Many-body localization

Last updated

Many-body localization (MBL) is a dynamical phenomenon occurring in isolated many-body quantum systems. It is characterized by the system failing to reach thermal equilibrium, and retaining a memory of its initial condition in local observables for infinite times. [1]

Contents

Thermalization and localization

Textbook quantum statistical mechanics [2] assumes that systems go to thermal equilibrium (thermalization). The process of thermalization erases local memory of the initial conditions. In textbooks, thermalization is ensured by coupling the system to an external environment or "reservoir," with which the system can exchange energy. What happens if the system is isolated from the environment, and evolves according to its own Schrödinger equation? Does the system still thermalize?

Quantum mechanical time evolution is unitary and formally preserves all information about the initial condition in the quantum state at all times. However, a quantum system generically contains a macroscopic number of degrees of freedom, but can only be probed through few-body measurements which are local in real space. The meaningful question then becomes whether accessible local measurements display thermalization.

This question can be formalized by considering the quantum mechanical density matrix ρ of the system. If the system is divided into a subregion A (the region being probed) and its complement B (everything else), then all information that can be extracted by measurements made on A alone is encoded in the reduced density matrix . If, in the long time limit, approaches a thermal density matrix at a temperature set by the energy density in the state, then the system has "thermalized," and no local information about the initial condition can be extracted from local measurements. This process of "quantum thermalization" may be understood in terms of B acting as a reservoir for A. In this perspective, the entanglement entropy of a thermalizing system in a pure state plays the role of thermal entropy. [3] [4] [5] Thermalizing systems therefore generically have extensive or "volume law" entanglement entropy at any non-zero temperature. [6] [7] [8] They also generically obey the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). [9] [10] [11]

In contrast, if fails to approach a thermal density matrix even in the long time limit, and remains instead close to its initial condition , then the system retains forever a memory of its initial condition in local observables. This latter possibility is referred to as "many body localization," and involves B failing to act as a reservoir for A. A system in a many body localized phase exhibits MBL, and continues to exhibit MBL even when subject to arbitrary local perturbations. Eigenstates of systems exhibiting MBL do not obey the ETH, and generically follow an "area law" for entanglement entropy (i.e. the entanglement entropy scales with the surface area of subregion A). A brief list of properties differentiating thermalizing and MBL systems is provided below.

History

MBL was first proposed by P.W. Anderson in 1958 [22] as a possibility that could arise in strongly disordered quantum systems. The basic idea was that if particles all live in a random energy landscape, then any rearrangement of particles would change the energy of the system. Since energy is a conserved quantity in quantum mechanics, such a process can only be virtual and cannot lead to any transport of particle number or energy.

While localization for single particle systems was demonstrated already in Anderson's original paper (coming to be known as Anderson localization), the existence of the phenomenon for many particle systems remained a conjecture for decades. In 1980 Fleishman and Anderson [23] demonstrated the phenomenon survived the addition of interactions to lowest order in perturbation theory. In a 1998 study, [24] the analysis was extended to all orders in perturbation theory, in a zero-dimensional system, and the MBL phenomenon was shown to survive. In 2005 [25] and 2006, [26] this was extended to high orders in perturbation theory in high dimensional systems. MBL was argued to survive at least at low energy density. A series of numerical works [27] [14] [28] [29] provided further evidence for the phenomenon in one dimensional systems, at all energy densities (“infinite temperature”). Finally, in 2014 [30] Imbrie presented a proof of MBL for certain one dimensional spin chains with strong disorder, with the localization being stable to arbitrary local perturbations – i.e. the systems were shown to be in a many body localized phase.

