Physique photography

Last updated
A 1950 photograph from physique studio Athletic Model Guild. Physique models were commonly photographed in "posing straps", the G-string-style undergarment worn here. Wells, Danny.jpg
A 1950 photograph from physique studio Athletic Model Guild. Physique models were commonly photographed in "posing straps", the G-string-style undergarment worn here.

Physique photography is a tradition of photography of nude or semi-nude (usually muscular) men which was largely popular between the early 20th century and the 1960s. Physique photography originated with the physical culture and bodybuilding movements of the early 20th century, but was gradually co-opted by homosexual producers and consumers, who favoured increasingly homoerotic content. The practiced reached its height in the 1950s and early 1960s with the inception of physique magazines, which existed largely to showcase physique photographs and were widely consumed by a mostly-gay audience.

Contents

Physique photography fell out of fashion toward the end of the 1960s, supplanted by increasingly explicit pornography as a result of loosening legal definitions of obscenity. Physique photographers have provided inspiration to later artists such as Robert Mapplethorpe, and, towards the end of the 20th century, their work has come to be appreciated as art in its own right. [1]

History

Eugen Sandow in 1894. Photographic depictions of the bodies of strongmen and athletes gained popularity through the early 20th century with the rise of the physical culture movement. Eugen Sandow, full-length portrait, standing facing left, wearing fig leaf LCCN91789066.tif
Eugen Sandow in 1894. Photographic depictions of the bodies of strongmen and athletes gained popularity through the early 20th century with the rise of the physical culture movement.

The early 20th century saw a sharp increase in interest in weightlifting and bodybuilding, partly spurred by the "physical culture" movement. Magazines devoted to physical culture began to appear in the 1890s with titles like Eugen Sandow's Physical Culture and increased in number and popularity through the early 20th century. Images of muscular athletes and bodybuilders also became common fodder in the wider press, and in visual media like postcards, which experienced a boom in popularity between 1900 and 1920.

By 1920, the demand for these photographs was sufficient to support photographers who dedicated themselves entirely to physique photography, such as John Hernic. [2]

Scholar Thomas Waugh dates the first appearance of a "systematic crypto-gay subculture" working behind the scenes of the bodybuilding sphere to the 1930s. [3] Gay physique photographers working during this era included Edwin F. Townsend, Earle Forbes, Robert Gebhart, Al Urban, Lon Hanagan, Lou Melan, Barton Horvath, and Dick Falcon (all but the last operating in New York City). [3]

Another early nexus for gay men's involvement in the physique world were bodybuilding competitions. The first of the modern bodybuilding competitions, Mr. America, began in 1939. [4] According to Bob Mizer, it was an "open secret" that gay men comprised a large portion of the audience for these competitions, in which men would display their muscled bodies on stage in skimpy costumes. [5] Gay men also became involved behind-the-scenes in the bodybuilding community, organizing competitions, and working as event photographers. [5]

In the early 1950s, the physique magazine began to appear as a genre, beginning with Bob Mizer's Physique Pictorial in 1951. While these magazines purported to be intended for fitness enthusiasts, like the physical culture and bodybuilding magazines that preceded them, they were in reality purchased almost entirely by gay men (and often produced by them). Compared to legitimate fitness magazines, they devoted their pages disproportionately to photography, including only perfunctory references to muscular development and exercises. They also tended to use models with more slender body types, and often featured more naturalistic poses.

Physique photography, along with the physique magazine genre, declined from the mid 1960s as relaxed legal standards for obscenity gave rise to increasingly hardcore pornography.

As gay subculture

The network of (largely gay) physique photographers and their customers represent among the earliest gay subcultures. Sexologist Alfred Kinsey was the earliest researcher to recognize (as early as 1939) the connection between the physique field and male homosexuality. In the course of his research, Kinsey interviewed many physique photographers, customers, and models, and would go on to form a long friendship with photographer and publisher Bob Mizer. The archives of the Kinsey Institute now contain one of the most significant collections of physique photography and related documents in the world. [6]

Photographs

Explicitness

Photographs featuring frontal nudity such as this 1950s Bob Mizer photo could not be published, but were discreetly offered for sale directly to customers. Bob Mizer, Boxer.jpg
Photographs featuring frontal nudity such as this 1950s Bob Mizer photo could not be published, but were discreetly offered for sale directly to customers.

During the heyday of physique photography, photographers around the world were generally unable to include frontal nudity in any photos that were to be published in books or magazines, due to legal prohibitions against obscenity. However, many photographers took nude photos which they offered for sale directly to customers.

