Moderator Mayhem

Last updated
Moderator Mayhem
Moderator Mayhem title.jpg
Developer(s) Copia, Leveraged Play
Publisher(s) Engine
Engine Vue.js
Platform(s) web browser
ReleaseMay 2023
Genre(s) Casual
Mode(s) Single-player

Moderator Mayhem is a casual web-based video game designed by Engine, Randy Lubin, and Mike Masnick of Techdirt targeted towards policymakers. [1] [2] It was published in May 2023. The game is about the challenges of content moderation of user-generated content on social media. [2] [3]

Contents

According to Cory Doctorow, the video game is based on a card game Masnick used to teach people about the difficulties of content moderation. [4]

It is designed for mobile phones but can also be played on personal computers.

A followup entitled Trust & Safety Tycoon was published in October 2023.

Gameplay

The player acts as a content moderator for a fictional social media company and requires decision making under time pressure, [5] [6] :11:44 getting feedback from a manager character along the way. [1] In later rounds, the player is required to judge appeals, or rely on the advice of an AI-based content moderation system. [1] [4] The gameplay is primarily swipe-based. [2] [4]

While the gameplay describes the topics content moderators encounter in real life, it does not display prohibited content. [1]

Reception

Moderator Mayhem was recognized as a way to better understand content moderation and the effect of policy thereon. The hosts of This Week in Google podcast said the game demonstrates how policies affect people, and that the game itself is an example of journalism. [6] :12:38 Doctorow suggests it as important to discussions of content moderation, because of the impact of technology regulation on people's lives. [4] Business Punk magazine suggests it may help the player appreciate the difficulty of the task of content moderation, [7] while Rob Pegoraro of PC Magazine said the game showed him he did not want a job as a content moderator. [1] Columbia Global Freedom of Expression noted the game's relevance to discussions of legal compliance, media safety and free speech. [8]

Der Standard compared the game, as well as the followup Trust & Safety Tycoon to the border guard simulator Papers, Please . [9]

Brendan Sinclair of GamesIndustry.biz appreciated both games' portrayals of the difficult choices moderators face but also wrote, "I'm a little concerned the takeaway people will have from it is that moderation is difficult so it's unreasonable to ask these companies to get it right." [5]

Trust & Safety Tycoon

In October 2023, Masnick, Lubin, and Leigh Beadon published a followup game titled Trust & Safety Tycoon. [10] [11] Players are tasked with hiring moderators and deciding what to automate, simulating real social media platforms. [9] According to David Pierce of The Verge , it "is like a corporate training manual... but a good and useful one." [10] The developers interviewed trust and safety workers as research for the game. [12]


Unlike Moderator Mayhem, Trust & Safety Tycoon does not rely on time pressure. Instead, players have to "juggle ... user growth, ad revenue, moderator speed, and team morale." [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cory Doctorow</span> Canadian-British blogger, journalist and author (born 1971)

Cory Efram Doctorow is a Canadian-British blogger, journalist, and science fiction author who served as co-editor of the blog Boing Boing. He is an activist in favour of liberalising copyright laws and a proponent of the Creative Commons organization, using some of its licences for his books. Some common themes of his work include digital rights management, file sharing, and post-scarcity economics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Content moderation</span> System to sort undesirable contributions

On Internet websites that invite users to post comments, content moderation is the process of detecting contributions that are irrelevant, obscene, illegal, harmful, or insulting, in contrast to useful or informative contributions, frequently for censorship or suppression of opposing viewpoints. The purpose of content moderation is to remove or apply a warning label to problematic content or allow users to block and filter content themselves.

<i>RollerCoaster Tycoon</i> Video game series

RollerCoaster Tycoon is a series of construction and management simulation games about building and managing an amusement park. Each game in the series challenges players with open-ended amusement park management and development, and allowing players to construct and customize their own unique roller coasters and other thrill rides.

