Moriarty Tribunal

Last updated

The Moriarty Tribunal, officially called the Tribunal of Inquiry into certain Payments to Politicians and Related Matters, was an Irish Tribunal of Inquiry established in 1997 into the financial affairs of politicians Charles Haughey and Michael Lowry. It has revealed significant tax evasion by these and other politicians and leading businessmen. As a consequence, the tax authorities have recovered millions of euro in settlements and penalties from many individuals. The final report of the tribunal was expected to be published in mid-January 2010, [1] but was delayed and was published 22 March 2011.

Contents

Background

As a result of change of management in Dunnes Stores, a leading retail group in Ireland, it was revealed in the press that Ben Dunne had made substantial secret payments to the former Taoiseach Charles Haughey and Minister Michael Lowry. In response the Bruton Government established The McCracken Inquiry in 1997 to investigate. The inquiry reported in late 1997 and confirmed the facts and revealed monies in secret Ansbacher accounts owned by Haughey for which it could not determine the source.

Establishment

The tribunal sat in Dublin Castle (Ireland) Dublin Castle Up Yard.JPG
The tribunal sat in Dublin Castle

In response to the McCracken Report, the new Ahern Government issued terms of reference for a new follow-up tribunal on 26 September 1997. The sole member of the Tribunal is the Honourable Mr Justice Michael Moriarty, leading to the name Moriarty Tribunal.

The terms were inquiry into (inter alia):

The preliminary report into the Haughey payments was published on 19 December 2006. [2] The final reports were published in 2011. [3]

Costs and delays

The Tribunal sat for the first time on 31 October 1997 and heard its first witness on 28 January 1999. By September 2004, the Tribunal had sat on 286 days but sittings were suspended pending a High Court hearing in which mobile phone entrepreneur Denis O'Brien tried unsuccessfully to prevent the tribunal from investigating Michael Lowry's involvement in his purchase of Doncaster Rovers F.C. [4] The tribunal ended up lasting much longer than anticipated and cost the state millions in direct costs and legal assistance to witnesses, something that has been criticised by the people whom the tribunal investigated.

In March 2010, it was estimated the tribunal had cost the state approximately €39 million, with final costs expected to exceed €100 million. [5]

Volume I

2006 Findings

Consequences

Volume II

Awarding of the second mobile phone licence

The circumstances surrounding the awarding of the second GSM mobile phone licence to the Esat Digifone consortium in 1996 (the biggest contract ever awarded by the State to a private company [10] ) by the Rainbow Coalition government was the focus of the work of the tribunal from 2007. The tribunal investigated whether money changed hands prior to the awarding of the licence to Esat Digifone by former Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications Michael Lowry TD. [11] Denis O'Brien claimed preliminary findings by the tribunal effectively state that the Esat consortium was "illegally" issued with the state's second mobile-phone licence because he had a "corrupt" relationship with Michael Lowry. [12] A number of failed bidders are suing the state over the handling of the competition process.

Esat Digifone

Esat Digifone logo Esat Digifone.png
Esat Digifone logo

In 1995, Esat Digifone was a consortium made up of Denis O'Brien's Communicorp (40%), Telenor AB (40%) and the remaining 20% held by institutional shareholders. Esat Digifone won the 1995 competition process and entered into exclusive negotiations with the Department of Transport, Energy and Communications.

