Killing of Muawanatul Chasanah

Last updated

Muawanatul Chasanah
Born1982
Indonesia
Died2 December 2001 (aged 19)
Bedok Reservoir, Singapore
Cause of death Peritonitis due to ruptured stomach
Occupation Domestic worker
Employer(s)Ng Hua Chye, Tan Chai Hong
Known forVictim of an abuse and murder case

On 2 December 2001, a 19-year-old Indonesian maid, Muawanatul Chasanah, was found beaten to death in a house by the Bedok Reservoir, Singapore.

Contents

Her killer was Ng Hua Chye, a tour guide and Chasanah's employer. Ng's wife, Tan Chai Hong, was also discovered to be involved. Both were arrested and charged in connection to the maid's death. [1] [2] Ng was eventually sentenced to 18 years and six months' imprisonment with 12 strokes of the cane for culpable homicide, while Ng's wife, who did not take part in the killing, was given a jail term of nine months for maid abuse and failing to make a police report on her husband's offences. [3]

Employment

In 2000, Chasanah, then 17 years old, travelled from Indonesia to Singapore to work as a maid. After she arrived in Singapore, she was employed by 47-year-old Ng Hua Chye and his wife, 30-year-old Tan Chai Hong (also known as Rainbow Tan), [4] who had a daughter and son. [5] Her first day of work began on 3 August 2000. [6]

Abuse and subsequent death

During her 9-month employment, Chasanah was subjected to a series of abuses by Ng and Tan. This occurred at both Ng and his sister's houses. [7] Each time she displeased Ng, he would repeatedly punch her, beat her with both a cane and a hammer, dump boiling water on her, or burn her with the ends of cigarettes. In one instance, after she drank his infant daughter's apple juice, Ng caned her until her face swelled up. [7]

Aside from physical abuse, she was also starved, most of her meals consisting of packets of instant noodles. When she began her job, she weighed 50 kg. On the day of her death, her weight had already dropped to 36 kg. [8]

Ng was also highly suspicious of Chasanah, claiming she wanted to "slip powders, herbs, and papers with Arabic writings" into the family's meals. He believed that this would make the family "obey her". [4]

In November 2001, Tan Chai Hong grabbed Chasanah's breasts after she failed to properly bathe her daughter. [2]

Death

On 1 December 2001, Chasanah was working in the home of Ng's sister. Ng accused the maid of stealing leftover porridge from his young daughter, later stating she was going to use the food to "cast a spell". [4] He punched her in the face, then kicked her in the stomach so hard that it ruptured. [9] [10] She vomited and fainted in the kitchen, afflicted by severe stomach pain. [7]

The following day, Ng stepped into the local police station, confessing to severely abusing her and kicking her in the stomach the previous day; he also expressed his fear that she may die. Paramedics were dispatched to Ng's flat, where they pronounced Chasanah dead on the scene. [11] She was found in a vomit-stained T-shirt and had a distended stomach. The autopsy reported that her body was covered in sores from what appeared to be an attack with the back of a hammer. Both her back and her neck were discoloured from an apparent scalding. [8] An autopsy report revealed that the maid had over 200 scars on her body. [12] Her cause of death was determined to be peritonitis that developed when her stomach ruptured. [13]

Arrest and sentencing of Ng and Tan

After the discovery of Chasanah's body, Ng, who surrendered himself at a police station, was arrested immediately. Originally charged with murder and facing the death penalty, he pled guilty to a reduced charge of culpable homicide, [1] after his lawyer Subhas Anandan made a plea bargain with the prosecution to reduce the murder charge since he voluntarily surrendered himself to the police before they arrested him. Ng also pleaded guilty to four out of seven charges of voluntarily causing hurt to the maid. The maximum penalty for manslaughter in Singapore was life imprisonment.

