOR   2525868.
  13. ↑ ZARNIKAU, JAY (2008), "Demand Participation in Restructured Markets", Competitive Electricity Markets, Elsevier, pp. 297–324, doi:10.1016/b978-008047172-3.50012-x, ISBN   9780080471723 , retrieved 2022-05-09
  14. ↑ Patruti, Alexandru (2015). "The Effects of Hoarding on Economic Growth from the Perspective of Capital Theory". Procedia Economics and Finance. 20: 494–502. doi: 10.1016/s2212-5671(15)00101-x . ISSN   2212-5671.
  15. ↑ "Is it time to carefully gauge the aspect of non-consumption in overall GDP math?". The Economic Times. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  16. ↑ "If a particular good's price elasticity is high, does this mean the supplier should increase the supply, decrease it, or keep it constant?". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  17. ↑ Fu, Yizheng; Su, Zhifang; Guo, Qianqian (2021-07-28). "The Impact of Financial Hoarding on Economic Growth in China". Sustainability. 13 (15): 8434. doi: 10.3390/su13158434 . ISSN   2071-1050.
  18. ↑ "Price Controls". Econlib. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  19. ↑ "Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)". Corporate Finance Institute. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  20. ↑ "Government Intervention and Disequilibrium | Boundless Economics". courses.lumenlearning.com. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  21. ↑ "Islam | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  22. ↑ "Hadith | Collection, Books, & Types | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  23. 1 2 "Profit Maximization and Hoarding: An Islamic Corrective". AlJumuah Magazine. 2020-04-17. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  24. ↑ Orhan, Zeyneb Hafsa (2020-12-10), "Money from the viewpoint of Islam, history of Islam and Islamic economics", Islamic Monetary Economics, Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge, pp. 1–12, doi:10.4324/9781003025191-1, ISBN   9781003025191, S2CID   228920707 , retrieved 2022-05-09
  25. 1 2 Sadr, Seyed Kazem (2016), "The Markets in the Early Islamic Era", The Economic System of the Early Islamic Period, New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, pp. 161–185, doi:10.1057/978-1-137-50733-4_7, ISBN   978-1-137-51749-4 , retrieved 2022-05-09
  26. ↑ Mirakhor, A (2016). Islam and the path to human and economic development. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN   978-1-349-28831-1. OCLC   951509702.
  27. ↑ Sadr, Seyed Kazem (2016-05-24). The Economic System of the Early Islamic Period: Institutions and Policies. Palgrave Macmillan US. ISBN   978-1-137-51749-4.
  28. ↑ Derome, Muhammad Darul Ehsan; Nazri, Mohd Arif (2017-11-15). "Kedudukan Hadith Dalam Juzuk 2 Kitab Kasyf Al-Ghummah Fi Ahwalil Mauta Fil Barzakh Wal Qiyamah". Al-Banjari: Jurnal Ilmiah Ilmu-Ilmu Keislaman. 16 (2): 307. doi: 10.18592/al-banjari.v16i2.1264 . ISSN   2527-6778.
  29. ↑ "SAHIH MUSLIM, BOOK 10: Transactions (Kitab Al-Buyu')". www.iium.edu.my. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  30. ↑ "Silver Thursday: How Two Wealthy Traders Cornered the Market". Investopedia. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
  31. ↑ "Silver Thursday | American history | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 2022-05-09.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.