It is now believed that MBL can arise also in periodically driven "Floquet" systems where energy is conserved only modulo the drive frequency. [31] [32] [33]

Emergent integrability

Many body localized systems exhibit a phenomenon known as emergent integrability. In a non-interacting Anderson insulator, the occupation number of each localized single particle orbital is separately a local integral of motion. It was conjectured [34] [35] (and proven by Imbrie) that a similar extensive set of local integrals of motion should also exist in the MBL phase. Consider for specificity a one dimensional spin-1/2 chain with Hamiltonian

where X, Y and Z are Pauli operators, and hI are random variables drawn from a distribution of some width W. When the disorder is strong enough (W>Wc) that all eigenstates are localized, then there exists a local unitary transformation to new variables τ such that

where τ are Pauli operators that are related to the physical Pauli operators by a local unitary transformation, the ... indicates additional terms which only involve τz operators, and the coefficients fall off exponentially with distance. This Hamiltonian manifestly contains an extensive number of localized integrals of motion or "l-bits" (the operators τzi, which all commute with the Hamiltonian). If the original Hamiltonian is perturbed, the l-bits get redefined, but the integrable structure survives.

Exotic orders

MBL enables the formation of exotic forms of quantum order that could not arise in thermal equilibrium, through the phenomenon of localization-protected quantum order. [36] A form of localization-protected quantum order, arising only in periodically driven systems, is the Floquet time crystal. [37] [38] [39] [40] [41]

Experimental realizations

A number of experiments have been reported observing the MBL phenomenon. [42] [43] [44] [45] Most of these experiments involve synthetic quantum systems, such as assemblies of ultracold atoms or trapped ions. [46] Experimental explorations of the phenomenon in solid state systems are still in their infancy.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quantum entanglement</span> Correlation between quantum systems

Quantum entanglement is the phenomenon that occurs when a duet of particles are generated, interact, or share spatial proximity in such a way that the quantum state of each particle of the group cannot be described independently of the state of the others, including when the particles are separated by a large distance. The topic of quantum entanglement is at the heart of the disparity between classical and quantum physics: entanglement is a primary feature of quantum mechanics not present in classical mechanics.

In the interpretation of quantum mechanics, a local hidden-variable theory is a hidden-variable theory that satisfies the principle of locality. These are models, usually deterministic, that attempt to account for the probabilistic features of quantum mechanics via the mechanism of underlying, but inaccessible variables, with the additional requirement that distant events be statistically independent.

In physics, thermalisation is the process of physical bodies reaching thermal equilibrium through mutual interaction. In general the natural tendency of a system is towards a state of equipartition of energy and uniform temperature that maximizes the system's entropy. Thermalisation, thermal equilibrium, and temperature are therefore important fundamental concepts within statistical physics, statistical mechanics, and thermodynamics; all of which are a basis for many other specific fields of scientific understanding and engineering application.

Quantum metrology is the study of making high-resolution and highly sensitive measurements of physical parameters using quantum theory to describe the physical systems, particularly exploiting quantum entanglement and quantum squeezing. This field promises to develop measurement techniques that give better precision than the same measurement performed in a classical framework. Together with quantum hypothesis testing, it represents an important theoretical model at the basis of quantum sensing.

In physics, the no-broadcasting theorem is a result of quantum information theory. In the case of pure quantum states, it is a corollary of the no-cloning theorem. The no-cloning theorem for pure states says that it is impossible to create two copies of an unknown state given a single copy of the state. Since quantum states cannot be copied in general, they cannot be broadcast. Here, the word "broadcast" is used in the sense of conveying the state to two or more recipients. For multiple recipients to each receive the state, there must be, in some sense, a way of duplicating the state. The no-broadcast theorem generalizes the no-cloning theorem for mixed states.

In quantum optics, a NOON state or N00N state is a quantum-mechanical many-body entangled state:

The topological entanglement entropy or topological entropy, usually denoted by , is a number characterizing many-body states that possess topological order.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Subir Sachdev</span> Indian physicist

Subir Sachdev is Herchel Smith Professor of Physics at Harvard University specializing in condensed matter. He was elected to the U.S. National Academy of Sciences in 2014, and received the Lars Onsager Prize from the American Physical Society and the Dirac Medal from the ICTP in 2018. He was a co-editor of the Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics from 2017–2019.

