Maradu apartments demolition order

Last updated November 11, 2024

On 8 May 2019, the Supreme Court of India ordered five apartments in Maradu municipality in Kerala to be demolished within one month, for violation of Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) rules, although only four of these apartments had yet been constructed.^[1] These four, already occupied by tenants, were Jains Coral Cove (Jain Housing and Construction Ltd), H2O Holy Faith (Holy Faith Builders and Developers Pvt Ltd) and Alfa Serene (Alfa Ventures Private Ltd) and Golden Kayaloram (KP Varkey & VS Builders). The fifth builder, Holiday Heritage, had scrapped the project.^[2]

Background and timeline

1986 The Environment Protection Act of 1986 was enacted in the wake of the Bhopal Tragedy. It came into force on 19 November 1986. The purpose of the Act is to implement the decisions of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment. They relate to the protection and improvement of the human environment and the prevention of hazards to human beings, other living creatures, plants and property. The Act is an "umbrella" legislation designed to provide a framework for central government coordination of the activities of various central and state authorities established under previous laws, such as the Water Act and the Air Act.^[3]
1991 In February 1991, a notification was issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) under the Environment Protection Act, 1986. This was for the regulation of activities in the coastal area. As per the notification, four categories of Coastal Regulation Zones (CRZ) were defined. CRZ I, CRZ II, CRZ III and CRZ IV.^[4]
1995 No Objection Certificate (NOC) was issued to Golden Kayaloram by the Secretary of Maradu Grama Panchayat.^[5]
1996 In 1996, the Coastal Zone Management Plan was introduced.^[6]
2005 The Local Self Government Department (LSGD) conducted a vigilance probe. During this probe, files were confiscated from the office of the Maradu Panchayat secretary.
2005-2006 The permission to construct the buildings was granted by the Maradu Panchayat.^[1]^[2]
2007 The Kerala Government sent a letter to the Maradu panchayat along with a list of all the cases in which violations/anomalies in the issue of building permits were detected during the inspection of the Senior Town Planner (Vigilance). The panchayat was asked to revoke all the listed building permits as per Rule 16 of the Kerala Municipality Building Rules 1999 (KMBR). On receiving the letter, the panchayat issued show-cause notice to the builders in all the cases. Even though the violations varied from CRZ violation, FAR more than 1.25, violations of open space, copy of final plan not available in the file, access width not shown etc., the allegation was the same and the notice was identical. (Even though there was no CRZ violation in the case of Golden Kayaloram, for example, the same notice was issued.^[7]) Alpha Ventures filed a writ petition seeking to quash the notice and to answer their reply seeking details on the basis of which the notice was issued. The High Court of Kerala admitted the writ petition and issued an interim order staying all further proceedings with respect to the notice issued to the builders. But the High Court, in the interim order allowed the Maradu panchayat to issue stop memo in accordance with the law. The Maradu panchayat did not issue any stop memo. Hence, Alpha Ventures continued the construction of the building.^[8] In June 2007, as per the instruction of the Kerala government, the Maradu panchayat gave a show-cause notice to the concerned builders.^[2]^[1] Jain Housing, Holy Faith Builders, and KP Varkey also continued the construction activities. Holiday Heritage discontinued their housing project.^[2]^[9] In 2007 itself, in an affidavit, a panchayat member stated that Maradu is CRZ II.^[10]
2010 Maradu panchayat became a municipality in November 2010.^[2] The municipality approached the Division Bench of the High Court with an appeal, which was dismissed. In 2016, the division bench of the Kerala High Court ruled that Maradu municipality was solely responsible for the situation.^[9]
2011 CZMP prepared in accordance with the Coastal Regulation Zone Notification of 2011 marked Maradu in the CRZ-II category.^[9]
2012 A single bench of the High Court of Kerala, set aside the show cause notice issued to Alpha Ventures by the Maradu panchayat.^[11]
2015 The division bench of the high court of Kerala gave its verdict on the matter. The show cause notice which was issued in 2007 by the panchayat was pointed out to be untenable and written in such a manner that it did not satisfy the rules. The Maradu municipality was blamed for the situation and the entire blame was placed on them.^[8] The Kerala Coastal Zone Management Authority (KCZMA) became a party to the case and moved the Supreme Court.
2018 The Supreme Court observed the builders did not give a reply to the show-cause notice issued by the panchayat and instead, filed writ petitions (WP) with the High Court. An expert committee was formed by the SC on 27 November 2018 to determine if the apartments are located in CRZ II or III. The three member committee reported that (as per the 1991 CRZ notification and the 1996 Kerala Coastal Zone Management Plan (KCZMP)), the area was CRZ III and not CRZ II. Maradu panchayat had issued the building permit without the permission of the KCZMA. The builders contended that the area was determined to be CRZ II as per the draft KCZMP created according to the 2011 CRZ notification. However, the argument of KCZMA was accepted by the Supreme Court.^[1]
May 2019 The Supreme Court accepted the contention of the KCZMA and ordered the five apartments to be demolished within a month.^[1] The Kerala government has contracted IIT Madras to develop a model for demolition of the buildings.^[9] The one-month period lapsed and all the review and writ petitions filed by the residents of the different apartments were denied.
September 2019 The Supreme Court, in an order issued on 6 September 2019 directed the state government to demolish the apartments and report by 20 September.^[12]^[13] Eviction notices were served to the residents subsequent to this. The residents say that they will resist the eviction.^[14]