Exclusive negotiations and new shareholding by Dermot Desmond

It transpired that during the contracting period a change in the shareholding in Esat Digifone had occurred with financier Dermot Desmond's IIU Nominees taking a share of 25% of the company and Communicorp and Telenor AB holding the remainder between them. The Department of Communications decided that the 25% holding by IIU Ltd. was unacceptable in May 1996 and demanded a return to the 40-40-20 structure, but this information was not communicated to the Attorney-General's office at the time. [13]

The department and Lowry demanded that the 40:40:20 breakdown of the shares in Esat should be restored prior to the issuing of the licence, which resulted in Desmond selling part of his shareholding to Communicorp and Telenor. [14] The licence was awarded to Digifone in May 1996, with Lowry announcing Digifone the winner before civil servants involved in judging the competition made their final decision. [15]

Government Buildings
location of the Attorney-General's Office Government Buildings, Dublin, Ireland.jpg
Government Buildings
location of the Attorney-General's Office

In May 1996, the Attorney-General's office sought the advice of barrister Richard Nesbitt regarding the change in shareholding. Nesbitt advised the government that the licence could be awarded regardless of the fact that Dermot Desmond had joined the consortium at a later date. [16] The advice of Nesbitt as recalled by Denis McFadden – a barrister in the A-G's office – was to the effect that IIU's entry was not a material change and merely amounted to "equity finance". [17]

Moriarty's findings

In February 2008, Judge Moriarty gave a legal finding that the written advice given by Richard Nesbitt in 1996 to the Attorney General's office did not cover what is known as "the ownership issue". [5] This finding followed a private meeting of tribunal counsel in October 2002 recalled by Denis McFadden BL and attended by, amongst others, John Gormley BL and Richard Nesbitt SC, Jerry Healy SC for the tribunal described Nesbitt's advice to the government as "shite". [18] Following the addition of new evidence, Judge Moriarty conceded that the advice of Richard Nesbitt did cover the acquisition of a 25% shareholding by IIU and that he would reappraise his interim findings that it did not. [19] Judge Moriarty admitted to making "not insignificant mistakes" in regards to the license issue which would have to be "taken on the chin and acknowledged". [20]

Statements by key participants

A media war broke out in early 2010 over the preliminary findings of the tribunal with Denis O'Brien, Michael Lowry TD and Judge Moriarty each making statements about the process.

O'Brien Statement

Denis O'Brien sent a letter to the chairman of the tribunal Judge Moriarty alleging that the tribunal's "activities really reaches a new low in Irish judicial history" and was "totally biased" [21] O'Brien has claimed that the tribunal had set out to "get his scalp", but "must now admit they were wrong" [22] Denis O'Brien established the website MoriartyTribunal.com on 16 October 2009. [23] [24] The site was created by the O'Brien team to present his perspective on the work of the Moriarty Tribunal [25]

Lowry statement

In January 2010 Michael Lowry TD issued a 3,400-word statement (available here) outlining his perspective on the tribunal. Lowry's claims relate principally to the involvement of financier Dermot Desmond as a 20 per cent shareholder in the Esat Digifone consortium and outlining that it was not possible for him to meddle in the process or direct a result without the collusion of civil servants. [26] Lowry has also criticised the tribunal in the Dáil, pointing out the high costs and delay involved.

Moriarty Statement

Judge Moriarty has said his report will be "founded unequivocally on evidence" and not on speculation and working hypotheses and that he was not "trying to cobble together a report that will unjustly condemn" people on "flimsy evidence". He was mystified as to why this "unthinkable suggestion" should be made concerning someone who had been appointed by both Houses of the Oireachtas. He had learned as a judge to be "big enough and humble enough to correct errors" but he was not saying errors had been made and important matters remained to be canvassed in evidence. [21] Judge Moriarty also hit back at the media campaign against the tribunal claiming he was "not going to be distracted by the prevalence of spin, and other controversies...that would not be welcomed by the courts." [27]

2011 Findings

Conclusions

  • Lowry "secured the winning" of the 1995 mobile licence for O'Brien.
  • O'Brien made two payments to Lowry in 1996 and 1999 totalling IR£500,000 (£147,000 and £300,000) and supported a loan of £420,000 given to Lowry in 1999, a benefit equivalent to a payment.
  • Lowry imparted substantive information to O'Brien which was "of significant value and assistance to him in securing the licence".
  • Lowry bypassed consideration by his Cabinet colleagues and thereby not only influenced, but delivered the result for Esat Digifone.
  • A US$50,000 donation to Fine Gael was made through Telenor on behalf of Esat Digifone.
  • Lowry sought to influence a hike in the lease for Marlborough House (Telecom Éireann headquarters) following a request from Mr Dunne. These rent increases would have improperly enriched Dunne, and were deemed to be "profoundly corrupt".
  • Lowry was criticised for his "cynical and venal abuse of office" and his brazen refusal to acknowledge the impropriety of his financial arrangements with O'Brien and Dunne.

