Kan fibration

In mathematics, Kan complexes and Kan fibrations are part of the theory of simplicial sets. Kan fibrations are the fibrations of the standard model category structure on simplicial sets and are therefore of fundamental importance. Kan complexes are the fibrant objects in this model category. The name is in honor of Daniel Kan.

Definitions

Definition of the standard n-simplex

The striped blue simplex in the domain has to exist in order for this map to be a Kan fibration

For each n ≥ 0, recall that the standard ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex, ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$, is the representable simplicial set

${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}(i)=\mathrm {Hom} _{\mathbf {\Delta } }([i],[n])}$

Applying the geometric realization functor to this simplicial set gives a space homeomorphic to the topological standard ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex: the convex subspace of ${\displaystyle \mathbb {R} ^{n+1}}$ consisting of all points ${\displaystyle (t_{0},\dots ,t_{n})}$ such that the coordinates are non-negative and sum to 1.

Definition of a horn

Main article: Horn of a simplex

For each k ≤ n, this has a subcomplex ${\displaystyle \Lambda _{k}^{n}}$, the k-th horn inside ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$, corresponding to the boundary of the n-simplex, with the k-th face removed. This may be formally defined in various ways, as for instance the union of the images of the n maps ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n-1}\rightarrow \Delta ^{n}}$ corresponding to all the other faces of ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$. ^[1] Horns of the form ${\displaystyle \Lambda _{k}^{2}}$ sitting inside ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{2}}$ look like the black V at the top of the adjacent image. If ${\displaystyle X}$ is a simplicial set, then maps

${\displaystyle s:\Lambda _{k}^{n}\to X}$

correspond to collections of ${\displaystyle n}$${\displaystyle (n-1)}$-simplices satisfying a compatibility condition, one for each ${\displaystyle 0\leq k\leq n-1}$. Explicitly, this condition can be written as follows. Write the ${\displaystyle (n-1)}$-simplices as a list ${\displaystyle (s_{0},\dots ,s_{k-1},s_{k+1},\dots ,s_{n})}$ and require that

${\displaystyle d_{i}s_{j}=d_{j-1}s_{i}\,}$ for all ${\displaystyle i<j}$ with ${\displaystyle i,j\neq k}$. ^[2]

These conditions are satisfied for the ${\displaystyle (n-1)}$-simplices of ${\displaystyle \Lambda _{k}^{n}}$ sitting inside ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$.

Definition of a Kan fibration

Lifting diagram for a Kan fibration

A map of simplicial sets ${\displaystyle f:X\rightarrow Y}$ is a Kan fibration if, for any ${\displaystyle n\geq 1}$ and ${\displaystyle 0\leq k\leq n}$, and for any maps ${\displaystyle s:\Lambda _{k}^{n}\rightarrow X}$ and ${\displaystyle y:\Delta ^{n}\rightarrow Y\,}$ such that ${\displaystyle f\circ s=y\circ i}$ (where ${\displaystyle i}$ is the inclusion of ${\displaystyle \Lambda _{k}^{n}}$ in ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$), there exists a map ${\displaystyle x:\Delta ^{n}\rightarrow X}$ such that ${\displaystyle s=x\circ i}$ and ${\displaystyle y=f\circ x}$. Stated this way, the definition is very similar to that of fibrations in topology (see also homotopy lifting property), whence the name "fibration".

Technical remarks

Using the correspondence between ${\displaystyle n}$-simplices of a simplicial set ${\displaystyle X}$ and morphisms ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}\to X}$ (a consequence of the Yoneda lemma), this definition can be written in terms of simplices. The image of the map ${\displaystyle fs:\Lambda _{k}^{n}\to Y}$ can be thought of as a horn as described above. Asking that ${\displaystyle fs}$ factors through ${\displaystyle yi}$ corresponds to requiring that there is an ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex in ${\displaystyle Y}$ whose faces make up the horn from ${\displaystyle fs}$ (together with one other face). Then the required map ${\displaystyle x:\Delta ^{n}\to X}$ corresponds to a simplex in ${\displaystyle X}$ whose faces include the horn from ${\displaystyle s}$. The diagram to the right is an example in two dimensions. Since the black V in the lower diagram is filled in by the blue ${\displaystyle 2}$-simplex, if the black V above maps down to it then the striped blue ${\displaystyle 2}$-simplex has to exist, along with the dotted blue ${\displaystyle 1}$-simplex, mapping down in the obvious way. ^[3]