Position of Golden Kayaloram residents

A curative petition was filed by the residents of Golden Kayaloram apartment on 10 September 2019. The petition was accepted by the court registry. It listed serious mistakes in 8 May Supreme Court order. The petition pointed out that a three-member technical committee was formed by the three member court appointed committee without the permission of the court.^[15]

The NOC was issued to Golden Kayaloram in 1995 (NO.A3.3/95) by the Secretary of Maradu Grama Panchayat and a copy of this was submitted as exhibit P1 in WP(C).No. 23293 of 2007 (W).^[5] This no objection certificate was issued by the Grama Panchayat before the Coastal Zone Management Plan (CZMP) of Kerala was approved in 1996.^[6]

The three member committee appointed by the Supreme Court of India had issued a notice to the builders of the apartments to respond about their CRZ status. No resident was asked to respond. The builder of Golden Kayaloram had submitted that "there are no CRZ violations alleged against M/s. Kayaloram Apartments by CZMA or any other authorities. Hence the proceedings with respect to CRZ violations is not sustainable against M/s. Kayaloram Apartments..."^[7]

Maradu and CRZ II and III

CRZ I areas are those "areas that are ecologically sensitive and important, such as... wildlife habitats, mangroves,... coral reefs, ...close tobreeding and spawning grounds of fish and other marine life, ...rich in genetic-diversity, ...likely to be inundated due to rise in sea level consequent upon global warming and such other areas as may be declared....."^[4]

CRZ II areas are those "that have already been developed up to or close to the shoreline." "Developed area" is defined as "...area within the municipal limits or in other legally designated urban areas which is already substantially built up and which has been provided with drainage and approach roads and other infrastructural facilities, such as water supply and sewerage mains."^[4]

CRZ III is described as "the areas that are relatively undisturbed and those which do not belong to either Category-I or II. These will include coastal zone in the rural areas (developed and undeveloped) and also areas within Municipal limits or in other legally designated urban areas which are not substantially built up".^[4]

Maradu is currently a municipal area and even before it was converted into a municipality, it was a legally designated urban area since it came under the Greater Cochin Development Authority.^[16]

The DLF property on the same banks of Chilavannoor lake also is in violation of CRZ norms (CRZ-I). It was first ordered to be demolished in 2012 by the single bench of Kerala High Court, but was stayed by the division bench. Instead, the division bench allowed regularization of the building after imposing a fine of 1 crore. An appeal went against this overruling to the Supreme Court of India, but the verdict was upheld.^[17]^[18]

In popular culture

• Vidhi is a 2021 Indian Malayalam-language film directed by Kannan Thamarakkulam, based on the Maradu apartments demolition order.

Opinions

A Mumbai-based advocate and the president of National Lawyers Campaign for Judicial Transparency and Reforms said that as per notification issued in 2011 by the central government, Maradu was brought under CRZ II and that even if the buildings were demolished, they could be reconstructed at the same location. Rules are procedural laws brought by the executive for enforcing the acts of parliament. The rules which are applicable to the buildings now are the rules in force today. As CRZ II applies to the buildings in question and there is no violation. The procedure adopted by the Supreme Court in bypassing the Kerala Municipality Act and rules under it was without jurisdiction and shocking.^[19]

Related Research Articles

Capital punishment in India is the highest legal penalty for crimes under the country's main substantive penal legislation, the Indian Penal Code, as well as other laws. Executions are carried out by hanging as the primary method of execution per Section 354(5) of the Criminal Code of Procedure, 1973 is "Hanging by the neck until dead", and is imposed only in the 'rarest of cases'.