In published photos, models were most commonly attired in a "posing strap": a G-string-like undergarment which covered only the genitals. In other cases, models wore shorts, swim suits, or had their genitals obscured by a towel, sheet, or other object. Nude photos taken from behind were sometimes printable depending on local standards and laws.

Another practice was to doctor negatives or prints to add an "inked-in" posing strap to a nude photo, rendering it suitable for publication. This technique was especially common among early physique photographers of the 1930s, many of whom shot nearly exclusively in the nude. [7]

By the 1970s, most physique photographers and studios were openly focusing on nude photography, abandoning the posing straps of the previous decades. Frontal nudity had become legally acceptable, though models could not necessarily be depicted with erections. [8] In the UK, the illegality of depicting erections in photographs led to a workaround wherein a model's tumescent penis would be maneuvered to point downward, so that it could be plausibly claimed that they were not truly "erect". [9]

Props, scenery, and costumes

Sometimes models were outfitted in archetypically masculine costumes, appearing as sailors, gladiators, wrestlers, or body builders. [10]

Models

With the exception of a few popular models such as Glenn Bishop and Ed Fury, physique models were generally not well compensated. Writing in 1965, Clark Polak estimated that a typical model was paid between $5 and $100. Some studios, such as Canada's Mark One, did not pay models at all. [11] Most models identified as heterosexual, [12] and varied in their awareness of and attitude toward the gay audience for their photographs. [13]

While some photographers maintained a strictly professional relationship with the models they photographed, others, such as John S. Barrington were known to regularly proposition models for sex. Others formed long-term (quasi-)romantic relationships with particular models, such as Bruce Bellas with Scotty Cunningham or Alonzo Hanagan and Raul Pacheco. [14]

Distribution

The most visible outlet for physique photographs was magazines - beginning with legitimate physical culture and bodybuilding magazines like Strength & Health , and later moving to dedicated physique magazines. The physique studios which provided photographs for physique magazines received little in the way of direct compensation from publishers; instead, the magazines served to advertise their mail order sales of photographs directly to readers. Many of the most prominent physique studios, such as those of Bruce Bellas and Lon of New York, started their own magazines, which essentially served as advertising catalogues. [15]

Photographs which were sold directly to customers were often more explicit than the ones displayed in magazines. In the early 1950s, many serious bodybuilding magazines ceased printing physique photographers' advertisements, under pressure from the US Post Office. For example, Iron Man explained to readers that they had discontinued ads for photos "except those printed and bound in book form that can be inspected and approved by us", because "too many advertisers used their ads for the sale of nudes and questionable photos". [16] It was this crackdown, in part, which led to the founding of physique magazines dedicated to homoerotic photography.

Because nude photographs were classified as obscene, some photographers sold them only in-person, to avoid prosecution by the Post Office. Some, such as Al Urban and Bruce Bellas, were known to travel the country to hand-deliver illicit photos. [17]

American physique photographers who sent their work through the mail were liable to be investigated by postal inspectors. During the early to mid 20th century, the US Post Office vigorously enforced the Comstock laws against sending obscene materials through the mail. Most major photographers faced intimidating or arrest at various points in their career, with many, including Bob Mizer and John Barrington, being jailed as a result. [18]

To avoid discovery, physique photographers (whether professional or amateur) were often forced to develop their own film (or find a sympathetic party to develop it for them), especially in the case of nude photographs. [9] Because Kodak had strict control over the development of 16 mm color film, physique films were long limited to black and white, which could be developed by third-party labs or by the photographers themselves. [19]

Notable photographers

PhotographerAliasesNotes
Gregor Arax AraxA Greek national who operated out of Paris under the mononym Arax. Took some of the most notable photographs of Steve Reeves. [20] Active beginning in the 1920s. [3] Heterosexual. [21] In 1950, he had his photographs seized by authorities, and was subject to legal harassment in the following two years. [21]
Alonzo Hanagan Lon of New York
Russ Warner WarnerA California photographer known for his photography of Steve Reeves. In 1955, his studio was raided by police, leading to one of his models being fired from the Oakland Fire Department. [22]
Bruce Bellas Bruce of Los Angeles
Robert Gebhart [3] GebbéActive in the United States in the 1950s and 1960s. [23]
John S. Barrington John Paignton [24] Also worked as a sculptor, journalist, and author. [25]
Ron FerreroLon of LondonFormer assistant to Lon of New York. [24]
John GrahamDoricOperated out of Knightsbridge, and often used local guardsmen as models. [24]
G. Rodney CrowtherWorked closely with entrepreneur H. Lynn Womack. [26]
Anthony GuytherVulcan StudiosOriginally based in New York City, but later formed a close association with H. Lynn Womack and moved to Washington, D.C. [27]
Frederick Kovert Kovert of HollywoodFormer silent film actor, active in the 1930s and 1940s. Bob Mizer began his career apprenticing with Kovert.
George Haimsohn [28] Plato
Dick FalconA bodybuilder who began photographing others in the 1930s. [29] Located in Columbus, Ohio. [3]
Barton HorvathBorn 1912. Began operating in New York City in the 1930s. [3]
Al Urban Among the most prominent photographers of the post-war "golden age" of physique photography. [3]
Jean FerreroA heterosexual photographer in Nice, France. [21]

