| Season(s) | Regular season | Postseason' |
|---|
| 2025 | Nathan Rourke (16) / Jeremiah Masoli (2) | Nathan Rourke (2) |
| 2024 | Vernon Adams (9) / Jake Dolegala (1) / Nathan Rourke (8) | Vernon Adams (1) |
| 2023 | Vernon Adams (16) / Dane Evans (2) | Vernon Adams (2) |
| 2022 | Nathan Rourke (10) / Michael O'Connor (1) / Antonio Pipkin (1) / Vernon Adams (6) | Nathan Rourke (2) |
| 2021 | Michael Reilly (12) / Nathan Rourke (2) | |
| 2020 | Season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2019 | Michael Reilly (16) / Danny O'Brien (2) |
| 2018 | Travis Lulay (12) / Jonathon Jennings (6) | Travis Lulay (1) |
| 2017 | Jonathon Jennings (14) / Travis Lulay (4) |
| 2016 | Jonathon Jennings (18) | Jonathon Jennings (2) |
| 2015 | Travis Lulay (10) / Jonathon Jennings (6) / John Beck (2) | Jonathon Jennings (1) |
| 2014 | Kevin Glenn (17) / Travis Lulay (1) | Kevin Glenn (1) |
| 2013 | Travis Lulay (11) / Thomas DeMarco (6) / Buck Pierce (1) | Travis Lulay (1) |
| 2012 | Travis Lulay (16) / Michael Reilly (2) | Travis Lulay (1) |
| 2011 | Travis Lulay (18) | Travis Lulay (2) |
| 2010 | Travis Lulay (9) / Casey Printers (8) / Jarious Jackson (1) | Travis Lulay (1) |
| 2009 | Buck Pierce (12) / Jarious Jackson (3) / Casey Printers (3) | Casey Printers (2) |
| 2008 | Buck Pierce (11) / Jarious Jackson (7) | Buck Pierce (2) |
| 2007 | Jarious Jackson (11) / Buck Pierce (4) / Dave Dickenson (3) | Jarious Jackson (1) |
| 2006 | Dave Dickenson (12) / Buck Pierce (6) | Dave Dickenson (2) |
| 2005 | Dave Dickenson (11) / Casey Printers (6) / Buck Pierce (1) | Dave Dickenson (1) |
| 2004 | Casey Printers (14) / Dave Dickenson (4) | Casey Printers (1) / Dave Dickenson (1) |
| 2003 | Dave Dickenson (17) / Spergon Wynn (1) | Spergon Wynn (1) |
| 2002 | Damon Allen (18) | Damon Allen (1) |
| 2001 | Damon Allen (16) / Tony Corbin (2) | Damon Allen (1) |
| 2000 | Damon Allen (18) | Damon Allen (3) |
| 1999 | Damon Allen (18) | Damon Allen (1) |
| 1998 | Damon Allen (18) | Damon Allen (1) |
| 1997 | Damon Allen (18) | Damon Allen (1) |
| 1996 | Damon Allen (13) / Andre Ware (4) / Giulio Caravatta (1) | |
| 1995 | Danny McManus (17) / Giulio Caravatta (1) | Danny McManus (1) |
| 1994 | Kent Austin (15) / Danny McManus (3) | Kent Austin (2) / Danny McManus (1) |
| 1993 | Danny Barrett (15) / Danny McManus (3) | Danny Barrett (1) |
| 1992 | Danny Barrett (10) / Tony Kimbrough (4) / Michael Johnson (2) / Gilbert Renfroe (2) | |
| 1991 | Doug Flutie (18) | Doug Flutie (1) |
| 1990 | Joe Paopao (9) / Doug Flutie (8) / Rickey Foggie (1) | |
| 1989 | Matt Dunigan (18) | |
| 1988 | Matt Dunigan (17) / Rickey Foggie (1) |
| 1987 | Roy Dewalt (16) / Greg Vavra (2) |
| 1986 | Roy Dewalt (18) |
| 1985 | Roy Dewalt (16) |
| 1984 | Roy Dewalt (12) / Tim Cowan (4) |
| 1983 | Roy Dewalt (16) |
| 1982 | Roy Dewalt (8) / Joe Paopao (8) |
| 1981 | Roy Dewalt (1) / Joe Paopao (15) |
| 1980 | Roy Dewalt (6) / Joe Paopao (9) / Mike Nott (1) |
| 1979 | Jerry Tagge (8) / Joe Paopao (8) |
| 1978 | Jerry Tagge (15) / Gary Keithley (1) |
| 1977 | Jerry Tagge (15) / Gary Keithley (1) |
| 1976 | Eric Guthrie (11) / Rick Cassata (3) / John Sciarra (2) |
| 1975 | Peter Liske (11) / Eric Guthrie (2) / Don Moorhead (3) |
| 1974 | Don Moorhead (14) / Peter Liske (2) |
| 1973 | Don Moorhead (12) / Carl Douglas (4) |
| 1972 | Don Moorhead (15) / Don Bunce (1) |
| 1971 | Don Moorhead (9) / Paul Brothers (7) |
| 1970 | Paul Brothers (16) |
| 1969 | Paul Brothers (16) |
| 1968 | Paul Brothers (9) / Pete Ohler (6) / Jackie Parker (1) |
| 1967 | Bernie Faloney (15) / Henry Schichtle (1) |
| 1966 | Joe Kapp (16) |
| 1965 | Joe Kapp (16) |
| 1964 | Joe Kapp (16) |
| 1963 | Joe Kapp (16) |
| 1962 | Joe Kapp (16) |
| 1961 | Joe Kapp (11) / Jim Walden (3) / Earl Keeley (1) / Bob Schloredt (1) |
| 1960 | Jim Walden (10) / Randy Duncan (6) |
| 1959 | Randy Duncan (16) |
| 1958 | George Herring (10) / Al Dorow (6) |
| 1957 | Maury Duncan (13) / Ron Vann (3) |
| 1956 | Jerry Gustafson (10) / Tony Teresa (4) / Arnie Galiffa (1) / Primo Villanueva (1) |
| 1955 | Arnie Galiffa (13) / Ron Clinkscale (3) |
| 1954 | John Mazur (10) / Gerry Tuttle (4) / Gene Robillard (1) |
|
