Jersey Act

Last updated
An early volume of the General Stud Book, Volume 6 Generalstudbookvolume6closed.jpg
An early volume of the General Stud Book, Volume 6

The Jersey Act was introduced to prevent the registration of most American-bred Thoroughbred horses in the British General Stud Book . It had its roots in the desire of British horse breeders to halt the influx of American-bred racehorses of possibly impure bloodlines during the early 20th century. Many American-bred horses were exported to Europe to race and retire to a breeding career after a number of U.S. states banned gambling, which depressed Thoroughbred racing as well as breeding in the United States. The loss of breeding records during the American Civil War and the late beginning of the registration of American Thoroughbreds led many in the British racing establishment to doubt that the American-bred horses were purebred.

Contents

In 1913, the Jockey Club and the owners of the General Stud Book passed a regulation named by the foreign press after the Jockey Club's senior steward, Lord Jersey, prohibiting the registration of horses in the book unless all of their ancestors had been registered. Despite protests from American breeders, the regulation remained in force until 1949. Among the factors influencing its relaxation were the racing success of ineligible horses in Europe and the damage caused to British and Irish breeders by the unavailability of French Thoroughbreds during and after the Second World War. In addition, by 1949 the possibly impure ancestors of the American bloodlines had receded far back in most horses' ancestry.

Background

Before the introduction in 1913 of what became popularly known—"with questionable taste" according to a correspondent writing in The Times —as the Jersey Act, [1] Thoroughbred horses in the United Kingdom were registered in the General Stud Book, the stud book for British and Irish Thoroughbreds. The rules allowed a horse to be registered if all of the horse's ancestors were registered in the General Stud Book or if it had been bred outside of Britain or Ireland and was registered in the stud book of its country of origin. [2] Overall the General Stud Book had the most stringent rules for registration of Thoroughbreds at the time, around 1900; other countries, including the United States, France, Australia and Russia, were considered by the British and Irish to be much laxer and to have allowed some non-Thoroughbred horses into their national stud books. [3]

The outlawing of race-track betting in parts of the United States between 1900 and 1913 led to a large influx of American-bred horses into Britain and Ireland, giving rise to fears among British breeders that they would be swamped by the American bloodlines and their own stock would become worthless. [4] The biggest state to outlaw betting was New York, which passed the Hart–Agnew Law in 1908. [5] By 1911, the average price for yearlings sold at auction was at a record low of $230 ($7,520 as of 2024). [6] Before 1900, most horses were imported into Britain to race, and rarely stayed for a breeding career. The outlawing of gambling resulted in large numbers of American horses that could no longer be supported, and many were shipped to Europe for racing. Because of the downturn in the horse market in the United States, it was assumed that most of the horses sent to Europe would stay there permanently and, after retirement from the racetrack, would enter their breeding careers outside of the United States. [2] [3] Between 1908 and 1913, over 1500 Thoroughbreds were exported from the United States. Those exported included 24 horses who had been or would later become champions – among them Artful, Colin, Henry of Navarre, Peter Pan, and Ballot. [7]

The American Stud Book , the registration book for American Thoroughbreds, was not founded until 1873, much later than the General Stud Book, [8] [lower-alpha 1] and the rules for registration required only that a horse have five generations of ancestors in the American Stud Book or other national stud books, unlike the General Stud Book rules. [10] In addition, many breeding records were destroyed during the American Civil War, as fighting during that conflict took place in noted American Thoroughbred breeding centers. The result was that most American Thoroughbreds in 1913 were unable to show an unblemished pedigree according to the General Stud Book rules. Adding to the problem was the fact that American horses were beginning to win the big horse races in England, starting with Iroquois, who won the 1881 Epsom Derby. [8]

J. B. Haggin, an American breeder and owner of Elmendorf Farm, had begun to ship large contingents of horses to England for sale, including the 1908 Grand National steeplechase winner Rubio, and the fear was that if other American breeders followed his lead, the English racing market would be overwhelmed. As a first step, the English racing authorities began to limit the number of training licences at Newmarket Racecourse, turning away a number of American breeders. [11] The General Stud Book rules for registration were also amended in 1909 to restrict registration to horses whose ancestry could be traced entirely to horses already registered in the General Stud Book, but horses registered in other national stud books were still allowed to be imported and registered. [12]

