| Year | Award Winner | School | Class | University |
|---|
| 2025 | Jaiden Haile | West Fargo Horace | AA | Gonzaga University |
| 2024 | Jocelyn Schiller | Grand Forks Red River | AA | University of North Dakota |
| 2023 | Logan Nissley | Bismarck Century | A | University of Nebraska |
| 2022 | Abby Duchscherer | Kindred | B | University of Alabama (softball) |
| 2021 | Samantha Oase | Hettinger/Scranton | B | Black Hills State University |
| 2020 | Reile Payne | Fargo Shanley | A | Bismarck State College (Volleyball and Basketball)
Ottawa University (volleyball) |
| 2019 | Megan Zander | Mandan | A | University of North Dakota
University of Mary |
| 2018 | Anna Holen | LaMoure/Litchville-Marion | B | University of Jamestown (volleyball) |
| 2017 | Tylee Irwin | Wahpeton | A | South Dakota State University |
| 2016 | Sarah Jacobson | Fargo Shanley | A | North Dakota State University |
| 2015 | Hannah Stewart | Minot Bishop Ryan | B | University of Iowa |
| 2014 | Paige Peterson | Jamestown | A | Augustana University |
| 2013 | Hannah Larson | Bismarck Century | A | University of Mary |
| 2012 | Holly Johnson | Minot | A | North Dakota State University |
| 2011 | Caitlin Farroh | Grand Forks Central | A | Northern State University |
| 2010 | Eli Benz | Kidder County | B | Gustavus Adolphus College |
| 2009 | Ali Collins | Mandan | A | University of Mary |
| 2008 | Christine Miller | New Town | B | Williston State College |
| 2007 | Jessica Kielpinski | Mandan | A | University of North Dakota |
| 2006 | Rebecca Feickert | Sheridan County | B | University of Kansas |
| 2005 | Rebecca Kielpinski | Mandan | A | University of Alaska Anchorage |
| 2004 | Ruthie Dockter | Washburn | B | University of North Dakota |
| 2003 | Carissa Jahner | Fargo North | A | University of North Dakota |
| 2001 | Katie Lorenz | Langdon | B | North Dakota State University |
| 2000 | Kari Hanson | Mandan | A | Kansas State University |
| 1999 | Lora Schauer | Wishek | B | North Dakota State University |
| 1998 | Mary Perrizo | Mandan | A | University of North Dakota |
| 1997 | Angie Welle | Fargo Shanley | A | Iowa State University |
| 1996 | Jaye Amundson | Mandan | A | North Dakota State University |
| 1995 (tie) | Lisa Maus | Hatton | B | University of Mary |
| Katie Richards | Hope-Page | B | University of North Dakota |
| Nina Topp | Midkota | B | Weber State University |
| 1994 | Brenna Stefonowicz | Divide County | B | North Dakota State University |
| 1993 | Tanya Fischer | Bowman | B | North Dakota State University |
| 1992 | Shelly Berg | Minot | A | Weber State University |
| 1991 | Christy Waldal | Beach | A | University of North Dakota |
| 1990 | Lynette Mund | Milnor | B | North Dakota State University |
| 1989 | Sarah Hokenson | Fargo Shanley | A | North Dakota State University |
| 1988 | Nadine Schmidt | Braddock | B | North Dakota State University |
| 1987 | Wanda Schwab | Esmond/Maddock | B | Valley City State University |
| 1986 | Sue Hesch | Wahpeton | A | University of Nebraska |
| 1985 (tie) | Durene Heisler | Devils Lake | A | University of North Dakota |
| Whitney Meier | Rolla | B | Louisiana State University |
| 1984 | Pat Smykowski | Lidgerwood | B | North Dakota State University |
