Piet Koen

Last updated

In May 2021, Koen was designated as the presiding judge in the corruption trial of former President Jacob Zuma and arms company Thales, Zuma's alleged co-conspirator in Arms Deal corruption. [5] He handed down his first major ruling in that matter in October 2021, rejecting Zuma's special plea to halt prosecution on the grounds that, among other things, prosecutor Billy Downer was not competent to try the case. [6] [7] He denied Zuma leave to appeal the special plea judgement in February 2022, [8] [9] as did the Constitutional Court in December 2022. [10] [11]

However, in the interim, Zuma lodged a private prosecution against Downer, alleging that Downer had leaked confidential documents in contravention of the National Prosecuting Authority Act. In November 2023, Koen solicited submissions about the potential appropriateness of him recusing himself from Zuma's corruption trial, on the basis that he had already heard – and expressed himself unconvinced by – Zuma's arguments about Downer's alleged leak. Zuma's counsel, Dali Mpofu, argued strongly in favour of Koen's recusal. [12] [13] When the trial resumed in January 2023, Koen recused himself, saying that "it is what the sound administration of justice, the constitution and my conscience dictate" because his prior statements on the alleged leak could create the perception of bias. [14] [15] [16]

Higher courts

Koen was an acting judge in the Supreme Court of Appeal between December 2014 and March 2015, between December 2019 and May 2020, and between October and November 2023. [1] In April 2020, he wrote for the Supreme Court majority in Mahlangu v Minister of Police, [17] which limited the Minister of Police's liability for unlawful detention until it was overturned by the Constitutional Court in 2021. [2]

In February 2021, Koen was among eleven candidates whom the Judicial Service Commission shortlisted for possible appointment to one of five permanent vacancies at the Supreme Court of Appeal. [18] During the interviews, which were held in April, Koen said that he took a "positivist" approach to judicial interpretation and aimed to "write judgments for the loser... the loser must understand why they have lost". [2] He was also criticised at length by Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, who said that a 2016 judicial management meeting with Koen had been "one of my worst experiences". [19] According to Mogoeng:

You were one of the leading voices in that meeting. It was one of the most unfortunate meetings a judge should ever have — and I am putting that in the lightest possible way... I was deeply concerned how you treat the advocates that appear before you — litigants and witnesses, and members of the public. I thought: how did he become a judge?... I am worried about discourtesy. You were extremely rude, it was completely unbefitting for a judge. [19]

At the conclusion of the interviews, the Judicial Service Commission did not recommended Koen for appointment to the Supreme Court. Commentators objected to Mogoeng's "thin-skinned and overly personal" questioning of Koen, [20] [21] and 82 members of the KwaZulu-Natal Society of Advocates signed a statement in Koen's defence. [22] The Mail & Guardian suggested in August 2021 that Mogoeng had misremembered or mischaracterised the 2016 meeting. [23]

In October 2022, Koen was again interviewed for possible elevation, this time as one of eleven candidates for five new vacancies at the Supreme Court of Appeal. [24] During his interview, he was asked about his approach to adjudicating Zuma's corruption trial. [25] [26] He also told the interview panel that he had "felt gutted by the criticism that had been expressed of me" during his last Judicial Service Commission, and he also provided transcripts and audio recordings of the 2016 meeting which Mogoeng had described. [27] Deputy Chief Justice Mandisa Maya said that Mogoeng's description did not fit with her perception of Koen, who, when acting at the appellate court, had "always behaved impeccably". [27] However, the Judicial Service Commission again declined to recommend Koen for appointment. [28] [29]

Personal life

Koen has two children. [1] According to a 2020 disclosure of financial interests, he held R7.7-million in managed investments. [30]

Related Research Articles

The Judicial Service Commission is a body specially constituted by the South African Constitution to recommend persons for appointment to the judiciary of South Africa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mogoeng Mogoeng</span> Chief Justice of South Africa

Mogoeng Thomas Reetsang Mogoeng is a South African jurist who served as the Chief Justice of South Africa from 8 September 2011 until his retirement on 11 October 2021.

Zukisa Laura Lumka Tshiqi is a South African judge of the Constitutional Court of South Africa. She formerly served in the Supreme Court of Appeal from December 2009 until October 2019, when President Cyril Ramaphosa elevated her to the Constitutional Court. She was a practising attorney until she was first appointed to the bench in the Gauteng High Court in 2005.

Xola Mlungisi Petse is a South African judge who has been the Deputy President of the Supreme Court of Appeal since 2019. A former attorney, he joined the Supreme Court as a puisne judge in June 2012. Before that, he was a judge of the Eastern Cape High Court from July 2005 to May 2012.

Rammaka Steven Mathopo is a judge of the Constitutional Court of South Africa. Before his elevation to that court in January 2022, he served in the Supreme Court of Appeal between June 2015 and December 2021. He was formerly a judge of the Gauteng High Court from January 2006 to May 2015, and he practised as an attorney for 17 years before then.

Jacob Zuma, the former president of South Africa, is currently being criminally charged for proven corruption in the 1999 Arms Deal. He was first indicted on the charges in June 2005, but attempts to prosecute him have been beset by legal challenges and political controversy. He is currently charged with two counts of corruption, one count each of racketeering and money laundering, and twelve counts of fraud, all arising from his receipt of 783 payments which the state alleges were bribes from businessman Schabir Shaik and French arms company Thales.

Nambitha Dambuza is a South African judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal. A former attorney, she sat in the Eastern Cape High Court from 2005 until her appointment to the Supreme Court in June 2015.