On 19 July 2002, Judicial Commissioner Choo Han Teck sentenced him to ten years in prison and ordered him to be caned six times for killing Chasanah. For the four maid abuse charges he was convicted of, he received an additional eight years and six months in prison and another six strokes of the cane, making it a total of 18+1⁄2 years imprisonment with 12 strokes of the cane. His sentence was the highest a maid abuser had received up to that point. [7]

Tan Chai Hong was also arrested. On 19 February 2003, magistrate Alvin Koh sentenced her to nine months’ prison time for grabbing and squeezing the maid's breasts. He considered adding a charge for not reporting her husband to the police, but decided against it. [2] While sentencing Tan, Koh remarked about the former offence: "this vicious attack which you inflicted on her breasts revealed your latent disregard for her dignity as a human being and as a woman." [2] However, Tan was granted a bail of S$5000 (US$3,706) and was subsequently released after paying the money. [2]

Reactions

Government response

Following Chasanah's death, the Indonesian government froze new foreign domestic worker contracts for a month in order to review the system. [14] [15]

Public response

A neighbour of Ng, a man named Mr Neo, commented on Chasanah's abuse and death, stating: "Even if I knew, I wouldn’t have called the police, it’s not my business. He can do what he wants, that’s his problem." In November 2002, this remark caused a group of Singaporeans to form an advocacy group called Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2), hoping to prevent any more acts of abuse against foreign domestic workers. [16]

In addition, Singaporean authorities believe that the publicity surrounding her death has assisted in reducing the number of reported maid abuse cases from 157 in 1997 to 43 in 2002. [14] The case was also re-enacted by Mediacorp's crime show True Files in 2003. [3]

Ng's lawyer Subhas Anandan also wrote about the case in his memoir. He said he was personally feeling repulsed at the extent of abuse suffered by the victim but he had to suppress his disgust to maintain a professional mind while managing his client's case. He also wondered how Ng, a father who dearly loved his children, could behave in such a barbaric way towards someone else's beloved daughter. [6]

The case was recalled nearly twenty years later when another convicted maid abuser Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who murdered her Burmese maid Piang Ngaih Don in 2016 and also abused her grievously, was sentenced to a much longer imprisonment term of 30 years for culpable homicide and assault on 22 June 2021, which reportedly surpassed that of Ng Hua Chye, who was released at this point of time, as the longest sentence ever meted out to a maid abuser in Singapore. Gaiyathiri, who was initially charged with murder, was also assisted by her 62-year-old mother Prema Naraynasamy, who was jailed for 17 years on multiple charges of maid abuse, and her husband Kevin Chelvam, who is currently on trial for maid abuse and removing the evidence of the abuse. [17] [18]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Capital punishment in Singapore</span>

Capital punishment in Singapore is a legal penalty. Executions in Singapore are carried out by long drop hanging, and usually take place at dawn. Thirty-three offences—including murder, drug trafficking, terrorism, use of firearms and kidnapping—warrant the death penalty under Singapore law.

Tay Yong Kwang is a Singaporean judge of the Supreme Court. He was first appointed Judicial Commissioner in 1997, appointed Judge in 2003, and appointed Judge of Appeal in 2016. He was noted for being the presiding judge in several notable cases that shocked the nation and made headlines in Singapore. He was most recently re-appointed for a further two year term on the Court of Appeal from 3 September 2024.

Choo Han Teck is a Singaporean judge of the Supreme Court. He was formerly a lawyer before his appointment to the court as a judge. It was revealed in 2021 that Choo was one of the defence lawyers representing Adrian Lim, the infamous Toa Payoh child killer who was executed in 1988 for charges of murdering a girl and boy as ritual sacrifices. In 1994, Choo also defended Phua Soy Boon, a jobless Singaporean who was hanged in 1995 for killing a moneylender.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Subhas Anandan</span> Singaporean criminal lawyer (1947–2015)

Subhas Anandan was a Singaporean criminal lawyer, who was known to have represented criminals in many high-profile cases that occurred in Singapore.

See Kee Oon is a Singaporean judge who is currently a Judge of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Josephus Tan</span> Singaporean lawyer

Josephus Tan Joon Liang, better known as Josephus Tan, is a Singaporean criminal defence lawyer.In 2015, Tan received the Singapore Youth Award.