Introduction

The owners of the General Stud Book, Weatherbys, consulted with the Jockey Club, the United Kingdom's racing authority, and discussions were held about the problems in pedigrees recorded in the American Stud Book. [2] At a meeting of the Jockey Club in spring 1913, Victor Child Villiers, Lord Jersey, the club's senior steward, proposed a resolution limiting the registration of American bloodlines. [8] It passed unanimously in May, [13] and a new regulation was placed in the General Stud Book, Volume 22: [4]

No horse or mare can, after this date, be considered as eligible for admission unless it can be traced without flaw on both sire's and dam's side of its pedigree to horses and mares themselves already accepted in the earlier volumes of the book. [14] [lower-alpha 2]

Although named the Jersey Act by a critical foreign press, after Lord Jersey, [1] the new regulation did not have the force of law as it was promulgated by the registration authorities of the Thoroughbred horse, not by the United Kingdom government. [4] [8] [10] Nor was it promulgated by the Jockey Club, which had no authority over registration, only over racing matters. [10] The regulation required that any horse registered in the General Stud Book trace in every line to a horse that had already been registered in the General Stud Book, effectively excluding most American-bred Thoroughbreds. [15]

Effects

An 1857 engraving of Lexington Lexington1.jpg
An 1857 engraving of Lexington

Because the new rule was not applied retroactively, all American-bred horses registered before 1913 remained on the register, and their descendants were also eligible for registration. [4] Of the 7,756 mares in Volume 27 of the General Stud Book, published in 1933, 930 would have been ineligible under the new rule. [1] The Jersey Act did have an immediate impact however, as the winner of the 1914 Epsom Derby, Durbar II, was ineligible for registration, as his dam, Armenia, was bred in the United States and was not herself eligible for the General Stud Book. [16]

The main problem for American breeders was the presence of the blood of Lexington in their breeding programs. Lexington's pedigree on his dam's side was suspect in the eyes of British racing authorities, and, as he had been the leading sire of racehorses in the United States for 16 years, his descendants were numerous. Most American-bred Thoroughbreds traced to Lexington at least once, [4] [17] and he was not the only horse with suspect bloodlines registered in the American Stud Book. [10]

Most British breeders thought the regulation necessary and welcomed it, whereas most American breeders found it insulting, and believed that it was intended merely to protect the British racehorse market. [4] The rule did adversely affect many British breeders as well, though, including even one senior member of the Jockey Club, Lord Coventry, whose successful line of racehorses was ineligible for registration. [1] Initially there was little foreign complaint or organized opposition, probably owing to the effect of the gambling bans in the United States on the domestic horse market. [13] The American Jockey Club did not even remark on the Jersey Act in its official publication, the Racing Calendar, and no mention of it appears in the Jockey Club's meeting minutes for 1913. [18] Contributing to the lack of outcry was a legal ruling in New York allowing oral betting at racetracks, which led to the growth of racing in the United States; by 1920 the American breeding market had rebounded and was booming. [19]

The Jersey Act did not prevent the racing of horses containing the banned bloodlines, as horses with the suspect breeding raced and won in England, but they were considered to be "half-bred". A number of American-bred horses carrying the lines of Lexington had already been imported into England, including Americus, Rhoda B, and Sibola, and because they were grandfathered in, they and their descendants were allowed to be registered in the General Stud Book. [4] [lower-alpha 3] Nor did it prevent the racing of horses that were not registered in the General Stud Book; it just prevented registration in the General Stud Book. [8] American bloodlines, whether registered in the General Stud Book or not, dominated English racing in the 1920s and 1930s. [4] Horses that were ineligible for General Stud Book registration, but were allowed to race, were identified with a Maltese cross in programs and auction listings. [11]

A number of American breeders, including the then-chairman of the American Jockey Club, William Woodward Sr., lobbied hard throughout the 1930s to have the regulation removed. [21] Woodward, and other defenders of the American bloodlines, argued that the racing performance of the horses proved their purity, even if they could not produce papers that did so. [22] Woodward declared in 1935 that "If we do not get together, we will grow apart." [23] Those arguing for keeping the Jersey Act in effect pointed out that the General Stud Book is a record of bloodlines, not a work recording racing ability. [22]

