Human-wildlife coexistence

Last updated

Human-wildlife coexistence involves agreement between consenting individuals representing the human communities sharing a landscape with wildlife, to live so that the wildlife can persist, within the limits required by the land and its non-human inhabitants in order to flourish, and within what is acceptable (regarding actual and perceived negative impacts caused by wildlife) and desirable for the human communities. [1]

Contents

It emerged from from human-wildlife conflict studies, and involves more than tolerance or acceptance of wildlife, implying a positive choice to coexist with wildlife despite the occasional costs. [2] Various accounts are given to explain its emergence into the conservation mainstream in the late 2010s, including a desire for a more positive framing of human-wildlife interactions, advances in understanding animal behaviour and capacities for relationships, and the perception that as humans and wild animals increasingly share landscapes in the Anthropocene, conservation strategies focusing on separation of humans and wildlife, lethal control or removal of problem animals, and policing human behaviour, are proving inadequate. [3] [4] [5]

Definitions

While there is no agreed standard definition, certain core ideas have been established. Coexistence has been characterised as a sustainable though dynamic state. There is a degree of co-adaptation between humans and wildlife in shared landscapes. Effective institutions are required to govern human interactions in socially legitimate ways, to ensure wild animal populations persist, with tolerable levels of risk for humans. [6] Others offer similar characterisations, but see coexistence as a dynamic, evolving process [7] or a sustainable condition. [8] All emphasise the context-specific particularity (and diversity) of coexistence scenarios. [9]

Outcomes of successful coexistence include socially legitimate agreement on managing human-wildlife interactions that ensure wildlife can persist and flourish, within the limits required by the land and its non-human inhabitants, and within what is acceptable and necessary for the human communities. [10] [11] [12]

Characteristics of human-wildlife coexistence

The IUCN position document Perspectives on human-wildlife coexistence outlines key characteristics of coexistence as follows: [13]

Examples of human-wildlife coexistence

Examples of documented human-wildlife coexistence scenarios include human-polar bear coexistence in Churchill, Manitoba, Canada, [14] human-crocodile coexistence in the Charotar region of Gujarat, India, [1] human-crocodile coexistence in East Timor, [15] human-cobra coexistence in Agumbe in Karnataka, India, [16] human coexistence with Komodo Dragons on Komodo Island, Indonesia, [17] human-hyena coexistence in Harar, Ethiopia, [18] and human-tiger coexistence in India. [19]

Ethnoprimatology, a subdiscipline of primatology, is the study of human coexistence with wild monkeys, apes, and other primates. The nexus of human-primate interactions is known as the "human-primate interface." [20]

Case study: Human-Crocodile Coexistence in Charotar

In central Gujarat State, in northwestern India, lies the region known as Charotar after its fertile soils. The rivers, wetlands and ponds are inhabited by mugger crocodiles (Crocodylus palustris). They are also settled and farmed, and communities share village-adjacent ponds (large dams) with mugger. Muggers figure in local folklore and are associated with the Hindu goddess Khodiyar, and despite occasional attacks including fatal ones, for the most part human-crocodile coexistence prevails. Both humans and crocodiles have learned to live alongside one another, both modifying their behaviour accordingly. When things go wrong, the crocodiles are not killed, but caught and removed, often to the Pariyej wetland.

After the daughter of a man from Traj village was killed by a crocodile in the village pond, the crocodile was caught and removed. The distraught father, Hemant Ode, did not turn against crocodiles, but became a mugger mitra (friend of the mugger) and dedicates time to educating other locals about how to live more safely alongside crocodiles.

At the village of Deva, a basking island has been built in the pond so the mugger can bask safely away from disturbance, also preventing people or livestock from being harmed after stumbling across them on the banks of the pond. Many villages also have crocodile exclusion enclosures built on their ponds.

At Malataj, it is believed that a local monk (commemorated in the local temple) put a spiritual injunction on the crocodiles of the pond never to harm a local. Apparently, this injunction has now held for 100s of years. Nevertheless, there is a prominent warning sign on the bank (pictured).

Further dimensions

Recent work studies coexistence from multi-species perspectives, considering the agency of both humans and wild animals, including work on brown bears in the Central Apennine Mountains in Italy, [21] and in the French Pyrenees. [22]

The cultural dimensions of human-wildlife coexistence requires interdisciplinary approaches in study [23] [24] [25] [26] and can include considerations of coexisting with introduced and invasive plants and animals. [27]

Policy and management

Mainstreaming human-wildlife coexistence into conservation policy and management is a goal of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework [28] and requires enabling recognition, monitoring and evaluation of coexistence scenarios in the field. It also requires collaboration with those affected, involving ethical consideration of humans and wildlife. [29] [30] [12] Such collaboration requires interdisciplinary approaches to the study of humans, and wild animals. Environmental humanities and social sciences thinkers are contributing more holistic visions for sharing the planet with wild beings. [31] [32]  Social science coexistence thinking informs work on coping with the recovery of populations of potentially harmful wild species, including large carnivore recovery in Europe, [33] and the return of saltwater crocodiles in Australia. [34]