Studios

StudioHeadLocationNotes
Galaxy [8] George Stockton Richmond, London
Kris Studios Dom Orejudos and Chuck Renslow Chicago

See also

Citations

  1. Cooper 2007, p. 111.
  2. Waugh 1996, p. 205.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Waugh 1996, p. 208.
  4. Waugh 1996, p. 210.
  5. 1 2 Johnson 2019, pp. 28–29.
  6. Waugh 1996, pp. 216, 231.
  7. Waugh 1996, p. 209.
  8. 1 2 Cooper 2007, p. 105.
  9. 1 2 Cooper 2007, p. 130.
  10. Escoffier 2009, p. 18.
  11. Waugh 1996, pp. 234–237.
  12. Krauss 2015, p. 219.
  13. Waugh 1996, pp. 236–237.
  14. Waugh 1996, pp. 231–232.
  15. Waugh 1996, p. 242.
  16. "Readers Roundup". Iron Man. 14 (4): 52. January 1955.
  17. Waugh 1996, pp. 247–248.
  18. Johnson 2010, p. 876.
  19. Waugh 1996, p. 248.
  20. Cooper 2007, p. 100.
  21. 1 2 3 Jackson, Julian (2009). Living in Arcadia : homosexuality, politics, and morality in France from the liberation to AIDS. University of Chicago Press. pp. 173–175. OCLC   748910710.
  22. Waugh 1996, p. 274.
  23. Cooper 2007, p. 285.
  24. 1 2 3 Cooper 2007, p. 104.
  25. Cooper 2007, p. 274.
  26. Johnson 2019, p. 220.
  27. Johnson 2019, pp. 220–221.
  28. Gunn, Drewey Wayne (2016-01-21). Gay American Novels, 1870-1970: A Reader's Guide. McFarland. ISBN   9780786499052.
  29. Krauss 2015, p. 212.

Related Research Articles

Tom of Finland Finnish artist

Touko Valio Laaksonen, best known by his pseudonym Tom of Finland, was a Finnish artist known for his stylized highly masculinized homoerotic art, and for his influence on late 20th-century gay culture. He has been called the "most influential creator of gay pornographic images" by cultural historian Joseph W. Slade. Over the course of four decades, he produced some 3,500 illustrations, mostly featuring men with exaggerated primary and secondary sex traits, wearing tight or partially removed clothing.

The Athletic Model Guild, or AMG, was a physique photography studio founded by Bob Mizer in December 1945. During those post-war years, United States censorship laws allowed women, but not men, to appear in various states of undress in what were referred to as "art photographs". Mizer began his business by taking pictures of men that he knew. His subjects would often pose for pictures which illustrated fitness tips and the like, but were also viewed as homoerotic material.

Bruce Bellas was an influential photographer of male nudes. Bellas was well known under the pseudonym Bruce of Los Angeles.

Pornographic magazine Magazines that contain content of an explicitly sexual nature

Pornographic magazines or erotic magazines, sometimes known as adult, sex or top-shelf magazines, are magazines that contain content of an explicitly sexual nature. Publications of this kind may contain images of attractive naked subjects, as is the case in softcore pornography, and, in the usual case of hardcore pornography, depictions of masturbation, oral, vaginal or anal sex.

Tony Sansone

Tony Sansone was an Italian-American bodybuilder and model.

Jim French (photographer)

Jim French was an American artist, illustrator, photographer, filmmaker, and publisher. He is best known for his association with Colt Studio which he, using the pseudonym Rip Colt, created in late 1967. Thomas parted from the endeavor in 1974 leaving French to continue to build what would become one of the most successful gay male erotica companies in the U.S.

Physique magazine Magazine genre

Physique magazines or beefcake magazines were magazines devoted to physique photography — that is, photographs of muscular "beefcake" men – typically young and attractive – in athletic poses, usually in revealing, minimal clothing. During their heyday in North America in the 1950s to 1960s, they were presented as magazines dedicated to fitness, health, and bodybuilding, with the models often shown demonstrating exercises or the results of their regimens, or as artistic reference material. However, their unstated primary purpose was erotic imagery, primarily created by and for gay men at a time when homosexuality was the subject of cultural taboos and government censorship.