The Jersey Act's major effect was the opposite of what was intended. In the years before the Second World War, British and Irish breeders had relied on imported Thoroughbreds from France to enrich their breeding lines, a source that was unavailable during the war, and concerns were beginning to be expressed that the situation might lead to excessive inbreeding. [24] Additionally, by the end of the war American-bred lines were some of the most successful racing lines in the world, effectively making the British and Irish breeding programmes that did not use them second-rate, [25] [26] and harming the rebuilding of English racing. [27] There were even calls for the creation of an international stud book to record all Thoroughbred pedigrees, thus eliminating any perceived slight on the bloodlines that were excluded from the General Stud Book. [28]

1949 amendment

Weatherbys, publishers of the Stud Book, approached the Jockey Club in 1948 to ask if it agreed that the Jersey Act was "too restrictive". [29] The rule was subsequently modified in June 1949, [8] after the racing careers of a number of horses such as Tourbillon and Djebel persuaded the Jockey Club to reconsider. [20] [lower-alpha 4] A number of French-bred Thoroughbreds began to race in England after the Second World War, but because they carried American lines they were considered half-breds. In 1948 two of England's five classic races were won by half-bred horses, My Babu and Black Tarquin, prompting the Jockey Club to amend the rule in the preface to the General Stud Book, [4] to state that:

Any animal claiming admission from now onwards must be able to prove satisfactorily some eight or nine crosses pure blood, to trace back for at least a century, and to show such performances of its immediate family on the Turf as to warrant the belief in the purity of its blood. [30] [lower-alpha 5]

The amendment removed the stigma of not being considered purebred from American-bred horses. [4] A major consideration was that by the late 1940s most of the horses with suspect pedigrees were so far back in most horses' ancestry that it no longer made much sense to exclude them. Neither did it make much sense to exclude some of the most successful racehorses in Europe from registration. [25] Weatherby's further amended its regulations in 1969, introducing the word "thoroughbred" to describe the horses registered in previous volumes of the General Stud Book. [19] In 2006, Blood-Horse Publications, publisher of The Blood-Horse magazine, chose the "repeal" of the Jersey Act as the 39th most important moment in American Thoroughbred horse racing history. [8]

Notes

  1. The first volume of the General Stud Book appeared in 1791. [9]
  2. Admission means registration in this instance.
  3. Americus was an ancestor of Mumtaz Mahal, herself an ancestor of Nasrullah. Sibola was an ancestor of Nearco. Both of these stallions were very influential in Thoroughbred breeding. [20]
  4. Tourbillon's maternal grandsire was Durbar II, who won the 1914 Epsom Derby and was the first winner of the Derby to be ineligible for the General Stud Book. [16]
  5. Crosses means generations of a pedigree, in this case that the pedigree goes back eight or nine generations.

Citations

  1. 1 2 3 4 Staff "The General Stud Book, The Full Story" The Times
  2. 1 2 3 Napier and Rasmussen Treasures of the Bloodstock Breeders' Review p. 642
  3. 1 2 Leicester Bloodstock Breeding p. 78
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Willett Classic Racehorse pp. 71–74
  5. Robertson History of Thoroughbred Racing in America p. 196
  6. Robertson History of Thoroughbred Racing in America p. 198
  7. Simon Racing Through the Century p. 55
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Blood-Horse Staff Horse Racing's Top 100 Moments pp. 124–125
  9. Willet Thoroughbred p. 96
  10. 1 2 3 4 Leicester Bloodstock Breeding p. 79
  11. 1 2 Robertson History of Thoroughbred Racing in America pp. 198–199
  12. Leicester Bloodstock Breeding pp. 79–80
  13. 1 2 Wall Judging the Horse pp. 189–190
  14. Quoted in Willett Classic Racehorse pp. 71–72
  15. Thoroughbred Times Staff "Racing Through the Century: 1911–1920" Thoroughbred Times
  16. 1 2 Napier and Rasmussen Treasures of the Bloodstock Breeders' Review p. 648
  17. Willett Classic Racehorse p. 107
  18. Jockey Club Racing Calendar Meeting minutes for 1913. The entire year was searched and nothing on the new regulation was mentioned.
  19. 1 2 Leicester Bloodstock Breeding pp. 80–81
  20. 1 2 Hewitt Great Breeders p. 277
  21. Sparkman "Errors" Thoroughbred Times
  22. 1 2 Montgomery Thoroughbred p. 170
  23. Quoted in Simon Racing Through the Century p. 105
  24. Staff "U.S. and General Stud Book" The Times
  25. 1 2 Napier and Rasmussen Treasures of the Bloodstock Breeders' Review p. 664
  26. Simon Racing Through the Century p. 141
  27. Williams "Juicy Steaks Decide Rickey's Camp Choice" The Pittsburgh Post
  28. Churchill "Today in Europe" The Palm Beach Post
  29. Staff "Jersey Act and the Stud Book" The Times
  30. Quoted in Willett Classic Racehorse p. 73