NeoGAF is an Internet forum primarily dedicated to the discussion of video games. Founded as an adjunct to a video game news site under the name Gaming-Age Forums, on April 4, 2006 it changed its name to NeoGAF and became independently hosted and administered.

Roblox is an online game platform and game creation system developed by Roblox Corporation that allows users to program and play games created by themselves or other users. Created by David Baszucki and Erik Cassel in 2004 and released in 2006, the platform hosts user-created games of multiple genres coded in the programming language Lua. For most of Roblox's history, it was relatively small, both as a platform and as a company. Roblox began to grow rapidly in the second half of the 2010s, and this growth has been accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Techdirt</span> American Internet blog

Techdirt is an American Internet blog that reports on technology's legal challenges and related business and economic policy issues, in context of the digital revolution. It focuses on intellectual property, patent, information privacy and copyright reform in particular.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ModSquad</span> Global digital engagement services company

ModSquad is a global digital company providing engagement services based in the United States. The company currently has over 10,000 moderators in its network. ModSquad provides managed, on-demand customer service, content moderation, social media, and community management services and teams across online, e-commerce, in-game, in-app, and social media channels.

<i>Worms Ultimate Mayhem</i> 2011 video game

Worms Ultimate Mayhem is a 3D artillery turn-based tactics video game developed by Team17. The game is a re-release of Worms 4: Mayhem with improved graphics. It features all-new content, story mode voice acting by Guy Harris, and other gameplay fixes such as reworked camera controls. The game features turn-based gameplay, a single-player campaign, and both local and online multiplayer. While primarily based on Worms 4: Mayhem, Ultimate Mayhem also includes content from Worms 3D, with its campaign and multiplayer maps included in the game.

Shadow banning, also called stealth banning, hellbanning, ghost banning, and comment ghosting, is the practice of blocking or partially blocking a user or the user's content from some areas of an online community in such a way that the ban is not readily apparent to the user, regardless of whether the action is taken by an individual or an algorithm. For example, shadow-banned comments posted to a blog or media website would be visible to the sender, but not to other users accessing the site.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">YouNow</span> American live broadcasting service company

YouNow is an American live streaming broadcasting service where users stream their own live video content or interact with the video streams of other users in real time. The service is available on its website and on Android and iOS apps.

<i>The Internet of Garbage</i> Book by Sarah Jeong

The Internet of Garbage is a 2015 non-fiction book by journalist and lawyer Sarah Jeong. It discusses online harassment as a threat to the useful functions of the internet and argues for new approaches to managing the issue. The book was reissued in 2018 with a new preface by Jeong.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mastodon (social network)</span> Self-hosted social network software

Mastodon is free and open-source software for running self-hosted social networking services. It has microblogging features similar to Twitter, which are offered by a large number of independently run nodes, known as instances or servers, each with its own code of conduct, terms of service, privacy policy, privacy options, and content moderation policies.

<i>Walkaway</i> (Doctorow novel) 2017 novel by Cory Doctorow

Walkaway is a 2017 science fiction novel by Canadian writer Cory Doctorow, published by Head of Zeus and Tor Books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Information Doesn't Want to Be Free</span> 2014 non-fiction book by Cory Doctorow

Information Doesn't Want to Be Free is a 2014 non-fiction book by the science fiction writer and Internet activist Cory Doctorow. In the book, he advocates loosening restrictions on intellectual property on the Internet. He states that "[i]nformation doesn’t want to be free,...people do.”

<i>The Cleaners</i> (2018 film) 2018 documentary film by Hans Block

The Cleaners is a 2018 documentary film directed by Hans Block and Moritz Riesewieck. The documentary details the work experience of content moderators who have to decide which content needs to be removed by employing a moderation system for social media websites.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bluesky (social network)</span> Decentralized social media network

Bluesky, also known as Bluesky Social, is a microblogging social platform and a public benefit corporation based in the United States. Jay Graber serves as the company's CEO and Twitter co-founder Jack Dorsey and XMPP creator Jeremie Miller sit on its board of directors.

