| Name | Electorate | Years in office |
|---|
| Aldcorn, Andrew Andrew Aldcorn | St Vincent | 1858–1859 |
| Arnold, William Munnings William Arnold | Durham | 1856–1875 |
| Bowker, Richard Richard Bowker | North Eastern Boroughs | 1858–1859, 1877–1880 |
| Buckley, Henry Henry Buckley | Stanley County | 1856–1859 |
| Byrnes, James James Byrnes | Parramatta | 1857–1861, 1864–1872 |
| Campbell, John John Campbell | Sydney Hamlets | 1856–1860 |
| Campbell, Robert Robert Campbell | Sydney City | 1856–1859 |
| Cooper, Daniel Sir Daniel Cooper | Sydney Hamlets | 1856–1860 |
| Cowper, Charles Charles Cowper | Sydney City | 1856–1859, 1860–1867, 1869–1870 |
| Cox, George George Cox | Wellington (County) | 1856–1859 |
| Cribb, Benjamin Benjamin Cribb | Stanley Boroughs | 1858–1859 |
| Dalley, William Bede William Dalley | Cumberland Boroughs | 1856–1857, 1858–1860, 1862–1864 |
| Deniehy, Daniel Daniel Deniehy | Argyle | 1857–1859, 1860 |
| Dickson, James James Dickson | Northumberland Boroughs | 1857–1859, 1859–1863 |
| Donaldson, Stuart Stuart Donaldson | Cumberland (South Riding) | 1856, 1856–1859 |
| Egan, Daniel Daniel Egan | Maneroo | 1856–1869, 1870 |
| Faucett, Peter Peter Faucett | King and Georgiana | 1856–1859, 1860, 1861–1865 |
| Flood, Edward Edward Flood | Cumberland (South Riding) | 1856–1860, 1869–1872 |
| Forster, William William Forster | United Counties of Murray and St Vincent | 1856–1860, 1861–1864, 1864–1869, 1869–1874, 1875–1876, 1880–1882 |
| Gordon, Samuel Samuel Gordon | Durham | 1856–1859, 1859–1860 |
| Hargrave, John John Hargrave [c] | East Camden | 1859 |
| Hart, James James Hart [b] | New England and Macleay | 1858–1869, 1870–1872 |
| Hay, John John Hay | Murrumbidgee | 1856–1867 |
| Hodgson, Arthur Arthur Hodgson | Clarence and Darling Downs | 1858–1860 |
| Jamison, Robert Robert Jamison | Cook and Westmoreland | 1856–1860 |
| Jenkins, Richard Lewis Richard Jenkins | Liverpool Plains and Gwydir | 1858–1860 |
| Jones, Richard Richard Jones | Durham | 1856–1860 |
| Lee, William William Lee | Roxburgh | 1856–1859 |
| Lloyd, Edward Henry Edward Lloyd | Liverpool Plains and Gwydir | 1858–1859 |
| Lord, George George Lord | Wellington and Bligh | 1856–1877 |
| Macarthur, James James Macarthur | West Camden | 1856, 1856–1859 |
| Macleay, George George Macleay | Murrumbidgee | 1856–1859 |
| Macleay, William John William Macleay | Lachlan and Lower Darling | 1856–1874 |
| Marks, John John Marks | East Camden | 1856–1859 |
| Martin, James James Martin | Cook and Westmoreland | 1856–1860, 1862–1863, 1863–1864, 1864–1872, 1872–1873 |
| Moriarty, Abram Abram Moriarty [b] | New England and Macleay | 1858 |
| Murray, Terence Aubrey Terence Murray | Southern Boroughs | 1856–1862 |
| Oakes, George George Oakes | Parramatta | 1856–1860, 1872–1874 |
| Owen, Robert Robert Owen [c] | East Camden | 1858–1859 |
| Parkes, Henry Henry Parkes [a] | Cumberland (North Riding) | 1856, 1858, 1859–1861, 1864–1870, 1870, 1872–1877, 1877–1882, 1882–1884, 1885–1887, 1887–1895 |
| Paterson, John John Paterson | Lachlan and Lower Darling | 1858–1859 |
| Piddington, William William Piddington | Northumberland and Hunter | 1856–1877 |
| Plunkett, John John Plunkett [a] | Cumberland (North Riding) | 1856–1857, 1858–1860 |
| Richardson, John John Richardson | Stanley Boroughs | 1856–1859 |
| Robertson, John John Robertson | Phillip, Brisbane and Bligh | 1856–1861, 1862–1865, 1865–1866, 1866–1870, 1870–1877, 1877–1878, 1882–1886 |
| Rotton, Henry Henry Rotton | Western Boroughs | 1858–1859, 1859–1860, 1860–1864 |
| Scott, Alexander Walker Alexander Scott | Northumberland and Hunter | 1856–1860, 1860–1861 |
| Smith, Thomas Whistler Thomas Smith | Cumberland (North Riding) | 1857–1859 |
| Suttor, William Henry William Suttor | Bathurst County | 1856–1859, 1860–1864, 1866–1872 |
| Taylor, William Tydd William Taylor | New England and Macleay | 1858–1859 |
| Thornton, George George Thornton | Sydney City | 1858–1859, 1867–1868 |
| Tooth, Robert Robert Tooth | Sydney City | 1858–1859 |
| Tooth, William William Tooth | Moreton, Wide Bay, Burnett and Maranoa | 1858–1859 |
| Weekes, Elias Elias Weekes | Northumberland Boroughs | 1856–1864 |
| White, George Boyle George White | Northumberland and Hunter | 1858–1859 |
| Wild, William William Wild | West Camden | 1858–1860 |
| Williamson, James James Williamson | Gloucester and Macquarie | 1858–1859 |