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Horse breed</span> Selectively bred populations of domesticated horses

A horse breed is a selectively bred population of domesticated horses, often with pedigrees recorded in a breed registry. However, the term is sometimes used in a broader sense to define landrace animals of a common phenotype located within a limited geographic region, or even feral "breeds" that are naturally selected. Depending on definition, hundreds of "breeds" exist today, developed for many different uses. Horse breeds are loosely divided into three categories based on general temperament: spirited "hot bloods" with speed and endurance; "cold bloods," such as draft horses and some ponies, suitable for slow, heavy work; and "warmbloods," developed from crosses between hot bloods and cold bloods, often focusing on creating breeds for specific riding purposes, particularly in Europe.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thoroughbred racing in Australia</span>

Thoroughbred horse racing is a spectator sport in Australia, and gambling on horse races is a very popular pastime with A$14.3 billion wagered in 2009/10 with bookmakers and the Totalisator Agency Board (TAB). The two forms of Thoroughbred horseracing in Australia are flat racing, and races over fences or hurdles in Victoria and South Australia. Thoroughbred racing is the third most attended spectator sport in Australia, behind Australian rules football and rugby league, with almost two million admissions to 360 registered racecourses throughout Australia in 2009/10. Horseracing commenced soon after European settlement, and is now well-appointed with automatic totalizators, starting gates and photo finish cameras on nearly all Australian racecourses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eclipse (horse)</span> British Thoroughbred racehorse

Eclipse was an undefeated 18th-century British Thoroughbred racehorse who won 18 races, including 11 King's Plates. He raced before the introduction of the British Classic Races, at a time when four-mile heat racing was the norm. He was considered the greatest racehorse of his time and the expression, "Eclipse first, the rest nowhere" entered the English vernacular as an expression of dominance.

The Weatherbys Group is a UK conglomerate involved in a wide range of activities largely within banking and horse racing. The original business was founded by James Weatherby in 1770.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lexington (horse)</span> American Thoroughbred racehorse and sire (1850–1875)

Lexington was a United States Thoroughbred race horse who won six of his seven race starts. Perhaps his greatest fame, however, came as the most successful sire of the second half of the nineteenth century; he was the leading sire in North America 16 times, and broodmare sire of many notable racehorses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sir Archy</span> 19th-century American Thoroughbred stallion

Sir Archy was an American Thoroughbred racehorse considered one of the best racehorses of his time and later one of the most important sires in American history. He was inducted into the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame in the inaugural class of 1955.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tulyar</span> Irish-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Tulyar (1949–1972) was an Irish bred, British-trained Thoroughbred racehorse and sire. He won The Derby, the St Leger Stakes, the King George VI & Queen Elizabeth Stakes, the Ormonde Stakes and the Eclipse Stakes setting a record for a single season's earnings in England. He stood at stud in Ireland and America, but failed to live up to expectations as a sire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thoroughbred breeding theories</span> Breeding theories to produce better Thoroughbred racehorses

Thoroughbred breeding theories, or racehorse theories, are used by horse breeders in an attempt to arrange matings that produce progeny successful in horse racing. Bloodstock experts also rely on these theories when purchasing young horses or breeding stock. A basic understanding of these theories can also help the racing public understand a horse's theoretical genetic potential. The breeding theories stem from the belief that careful analysis of bloodlines can lend predictability to breeding outcomes. A well-designed mating increases the probability of the offspring's success, although many other factors also come into play.