Recommendations

  • Greater precautions ought to have been taken to segregate those conducting the evaluation of the mobile phone licence bids from their political master.
  • All donations to politicians or political parties should be reported to the SIPO (Standards in Public Office) Commission.
  • All recommendations by public office holders to the Revenue Commissioners be in writing.

Criminal investigation

Following the publication of the final report of the tribunal copies were sent to the Revenue Commissioners, the Garda Commissioner and the Director of Public Prosecutions. A team of detectives, led by the Criminal Assets Bureau (CAB) chief, DCS Eugene Corcoran, investigated if the report could identify any criminal wrongdoing that could be then investigated. [28]

See also

Related Research Articles

Dermot Desmond is an Irish businessman and financier. He is estimated to be worth €2.04 billion and is ranked by the Sunday Independent as the ninth-richest person in Ireland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael Lowry (politician)</span> Irish politician (born 1953

Michael Lowry is an Irish independent politician who has served as a Teachta Dála (TD) since 1987, currently for the Tipperary constituency. He previously served as Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications from 1994 to 1996 and Chair of the Fine Gael parliamentary party from 1993 to 1994.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">O2 (Ireland)</span> Former broadband and telecommunications provider in Ireland

Telefónica Ireland was a broadband and telecommunications provider in Ireland that traded under the O2 brand (typeset as O2). O2 Ireland was previously called Esat Digifone when it was owned by Esat Telecommunications (and Telenor) from 1997 to 2006.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">BT Ireland</span>

BT Communications (Ireland) Limited is a telecommunications and internet company in Ireland. It is a subsidiary of BT Group plc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Denis O'Brien</span> Irish billionaire businessman

Denis O'Brien is an Irish billionaire businessman, and the founder and owner of Digicel. He was listed among the World's Top 200 Billionaires in 2015 and was Ireland's richest native-born citizen for several years. His business interests have also extended to aircraft leasing, utilities support (Actavo), petroleum, football, and healthcare. As former chairman of the Esat Digifone consortium, O'Brien was questioned by the Moriarty Tribunal, which investigated the awarding of a mobile phone licence to Esat, among other things.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">CRH plc</span> Irish building materials company

CRH plc is an international group of diversified building materials businesses whose headquarters is in Dublin, Ireland. It manufactures and supplies a wide range of products for the construction industry. The group was formed through a 1970 merger of two leading Irish public companies, Cement Limited and Roadstone Limited (1949). CRH's primary listing is on the New York Stock Exchange since 2023, prior to which it was on the London Stock Exchange and on Euronext Dublin.

Bernard Dunne was an Irish businessman. Director of his family firm, Dunnes Stores, one of the largest chains of department stores in Ireland, he then owned a chain of fitness centres called Ben Dunne Gyms.

John Patrick McManus is an Irish businessman and racehorse owner. His career spanned from the 1980s to the 2010s. He was a major shareholder of Manchester United, until his stake was bought out by Malcolm Glazer in 2005.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bertie Ahern</span> 11th Taoiseach from 1997 to 2008

Bartholomew Patrick "Bertie" Ahern is an Irish former Fianna Fáil politician who served as Taoiseach from 1997 to 2008, Leader of Fianna Fáil from 1994 to 2008, Leader of the Opposition from 1994 to 1997, Tánaiste and Minister for Arts, Culture and the Gaeltacht from November 1994 to December 1994, Deputy Leader of Fianna Fáil from 1992 to 1994, Minister for Industry and Commerce in January 1993, Minister for Finance from 1991 to 1994, Minister for Labour from 1987 to 1991, Government Chief Whip and Minister of State at the Department of Defence from March 1982 to December 1982 and Lord Mayor of Dublin from 1986 to 1987. He served as a Teachta Dála (TD) from 1977 to 2011.