The SP formula for the dephasing rate of a particle that moves in a fluctuating environment unifies various results that have been obtained, notably in condensed matter physics, with regard to the motion of electrons in a metal. The general case requires to take into account not only the temporal correlations but also the spatial correlations of the environmental fluctuations. These can be characterized by the spectral form factor , while the motion of the particle is characterized by its power spectrum . Consequently, at finite temperature the expression for the dephasing rate takes the following form that involves S and P functions:

In quantum many-body physics, topological degeneracy is a phenomenon in which the ground state of a gapped many-body Hamiltonian becomes degenerate in the limit of large system size such that the degeneracy cannot be lifted by any local perturbations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Time crystal</span> Structure that repeats in time; a novel type or phase of non-equilibrium matter

In condensed matter physics, a time crystal is a quantum system of particles whose lowest-energy state is one in which the particles are in repetitive motion. The system cannot lose energy to the environment and come to rest because it is already in its quantum ground state. Because of this, the motion of the particles does not really represent kinetic energy like other motion; it has "motion without energy". Time crystals were first proposed theoretically by Frank Wilczek in 2012 as a time-based analogue to common crystals – whereas the atoms in crystals are arranged periodically in space, the atoms in a time crystal are arranged periodically in both space and time. Several different groups have demonstrated matter with stable periodic evolution in systems that are periodically driven. In terms of practical use, time crystals may one day be used as quantum computer memory.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quantum scar</span>

Quantum scarring refers to a phenomenon where the eigenstates of a classically chaotic quantum system have enhanced probability density around the paths of unstable classical periodic orbits. The instability of the periodic orbit is a decisive point that differentiates quantum scars from the more trivial observation that the probability density is enhanced in the neighborhood of stable periodic orbits. The latter can be understood as a purely classical phenomenon, a manifestation of the Bohr correspondence principle, whereas in the former, quantum interference is essential. As such, scarring is both a visual example of quantum-classical correspondence, and simultaneously an example of a (local) quantum suppression of chaos.

The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis is a set of ideas which purports to explain when and why an isolated quantum mechanical system can be accurately described using equilibrium statistical mechanics. In particular, it is devoted to understanding how systems which are initially prepared in far-from-equilibrium states can evolve in time to a state which appears to be in thermal equilibrium. The phrase "eigenstate thermalization" was first coined by Mark Srednicki in 1994, after similar ideas had been introduced by Josh Deutsch in 1991. The principal philosophy underlying the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis is that instead of explaining the ergodicity of a thermodynamic system through the mechanism of dynamical chaos, as is done in classical mechanics, one should instead examine the properties of matrix elements of observable quantities in individual energy eigenstates of the system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christopher Monroe</span> American physicist

Christopher Roy Monroe is an American physicist and engineer in the areas of atomic, molecular, and optical physics and quantum information science, especially quantum computing. He directs one of the leading research and development efforts in ion trap quantum computing. Monroe is the Gilhuly Family Presidential Distinguished Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering and Physics at Duke University and is College Park Professor of Physics at the University of Maryland and Fellow of the Joint Quantum Institute and Joint Center for Quantum Computer Science. He is also co-founder and chief scientist at IonQ, Inc.

Quantum illumination is a paradigm for target detection that employs quantum entanglement between a signal electromagnetic mode and an idler electromagnetic mode, as well as joint measurement of these modes. The signal mode is propagated toward a region of space, and it is either lost or reflected, depending on whether a target is absent or present, respectively. In principle, quantum illumination can be beneficial even if the original entanglement is completely destroyed by a lossy and noisy environment.

Stochastic thermodynamics is an emergent field of research in statistical mechanics that uses stochastic variables to better understand the non-equilibrium dynamics present in many microscopic systems such as colloidal particles, biopolymers, enzymes, and molecular motors.

