Killing of Laddie Gillett

Last updated

Killing of Laddie Gillett
Laddie Gillett portrait, published Sep 2021.jpg
Gillett in 2021
Date14 July 2021 (2021-07-14)
Timeca 9:30 pm local time
LocationPlacencia Beach Club, Placencia, Stann Creek
TypeUnlawful police killing
TargetTwo teenagers
PerpetratorTwo plain clothes police officers, one security guard
Deaths1 (Gillett)
Non-fatal injuries1 (Palacio)
Convicted1 (Martinez)
ConvictionsManslaughter by negligence
Sentence18 years

On 14 July 2021, at approximately 9:30 pm local time, in Placencia, Stann Creek, 14-year-old Laddie Gillett was shot and killed by police corporal Kareem Martinez. The incident sparked widespread protests in Belize, being popularly deemed an unlawful police killing. Martinez was found guilty of manslaughter by negligence for the killing on 21 April 2023, and sentenced to 18 years in prison.

Contents

Background

The use of excessive force (including fatal) by law enforcement in Belize is thought to be on the rise, following a yet unmitigated boom in violent and organised crime since the late 1990s. [n 1] A 2019 study by Hannes Warnecke-Berger of the University of Leipzig noted 'police brutality seems to have become an everyday practice [which includes] the beating of children in the streets, torture of suspects in custody as well as police killings.' [1] Similarly, a 2021 poll by the World Justice Project found that only 47 percent of respondents believed police do not use excessive force, with only 35 percent believing police were investigated for misconduct. [2]

Killing

On the night of 14 July, 14-year-old Laddie Gillett and his 19-year-old friend Thomas Palacio were making their way back to Chabil Mar Villas in Placencia, Stann Creek, where they were holidaying, at a brisk pace in order to beat the COVID-19 curfew, after having dropped off a female friend back at her resort. [n 2] Shortly after 9:30 pm local time, in front of the Placencia Beach Club, the boys came across two men in dark clothing confronting them with guns (who were not uniformed, and did not identify themselves as police officers, according to Palacio). [n 3] Believing they were about to be robbed at gunpoint, the boys immediately ran away from the armed men, whereupon Gillett was shot and killed by police corporal Kareem Martinez (with his 9 mm service pistol), while Palacio was tackled and physically assaulted by police constable Claude Augustine and a nearby security guard Devon Castillo. [n 4]

Aftermath

By 15 July, Martinez had been detained pending criminal and internal investigations. [3] On 16 July, the corporal was charged with manslaughter by negligence and granted bail of $8,000 while awaiting trial. [4] The internal investigation led to Martinez’s dismissal from the Police Department by the year's end. [5] The former corporal was found guilty of manslaughter by negligence on 21 April 2023, and sentenced to 18 years in Central Prison on 23 May. [n 5]

The incident sparked outrage across the country, with multiple candlelit vigils for Gillett, and protests demanding that Martinez be charged with murder, and further demanding police reform. [n 6] The Prime Minister, Johnny Briceno, condemned the incident, stating 'there must be consequences' for the killing, and agreeing that police needed continuous training on the proper use of lethal force. [6] The Commissioner of Police, Chester Williams, said the shooting was not a justifiable use of force. [7] The Minister of Youth, Kevin Bernard, echoed Briceno's and Williams's sentiments. [8] The Human Rights Commission denounced the killing and stressed that 'this kind of systematic abuse of authority by some police officers and their disregard of the humanity and dignity of Belizean citizens can no longer be countenanced.' [5] The Progressive Party condemned the 'recurrent issues of brutality' by the police and 'diminished charges assigned to officers involved […] the scandalously low rate of successful prosecution of said officers, and the light sentences accorded to the few that would be found guilty.' [5] The United Democratic Party called for 'a full and objective investigation,' urging the Police Department to ensure officers refrained from excessive force. [9]

Gillett's family called for the passing of Laddie's Law, which would establish civilian oversight of the Police Department, among other policing reforms. [10] They founded the Justice for Laddie Foundation within a year to 'to carry on Laddie's legacy and provide support for Belize's young people.' [11]