Chandragiri Fort is a fort built in the 17th century, situated in Kasaragod District of Kerala, India. This large squarish fort is 150 feet (46 m) above sea level and occupies an area of about seven acres the adjacent to Chandragiri river. The fort is now in ruins.

The California Coastal Commission (CCC) is a state agency within the California Natural Resources Agency with quasi-judicial control of land and public access along the state's 1,100 miles (1,800 km) of coastline. Its mission as defined in the California Coastal Act is "to protect, conserve, restore, and enhance the environment of the California coastline".

Maradu is a municipality and census town in the Ernakulam district of Kerala, India. Maradu is an inner suburb of the Kochi metropolitan area and is located 6 km (3.7 mi) south of the Kochi city centre. As per the 2011 Indian census, Maradu has a population of 44,704 people.

Dhananjaya Yeshwant Chandrachud is an Indian jurist, who served as the 50th Chief Justice of India from 9 November 2022 to 10 November 2024. He was appointed a judge of the Supreme Court of India in May 2016. He has also previously served as the chief justice of the Allahabad High Court from 2013 to 2016 and as a judge of the Bombay High Court from 2000 to 2013. He also served as the ex-officio Patron-in-Chief of the National Legal Services Authority and the de facto Chancellor of the National Law School of India University.

Sobha Hi-tech city is a planned industry township for knowledge-based companies to be constructed in Kochi, India. The project, being constructed by Sobha Developers Ltd, will come up at Maradu. With an initial investment of Rs. 50 billion, the project also has the single highest investment in Kerala. On completion, the project is expected to have 7,000,000 square feet (650,000 m²) of developed space for research, trade and development in Information technology, biotechnology, electronic hardware and other knowledge based services. The project would be among the largest such ventures in the country, and is expected to generate over 75,000 direct jobs.

Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 is an Act of the Parliament of India enacted by the NDA government to prevent money laundering and to provide for confiscation of property derived from money laundering. PMLA and the Rules notified thereunder came into force with effect from 1 July 2005. The Act and Rules notified thereunder impose obligation on banking companies, financial institutions and intermediaries to verify the identity of clients, maintain records and furnish information in prescribed form to Financial Intelligence Unit – India (FIU-IND).

India-based Neutrino Observatory (INO) is a particle physics research project under construction to primarily study atmospheric neutrinos in a 1,200 meters (3,900 ft) deep cave under INO Peak near Theni, Tamil Nadu, India. This project is notable in that it is anticipated to provide a precise measurement of neutrino mixing parameters. The project is a multi-institute collaboration and one of the biggest experimental particle physics projects undertaken in India.

The Special Marriage Act, 1954 is an Act of the Parliament of India with provision for secular civil marriage for people of India and all Indian nationals in foreign countries, irrelevant of the religion or faith followed by either party. The Act originated from a piece of legislation proposed during the late 19th century. Marriages solemnized under Special Marriage Act are not governed by personal laws and is considered to be secular.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">P. B. Sahasranaman</span> Indian lawyer

Pallavoor Bharatharaj Sahasranaman also referred to as P.B.Sahasranaman, is an Indian lawyer, who specializes in environmental laws. He primarily practices at the Kerala High Court but also appears in the Supreme Court of India and the National Green Tribunal. He is also a popular author in Environment Law.

Nucleus Mall is a mall in Kochi, Kerala and is located in the developing suburban of Maradu, near to Thripunithura and around 8 km (5.0 mi) from the city centre. The mall is constructed and managed by ABAD Builders, a prominent builder of villas and apartments based in Kochi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ranjan Gogoi</span> 46th Chief Justice of India, Member of Rajya Sabha

Ranjan Gogoi is an Indian former advocate and judge who served as the 46th Chief Justice of India from 2018 to 2019, having previously served as a Judge of the Supreme Court of India from 2012 to 2018. He is currently a Member of the Rajya Sabha, having been nominated by President Ram Nath Kovind on 16 March 2020. Gogoi served as a judge in the Gauhati High Court from 2001 to 2010, and then was transferred as a judge to the Punjab and Haryana High Court from 2010 to 2011 where he later was the Chief Justice from 2011 to 2012. He is also a member of the Committee on External Affairs in the Rajya Sabha.

Vanashakti is a non-profit environmental NGO based in Mumbai, Maharashtra. It was formed in 2006, by Meenakshi Menon, Namita Roy Ghose, and Peter Armand Menon. Vanashakti aims to conserve the forests, wetlands, wildlife corridors, habitats, through education and litigation to achieve its objectives of creating awareness about environmental topics, protecting and reviving rivers and preventing opencast mining in areas that are well-endowed with biodiversity. It also directs its efforts in involving local forest-dwelling communities to protect the biodiversity of the region and provides sustainable livelihood options for forest dependent and coastal communities. Vanashakti's thrust areas are forest, mangrove and wetland protection, environmental education for both urban and rural schools, livelihoods for forest based communities and scientific investigation into local environmental degradation.