Kan complexes defined from Kan fibrations

A simplicial set ${\displaystyle X}$ is called a Kan complex if the map from ${\displaystyle X\to \{*\}}$, the one-point simplicial set, is a Kan fibration. In the model category for simplicial sets, ${\displaystyle \{*\}}$ is the terminal object and so a Kan complex is exactly the same as a fibrant object. Equivalently, this could be stated as: if every map ${\displaystyle \alpha$ :\Lambda _{k}^{n}\to X} from a horn has an extension to ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$, meaning there is a lift ${\displaystyle {\tilde {\alpha }}:\Delta ^{n}\to X}$ such that

${\displaystyle \alpha ={\tilde {\alpha }}\circ \iota }$

for the inclusion map ${\displaystyle \iota$ :\Lambda _{k}^{n}\hookrightarrow \Delta ^{n}}, then ${\displaystyle X}$ is a Kan complex. Conversely, every Kan complex has this property, hence it gives a simple technical condition for a Kan complex.

Examples

Simplicial sets from singular homology

An important example comes from the construction of singular simplices used to define singular homology, called the singular functor ^{[4] pg 7}

${\displaystyle S:{\text{Top}}\to s{\text{Sets}}}$.

Given a space ${\displaystyle X}$, define a singular ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex of X to be a continuous map from the standard topological ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex (as described above) to ${\displaystyle X}$,

${\displaystyle f:\Delta _{n}\to X}$

Taking the set of these maps for all non-negative ${\displaystyle n}$ gives a graded set,

${\displaystyle S(X)=\coprod _{n}S_{n}(X)}$.

To make this into a simplicial set, define face maps ${\displaystyle d_{i}:S_{n}(X)\to S_{n-1}(X)}$ by

${\displaystyle (d_{i}f)(t_{0},\dots ,t_{n-1})=f(t_{0},\dots ,t_{i-1},0,t_{i},\dots ,t_{n-1})\,}$

and degeneracy maps ${\displaystyle s_{i}:S_{n}(X)\to S_{n+1}(X)}$ by

${\displaystyle (s_{i}f)(t_{0},\dots ,t_{n+1})=f(t_{0},\dots ,t_{i-1},t_{i}+t_{i+1},t_{i+2},\dots ,t_{n+1})\,}$.

Since the union of any ${\displaystyle n+1}$ faces of ${\displaystyle \Delta _{n+1}}$ is a strong deformation retract of ${\displaystyle \Delta _{n+1}}$, any continuous function defined on these faces can be extended to ${\displaystyle \Delta _{n+1}}$, which shows that ${\displaystyle S(X)}$ is a Kan complex. ^[5]

Relation with geometric realization

It is worth noting the singular functor is right adjoint to the geometric realization functor

${\displaystyle |\cdot |:s{\text{Sets}}\to {\text{Top}}}$

giving the isomorphism

${\displaystyle {\text{Hom}}_{\text{Top}}(|X|,Y)\cong {\text{Hom}}_{s{\text{Sets}}}(X,S(Y))}$

Simplicial sets underlying simplicial groups

It can be shown that the simplicial set underlying a simplicial group is always fibrant ^{[4] pg 12}. In particular, for a simplicial abelian group, its geometric realization is homotopy equivalent to a product of Eilenberg-Maclane spaces

${\displaystyle \prod _{i\in I}K(A_{i},n_{i})}$

In particular, this includes classifying spaces. So the spaces ${\displaystyle S^{1}\simeq K(\mathbb {Z} ,1)}$, ${\displaystyle \mathbb {CP} ^{\infty }\simeq K(\mathbb {Z} ,2)}$, and the infinite lens spaces ${\displaystyle L_{q}^{\infty }\simeq K(\mathbb {Z} /q,2)}$ are correspond to Kan complexes of some simplicial set. In fact, this set can be constructed explicitly using the Dold–Kan correspondence of a chain complex and taking the underlying simplicial set of the simplicial abelian group.

