Murder of Sophie Elliott

Last updated

Sophie Elliott
Sophie Kate Elliott.jpg
Born
Sophie Kate Elliott

(1985-06-11)11 June 1985
Died9 January 2008(2008-01-09) (aged 22)
Dunedin, New Zealand
Cause of deathBlood loss as result of stabbing
Alma mater University of Otago
Parent(s)Gil and Lesley Elliott
Clayton Weatherston
Born
Clayton Robert Weatherston

(1976-01-09) 9 January 1976 (age 47)
OccupationUniversity economics tutor
Criminal chargeMurder
Criminal penalty Life imprisonment with 18 years non-parole period
Criminal statusIn prison

On 9 January 2008, 22-year-old Sophie Kate Elliott (born 11 June 1985 [1] ) was stabbed to death by ex-boyfriend Clayton Robert Weatherston (born 9 January 1976), in Dunedin, New Zealand. [2] [3] [4] The crime and trial were covered extensively in the news media, and contributed to the government abolishing the partial defence of provocation in cases of murder. [5] [6] [7]

Contents

Murder

Elliott and Weatherston had a romantic relationship which lasted around six months and ended before her death. In court, witnesses described the relationship as troubled. Weatherston had been an economics lecturer at the University of Otago, and also taught Elliott, who completed an honours degree in economics. On the day she died, she was packing to relocate to Wellington the next day, and start a job at the New Zealand Treasury. [8]

At around 12:30 pm on 9 January 2008, Sophie Elliott and her mother Lesley were at the family home in the suburb of Ravensbourne northeast of the city centre when Weatherston arrived unannounced, saying he had a farewell present. A short time later Lesley heard her daughter screaming. A New Zealand Police officer, Constable John Cunningham, responding to a 111 call from Lesley found Weatherston locked in Sophie's bedroom. When asked what he had done, he told the officer "I killed her". [9] He was then arrested and taken into custody.

Forensic pathologist Martin Sage performed the autopsy the next day, and found Elliott died from blood loss. Two wounds pierced her heart and one lung, with other wounds to her neck and throat severing the main artery and the major vein. In total she received 216 separate injuries, mostly stab wounds from a knife blade, with some inflicted by scissors. Additionally there were seven blunt force injuries. The pathologist found some defensive wounds, and that the attack targeted aspects of beauty and was intended to disfigure. [10]

Trial

At the end of a week-long depositions hearing during May 2008 in the Dunedin High Court, Weatherston pleaded not guilty and was committed for trial by two justices of the peace. The trial moved to the Christchurch High Court for suppressed reasons, and was scheduled to start on 22 June 2009. Weatherston was represented by Judith Ablett-Kerr QC, who argued a defence of provocation. [2] The knife used in the attack came from Weatherston's kitchen; the defence stated he carried it concealed all the time for self-defence. Two psychiatrists also appeared for the defence, stating he had narcissistic personality disorder. [11]

After a five-week trial the jury returned a verdict of guilty on 22 July, [3] and on 15 September Justice Judith Potter sentenced Weatherston to life imprisonment with a minimum non-parole period of 18 years, saying she believed the killing was deliberate and controlled. [12] The news media in November 2009 revealed that the victim impact statement of Sophie Elliott's father had been censored at the request of the judge, preventing him from addressing some of the claims Weatherston made during the trial. [13] [14]

Appeal

On 13 October 2009, Weatherston's lawyers filed an appeal, claiming there was a "lynch mob" mentality over his actions. [15] [16]

On 7 April 2011, Weatherston's lawyer Robert Lithgow QC appealed the 2009 verdict before the Court of Appeal on seven grounds, including that Weatherston did not receive a fair trial due to widespread media coverage, with the magazine Listener attacking the provocation defence. Lithgow also argued that comments made by Law Commission deputy president Warren Young unduly influenced the Christchurch jury, [17] and challenged the use of photographs of the wounds Weatherston inflicted on Elliott as exhibits.

Crown prosecutor Cameron Mander opposed these arguments, pointing out that the jury had been directed to ignore media coverage of the case and that Young's attack on provocation could not be linked specifically to the Elliott murder. [18] Elliott's parents and Sensible Sentencing Trust spokesman Garth McVicar also criticised the appeal.