City of Kollam or Quilon is known as Prince of Arabian Sea, situated on the banks of Arabian Sea and Ashtamudi Lake. A major portion of Kollam Municipal Corporation area is occupied by Ashtamudi Lake. It is the most visited backwater and lake of Kerala, with a unique wetland ecosystem, a palm-shaped large water body, next only to the Vembanad estuary ecosystem of the state. Ashtamudi means 'eight coned'(Ashta = 'eight'; mudi = 'coned') in the local language of Malayalam. This name is indicative of the lake's topography: a lake with multiple branches. The lake is also called the gateway to the backwaters of Kerala. This lake is extremely famous for House Boat and Backwater Resorts.

Under the section 3 of Environment Protection Act, 1986 of India, Coastal Regulation Zone notification was issued in February 1991 for the first time, for regulation of activities in the coastal area by the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF).

George Kovoor was an Indian neurosurgeon, who gained popularity after being featured in many YouTube channels and Malayalam television shows as a Christian evangelist.

Dharmveer Swarajya Rakshak Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj Coastal Road is an 8-lane, 29.2-km long grade separated expressway along Mumbai's western coastline connecting Marine Lines in the south to Kandivali in the north. It is projected to be used by 130,000 vehicles daily, and is expected to reduce travel time between South Mumbai and the Western Suburbs from 2 hours to only 40 minutes. The estimated cost of the project is ₹13,060 crore (US$1.6 billion). Its first phase, which was inaugurated on 11 March 2024, is a 10.58 km section from Princess Street flyover to the Worli end of the Bandra–Worli Sea Link.

The Versova–Bandra Sea Link (VBSL), officially Swatantrya Veer Savarkar Sea Link, is an under-construction bridge in Mumbai, Maharashtra, India as a part of Coastal Road Phase-3 or Western Coastal Road. The 17.17-kilometre (10.67 mi) bridge will connect Versova, a neighbourhood in the suburb of Andheri to the Bandra–Worli Sea Link in Bandra, as part of the Coastal Road. The 8-lane sea link is expected to reduce congestion on the Western Express Highway and the Western Line of the Mumbai Suburban Railway.

Events in the year 2020 in Kerala.

Sreeja S versus Commissioner of Police &Ors.(2018) is case where Kerala High Court held that separating the adults in a consensual relationship is a violation of the Constitutional right, regardless of their sexual orientation.

References

1 2 3 4 5 Correspondent, Legal (8 May 2019). "SC orders demolition of 5 apartments Ernakulam's Maradu municipality". The Hindu . Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.{{cite news}}: |last1= has generic name (help)
1 2 3 4 5 Joseph, Neethu (13 September 2019). "How 344 families in Kochi apartments got entangled in legal battle that began 10 yrs ago". The News Minute. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ "THE ENVIRONMENT (PROTECTION) ACT, and the motions of the restrictions will depend on the history of environment. 1986". envfor.nic.in. Archived from the original on 13 June 2002. Retrieved 15 September 2019.
1 2 3 4 "THE COASTAL REGULATION ZONE NOTIFICATION, 1991 CONSOLIDATED VERSION [INCORPORATING AMENDMENTS UPTO 24TH JULY 2003]" (PDF). Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment.
1 2 MOHAN, K. SURENDRA. "K.V.Jose vs Government Of Kerala on 30 December, 2006". Indian Kanoon. THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
1 2 "The Kerala State State Coastal ... vs The State Of Kerala Maradu ... on 8 May, 2019". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
1 2 REPORT FILED BY THE COMMITTEE CONSTITUTED AS PER THE INTERIM ORDER DATED 27.11.2018 IN SLP (C) NOS. 4238-4241/2016 AND 4231-4234/2014, BEFORE THE HONOURABLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA. p. 17.
1 2 "JUDGMENT of HIGH COURT OF KERALA dated JUNE 2015". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 15 September 2019.
1 2 3 4 Krishna, Navmi. "Explained The Maradu imbroglio of a SC order, flat owners, Kerala govt, and municipal authorities". The Hindu. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ Aravind, Indulekha (14 September 2019). "Kerala: Uncertainty looms over 357 families as deadline to vacate Maradu flats ends today". Economic Times. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ "Alfa Ventures Pvt.Ltd vs Government Of Kerala Represented ... on 19 September, 2012". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 15 September 2019.
↑ Anand Choudhary, Amit (7 September 2019). "Supreme Court warns Kerala government, says demolish 4 Kochi buildings by September 20". The Times of India. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ P S Unnithan, Gopikrishnan. "Kerala: Uncertainty looms over 357 families as deadline to vacate Maradu flats ends today" . Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ "Kerala: Residents of Maradu flats to defy eviction notice". 11 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ "Maradu flats: SC accepts curative petition by flat owners". 11 September 2019. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.
↑ GCDA, Official Web site of GCDA, 'About Us' page
↑ "Kerala: Tale of two Coastal Regulation Zone violation cases, two SC rulings". The Indian Express. 16 September 2019. Retrieved 4 May 2020.
↑ Nandy, Mayank Aggarwal, Madhurima (11 January 2018). "SC order on DLF project in Kerala could set wrong precedent, say experts". Livemint. Retrieved 4 May 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
↑ "Saving Maradu apartments: A simple solution". The Times of India. 14 September 2019. Retrieved 23 September 2019.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[TH1-1] 1 2 3 4 5 Correspondent, Legal (8 May 2019). "SC orders demolition of 5 apartments Ernakulam's Maradu municipality". The Hindu . Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.{{cite news}}: |last1= has generic name (help)