Eugene Singarajah Thuraisingam is a Singaporean lawyer. He is the founder of the law firm Eugene Thuraisingam LLP, a law firm that specialises in international arbitration and criminal and commercial litigation. He is also known for his advocacy of human rights and for his opposition of the death penalty in Singapore. In relation to his domestic practice as a criminal lawyer in Singapore, Thuraisingam has defended many alleged suspects in high profile criminal trials, including those who were dissidents and critics of the government of Singapore. For his legal service for many defendants in the court of Singapore, Doyles Guide has named him as a leading criminal defence lawyer in Singapore in 2020.

On 30 October 2010, at Downtown East, Singapore, 19-year-old Darren Ng Wei Jie, a Singaporean student from Republic Polytechnic, was slashed by 12 youths from a rival gang after a staring incident between one of Ng's friends and one of these youths attacking him. Ng suffered from 28 knife wounds and died in Changi General Hospital five hours after the incident. The case was classified as murder, and the police arrested all the suspects. Six of them were charged with murder, but all except one were sentenced to serve lengthy jail terms with caning for culpable homicide, while the others were sentenced to varied jail terms and caning for rioting.

The President's Pleasure (TPP) in Singapore was a practice of indefinite imprisonment formerly applied to offenders who were convicted of capital offences but were below the age of 18 at the time of their crimes. Such offenders were not sentenced to death in accordance with the death penalty laws in Singapore; they were instead indefinitely detained by order of the President of Singapore. This is similarly practised contemporarily for offenders who were of unsound mind when they committed their crimes, who are thus indefinitely detained at prisons or medical facilities in Singapore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Piang Ngaih Don</span> 2016 case of a Myanmar maid abused to death in Singapore

On the morning of 26 July 2016, Burmese maid Piang Ngaih Don was found tortured, starved and beaten to death in a flat in Bishan, Singapore.

Maid abuse is the maltreatment or neglect of a person hired as a domestic worker, especially by the employer or by a household member of the employer. It is any act or failure to act that results in harm to that employee. It takes on numerous forms, including physical, sexual, emotional, and economic abuse. The majority of perpetrators tend to be female employers and their children. These acts may be committed for a variety of reasons, including to instil fear in the victim, discipline them, or act in a way desired by the abuser.

On 23 October 2016, a five-year-old boy was pronounced dead at a children's hospital in Singapore. He was found to have been a victim of child abuse by his conservative parents Azlin binte Arujunah and Ridzuan bin Mega Abdul Rahman for months leading up to his death. This involved both Azlin and Ridzuan using boiling hot water to scald the boy on several occasions, inflicting severe burns and scald injuries which caused the boy to die in hospital weeks after the first of the four scalding incidents. The couple was later arrested and charged with murder. To protect his surviving siblings' identities and their privacy, the boy was not named in the media.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sundarti Supriyanto</span> Former Indonesian maid who was jailed in Singapore for culpable homicide

Sundarti Supriyanto is a former Indonesian maid who killed her employer and her employer’s daughter in Bukit Merah, Singapore. She was originally in line for the death penalty when she faced two charges of murder under section 300(c) of the Penal Code for the two deaths, which became known as the “Bukit Merah double murders” in Singapore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Death of Annie Ee</span> 2015 fatal abuse case of an intellectually disabled waitress in Singapore

Annie Ee Yu Lian was a Singaporean waitress who was abused for eight months before she died on 13 April 2015 at the age of 26. Ee's abusers were her 31-year-old childhood friend, Tan Hui Zhen, and Tan's 38-year-old husband, Pua Hak Chuan, who were both her flatmates in the couple's four-room Woodlands flat. The cause of death was certified to be acute fat embolism as a result of the beatings Ee received from Tan and Pua. It was also revealed that Annie Ee had an intellectual disability, which was one of the factors behind the public outcry against the couple.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Life imprisonment in Singapore</span>

Life imprisonment is a legal penalty in Singapore. This sentence is applicable for more than forty offences under Singapore law, such as culpable homicide not amounting to murder, attempted murder, kidnapping by ransom, criminal breach of trust by a public servant, voluntarily causing grievous hurt with dangerous weapons, and trafficking of firearms, in addition to caning or a fine for certain offences that warrant life imprisonment.