Brian Moore McCracken is a retired Irish judge who served as a Judge of the Supreme Court from 2002 to 2006 and a Judge of the High Court from 1995 to 2002. He is an officer of Trinity College Dublin – Visitor of the College.

The Tribunal of Inquiry into Certain Planning Matters and Payments, commonly known as the Mahon Tribunal after the name of its last chairman, was a public inquiry in Ireland established by Dáil Éireann in 1997 to investigate allegations of corrupt payments to politicians regarding political decisions. It mostly investigated planning permissions and land rezoning issues in the 1990s in the Dublin County Council area. Judge Alan Mahon was the final chair of the tribunal and its other members were Judge Mary Faherty and Judge Gerald Keys. The original chairman, who was the sole member until just before his retirement, was Judge Feargus Flood, giving rise to the original common name of the Flood Tribunal.

Since at least the 1970s, many Irish political scandals relating to miscarriage of justice, dereliction of duty and corruption by public officials have resulted in the establishment of extra-judicial Tribunals of Enquiry, which are typically chaired by retired High-Court judges and cannot make judgements against any of the parties. Since 2004 many such scandals have been investigated by the less costly but less transparent Commissions of Investigation. Many Irish scandals, however, have not resulted in trials or public enquiries.

Sarah Carey is an Irish columnist, broadcaster and communications consultant. She writes for the Irish Independent. From March 2011 until August 2017 she presented Talking Point on Newstalk. She is a former columnist for The Sunday Times,The Herald and The Irish Times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Corruption in the Republic of Ireland</span> Institutional corruption in the country

Transparency International's 2023 Corruption Perceptions Index scored Ireland at 77 on a scale from 0 to 100. When ranked by score, Ireland ranked 11th among the 180 countries in the Index, where the country ranked first is perceived to have the most honest public sector. For comparison with worldwide scores, the best score was 90, the average score was 43, and the worst score was 11. For comparison with regional scores, the highest score among Western European and European Union countries was 90, the average score was 65 and the lowest score was 42.

It is alleged that as a result of benefits extended to Michael Lowry by Denis O'Brien that Esat Digifone was given an unfair advantage in the procurement of a mobile phone operator's licence.

Sam Smyth is an investigative reporter, columnist and broadcaster. He works for the Irish Mail on Sunday and formerly worked for the Irish Independent, Sunday Independent, and Sunday Tribune newspapers.

Michael Anthony Moriarty, SC is a retired Irish judge who served as a Judge of the High Court from 1996 to 2018 and a Judge of the Circuit Court from 1987 to 1996.

Michael "Mick" McGinley is an Irish former Gaelic footballer who played for St Eunan's and the Donegal county team.

<i>Comcast Int. Holdings v Minister for Public Enterprise & ors and Persona Digital Telephony Ltd v Minister for Public Enterprise & ors</i> Irish Supreme Court case

Comcast Int. Holdings v Minister for Public Enterprise & ors and Persona Digital Telephony Ltd v Minister for Public Enterprise & ors [2012] IESC 50 is an Irish Supreme Court case which originated from the controversial decision of Michael Lowry, then Minister for Public Enterprise, to grant the second state mobile phone license to ESAT Digiphone. It has been described as "an absolutely unique case without any precedent in the ninety year history of the state."

John Byrne was an Irish property developer and businessperson known for building large offices in central Dublin with his company the Carlisle Trust.