A fracton is an emergent topological quasiparticle excitation which is immobile when in isolation. Many theoretical systems have been proposed in which fractons exist as elementary excitations. Such systems are known as fracton models. Fractons have been identified in various CSS codes as well as in symmetric tensor gauge theories.

Many-body localization (MBL) is a dynamical phenomenon which leads to the breakdown of equilibrium statistical mechanics in isolated many-body systems. Such systems never reach local thermal equilibrium, and retain local memory of their initial conditions for infinite times. One can still define a notion of phase structure in these out-of-equilibrium systems. Strikingly, MBL can even enable new kinds of exotic orders that are disallowed in thermal equilibrium – a phenomenon that goes by the name of localization-protected quantum order (LPQO) or eigenstate order.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electron-on-helium qubit</span> Quantum bit

An electron-on-helium qubit is a quantum bit for which the orthonormal basis states |0⟩ and |1⟩ are defined by quantized motional states or alternatively the spin states of an electron trapped above the surface of liquid helium. The electron-on-helium qubit was proposed as the basic element for building quantum computers with electrons on helium by Platzman and Dykman in 1999. 

David Alan Huse is an American theoretical physicist, specializing in statistical physics and condensed matter physics.

References

  1. Nandkishore, Rahul; Huse, David A. (2015). "Many-Body Localization and Thermalization in Quantum Statistical Mechanics". Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics. 6 (1): 15–38. arXiv: 1404.0686 . Bibcode:2015ARCMP...6...15N. doi:10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-031214-014726. ISSN   1947-5454. S2CID   118465889.
  2. Sakurai JJ. 1985. Modern Quantum Mechanics. Menlo Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings
  3. Deutsch, J M (July 26, 2010). "Thermodynamic entropy of a many-body energy eigenstate". New Journal of Physics. 12 (7): 075021. arXiv: 0911.0056 . doi:10.1088/1367-2630/12/7/075021. S2CID   119180376.
  4. Santos, Lea F.; Polkovnikov, Anatoli; Rigol, Marcos (July 5, 2012). "Weak and strong typicality in quantum systems". Physical Review E. 86 (1): 010102. arXiv: 1202.4764 . doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.86.010102 . PMID   23005351.
  5. Deutsch, J. M.; Li, Haibin; Sharma, Auditya (April 30, 2013). "Microscopic origin of thermodynamic entropy in isolated systems". Physical Review E. 87 (4): 042135. arXiv: 1202.2403 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.87.042135. PMID   23679399. S2CID   699412.
  6. Garrison, James R.; Grover, Tarun (April 30, 2018). "Does a Single Eigenstate Encode the Full Hamiltonian?". Physical Review X. 8 (2): 021026. arXiv: 1503.00729 . doi: 10.1103/PhysRevX.8.021026 .
  7. Dymarsky, Anatoly; Lashkari, Nima; Liu, Hong (January 25, 2018). "Subsystem eigenstate thermalization hypothesis". Physical Review E. 97 (1): 012140. doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.97.012140. hdl: 1721.1/114450 . PMID   29448325.
  8. Huang, Yichen (January 2019). "Universal eigenstate entanglement of chaotic local Hamiltonians". Nuclear Physics B. 938: 594–604. doi: 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2018.09.013 .
  9. Deutsch, J. M. (February 1, 1991). "Quantum statistical mechanics in a closed system". Physical Review A. 43 (4): 2046–2049. Bibcode:1991PhRvA..43.2046D. doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.43.2046. PMID   9905246. S2CID   40633146.