References

  1. 1 2 Pooley, Simon; Bhatia, Saloni; Vasava, Anirudhkumar (2021). "Rethinking the study of human–wildlife coexistence". Conservation Biology. 35 (3): 784–793. Bibcode:2021ConBi..35..784P. doi:10.1111/cobi.13653. ISSN   1523-1739. PMC   8246872 . PMID   33044026.
  2. Glikman, Jenny Anne; Frank, Beatrice; Ruppert, Kirstie A.; Knox, Jillian; Sponarski, Carly C.; Metcalf, Elizabeth Covelli; Metcalf, Alexander L.; Marchini, Silvio (2021-10-14). "Coexisting With Different Human-Wildlife Coexistence Perspectives". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 703174. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.3174G. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.703174 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  3. Nyhus, Philip J. (2016-10-17). "Human–Wildlife Conflict and Coexistence" . Annual Review of Environment and Resources. 41: 143–171. doi:10.1146/annurev-environ-110615-085634. ISSN   1543-5938.
  4. König, Hannes J.; Kiffner, Christian; Kramer-Schadt, Stephanie; Fürst, Christine; Keuling, Oliver; Ford, Adam T. (2020). "Human–wildlife coexistence in a changing world". Conservation Biology. 34 (4): 786–794. Bibcode:2020ConBi..34..786K. doi:10.1111/cobi.13513. ISSN   1523-1739. PMID   32406977.
  5. Pooley, S.; Barua, M.; Beinart, W.; Dickman, A.; Holmes, G.; Lorimer, J.; Loveridge, A.j.; Macdonald, D.w.; Marvin, G.; Redpath, S.; Sillero-Zubiri, C.; Zimmermann, A.; Milner-Gulland, E.j. (2017). "An interdisciplinary review of current and future approaches to improving human–predator relations". Conservation Biology (in Spanish). 31 (3): 513–523. Bibcode:2017ConBi..31..513P. doi:10.1111/cobi.12859. ISSN   1523-1739. PMID   27783450.
  6. Carter, Neil H.; Linnell, John D. C. (2016-08-01). "Co-Adaptation Is Key to Coexisting with Large Carnivores". Trends in Ecology & Evolution. 31 (8): 575–578. Bibcode:2016TEcoE..31..575C. doi: 10.1016/j.tree.2016.05.006 . ISSN   0169-5347. PMID   27377600.
  7. Glikman, Jenny A.; Frank, Beatrice; Marchini, Silvio (2019), Frank, Beatrice; Glikman, Jenny A.; Marchini, Silvio (eds.), "Human–Wildlife Interactions: Multifaceted Approaches for Turning Conflict into Coexistence", Human–Wildlife Interactions: Turning Conflict into Coexistence, Conservation Biology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 439–452, ISBN   978-1-108-41606-1 , retrieved 2025-08-08
  8. Marchini, Silvio; Ferraz, Katia M. P. M. B.; Foster, Vania; Reginato, Thiago; Kotz, Aline; Barros, Yara; Zimmermann, Alexandra; Macdonald, David W. (2021-11-24). "Planning for Human-Wildlife Coexistence: Conceptual Framework, Workshop Process, and a Model for Transdisciplinary Collaboration". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 752953. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.2953M. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.752953 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  9. Gao, Yufang; Clark, Susan G. (2023-06-01). "An interdisciplinary conception of human-wildlife coexistence" . Journal for Nature Conservation. 73 126370. Bibcode:2023JNatC..7326370G. doi:10.1016/j.jnc.2023.126370. ISSN   1617-1381.
  10. Pooley, Simon (2021-09-28). "Coexistence for Whom?". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 726991. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.6991P. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.726991 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  11. Aguilar, Lucrecia K.; Webb, Christine E. (2024-03-01). "Keystones for conservation: Diversity, Wellbeing, Coexistence" . Biological Conservation. 291 110464. Bibcode:2024BCons.29110464A. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2024.110464. ISSN   0006-3207.
  12. 1 2 Pooley, Simon (2025). "Conservation and coexistence at a crossroads". Conservation Biology. 39 (1) e14433. Bibcode:2025ConBi..39E4433P. doi:10.1111/cobi.14433. ISSN   1523-1739. PMC   11780208 . PMID   39699286.
  13. "Policies". HWCTF. Retrieved 2025-08-08.
  14. Miller, Katharina M.; Berg, Georgina; Lickers, Michael; McIvor, Nickia; Henri, Dominique A. (2025-01-31). "Coexistence between people and polar bears supports Indigenous knowledge mobilization in wildlife management and research". Communications Earth & Environment. 6 (1): 74. Bibcode:2025ComEE...6...74M. doi: 10.1038/s43247-025-02017-6 . ISSN   2662-4435.