Three Court of Appeal judges reviewed the 2009 trial and verdict, [17] and on 17 June 2011 denied the appeal on all seven grounds. They said that Justice Potter had directed the jury sufficiently to ignore media coverage, and that the use of the photographs did not undermine the trial's fairness. [19]

Weatherston sought leave of the Supreme Court to appeal the Court of Appeal's denial, but it rejected this on 13 September 2011. [20]

Sophie Elliott Foundation

On 6 October 2010, the Sophie Elliott Foundation was launched. [21] The aim of the foundation was to warn and educate young women of the signs of an abusive relationship. One of the trustees was Kristin Dunne-Powell, who suffered abuse at the hands of high-profile sports presenter Tony Veitch. The foundation's main aim was to raise money to fund a nationwide primary prevention programme and to support local community initiatives which aligned with the foundation. [22] On 10 June 2011, Elliott's parents launched the book Sophie Elliott—A Mother's Story of Her Family's Loss and Their Quest For Change to present her side of the story while warning young women of the dangers of domestic violence. [23] In 2013, the foundation partnered up with the New Zealand Police and Ministry of Social Development to develop a one-day workshop for Year 12 students named Loves-Me-Not, to educate students on healthy relationships and prevent abusive relationships. [24]

In 2019, Elliott's mother Lesley Elliott closed the foundation, stating that her Parkinson's disease prevented her from continuing to run the foundation, and that she did not want another person controlling her daughter's image. [25] As of 2021, the New Zealand Police continue to run the Loves-Me-Not workshop in high schools. [26] [27]

Related Research Articles

The gay panic defense or homosexual advance defence is a strategy of legal defense, which refers to a situation in which a heterosexual individual charged with a violent crime against a homosexual individual claims they lost control and reacted violently because of an unwanted sexual advance that was made upon them. A defendant will use available legal defenses against assault and murder, with the aim of seeking an acquittal, a mitigated sentence, or a conviction of a lesser offense. A defendant may allege to have found the same-sex sexual advances so offensive or frightening that they were provoked into reacting, were acting in self-defense, were of diminished capacity, or were temporarily insane, and that this circumstance is exculpatory or mitigating.

In law, provocation is when a person is considered to have committed a criminal act partly because of a preceding set of events that might cause a reasonable individual to lose self control. This makes them less morally culpable than if the act was premeditated (pre-planned) and done out of pure malice. It "affects the quality of the actor's state of mind as an indicator of moral blameworthiness."

In 2004, seven men living on Pitcairn Island faced 55 charges relating to sexual offences against children and young adults. The accused represented a third of the island's male population and included Steve Christian, the mayor. On 24 October, all but one of the defendants were found guilty on at least some of the charges. Another six men living abroad, including Shawn Christian, who later served as mayor of Pitcairn, were tried on 41 charges in a separate trial in Auckland, New Zealand, in 2005.

Battered woman syndrome (BWS) is a psychological trauma that results from ongoing physical, psychological, and/or sexual abuse, typically at the hands of an intimate partner. This syndrome is one of a group of conditions known as Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) and can lead to symptoms of depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and even physical health problems. BWS can also result in the development of a “survival personality”, in which the person acts out of fear and attempts to avoid further harm. The symptoms of BWS are often divided into three categories: physical, psychological, and behavioral. Physically, victims of BWS may display signs of physical injury or illness, such as bruises, broken bones, or chronic fatigue. Psychologically, they may experience depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, and feelings of helplessness, guilt, and fear. Behaviorally, victims may exhibit a range of behaviors, including self-isolation, suicidal thoughts, and substance abuse. It is important to recognize that the effects of BWS may vary from person to person. Treatment for BWS typically includes individual and group therapy, as well as support from family and friends. Treatment may focus on helping the victim to develop healthy coping mechanisms, identify triggers for abusive behavior, and build self-esteem. In addition, it is important to ensure that the victim has access to safe housing and other resources, such as legal aid and counseling. Battered woman syndrome (BWS) is a pattern of signs and symptoms displayed by a woman who has suffered persistent intimate partner violence: whether psychological, physical, or sexual, from her male partner. It is classified in the ICD-9 (code 995.81) as battered person syndrome, but is not in the DSM-5. It may be diagnosed as a subcategory of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bain family murders</span> 1994 multiple homicide in New Zealand

On 20 June 1994, Robin and Margaret Bain and three of their four children – Arawa, Laniet, and Stephen – were shot to death in Dunedin, New Zealand. The only suspects were David Cullen Bain, the eldest son and only survivor, and Robin Bain, the father. David Bain, aged 22, was charged with five counts of murder. In May 1995, he was convicted on each of the five counts and sentenced to mandatory life in prison with a minimum non-parole period of sixteen years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Chauvel (politician)</span> New Zealand politician and lawyer

Charles Pierre Chauvel is a New Zealand lawyer and former New Zealand politician who was a Labour list Member of Parliament (2006–2013) until his resignation to take up a position with the UN Development Programme. He was the first New Zealand MP of Tahitian ancestry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antonie Dixon</span> New Zealand thief and murderer

Antonie Dixon was a convicted New Zealand thief and murderer. His most notorious crimes were committed in an 11-hour spree of violence in 2003 in which he completely or partially severed the hands or arms of two women with a Samurai sword, shot a man dead with a homemade sub-machine gun and kidnapped another man. Dixon acquired over 150 convictions, mostly for theft and burglary; he was imprisoned at least 14 times. His former girlfriend Simonne Butler said he used methamphetamine from at least 2001.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kaikorai Valley College</span> State, co-educational, secondary school in Dunedin

Kaikorai Valley College is a large co-educational secondary school in Dunedin, New Zealand. Initially starting as Kaikorai Valley High School in 1958, the school combined with Kenmure Intermediate School in 1996 to become Kaikorai Valley College,. It celebrated its 50th jubilee in 2008.

