Plot
Violent criminal Vince and his girlfriend and partner-in-crime Fay rob a pair of Las Vegas mobsters of a briefcase containing $850,000, killing one of them in the process. During their getaway, the couple argue over what to do with the money and, having had enough of his controlling ways, Fay knocks Vince out and drives away with the money.
Jack Andrews is a widowed private investigator operating out of Reno. Guilt-ridden over his failure to save his wife from a car crash, he has accrued $10,000 in gambling debts and loan sharks are circling. Fay turns up at his office posing as a battered wife on the run from her abusive husband and offers him ten grand to fake her death so she can start a new life. Although he doubts Fay’s story, Jack feels sorry for her and agrees to help.
Jack and Fay stage her death at a motel, though unbeknownst to Jack, a matchbook with his name written in it is left in the room. Jack falls for Fay and agrees to meet her later at her motel, but after ditching the evidence-filled car in a lake he returns to find she has fled to Las Vegas, along with the remaining half of the money she owes him.
The next day, the police arrest Jack for Fay’s "murder" but release him due to insufficient evidence. Meanwhile, Vince reads about the murder in the paper and learns Jack’s name. Jack, believing Fay must have had a good reason to leave, prepares to follow her to Vegas, but is thwarted when the loan sharks return and take the rest of the advance she gave him. Shortly after, he is visited by Vince, who attacks him and demands to know where Fay is. Jack outwits him and escapes, leaving for Vegas in his car. The mob learn from the loan sharks that Jack has their money, and resolve to kill him.
Jack reaches Vegas and finds out from his partner, Alan, that Fay is staying at a hotel under an alias similar to the fake ID he gave her. Jack finds her gambling at the hotel casino’s craps table, though not before the pit boss spots the mob money she is using and calls the gangsters. Jack takes Fay to her room to get his money and sees the briefcase full of cash. Before he can find out what is really going on, a couple of mobsters barge in, looking for the money. When one of them prepares to kill them, Fay pulls a gun and shoots him dead while the other escapes. Jack and Fay flee in his car and Fay admits to him she stole the money from Vince after they stole it from the mob. Fay manages to persuade Jack she ran because she was afraid Vince would kill her.
Jack and Fay drive to a lakeside motel where they make love. Although he admits he does not trust her, Jack suggests they go to Maine to start a new life together, and Fay agrees. The next morning they hear on the radio the police are seeking them for the murder of the mobster, who was part of a powerful crime family. ‘Kill me again,’ says Fay, suggesting they fake their own deaths to escape. Jack calls Alan to say goodbye, unwittingly revealing their location.
Jack and Fay take a boat onto the lake where he explains his plan: they’ll blow up the boat to make it appear they died in an accident, then swim to shore and retrieve the money from a drop off before fleeing to Maine. Meanwhile, Vince tortures Alan to find out Fay and Jack’s whereabouts before killing him.
Jack leaves a reluctant and untrusting Fay at the motel while he drives to the drop off to bury the money. He stops to buy supplies at the Arizona border, thinks about driving away with the money, but decides to stick to the plan. He buries the money and supplies on an Indian reservation and returns to the motel where he finds Fay tied up by a gun-toting Vince, who demands to know where the money is. Jack calls Vince’s bluff, knowing he can’t kill him if he wants to find the money. Vince threatens to kill Fay instead, but again Jack calls his bluff, much to Fay’s dismay. Jack proposes a deal: he’ll take Fay and half the money and let Vince know in two days where the rest is. Vince ties Jack up and shuts him in the closet so he can think over his offer, but instead proceeds to rape Fay. She grabs the gun and shoots Vince, and she and Jack escape.
Their plan scuppered, Jack and Fay drive to the drop off to retrieve the money. Just as Jack digs up the case, Vince appears, alive and well, and Jack realises he has been tricked. Fay shoots him and he falls into the lake. She and Vince take the case and drive away in Jack’s car, only to find they too have been tricked: the case is empty. The cops appear and chase the couple to the border where they crash into a fuel tank, dying in the explosion. Jack, wounded but alive and in possession of the money, is rescued from the lake by a pair of Indians who drive him to safety.
Production
While working as a storyboarder on features like Robocop and Something Wild, John Dahl was also writing spec scripts with his writing partner David W. Warfield. When Warfield posed the question of how to get someone to utter the phrase ‘Kill me again’, the pair decided to make their next project a neo-noir, inspired by pulp fiction titles such as D.O.A.. [3]
Dahl and Warfield made a pact that they would accept offers to sell the script for $300,000 or above, otherwise they would make it themselves, with Warfield producing and Dahl directing. Having failed to garner offers above $250,000, the pair set about making the film themselves. Through Steve Golin and Sigurjón Sighvatsson’s production company they reached a deal with PolyGram to produce Kill Me Again, with Dahl directing. MGM agreed to co-finance the production if they could get Val Kilmer to star. [3]
Kilmer’s name was prominent at the time, having just starred in Willow. He ended up getting paid twice what he earned on that film for Kill Me Again. Dahl said that Kilmer was difficult to work with, although he helped in getting Joanne Whalley for the female lead. Dahl and the producers were interested in casting Whalley, who unbeknownst to them was married to Kilmer. When they mentioned her name to Kilmer he said, ‘Oh that’s interesting because I’m actually married to her.’ [3]
MGM and Kilmer were cool on the final product, and little money or effort was spent on promoting it. It received a small theatrical release, showing in around 200 theaters. Some good reviews were enough to persuade MGM to show it in one theater in Los Angeles, earning the film a positive review in the Los Angeles Times and an extended run in L.A. However, this was not enough to influence MGM into promoting the film further. [3]
