Monarchomachs

Last updated

The Monarchomachs (French : Monarchomaques) were originally French Huguenot theorists who opposed monarchy at the end of the 16th century, known in particular for having theoretically justified tyrannicide. The term was originally a pejorative word coined in 1600 by the Scottish royalist and Catholic William Barclay (1548–1608) from the Greek μόναρχος (monarchos  "monarch, sole ruler") and μάχομαι ("makhomai"   the verb meaning "to fight"), meaning "those who fight against monarchs" or "anti-monarchists".

Contents

Born out of the French Wars of Religion, they were most active between 1573, a year after the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre, and 1584. The Monarchomachs pleaded in favour of a form of "popular sovereignty". Arguing for a sort of contract between the sovereign and the people, they have been considered as the precursors of social contract theories. [1]

Theory of tyrannicide

The Monarchomachs included jurists such as the Calvinists François Hotman (1524–1590), Théodore de Bèze (1519–1605), Simon Goulart (1543–1628), Nicolas Barnaud (1538–1604), Hubert Languet (1518–1581), Philippe de Mornay (1549–1623) and George Buchanan (1506–1582), as well as Catholic writers such as Juan de Mariana (1536–1624). They had a special influence in the so-called Dutch revolt and contributed to the Netherlands' Act of Abjuration. Through the means of libels and theoretical tracts, they revived the doctrine of the tyrannicide. It had been opposed during the Middle Ages by the "legists" (jurists who theorized the royal power) who attempted to reserve the title of tyrant to those who tried to overturn the ruling monarch. Legists thus ended up legitimizing, under the name of "tyrannicide", the assassinations of political opponents ordered by the monarch. The Dutch Constitutional Law professor A.M. Donner on page 16 of his state law manual calls Johannus Althusius "the last of the monarchomachs". Typically Johannes Althusius in his Politica opposes Jean Bodin.

Monarchomachs considered that the end of the state was prosperity of the whole social group, as the true sovereign, granting effective practice of power to the king, whose authority remained of divine right. [1] Exercise of popular sovereignty was to be delegated to the magistrates and the officers of the crown. They considered that the people were a collective body, possessed of a specific wisdom, which allowed them to understand better than the king the common good, distinct from the interest of each of its parties. Assimilated to the medieval universitas , the people was thus considered as a legal subject, whose interests were represented by the General Estates. [2] [3] This conception of the magistrates and the association of wise people as best representants of the people separated them from modern conception of democracy, as they restricted effective power to a minority. Max Weber considered them in his lecture Politics as a Vocation as participants of the movement of rationalization of law in Europe.

The Monarchomachs also claimed that if the sovereign persecuted true religion, he would violate the contract concluded between God and the people, who were thus granted a right of rebellion. They were inspired by Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, and the School of Salamanca on the killing of "bad kings". This legitimization of tyrannicide may have inspired as much the friar Clément, who assassinated Henry III in 1589, as Ravaillac, who assassinated Henry IV in 1610. [4] Rebellion against tyranny was considered not only as necessary, but as a divine right.

Monarchomach theory in the 16th century

The term Monarchomachs was coined by William Barclay [5] in his book De Regno et Regali Potestate (”About the Powers of Authority and Royalty”), published in 1600. Barclay's theory was that the Huguenots had lost their struggle with the Catholic Church and were turning their battle towards the government to undermine the king's support of the Catholics. Eventually, the term was used to classify anyone who was opposed to the king's rule.

At first a Protestant doctrine, the notion of tyrannicide was reappropriated by the Catholics when Protestants came to be kings. It was then used in revolutionary discourses during the debates concerning the execution of Louis XVI, while the right of rebellion was included in the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen.

Influenced by the Huguenots, some British thinkers also embraced the Monarchomaque movement.[ who? ]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Henry IV of France</span> King of France from 1589 to 1610

Henry IV, also known by the epithets Good King Henry or Henry the Great, was King of Navarre from 1572 and King of France from 1589 to 1610. He was the first monarch of France from the House of Bourbon, a cadet branch of the Capetian dynasty. He pragmatically balanced the interests of the Catholic and Protestant parties in France as well as among the European states. He was assassinated in Paris in 1610 by a Catholic zealot, and was succeeded by his son Louis XIII.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Barclay (jurist)</span> Scottish jurist

William Barclay (1546–1608) was a Scottish jurist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">François Ravaillac</span> French Catholic zealot who assassinated King Henry IV of France in 1610

François Ravaillac was a French Catholic who assassinated King Henry IV of France in 1610.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Philippe de Mornay</span> French Protestant writer (1549–1623)

Philippe de Mornay, seigneur du Plessis Marly, usually known as Du-Plessis-Mornay or Mornay Du Plessis, was a French Protestant writer and member of the anti-monarchist Monarchomaques.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">François Hotman</span> French lawyer and writer (1524–1590)

François Hotman was a French lawyer and writer, associated with the legal humanists and with the monarchomaques, who struggled against absolute monarchy. His first name is often written 'Francis' in English. His surname is Latinized by himself as Hotomanus, by others as Hotomannus and Hottomannus. He has been called "one of the first modern revolutionaries".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean Papire Masson</span>

Jean Papire Masson Latin: Papirius was a French humanist historian, known also as a geographer, biographer, literary critic and jurist.