Arthur Allan Thomas is a New Zealand man who was granted a Royal Pardon and compensation after being wrongfully convicted of the murders of Harvey and Jeannette Crewe in June 1970. Thomas was married and farming a property in the Pukekawa district, south of Auckland before the case. Following the revelation that the crucial evidence against him had been faked, Thomas was pardoned in 1979 and awarded NZ$950,000 in compensation for his 9 years in prison and loss of earnings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air New Zealand Flight 2279</span> 2008 attempted aircraft hijacking

Air New Zealand Flight 2279 was a commuter flight operated by Air National on behalf of Eagle Airways, a regional carrier division of Air New Zealand. The flight was the subject of an unsuccessful hijack attempt on 8 February 2008 during which both pilots and a passenger suffered knife wounds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Urban Höglin and Heidi Paakkonen</span> Murder of two Swedish tourists

Swedish tourists Sven Urban Höglin, aged 23, and his fiancée Heidi Birgitta Paakkonen, aged 21, disappeared while tramping on the Coromandel Peninsula of New Zealand in 1989. Police, residents, and military personnel conducted the largest land-based search undertaken in New Zealand, attempting to find the couple. In December 1990, David Wayne Tamihere was convicted of murdering Höglin and Paakkonen, and sentenced to life imprisonment based largely on the testimony of three prison inmates.

Gregory James King was a New Zealand criminal defence lawyer and broadcaster. He has been described as "one of this country's finest legal brains".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Mallory Manning</span> New Zealand crime

Ngatai Lynette Manning was murdered in Christchurch, New Zealand, on 18 December 2008. Manning was picked up from Manchester Street and presumably taken to a property in Avonside and brutally killed by stabbing, strangling and assault with a metal pole. Her body was then dumped in the nearby Avon River and found the next morning by a kayaker. In March 2012 a 24-year-old man was arrested and charged with the murder and abduction of Manning. He was later convicted of her murder, however this conviction was overturned on appeal and the charge was later dismissed.

Christine Marie Lundy, 38, and her 7-year-old daughter Amber Grace Lundy were murdered in Palmerston North, New Zealand, on 29 August 2000. Cell phone data proved that Christine's husband, Mark Lundy was in Petone at 5:30 pm and 8:28 pm that night. He was also confirmed as being in his motel in Petone between 11:30 pm and 1:00 am by a sex worker. In February 2001, after a six month investigation, Mark Edward Lundy, was arrested and charged with murdering his wife and daughter.

Colin Bouwer (1950-2018) was a South African-born New Zealand former doctor who rose to become Head of Psychiatry at the University of Otago in Dunedin, New Zealand. He spent 16 years in prison for the murder of his third wife Annette. His crime was dramatised in the TV movie Bloodlines, with Bouwer being portrayed by Mark Mitchinson. His son from a previous marriage was also convicted of an unrelated murder in 2003. His first wife was also convicted of helping their son cover up his crime.

Ben Smart and Olivia Hope, two young New Zealanders, disappeared in the early hours of the morning on New Year's Day, 1 January 1998. The two friends had been celebrating on New Year's Eve at Furneaux Lodge in the Marlborough Sounds with other partygoers. The pair accepted an offer from a stranger to stay aboard his yacht in the early hours of the morning, and it was the last time they were seen alive. The disappearance of the duo sparked one of the most publicised and controversial investigations in New Zealand's history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lesley Elliott (campaigner)</span> New Zealand nurse and campaigner (1946–2022)

Lesley Frances Elliott was a New Zealand nurse and the founder and chairperson of the Sophie Elliott Foundation, an organisation that educated New Zealanders on the signs of abuse in personal relationships. She was moved to start the work after her daughter Sophie was killed by her former boyfriend in January 2008. She realised that she had been unaware that he was abusive, but that it was possible to identify the signs. In 2019, she closed the Sophie Elliott Foundation as her Parkinson's disease was preventing her from continuing to run the foundation and she did not want another person to control her daughter's image.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judith Ablett-Kerr</span>

Judith Mary Ablett-Kerr is a criminal defence lawyer and King's Counsel in New Zealand.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Grace Millane</span> 2018 killing of a British tourist in New Zealand

Grace Emmie Rose Millane was a British tourist whose disappearance in Auckland, New Zealand, in December 2018 sparked international attention. A 26-year-old man, Jesse Shane Kempson, was charged with her murder on 8 December 2018, and her body was found in the Waitākere Ranges to the west of Auckland the following day. Kempson's name was suppressed by New Zealand courts, meaning it could not be published in New Zealand; however, some international media outlets chose to publish it contrary to the New Zealand court order.