Lords of the Earth (LOTE) is a play-by-email game, first published by Thomas Harlan in 1983 during a growing era of PBM games. Initially played by postal mail, the game featured mixed moderation—computer moderated with some human assistance. By 2002, the publisher processed turns by email (PBeM). Lords of the Earth comprises multiple campaigns, each one a separate game. Campaign 1 is the oldest, set in the mid-1800s in the "Age of Air and Steam". Other campaigns begin from 2000 BCE to 1400 CE. Settings were global in scale, with one campaign featuring an outer space setting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Texas House Bill 20</span>

An Act Relating to censorship of or certain other interference with digital expression, including expression on social media platforms or through electronic mail messages, also known as Texas House Bill 20 (HB20), is a Texas anti-deplatforming law enacted on September 9, 2021.

Moody v. NetChoice, LLC and NetChoice, LLC v. Paxton are pending United States Supreme Court cases related to protected speech under the First Amendment, content moderation by interactive service providers on the Internet under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, and two state statutes passed in Florida and Texas that sought to limit this moderation. While originating with statutes in two different states, the Moody and Paxton cases are often discussed in tandem because the U.S. Supreme Court is likely to review them together.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Enshittification</span> Systematic decline in online platform quality

Enshittification is a term coined by writer Cory Doctorow in November 2022 to describe a pattern of decreasing quality observed in online services and products such as Amazon, Facebook, Google Search, Twitter, Bandcamp, Reddit, Uber and Unity. The American Dialect Society selected the term as its 2023 Word of the Year. Doctorow has also used the term platform decay to describe the same concept.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Pegoraro, Rob (May 15, 2023). "Think You Can Be a Content Moderator? Test Your Skills With This Game". PCMag . Retrieved 2023-07-05.
  2. 1 2 3 Robertson, Adi (May 11, 2023). "I am going to win content moderation, something that is both normal to want and possible to achieve". The Verge .
  3. Hill, Kashmir (July 29, 2023). "An Internet Veteran's Guide to Not Being Scared of Technology". New York Times . Redwood City, California . Retrieved 2023-08-20.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Doctorow, Cory (May 13, 2023). "Revenge of the Linkdumps". Pluralistic . Retrieved 2023-07-09.
  5. 1 2 3 Sinclair, Brendan (Oct 27, 2023). "Why is Trust and Safety so hard? | This Week in Business". GamesIndustry.biz . Retrieved 2023-11-02.
  6. 1 2 Leo Laporte; Jeff Jarvis; Stacey Higginbotham; Ant Pruitt (May 17, 2023). "This Week in Google 716: It's Pronounced Papyri". twit.tv (Podcast). TWiT.tv. Event occurs at 7:24-13:52 (11:44, 12:17, 12:38, 13:13). Retrieved 2023-07-05.
  7. Business Punk Redaktion (May 15, 2023). "Bei diesem Spiel könnt ihr eure Fähigkeiten als Content-Moderator:in testen". Business Punk  [ de ]. Retrieved 2023-07-05.
  8. "South African Supreme Court of Appeal affirms gratuitous displays of the old national flag constitute hate speech". Newsletter Archive. Columbia Global Freedom of Expression. June 2, 2023. Retrieved 2023-07-07 via campaign-archive.com.
  9. 1 2 "Browserspiel simuliert den Wahnsinn von Social-Media-Plattformen". Game zum Nachdenken. Der Standard (in German). 20 October 2023. Retrieved 2023-10-25.
  10. 1 2 Pierce, David (Oct 22, 2023). "Mario and Spider-Man are both back in a big way". The Verge . Retrieved 2023-10-25.
  11. Robertson, Adi (Oct 17, 2023). "Consider the bronies". The Verge . Retrieved 2023-10-25.
  12. Lima, Cristiano; DiMolfetta, David (October 17, 2023). "Think you could make a safer social media site? This game lets you try". The Technology 202. The Washington Post . Retrieved 2023-12-06.