MANual Enterprises, Inc. v. Day, 370 U.S. 478 (1962), is a decision by the United States Supreme Court which held that magazines consisting largely of photographs of nude or near-nude male models are not obscene within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 1461. It was the first case in which the Court engaged in plenary review of a Post Office Department order holding obscene matter "nonmailable."

Nude photography Photography of the naked human body.

Nude photography is the creation of any photograph which contains an image of a nude or semi-nude person, or an image suggestive of nudity. Nude photography is undertaken for a variety of purposes, including educational uses, commercial applications and artistic creations. The exhibition or publication of nude photographs may be controversial, more so in some cultures or countries than in others, and especially if the subject is a minor.

George Quaintance American artist

George Quaintance was an American artist, famous for his "idealized, strongly homoerotic" depictions of men in mid-20th-century physique magazines. Using historical settings to justify the nudity or distance the subjects from modern society, his art featured idealized muscular, semi-nude or nude male figures; Wild West settings were a common motif. His artwork helped establish the stereotype of the "macho stud" who was also homosexual, leading him to be called a "pioneer of a gay aesthetic". He was an influence on many later homoerotic artists, such as Tom of Finland.

Al Urban (photographer) American physique photographer

Albert J. Urban, Jr. (1917-1992) was an American physique photographer. His work appeared widely in physical culture and physique magazines of the 1940s and 1950s. Scholar Thomas Waugh described Urban as one of the "pillars of the postwar golden age of gay physique culture".

Bob Mizer American photographer and filmmaker

Robert Henry Mizer was an American photographer and filmmaker, known for pushing boundaries of depicting male homoerotic content with his work in the mid 20th century.

<i>Strength & Health</i>

Strength & Health was a bodybuilding/fitness/Olympic weightlifting magazine, one of the earliest magazines devoted to fitness and bodybuilding. Until the late 1960s, it was the most popular weightlifting magazine in the United States. It was published between 1932 and 1986 in 54 Volumes, a volume a year in 6 parts, published every 2–3 months.

Alonzo Hanagan American photographer

Alonzo "Lon" Hanagan was an American physique photographer during the 1940s and 1950s. He produced erotic images of men under the alias "Lon of New York", or simply "Lon".

<i>Physique Pictorial</i>

Physique Pictorial is an American magazine, one of the leading beefcake magazines of the mid-20th century. During its run from 1951 to 1990 as a quarterly publication, it exemplified the use of bodybuilding culture and classical art figure posing, as a cover for homoerotic male images, and to evade charges of obscenity.

<i>Grecian Guild Pictorial</i> Magazine

Grecian Guild Pictorial was an American physique magazine published from 1955 until 1968. While ostensibly dedicated to art, health, and exercise, like other physique magazines of the time, it was understood that, in practice, its homoerotic photography and illustrations were almost exclusively created by and for gay men. It differed from other physique magazines in its focus on themes and imagery from Ancient Greece, which was seen by many as a coded reference to homosexuality. It has been described as one of the "gayer" of the physique magazines.

<i>Tomorrows Man</i> Physique magazine

Tomorrow's Man was a digest size physique magazine published from 1952 to 1971. It was one of the first physique magazines, debuting a year after Bob Mizer's Physique Pictorial. It was the creation of Irvin ("Irv") Johnson, a Chicago gym owner and trainer. As of 1957, it had the highest circulation of any physique magazine in the United States. It was the first of many physique magazines to feature the artwork of Dom Orejudos. Tomorrow's Man was initially edited by William Bunton, who went on to work for competing magazine VIM in May 1954.

<i>TWO</i> (magazine) Canadian gay magazine

TWO, subtitled The Homosexual Viewpoint in Canada, was a Toronto gay magazine published between 1964 and 1966. It combined physique photography with a variety of editorial content including articles, reviews of local gay nightlife, and fiction. TWO was one of Toronto's first gay magazines, and was among the first magazines to combine the pictorial content of the physique genre with overtly gay editorial content.

John S. Barrington (1920-1991) was a British physique photographer and publisher. Barrington's photos of nude or semi-nude men appeared widely in British and American physique magazines, sometimes under the pseudonym John Paignton. Barrington published many of his own physique magazines, including Male Model Monthly, the first in Britain. He also published a number of books related to photography and anthropometry. Barrington was a prolific artist and publisher, and by 1984 was said to have published more nude titles than any other individual in Europe or the United States.

Russ Warner American photographer (1917–2004)

Russ Warner (1917–2004) was an American physique photographer. His photographs of bodybuilders appeared widely in physique and bodybuilding magazines of the 1950s and 1960s. His photography studio was initially located in Oakland California; he later relocated to the Los Angeles area.

References