[TNM1-2] 1 2 3 4 5 Joseph, Neethu (13 September 2019). "How 344 families in Kochi apartments got entangled in legal battle that began 10 yrs ago". The News Minute. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[3] "THE ENVIRONMENT (PROTECTION) ACT, and the motions of the restrictions will depend on the history of environment. 1986". envfor.nic.in. Archived from the original on 13 June 2002. Retrieved 15 September 2019.

[crz1991-4] 1 2 3 4 "THE COASTAL REGULATION ZONE NOTIFICATION, 1991 CONSOLIDATED VERSION [INCORPORATING AMENDMENTS UPTO 24TH JULY 2003]" (PDF). Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment.

[IK1-5] 1 2 MOHAN, K. SURENDRA. "K.V.Jose vs Government Of Kerala on 30 December, 2006". Indian Kanoon. THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[IK2-6] 1 2 "The Kerala State State Coastal ... vs The State Of Kerala Maradu ... on 8 May, 2019". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[CR-7] 1 2 REPORT FILED BY THE COMMITTEE CONSTITUTED AS PER THE INTERIM ORDER DATED 27.11.2018 IN SLP (C) NOS. 4238-4241/2016 AND 4231-4234/2014, BEFORE THE HONOURABLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA. p. 17.

[HC1-8] 1 2 "JUDGMENT of HIGH COURT OF KERALA dated JUNE 2015". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 15 September 2019.

[TH2-9] 1 2 3 4 Krishna, Navmi. "Explained The Maradu imbroglio of a SC order, flat owners, Kerala govt, and municipal authorities". The Hindu. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[ET1-10] Aravind, Indulekha (14 September 2019). "Kerala: Uncertainty looms over 357 families as deadline to vacate Maradu flats ends today". Economic Times. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[HC2-11] "Alfa Ventures Pvt.Ltd vs Government Of Kerala Represented ... on 19 September, 2012". Indian Kanoon. Retrieved 15 September 2019.

[ToI3-12] Anand Choudhary, Amit (7 September 2019). "Supreme Court warns Kerala government, says demolish 4 Kochi buildings by September 20". The Times of India. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[IT1-13] P S Unnithan, Gopikrishnan. "Kerala: Uncertainty looms over 357 families as deadline to vacate Maradu flats ends today" . Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[ToI4-14] "Kerala: Residents of Maradu flats to defy eviction notice". 11 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[Matr1-15] "Maradu flats: SC accepts curative petition by flat owners". 11 September 2019. Archived from the original on 14 September 2019. Retrieved 14 September 2019.

[gcda-aboutus-16] GCDA, Official Web site of GCDA, 'About Us' page

[17] "Kerala: Tale of two Coastal Regulation Zone violation cases, two SC rulings". The Indian Express. 16 September 2019. Retrieved 4 May 2020.

[18] Nandy, Mayank Aggarwal, Madhurima (11 January 2018). "SC order on DLF project in Kerala could set wrong precedent, say experts". Livemint. Retrieved 4 May 2020.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

[TToI1-19] "Saving Maradu apartments: A simple solution". The Times of India. 14 September 2019. Retrieved 23 September 2019.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]