See also

Notes and references

Notes

  1. ↑ WB, p. 223.
  2. ↑ WJP, p. 7.
  3. ↑ Reporter, para 2-3; Amandala a, p. 37; Amandala c, pp. 1–2.
  4. ↑ State, sec 1A para 3; Amandala c, p. 1.
  5. 1 2 3 State, sec 1A para 3.
  6. ↑ 7 a, paras 1-4.
  7. ↑ State, sec 1A para 3; Loop, paras 5-7; Reporter, paras 1-2, 4; Amandala a, p. 37.
  8. ↑ Amandala i, paras 1-4.
  9. ↑ Reporter, para 13.
  10. ↑ Amandala e, p. 6.
  11. ↑ JFL, para 20.
  1. ↑ WB, for instance, found that the homicide rate in Belize has been steadily increasing since the late 1990s (pp. 4-6, 197, 209), noting that the vast majority of crime is often blamed on gangs by the state, scholars, and media (pp. 1, 8, 198, 209-210), and that the state often responds to such crime with brutal repression (pp. 1, 8, 198, 223-225).
  2. ↑ State, sec 1A para 3; Loop, paras 1, 3, 11; Reporter, paras 10-12; Amandala a, p. 1; Amandala b, p. 4. The COVID-19 regulations in effect at the time (Statutory Instrument No 74 of 2021) set a 6 pm curfew for unaccompanied and 10 pm curfew for accompanied minors on Wednesdays (Reporter, para 15). Gillett's uncle, Emil Bradley, claimed 'his nephew was only a couple of yards away from the condo that the family had rented [in Chabil Mar] and that he could see them [Gillett and Palacio] from where they were hanging out and could even shout over at them if need be' (Reporter, para 12). Palacio claimed that he and Gillett and their female friend had been having cake at the beach before dropping her off at her resort, a two minute walk from Chabil Mar (Amandala b, p. 4).
  3. ↑ State, sec 1A para 3; Amandala b, p. 4; 7, paras 1-3. The officers had been called in at circa 9:30 pm local time for suspicious activity by the security guard of a resort near the scene, according to the Police Department (Loop, para 4; Reporter, para 7; Amandala a, p. 1). According to the same, the guard and responding officers were on high alert that night as the aforementioned resort had allegedly seen multiple break in attempts the night prior (Reporter, para 7, 9). Gillett's biological uncle, Henry Gillett, noted that racism may have played a role in the level of distrust and aggression displayed by the guard and officers (Amandala d, p. 3). Gillett's adoptive family, the Bradley-Flemings, expressed similar disbelief as to what exactly could have been suspicious about Gillett and Palacio's having cake at the beach (Amandala e, pp. 6, 10).
  4. ↑ State, sec 1A para 3; Loop, paras 3-4, 9-10; Reporter, para 8; Amandala f, p. 42; Amandala h, pp. 1, 13. Gillett was pronounced dead on arrival at Placencia Polyclinic (Reporter, para 8; Amandala a, p. 1). Palacio reported he feared for his life at that point (State, sec 1A para 3; Amandala b, p. 4). Palacio's mother claimed that upon Gillett's death, Augustine asked Martinez, 'What will we do with this one?' (Amandala a, p. 37).
  5. ↑ Amandala f, pp. 1, 42; Amandala h, pp. 1, 13. As of the date of Martinez's conviction, Augustine had not been disciplined by the Police Department, though the court noted the threatening, physical assault, and false imprisonment of Palacio had been potentially criminal (Amandala h, p. 13).
  6. ↑ Civicus, para 1; Reporter, para 14; Amandala a, p. 37; Neal, p. 6; Amandala c, p. 2; Amandala d, p. 3; Lopez, pp. 5, 13; Amandala e, pp. 6, 10; Amandala f, p. 1. On 20 July in Camalote, Cayo, two men were detained for allegedly setting tyres on fire on a highway in protest of the killing (Civicus, para 1). A similar protest set for 1 August in Belize City was denied a permit by the Police Department (Civicus, para 1).

References

  1. "Approaching Laddie's One Year Anniversary on July 14th". Justice for Laddie (Website). Belize: Laddie Fdn. 22 June 2022.
  2. "Unjustified Force! Cop Kills Youth, 14, Who was Trying to Obey COVID-19 Curfew". The Reporter. Belize. 15 July 2021.
  3. "Belize: 14-Year-Old Fatally Shot by Police, Probe Launched". Loop. Jamaica. 16 July 2021.
  4. "Belize: Protesters Demand Justice for Teenager Killed by Police". Civicus Monitor. South Africa. 28 October 2021.
  5. 2021 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: Belize (Report). USA: State Dept. 12 April 2022.PD-icon.svg This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
  6. "Boy, 14, Killed by Police". Amandala. No. 3474. Belize. 16 July 2021.
  7. Neal RA (16 July 2021). "Outrage!". Amandala. No. 3474. Belize.
  8. "Laddie's Companion Sets Record Straight". Amandala. No. 3475. Belize. 20 July 2021.
  9. "PC Martinez Charged for Laddie's Death". Amandala. No. 3475. Belize. 20 July 2021.
  10. "Laddie's Death Sparks Weekend of Outcry". Amandala. No. 3475. Belize. 20 July 2021.
  11. Lopez M (20 July 2021). "Child Victim – Individual or Systemic Flaw?". Amandala. No. 3475. Belize.
  12. "Laddie Gillett: A Fallen Star, A Rising Angel". Amandala. No. 3476. Belize. 23 July 2021.
  13. "Former P.C. Gets 18 Years for Taking Laddie Gillett's Life". Amandala. No. 3650. Belize. 26 May 2023.
  14. WJP (2022). The Rule of Law in Belize: Key Findings from the General Population Poll 2021 (Report). USA: World Justice Project.
  15. Warnecke-Berger H (2019). Politics and Violence in Central America and the Caribbean. Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan Cham. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-89782-0. ISBN   978-3-319-89781-3. LCCN   2018942510.
  16. "Justice for Laddie Celebrated". Amandala. No. 3642. Belize. 25 April 2023.
  17. "One Last Run for Laddie". 7 News. Belize. 14 July 2022.
  18. "PM Says Police Need Better Training". 7 News. Belize. 21 July 2021.
  19. "Minister of Youth Speaks on Laddie's Death". Amandala. Belize. 28 July 2021.

16°31′30″N88°22′05″W / 16.52489°N 88.36794°W / 16.52489; -88.36794

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.