  10. Srednicki, Mark (August 1, 1994). "Chaos and quantum thermalization". Physical Review E. 50 (2): 888–901. arXiv: cond-mat/9403051 . Bibcode:1994PhRvE..50..888S. doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.50.888. PMID   9962049. S2CID   16065583.
  11. Rigol, Marcos; Dunjko, Vanja; Olshanii, Maxim (April 2008). "Thermalization and its mechanism for generic isolated quantum systems". Nature. 452 (7189): 854–858. arXiv: 0708.1324 . Bibcode:2008Natur.452..854R. doi:10.1038/nature06838. PMID   18421349. S2CID   4384040.
  12. Nandkishore, Rahul; Gopalakrishnan, Sarang; Huse, David A. (2014). "Spectral features of a many-body-localized system weakly coupled to a bath". Physical Review B. 90 (6): 064203. arXiv: 1402.5971 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.90.064203. ISSN   1098-0121. S2CID   118568500.
  13. Kim, Hyungwon; Huse, David A. (2013). "Ballistic Spreading of Entanglement in a Diffusive Nonintegrable System". Physical Review Letters. 111 (12): 127205. arXiv: 1306.4306 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.127205. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   24093298. S2CID   41548576.
  14. 1 2 Žnidarič, Marko; Prosen, Tomaž; Prelovšek, Peter (February 25, 2008). "Many-body localization in the Heisenberg XXZ magnet in a random field". Physical Review B. 77 (6): 064426. arXiv: 0706.2539 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.77.064426. S2CID   119132600.
  15. Bardarson, Jens H.; Pollmann, Frank; Moore, Joel E. (2012). "Unbounded Growth of Entanglement in Models of Many-Body Localization". Physical Review Letters. 109 (1): 017202. arXiv: 1202.5532 . doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.017202 . ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   23031128.
  16. Huang, Yichen (May 2017). "Entanglement dynamics in critical random quantum Ising chain with perturbations" (PDF). Annals of Physics. 380: 224–227. doi:10.1016/j.aop.2017.02.018. S2CID   44548875.
  17. Huang, Yichen; Zhang, Yong-Liang; Chen, Xie (July 2017). "Out-of-time-ordered correlators in many-body localized systems" (PDF). Annalen der Physik. 529 (7): 1600318. doi:10.1002/andp.201600318. S2CID   42690831.
  18. Fan, Ruihua; Zhang, Pengfei; Shen, Huitao; Zhai, Hui (May 2017). "Out-of-time-order correlation for many-body localization". Science Bulletin. 62 (10): 707–711. arXiv: 1608.01914 . doi: 10.1016/j.scib.2017.04.011 .
  19. He, Rong-Qiang; Lu, Zhong-Yi (February 10, 2017). "Characterizing many-body localization by out-of-time-ordered correlation". Physical Review B. 95 (5): 054201. arXiv: 1608.03586 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.95.054201. S2CID   119268185.
  20. Swingle, Brian; Chowdhury, Debanjan (February 21, 2017). "Slow scrambling in disordered quantum systems". Physical Review B. 95 (6): 060201. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.95.060201. hdl: 1721.1/107244 . S2CID   53485500.
  21. Chen, Xiao; Zhou, Tianci; Huse, David A.; Fradkin, Eduardo (July 2017). "Out-of-time-order correlations in many-body localized and thermal phases". Annalen der Physik. 529 (7): 1600332. arXiv: 1610.00220 . doi:10.1002/andp.201600332. S2CID   119201477.
  22. Anderson, P. W. (1958). "Absence of Diffusion in Certain Random Lattices". Physical Review. 109 (5): 1492–1505. Bibcode:1958PhRv..109.1492A. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.109.1492. ISSN   0031-899X.
  23. Fleishman, L.; Anderson, P. W. (1980). "Interactions and the Anderson transition". Physical Review B. 21 (6): 2366–2377. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.21.2366. ISSN   0163-1829.