Amber-Rose Rush was a 16-year-old New Zealander whose death in Dunedin in February 2018 drew extensive national media coverage. Venod Skantha, a 30-year-old Dunedin doctor, was subsequently charged with her murder. The trial of Skantha commenced on 4 November 2019 at the Dunedin High Court on a charge of murder and four counts of threatening to kill. On 26 November 2019, Skantha was found guilty of all charges. In 2020 he was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a minimum non-parole term of 19 years. On 14 April 2021, the New Zealand Court of Appeal dismissed Skantha's appeal and affirmed his conviction. The following day, Skantha was reported to have died in custody.

References

  1. ↑ Gilchrist, Shane (10 June 2011). "Elliott book aims 'to set record straight'". Otago Daily Times. Retrieved 10 June 2011. Tomorrow [11 June 2011] would have been Miss Elliott's 26th birthday.
  2. 1 2 "Sophie Elliott killing: Weatherston 'calm, collected'". stuff.co.nz. 24 June 2009. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  3. 1 2 Hartevelt, John (22 July 2009). "Weatherston guilty of murder". The Press. Retrieved 15 October 2009.
  4. ↑ "NZ tutor guilty of girlfriend's murder". The Sydney Morning Herald. 22 July 2009. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  5. ↑ "Unanimous 'no' to provocation defence". The New Zealand Herald. 19 August 2009. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  6. ↑ "Clayton Weatherston to be sentenced today". 3 News. 15 September 2009. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  7. ↑ "Provocation defence abolished". The New Zealand Herald. 27 November 2009. Retrieved 26 November 2009.
  8. ↑ Porteous, Debbie & Harvey, Sarah (11 January 2008). "Murder cuts short life of brilliant student". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  9. ↑ Hartevelt, John (8 July 2009). "I killed her, Weatherston told officer at scene". The Press. Retrieved 18 October 2009.
  10. ↑ Sinclair, Kay (7 July 2009). "Sophie 'died from blood loss'". Otago Daily Times. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  11. ↑ Price, Mark (25 July 2009). "Narcissists – those infatuated with self". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  12. ↑ Porteous, Debbie (15 September 2009). "Weatherston gets life". Otago Daily Times. Retrieved 15 October 2009.
  13. ↑ Patrick Gower (13 November 2009). "Sophie's father says judge censored him". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 1 February 2010.
  14. ↑ "Censored: What Sophie's father Gil could not say". The New Zealand Herald. 13 November 2009. Retrieved 1 February 2010.
  15. ↑ Hartevelt, John (14 October 2009). "Appeal by killer appalls Elliott family". The Press. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  16. ↑ "Clayton Weatherston to appeal conviction". The New Zealand Herald. 13 October 2009. Retrieved 16 October 2009.
  17. 1 2 "Weatherston not given fair trial: lawyer". Otago Daily Times. 7 April 2011. Retrieved 25 April 2011.
  18. ↑ "Crown dismisses Weatherston's claim trial was unfair". One News. 6 April 2011. Retrieved 25 April 2011.
  19. ↑ "Family thankful killer's appeal dismissed". Stuff.co.nz. 17 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2011.
  20. ↑ "Weatherston to stay in jail – final appeal rejected". The New Zealand Herald. 13 September 2011. Retrieved 14 September 2011.
  21. ↑ Satherley, Dan (6 October 2010). "Sophie Elliott Foundation launched". 3 News NZ.
  22. ↑ Harvey, Sarah (6 October 2010). "Sophie Elliott Foundation launched". The Southland Times. Retrieved 28 March 2011.
  23. ↑ Booker, Jarrod (11 June 2011). "Family's bid to honour Sophie". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 18 June 2011.
  24. ↑ "Loves-Me-Not Relationship Education". Sophie Elliott Foundation. Archived from the original on 5 January 2020.
  25. ↑ "Lesley Elliott closes Sophie Elliott Foundation 11 years after her daughter's murder". Newshub. Retrieved 31 May 2020.
  26. ↑ O'Connell, Tim (31 August 2019). "Sophie Elliott Foundation to close, Police to continue Lesley Elliott's work in preventing abuse". Stuff.co.nz. Retrieved 21 July 2021.
  27. ↑ "Loves-Me-Not". New Zealand Police. Retrieved 21 July 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.