Nicolas Barnaud (1538–1604) was a French Protestant writer, physician and alchemist, from Crest, in Dauphiné, from which he took the name Delphinas. He was a member of the Monarchomaques.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Succession of Henry IV of France</span> Henry III of Navarres accession as King of France

Henry III of Navarre's succession to the throne in 1589 was followed by a war of succession to establish his legitimacy, which was part of the French Wars of Religion (1562–1598). Henry IV inherited the throne after the assassination of Henry III, the last Valois king, who died without children. Henry was already King of Navarre, as the successor of his mother, Jeanne d'Albret, but he owed his succession to the throne of France to the line of his father, Antoine of Bourbon, an agnatic descendant of Louis IX. He was the first French king from the House of Bourbon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">François de Scépeaux</span> French Marshal and Diplomat

François de Scépeaux de Vieilleville, lord of Vieilleville, 1st comte of Durtal, was a French governor, diplomat, ambassador, conseillé du roi and marshal. During his career, he would serve four French kings. He fought throughout the later years of the Italian Wars, acquiring for himself the key frontier governorship of Metz in 1553. Under King Charles IX he would be elevated to marshal and would serve the crown in the early religious wars, increasingly in the role of peacemaker and diplomat, though with scattered military service as with the recapture of Le Havre in 1563. He died in 1571, shortly before France would be shaken by the St Bartholomew's Day Massacre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Myriam Yardeni</span> Israeli historian

Myriam Yardeni was an Israeli historian and scholar of French history. She was professor of general history at the University of Haifa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre de la Place</span> French Huguenot martyr

Duke Pierre de la Place was a French Huguenot martyr, who died a few days after the 1572 St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre of the Huguenots. According to Foxe, he was informed of the massacre, and ordered to report to the King, to await the King's pleasure. He fled, but was unable to find shelter with any Catholics, and eventually returned to his house and fortified himself in, leading his wife and servants in prayer while he waited. He was eventually obliged to leave with the King's men, who led him into the clutches of assassins who killed him. His corpse was placed in a stable, where it was desecrated with horse dung, and his house was plundered.

Jaques Couet du Vivier (Couët) was a Huguenot pastor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Louise Marguerite of Lorraine</span> Princess of Conti

Louise Marguerite of Lorraine, Princess of Conti was a daughter of the Duke of Guise and a member of the House of Lorraine. She married François de Bourbon, titled the Prince of Conti. As such, after her marriage she was the Princess of Conti. She died without any surviving issue.

Charlotte Duplessis-Mornay was a French writer of the Reformation, known for her first-person account of the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre (1572) and for authoring the Memoires de Messire Philippes de Mornay, about her husband, Philippe de Mornay.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Grégoire (jurist)</span> French jurist and philosopher (c.1540–1597)

Pierre Grégoire (c.1540–1597) was a French jurist and philosopher

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barthélemy de Laffemas</span>

Barthélemy de Laffemas was an economist, born in Beausemblant, France in 1545. He is officially recorded as dying in Paris in 1612. However, it is rumoured that he actually died on September 23, 1611, after falling from his horse. He is known as the first person to write about underconsumption

Gerardina Tjaberta van Ysselsteyn was a Dutch art historian and textile specialist who wrote several books on the Dutch textile industry.

Louis-François L'Héritier, also known under the name L'Héritier de l'Ain was a 19th-century French playwright, essayist, novelist and journalist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul-Alexis Mellet</span>

Paul-Alexis Mellet is a French early modern historian and expert in the political and religious ideas from early modernity. He is a professor at the University of Geneva and a member of the Institute of Reformation History. Formerly, he was a professor at the University of Cergy-Pontoise, and at the University of Tours.

Events from the year 1593 in France

References

  1. 1 2 Les Monarchomaques, Gallica (in French)
  2. Memo.fr Archived 2007-05-07 at the Wayback Machine (in French)
  3. Un pouvoir constituant... pour libres professeurs ? (on the book of Jean Fabien Spitz, John Locke et les fondements de la liberté moderne), by François Matheron, Multitudes, June 2002 (in French)
  4. Jacques Clément avant Ravaillac, Le Figaro , 30 November 2006 (in French)
  5. Quentin Skinner, The Foundations of Modern Political Thought, Cambridge University Press, 1978, p. 301.

Sources