  24. Altshuler, Boris L.; Gefen, Yuval; Kamenev, Alex; Levitov, Leonid S. (1997). "Quasiparticle Lifetime in a Finite System: A Nonperturbative Approach". Physical Review Letters. 78 (14): 2803–2806. arXiv: cond-mat/9609132 . Bibcode:1997PhRvL..78.2803A. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.2803. ISSN   0031-9007. S2CID   18852288.
  25. Gornyi, I. V.; Mirlin, A. D.; Polyakov, D. G. (2005). "Interacting Electrons in Disordered Wires: Anderson Localization and Low-TTransport". Physical Review Letters. 95 (20): 206603. arXiv: cond-mat/0506411 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.95.206603. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   16384079. S2CID   39376817.
  26. Basko, D.M.; Aleiner, I.L.; Altshuler, B.L. (2006). "Metal–insulator transition in a weakly interacting many-electron system with localized single-particle states". Annals of Physics. 321 (5): 1126–1205. arXiv: cond-mat/0506617 . Bibcode:2006AnPhy.321.1126B. doi:10.1016/j.aop.2005.11.014. ISSN   0003-4916. S2CID   18345541.
  27. Oganesyan, Vadim; Huse, David A. (2007). "Localization of interacting fermions at high temperature". Physical Review B. 75 (15): 155111. arXiv: cond-mat/0610854 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.75.155111. ISSN   1098-0121. S2CID   119488834.
  28. Pal, Arijeet; Huse, David A. (2010). "Many-body localization phase transition". Physical Review B. 82 (17): 174411. arXiv: 1010.1992 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.82.174411. ISSN   1098-0121. S2CID   41528861.
  29. Serbyn, Maksym; Papić, Z.; Abanin, D. A. (2014). "Quantum quenches in the many-body localized phase". Physical Review B. 90 (17): 174302. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.90.174302. hdl: 1721.1/91499 . ISSN   1098-0121. S2CID   18658716.
  30. Imbrie, John Z. (2016). "On Many-Body Localization for Quantum Spin Chains". Journal of Statistical Physics. 163 (5): 998–1048. arXiv: 1403.7837 . doi:10.1007/s10955-016-1508-x. ISSN   0022-4715. S2CID   11250762.
  31. D’Alessio, Luca; Polkovnikov, Anatoli (2013). "Many-body energy localization transition in periodically driven systems". Annals of Physics. 333: 19–33. arXiv: 1210.2791 . doi:10.1016/j.aop.2013.02.011. ISSN   0003-4916. S2CID   118476386.
  32. Lazarides, Achilleas; Das, Arnab; Moessner, Roderich (2015). "Fate of Many-Body Localization Under Periodic Driving". Physical Review Letters. 115 (3): 030402. arXiv: 1410.3455 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.030402. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   26230771. S2CID   28538293.
  33. Ponte, Pedro; Papić, Z.; Huveneers, François; Abanin, Dmitry A. (2015). "Many-Body Localization in Periodically Driven Systems" (PDF). Physical Review Letters. 114 (14): 140401. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.140401. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   25910094. S2CID   38608177.
  34. Serbyn, Maksym; Papić, Z.; Abanin, Dmitry A. (2013). "Local Conservation Laws and the Structure of the Many-Body Localized States". Physical Review Letters. 111 (12): 127201. arXiv: 1305.5554 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.127201. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   24093294. S2CID   13006260.
  35. Huse, David A.; Nandkishore, Rahul; Oganesyan, Vadim (2014). "Phenomenology of fully many-body-localized systems". Physical Review B. 90 (17): 174202. arXiv: 1305.4915 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.90.174202. ISSN   1098-0121. S2CID   5553355.
  36. Huse, David A.; Nandkishore, Rahul; Oganesyan, Vadim; Pal, Arijeet; Sondhi, S. L. (2013). "Localization-protected quantum order". Physical Review B. 88 (1): 014206. arXiv: 1304.1158 . Bibcode:2013PhRvB..88a4206H. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.88.014206 . ISSN   1098-0121.