References

  1. "Anxious wait for some as Moriarty report nears publication". The Irish Times . 9 January 2010. Archived from the original on 19 October 2012. Retrieved 9 January 2010.
  2. Moriarty, Michael (2006). Report of the Tribunal of Inquiry into Payments to Politicians and Related Matters, Part 1 (PDF) (Report). Government of Ireland. ISBN   0-7557-7459-0. Archived from the original (PDF) on 19 May 2011.
  3. Moriarty, Michael (March 2011). Report of the Tribunal of Inquiry into Payments to Politicians and Related Matters, Part 2 (PDF) (Report). Vol. 1. Government of Ireland. Archived from the original (PDF) on 4 March 2016.
  4. Collins, Liam (28 August 2005). "O'Brien makes money and loses friends". Irish Independent. Archived from the original on 24 October 2010. Retrieved 28 March 2011.
  5. 1 2 The cost of the Moriarty mistakes Archived 20 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 27 March 2010
  6. "Haughey stole from Lenihan medical fund – Tribunal". Archived from the original on 9 March 2007. Retrieved 19 December 2006.
  7. "Tribunal 'cannot accept' Haughey knew little of finances". Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 19 December 2006.
  8. "Haughey accepted cash for favours – Report". Archived from the original on 21 December 2006. Retrieved 19 December 2006.
  9. "Independent.ie". 24 March 2013. Archived from the original on 12 April 2017. Retrieved 12 April 2017.
  10. Disgraced Lowry in attack on Moriarty Tribunal Archived 16 January 2010 at the Wayback Machine Michael Brennan & Sam Smyth Irish Independent 14 January 2010
  11. More a case of survival than of winning or losing Archived 19 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Laura Slattery Irish Times 31 December 2009
  12. O’Brien licence award 'illegal' Archived 4 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine Mark Tighe Sunday Times 26 July 2009
  13. Tribunal hears of Desmond decision Archived 23 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 19 March 2010
  14. Esat Digifone shares traded before licence was awarded Archived 24 October 2010 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 28 April 2009
  15. O'Brien, Digifone and the Kaiser factor Archived 1 January 2005 at the Wayback Machine Ted Harding & Sean MacCarthaigh Sunday Business Post 15 December 2002
  16. 'There is no smoking gun' – O'Brien lashes tribunal [ permanent dead link ] Emmet Oliver Sunday Tribune 26 July 2009
  17. Advice 'no doubt' gave go-ahead to Digifone – official Archived 23 November 2010 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 19 March 2010
  18. Moriarty chairman 'rejected' counsel evidence Archived 20 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 23 March 2010
  19. Moriarty to re-examine ruling over advice to AG Archived 23 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Sam Smyth Irish Independent 23 March 2010
  20. Line pursued by tribunal 'based on a false premise' Archived 20 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena "Irish Times" 24 March 2010
  21. 1 2 O'Brien letter to Moriarty called tribunal 'totally biased' Archived 23 November 2010 at the Wayback Machine Colm Keena Irish Times 19 March 2009
  22. O'Brien wants 2008 Moriarty findings withdrawn Archived 22 March 2010 at the Wayback Machine Ireland Online 19 March 2009
  23. "Denis O'Brien attacks Moriarty tribunal". Archived from the original on 23 September 2021. Retrieved 11 November 2009.
  24. "Law Society refused O'Brien advert". The Irish Times . Archived from the original on 18 February 2011. Retrieved 11 November 2009.
  25. O'Brien launches alternative tribunal website [ permanent dead link ]
  26. Lowry criticises Moriarty tribunal in advance of report Archived 19 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Stephen Collins Irish Times 14 January 2010
  27. Moriarty goes on attack Archived 23 October 2012 at the Wayback Machine Sam Smyth Irish Independent 19 March 2009
  28. Garda chief to consult DPP over Moriarty findings Archived 7 October 2011 at the Wayback Machine Tom Brady Irish Independent 4 October 2011

Tribunal reports