Geometric realizations of small groupoids

Another important source of examples are the simplicial sets associated to a small groupoid ${\displaystyle {\mathcal {G}}}$. This is defined as the geometric realization of the simplicial set ${\displaystyle [\Delta ^{op},{\mathcal {G}}]}$ and is typically denoted ${\displaystyle B{\mathcal {G}}}$. We could have also replaced ${\displaystyle {\mathcal {G}}}$ with an infinity groupoid. It is conjectured that the homotopy category of geometric realizations of infinity groupoids is equivalent to the homotopy category of homotopy types. This is called the homotopy hypothesis.

Non-example: standard n-simplex

It turns out the standard ${\displaystyle n}$-simplex ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$ is not a Kan complex ^{[6] pg 38}. The construction of a counter example in general can be found by looking at a low dimensional example, say ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{1}}$. Taking the map ${\displaystyle \Lambda _{0}^{2}\to \Delta ^{1}}$ sending

${\displaystyle {\begin{matrix}[0,2]\mapsto [0,0]&[0,1]\mapsto [0,1]\end{matrix}}}$

gives a counter example since it cannot be extended to a map ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{2}\to \Delta ^{1}}$ because the maps have to be order preserving. If there was a map, it would have to send

${\displaystyle {\begin{aligned}0\mapsto 0\\1\mapsto 1\\2\mapsto 0\end{aligned}}}$

but this isn't a map of simplicial sets.

Categorical properties

Simplicial enrichment and function complexes

For simplicial sets ${\displaystyle X,Y}$ there is an associated simplicial set called the function complex${\displaystyle {\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y)}$, where the simplices are defined as

${\displaystyle {\textbf {Hom}}_{n}(X,Y)={\text{Hom}}_{s{\text{Sets}}}(X\times \Delta ^{n},Y)}$

and for an ordinal map ${\displaystyle \theta$ :[m]\to [n]} there is an induced map

${\displaystyle \theta ^{*}:{\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y)_{n}\to {\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y)_{m}}$

(since the first factor of Hom is contravariant) defined by sending a map ${\displaystyle f:X\times \Delta ^{n}\to Y}$ to the composition

${\displaystyle X\times \Delta ^{m}\xrightarrow {1\times \theta } X\times \Delta ^{n}\xrightarrow {f} Y}$

Exponential law

This complex has the following exponential law of simplicial sets

${\displaystyle {\text{ev}}_{*}:{\text{Hom}}_{s{\text{Sets}}}(K,{\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y))\to {\text{Hom}}_{s{\text{Sets}}}(X\times K,Y)}$

which sends a map ${\displaystyle f:K\to {\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y)}$ to the composite map

${\displaystyle X\times K\xrightarrow {1\times g} X\times {\textbf {Hom}}(X,Y)\xrightarrow {ev} Y}$

where ${\displaystyle ev(x,f)=f(x,\iota _{n})}$ for ${\displaystyle \iota _{n}\in {\text{Hom}}_{\Delta }([n],[n])}$ lifted to the n-simplex ${\displaystyle \Delta ^{n}}$. ^

Kan fibrations and pull-backs

Given a (Kan) fibration ${\displaystyle p:X\to Y}$ and an inclusion of simplicial sets ${\displaystyle i:K\hookrightarrow L}$, there is a fibration ^{[4] pg 21}

${\displaystyle {\textbf {Hom}}(L,X)\xrightarrow {(i^{*},p_{*})} {\textbf {Hom}}(K,X)\times _{{\textbf {Hom}}(K,Y)}{\textbf {Hom}}(L,Y)}$

(where ${\displaystyle {\textbf {Hom}}}$ is in the function complex in the category of simplicial sets) induced from the commutative diagram

${\displaystyle {\begin{matrix}{\textbf {Hom}}(L,X)&\xrightarrow {p_{*}} &{\textbf {Hom}}(L,Y)\\i^{*}\downarrow &&\downarrow i^{*}\\{\textbf {Hom}}(K,X)&\xrightarrow {p_{*}} &{\textbf {Hom}}(K,Y)\end{matrix}}}$

where ${\displaystyle i^{*}}$ is the pull-back map given by pre-composiiton and ${\displaystyle p_{*}}$ is the pushforward map given by post-composition. In particular, the previous fibration implies ${\displaystyle p_{*}:{\textbf {Hom}}(L,X)\to {\textbf {Hom}}(L,Y)}$ and ${\displaystyle i^{*}:{\textbf {Hom}}(L,Y)\to {\textbf {Hom}}(K,Y)}$ are fibrations.