  37. Khemani, Vedika; Lazarides, Achilleas; Moessner, Roderich; Sondhi, S. L. (2016). "Phase Structure of Driven Quantum Systems". Physical Review Letters. 116 (25): 250401. arXiv: 1508.03344 . Bibcode:2016PhRvL.116y0401K. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.250401 . ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   27391704.
  38. Else, Dominic V.; Bauer, Bela; Nayak, Chetan (2016). "Floquet Time Crystals". Physical Review Letters. 117 (9): 090402. arXiv: 1603.08001 . Bibcode:2016PhRvL.117i0402E. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.117.090402. ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   27610834. S2CID   1652633.
  39. von Keyserlingk, C. W.; Khemani, Vedika; Sondhi, S. L. (2016). "Absolute stability and spatiotemporal long-range order in Floquet systems". Physical Review B. 94 (8): 085112. arXiv: 1605.00639 . Bibcode:2016PhRvB..94h5112V. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevB.94.085112 . ISSN   2469-9950.
  40. Zhang, J.; Hess, P. W.; Kyprianidis, A.; Becker, P.; Lee, A.; Smith, J.; Pagano, G.; Potirniche, I.-D.; Potter, A. C.; Vishwanath, A.; Yao, N. Y.; Monroe, C. (2017). "Observation of a discrete time crystal". Nature. 543 (7644): 217–220. arXiv: 1609.08684 . Bibcode:2017Natur.543..217Z. doi:10.1038/nature21413. ISSN   0028-0836. PMID   28277505. S2CID   4450646.
  41. Choi, Soonwon; Choi, Joonhee; Landig, Renate; Kucsko, Georg; Zhou, Hengyun; Isoya, Junichi; Jelezko, Fedor; Onoda, Shinobu; Sumiya, Hitoshi; Khemani, Vedika; von Keyserlingk, Curt; Yao, Norman Y.; Demler, Eugene; Lukin, Mikhail D. (2017). "Observation of discrete time-crystalline order in a disordered dipolar many-body system". Nature. 543 (7644): 221–225. arXiv: 1610.08057 . Bibcode:2017Natur.543..221C. doi:10.1038/nature21426. ISSN   0028-0836. PMC   5349499 . PMID   28277511.
  42. Kondov, S. S.; McGehee, W. R.; Xu, W.; DeMarco, B. (2015). "Disorder-Induced Localization in a Strongly Correlated Atomic Hubbard Gas". Physical Review Letters. 114 (8): 083002. arXiv: 1305.6072 . doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.083002 . ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   25768762.
  43. Schreiber, M.; Hodgman, S. S.; Bordia, P.; Luschen, H. P.; Fischer, M. H.; Vosk, R.; Altman, E.; Schneider, U.; Bloch, I. (2015). "Observation of many-body localization of interacting fermions in a quasirandom optical lattice". Science. 349 (6250): 842–845. arXiv: 1501.05661 . doi:10.1126/science.aaa7432. ISSN   0036-8075. PMID   26229112. S2CID   5112350.
  44. Choi, J.-y.; Hild, S.; Zeiher, J.; Schauss, P.; Rubio-Abadal, A.; Yefsah, T.; Khemani, V.; Huse, D. A.; Bloch, I.; Gross, C. (2016). "Exploring the many-body localization transition in two dimensions". Science. 352 (6293): 1547–1552. arXiv: 1604.04178 . Bibcode:2016Sci...352.1547C. doi:10.1126/science.aaf8834. ISSN   0036-8075. PMID   27339981. S2CID   35012132.
  45. Wei, Ken Xuan; Ramanathan, Chandrasekhar; Cappellaro, Paola (2018). "Exploring Localization in Nuclear Spin Chains". Physical Review Letters. 120 (7): 070501. arXiv: 1612.05249 . Bibcode:2018PhRvL.120g0501W. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.070501 . ISSN   0031-9007. PMID   29542978.
  46. Smith, J.; Lee, A.; Richerme, P.; Neyenhuis, B.; Hess, P. W.; Hauke, P.; Heyl, M.; Huse, D. A.; Monroe, C. (2016). "Many-body localization in a quantum simulator with programmable random disorder". Nature Physics. 12 (10): 907–911. arXiv: 1508.07026 . Bibcode:2016NatPh..12..907S. doi:10.1038/nphys3783. ISSN   1745-2473. S2CID   53408060.