Foundation stock or foundation bloodstock refers to animals that are the progenitors, or foundation, of a breed or of a given bloodline within such. Many modern breeds can be traced to specific, named foundation animals, but a group of animals may be referred to collectively as foundation bloodstock when one distinct population provides part of the underlying genetic base for a new distinct population.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thoroughbred</span> Horse breed developed for racing

The Thoroughbred is a horse breed developed for horse racing. Although the word thoroughbred is sometimes used to refer to any breed of purebred horse, it technically refers only to the Thoroughbred breed. Thoroughbreds are considered "hot-blooded" horses that are known for agility, speed, and spirit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sir Martin</span> American-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Sir Martin (1906–1930) was a Thoroughbred racehorse that was foaled in 1906 in Lexington, Kentucky at Hamburg Place, the stud farm of noted turfman and horse trainer John E. Madden. Sir Martin was a half brother to the first Triple Crown winner Sir Barton, and he raced in the United States, Great Britain and France. Sir Martin was the betting favorite for the 1909 Epsom Derby, but stumbled and threw his jockey at the Tattenham Corner turn, allowing King Edward VII's horse Minoru to win.

Kings Best was an American-bred Thoroughbred racehorse best known for winning the 2000 Guineas Stakes. He was described by his trainer Michael Stoute as the best miler he'd ever trained.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Durbar (horse)</span> French-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Durbar was a French racehorse. Although not the best of his generation in France he proved too good for the leading British colts in the 1914 Epsom Derby, which he won by three lengths. His pedigree was controversial, with the British authorities not recognising him as a Thoroughbred. His racing career was ended by the outbreak of the First World War.

Americus, was an American Thoroughbred racehorse who was exported to England. He had some success as a racehorse, but was more notable for his influence at stud. He was bred in California and won the 1895 Culver Stakes prior to his export. He continued to race in England, until he was nine years old, while also standing as a breeding stallion. He stood at stud in Italy, Ireland, Germany, and Belgium before dying in Germany in 1910. Americus' most famous descendant was his great-granddaughter Mumtaz Mahal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cobweb (horse)</span> British-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Cobweb (1821–1848) was an undefeated British Thoroughbred racehorse and who won two British Classic Races as a three-year-old and went on to become a highly successful broodmare. Cobweb's racing career consisted of three competitive races in the early part of 1824. After winning on her debut she claimed a second prize when her opponents were withdrawn by their owners. She then won the 1000 Guineas at Newmarket Racecourse and the Oaks Stakes at Epsom Downs Racecourse before being retired to stud.

Habitat was an American-bred, British-trained Thoroughbred racehorse and sire. In a racing career which lasted from April until October 1969, the colt ran eight times and won five races. Unraced as a two-year-old, he proved to be the best European miler of 1969, winning the Lockinge Stakes and the Wills Mile in England and travelling to France to win the Prix Quincey and the Prix du Moulin. He was then retired to stud where he became a very successful sire of racehorses and broodmares.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sterling (horse)</span> British-bred Thoroughbred racehorse

Sterling was a British racehorse and sire. While not particularly successful in terms of major wins, he was very highly regarded, being rated by his jockey Harry Custance as the equal of Thormanby.

Combat (1944–1967) was an undefeated British Thoroughbred racehorse and sire. Despite winning all nine of his reces, his career was largely overshadowed by that of his more celebrated stablemate Tudor Minstrel. He won all four of his races as a two-year-old in 1946 and all five in the following year including the Blue Riband Trial Stakes, Rous Memorial Stakes and Sussex Stakes. He was then retired to stud where he had limited success as a sire of winners.

Hycilla was a British Thoroughbred racehorse and broodmare, who raced during World War II and was best known for winning the classic Oaks Stakes in 1944. Unraced as a juvenile, she finished second on her three-year-old debut before winning the Oaks, which was run that year at Newmarket Racecourse. She was beaten when favourite for St Leger but ended her year with a win in the Champion Stakes. In the following year, she failed to win but ran well in defeat when third in a strongly-contested Coronation Cup. She retired to become a broodmare in the United States but made little impact, producing four minor stakes winners.

Australian was a British-bred Thoroughbred racehorse and sire. He was exported to the United States where he had modest success as a racehorse but became a very successful and influential breeding stallion.

References