Applications

Homotopy groups of Kan complexes

The homotopy groups of a fibrant simplicial set may be defined combinatorially, using horns, in a way that agrees with the homotopy groups of the topological space which realizes it. For a Kan complex ${\displaystyle X}$ and a vertex ${\displaystyle x:\Delta ^{0}\to X}$, as a set ${\displaystyle \pi _{n}(X,x)}$ is defined as the set of maps ${\displaystyle \alpha$ :\Delta ^{n}\to X} of simplicial sets fitting into a certain commutative diagram:

${\displaystyle \pi _{n}(X,x)=\left\{\alpha$ :\Delta ^{n}\to X:{\begin{matrix}\Delta ^{n}&{\overset {\alpha }{\to }}&X\\\uparrow &&\uparrow x\\\partial \Delta ^{n}&\to &\Delta ^{0}\end{matrix}}\right\}}

Notice the fact ${\displaystyle \partial \Delta ^{n}}$ is mapped to a point is equivalent to the definition of the sphere ${\displaystyle S^{n}}$ as the quotient ${\displaystyle B^{n}/\partial B^{n}}$ for the standard unit ball

${\displaystyle B^{n}=\{x\in \mathbb {R} ^{n}:||x||_{eu}\leq 1\}}$

Defining the group structure requires a little more work. Essentially, given two maps ${\displaystyle \alpha ,\beta$ :\Delta ^{n}\to X} there is an associated ${\displaystyle (n+1)}$-simplice ${\displaystyle \omega$ :\Delta ^{n+1}\to X} such that ${\displaystyle d_{n}\omega$ :\Delta ^{n}\to X} gives their addition. This map is well-defined up to simplicial homotopy classes of maps, giving the group structure. Moreover, the groups ${\displaystyle \pi _{n}(X,x)}$ are Abelian for ${\displaystyle n\geq 2}$. For ${\displaystyle \pi _{0}(X)}$, it is defined as the homotopy classes ${\displaystyle [x]}$ of vertex maps ${\displaystyle x:\Delta ^{0}\to X}$.

Homotopy groups of simplicial sets

Using model categories, any simplicial set ${\displaystyle X}$ has a fibrant replacement ${\displaystyle {\hat {X}}}$ which is homotopy equivalent to ${\displaystyle X}$ in the homotopy category of simplicial sets. Then, the homotopy groups of ${\displaystyle X}$ can be defined as

${\displaystyle \pi _{n}(X,x):=\pi _{n}({\hat {X}},{\hat {x}})}$

where ${\displaystyle {\hat {x}}}$ is a lift of ${\displaystyle x:\Delta ^{0}\to X}$ to ${\displaystyle {\hat {X}}}$. These fibrant replacements can be thought of a topological analogue of resolutions of a chain complex (such as a projective resolution or a flat resolution).

See also

• Model category
• Simplicial homotopy theory
• Simplicially enriched category
• Weak Kan complex (also called quasi-category, ∞-category)
• ∞-groupoid
• Fibration of simplicial sets

References

1. See Goerss and Jardine, page 7
2. See May, page 2
3. May uses this simplicial definition; see page 25
4. Goerss, Paul G.; Jardin, John F. (2009). Simplicial Homotopy Theory. Birkhäuser Basel. ISBN   978-3-0346-0188-7. OCLC   837507571.
5. See May, page 3
6. Friedman, Greg (2016-10-03). "An elementary illustrated introduction to simplicial sets". arXiv: 0809.4221 [math.AT].

• An elementary illustrated introduction to simplicial sets

Bibliography

• Goerss, Paul G.; Jardine, John F. (1999). Simplicial Homotopy Theory. Basel: Birkhäuser Basel. doi:10.1007/978-3-0348-8707-6. ISBN   978-3-0348-9737-2. MR   1711612.
• May, J. Peter (1992) [1967]. Simplicial objects in algebraic topology. Chicago Lectures in Mathematics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. ISBN   0-226-51180-4. MR   1206474.