  15. Brackhane, Sebastian; Fukuda, Yusuke; Xavier, Flaminio M. E.; Araujo, Vitorino de; Gusmao, Marcal; Trindade, Josh; Carvalho, Demétrio do Amaral de; Pires, Rui Dos Reis; Webb, Grahame (2024). "Wildlife conservation through traditional values: alarming numbers of crocodile attacks reported from Timor-Leste". Oryx. 58 (3): 347–350. doi: 10.1017/S0030605324000036 . ISSN   0030-6053.
  16. Lenin, Janaki (2023-12-25). "Venomous Gods". Current Conservation. Retrieved 2025-08-11.
  17. Panggur M.; Wiyajanti A; Ardiantiono (2023-12-25). "Living in harmony with dragons". Current Conservation. Retrieved 2025-08-11.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  18. "Among the Bone Eaters: Encounters with Hyenas in Harar By Marcus Baynes-Rock and Foreword by Elizabeth Marshall Thomas". www.psupress.org. Retrieved 2025-08-17.
  19. "Living with Tigers: How to manage coexistence for the benefit of people and tigers | Publications | WWF". World Wildlife Fund. Retrieved 2025-08-11.
  20. Fuentes, Augustin; Hockings, Kimberley J. (August 24, 2010). "The ethnoprimatological approach in primatology". American Journal of Primatology via Wiley.
  21. Mayer, Paula; Grêt-Regamey, Adrienne; Ciucci, Paolo; Salliou, Nicolas; Stritih, Ana (2023-06-01). "Mapping human- and bear-centered perspectives on coexistence using a participatory Bayesian framework". Journal for Nature Conservation. 73 126387. Bibcode:2023JNatC..7326387M. doi:10.1016/j.jnc.2023.126387. hdl: 20.500.11850/604873 . ISSN   1617-1381.
  22. Culos, Manon; Ouvrier, Alice; Vimal, Ruppert (2025-02-01). "Thinking coexistence in human-dominated landscapes with the lens of multi-species assemblages: Farmers, brown bears and other wild species in the Pyrenees" . Biological Conservation. 302 111006. Bibcode:2025BCons.30211006C. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2025.111006. ISSN   0006-3207.
  23. Jolly, Helina (2022). "Indigenous insights on human–wildlife coexistence in southern India" . Conservation Biology. 36 (6) e13981. Bibcode:2022ConBi..36E3981J. doi:10.1111/cobi.13981. PMID   36000317.
  24. Thekaekara, Tarsh; Bhagwat, Shonil A.; Thornton, Thomas F. (2021-10-27). "Coexistence and Culture: Understanding Human Diversity and Tolerance in Human-Elephant Interactions". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 735929. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.5929T. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.735929 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  25. Oommen, Meera Anna (2021-07-21). "Beasts in the Garden: Human-Wildlife Coexistence in India's Past and Present". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 703432. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.3432O. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.703432 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  26. "IUCN SSC Guidelines on Human-Wildlife Conflict and Coexistence". HWCTF. Retrieved 2025-08-11.
  27. "People and Nature". besjournals. doi:10.1002/(ISSN)2575-8314 . Retrieved 2025-08-11.
  28. "COP15: Final text of Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework". Convention on Biological Diversity. Retrieved 2025-08-11.
  29. "Policies". HWCTF. Retrieved 2025-08-08.
  30. "Human-Wildlife Coexistence: Business as Usual Conservation... : Conservation and Society". LWW. doi: 10.4103/cs.cs_26_21 . Archived from the original on 2025-06-30. Retrieved 2025-08-08.
  31. Rose, Deborah Bird; van Dooren, Thom; Chrulew, Matthew; Cooke, Stuart; Kearnes, Matthew; O'Gorman, Emily (2012-05-01). "Thinking Through the Environment, Unsettling the Humanities". Environmental Humanities. 1 (1): 1–5. doi: 10.1215/22011919-3609940 . ISSN   2201-1919.
  32. Schroer, Sara Asu (2021-11-11). "The Arts of Coexistence: A View From Anthropology". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 711019. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.1019S. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.711019 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  33. Pettersson, Hanna L.; Quinn, Claire H.; Holmes, George; Sait, Steven M.; López-Bao, José Vicente (2021-09-10). "Welcoming Wolves? Governing the Return of Large Carnivores in Traditional Pastoral Landscapes". Frontiers in Conservation Science. 2 710218. Bibcode:2021FrCS....2.0218P. doi: 10.3389/fcosc.2021.710218 . ISSN   2673-611X.
  34. Saunders, Lachlan; Jukes, Scott (2025-03-17). "Learning to Live with Dungalaba: Embracing Indigenous Knowledge Practises for Respectful Coexistence with Saltwater Crocodiles in the Northern Territory". Australian Journal of Environmental Education: 1–14. doi: 10.1017/aee.2025.3 . ISSN   0814-0626.

Further reading