On 25 June 2018, at Singapore's Choa Chu Kang, 17-year-old Zin Mar Nwe, a foreign maid from Myanmar, used a knife to stab her employer's mother-in-law, who was alleged to have abused the maid. The 70-year-old elderly victim, an Indian national, sustained 26 knife wounds and died from acute haemorrhage caused by the stabbing. Zin was arrested not long after the killing and charged with murder. Although the victim was initially named in the local and international media, her name was subsequently not reported to protect the identity of one of her family members who was underage.

On 13 April 2015, inside their condominium in Choa Chu Kang, Singapore, 26-year-old motion graphics designer Ng Yao Cheng was attacked and stabbed to death by his youngest brother during an argument. The suspect, 21-year-old polytechnic graduate Ng Yao Wei, was arrested and charged with murder. It was revealed through investigations and trial that Ng Yao Wei had been relentlessly abused by his older brother and this long-standing resentment culminated into the stabbing. After it came to light through psychiatric assessments that Ng was suffering from depression at the time of his brother's murder, Ng's murder charge was reduced to manslaughter and he was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment on 19 September 2016.

References

  1. 1 2 "Singapore man gets 18 and half years in jail for maid abuse". Asian Economic News. 22 July 2002. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 4 July 2021– via The Free Library.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 "Woman jailed nine months for maid abuse". The Star. 21 February 2003. Archived from the original on 11 July 2021. Retrieved 4 July 2021.
  3. 1 2 "True Files S2 Ep 12 Maid Abused To Death". meWATCH. Retrieved 10 July 2021.
  4. 1 2 3 "'Spells', torture and death". TODAY. 19 July 2002. p. 4. Retrieved 7 July 2021– via eresources.nlb.gov.sg.
  5. ↑ "Maid torturer gets 18 years in jail". TODAY. 20 July 2002. p. 5. Retrieved 7 July 2021– via eresources.nlb.gov.sg.
  6. 1 2 Anandan, Subhas (15 June 2015). The Best I Could. Marshall Cavendish International Asia Pte Ltd. ISBN   978-981-4677-88-2. Archived from the original on 31 May 2024. Retrieved 28 July 2022.
  7. 1 2 3 4 "Judicial caning in Singapore, July 2002 - CORPUN ARCHIVE sgj00207". The Straits Times. 20 July 2002. Archived from the original on 28 July 2022. Retrieved 6 July 2021– via corpun.com.
  8. 1 2 Anggraeni, Dewi (2006). Dreamseekers: Indonesian Women as Domestic Workers in Asia. Equinox Publishing. ISBN   978-979-3780-28-3. Archived from the original on 19 April 2023. Retrieved 28 July 2022.
  9. ↑ "18 years for man who killed maid" . The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
  10. ↑ "Plight of the maid: report lifts lid on global suffering" . The Independent. 1 April 2009. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
  11. ↑ Han Teck, Choo (19 July 2002). "Public Prosecutor v Ng Hua Chye [2002] SGHC 154" (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 8 July 2021.
  12. ↑ "Hell's kitchen for Singapore maids". The Age. 24 July 2002. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
  13. ↑ "Asians Oppose U.S. Attack on Iraq; Foreign Workers' Treatment in Israel, Singapore". WRMEA. 7 November 2002. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 8 July 2021.
  14. 1 2 Kammerer, Peter (25 February 2003). "Indonesia acts to protect its migrant workers". South China Morning Post. Archived from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 6 July 2021.
  15. ↑ "Malaysia employers look forward to hiring Indonesian domestic workers again, but fees remain a concern". CNA. Archived from the original on 18 April 2022. Retrieved 18 April 2022.
  16. ↑ Lyons, Lenore T. (1 October 2005). "Transient Workers Count Too? The intersection of citizenship and gender in Singapore's civil society" (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 9 July 2021. Retrieved 5 July 2021.
  17. ↑ "30 years' jail for woman who starved and tortured Myanmar maid to death". The Straits Times. 22 June 2021. Archived from the original on 29 June 2021. Retrieved 10 July 2021.
  18. ↑ "Fatal maid abuse: Woman gets more jail time for asking police officer son-in-law to remove CCTV recorder". TODAY. 26 June 2023. Archived from the original on 26 June 2023. Retrieved 31 May 2024.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.