Fayeeza Kathree-Setiloane is a South African judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal. She joined the appellate court in December 2023 after 13 years in the Gauteng High Court. Before her appointment to the bench in October 2010, she practiced as an advocate of the High Court in Johannesburg; she was involved in constitutional litigation, including through the Legal Resources Centre, and also served a stint in corporate advisory at Werksmans.

Selewe Peter "Billy" Mothle is a South African judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal. Before his elevation to that court, he was a judge of the Gauteng High Court from January 2011 to June 2021. He rose to prominence as a lawyer in Pretoria, where he practised as an attorney until he gained admittance as an advocate in 1998. He took silk in 2008.

Dumisani Hamilton Zondi is a South African judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal. He was appointed as the chairperson of the Electoral Court in 2022. Before his elevation to the Supreme Court in June 2014, he served in the Western Cape High Court between 2007 and 2014, as well as in the Competition Appeal Court between 2011 and 2014. He entered legal practice as an attorney in 1986.

Aubrey Phago Ledwaba is South African judge who is currently serving as the Deputy Judge President of the Gauteng Division of the High Court of South Africa. Formerly a practising attorney in Gauteng, he joined the bench as a puisne judge in November 2005 and was elevated to his leadership position in July 2013. He was an acting judge in the Constitutional Court in 2019 and an acting judge in the Supreme Court of Appeal between 2020 and 2021.

Petrus Gcinumuzi Malindi is South African judge of the High Court of South Africa. He was appointed to the Gauteng Division in July 2021 after 25 years as a practising advocate, during which time he was well known for his association with the African National Congress. He was admitted to the Johannesburg Bar in 1995 and took silk in 2010. During apartheid, he rose to prominence as an anti-apartheid activist and defendant in the Delmas Treason Trial, which led to his conviction for terrorism and his imprisonment on Robben Island.

Annali Christelle Basson is a South African judge of the High Court of South Africa. She was appointed to the Gauteng Division in January 2016 after serving in the Labour Court from 2007 to 2016. Before her appointment to the bench, she was a legal academic at the University of South Africa, where she specialised in labour law and mercantile law. She was an acting judge in the Constitutional Court in 2018 and was shortlisted for permanent appointment to that court in 2019.

Alan Christopher Dodson SC is a South African lawyer who was a judge of the Land Claims Court from 1995 to 2000. He was also the chairperson of the United Nations's Housing and Property Claims Commission in Kosovo from 2000 to 2007. A member of the Johannesburg Bar since 2001 and Senior Counsel since 2011, he formerly practised as an attorney between 1987 and 1995.

Anna Maleshane Kgoele, also spelled Annah Malefsane Kgoele, is a South African judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal. She joined the appellate court in December 2023 after 14 years in the High Court of South Africa. From 2014 to 2018, she was the president of the South African chapter of the International Association of Women Judges.

Thoba Portia Poyo-Dlwati is a South African judge who is currently serving as the Judge President of the KwaZulu-Natal High Court. She joined the court as a puisne judge in June 2014 and was elevated to the judge presidency in January 2023, appointed by President Cyril Ramaphosa as the division's first female judge president.

Cagney John Musi is a South African judge who is currently serving as Judge President of the Free State High Court. He was appointed to the court as a puisne judge in June 2005 and was elevated to the judge presidency in December 2018 after two years' service as Deputy Judge President. Before joining the bench, he was a public prosecutor from 1986 to 1992 and a magistrate from 1992 to 2004.

Gayaat Salie-Hlophe, formerly known as Gayaat Salie-Samuels, is a South African judge of the High Court of South Africa. She was appointed to the Western Cape Division in January 2015 after nearly 17 years as a practising attorney in Cape Town. She was an acting judge in the Supreme Court of Appeal in 2022.

Mokgere Busisiwe Shareen Masipa is a South African judge of the High Court of South Africa. She was appointed to the KwaZulu-Natal Division in July 2016 after 14 years as a practising attorney in Durban. She is an expert on labour law.

Mmathebe Violet Phatshoane is a South African judge who is currently serving as Deputy Judge President of the Northern Cape High Court. She joined the court as a puisne judge in May 2011 and was appointed to the deputy judge presidency in July 2021. Before entering the judiciary, she practised as an attorney in Bloemfontein, specialising in commercial law and labour law.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 "Koen, Petrus Arnolus". Supreme Court of Appeal. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "Judge Piet A Koen". Judges Matter. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  3. ↑ "T Mbeki on appointment of Judges". South African Government. 13 November 2006. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  4. ↑ "Cwele sentenced to 12 years for drug dealing". The Mail & Guardian. 6 May 2011. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  5. ↑ Chabalala, Jeanette (13 May 2021). "Piet Koen named as Zuma trial judge, amid rumours of defence bid to oust Billy Downer". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  6. ↑ Maughan, Karyn (27 October 2021). "How Judge Piet Koen's ruling puts Jacob Zuma in a very tight corner". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  7. ↑ "High court dismisses Zuma's plea for state prosecutor Billy Downer's removal in arms deal corruption trial". The Mail & Guardian. 26 October 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  8. ↑ Maughan, Karyn (16 February 2022). "Koen dismisses all 6 Zuma legal challenges to his prosecution, orders trial must start in April". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  9. ↑ "High court dismisses Zuma's bid for appeal, trial to resume in April". The Mail & Guardian. 16 February 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  10. ↑ Maughan, Karyn (8 December 2022). "ConCourt dismisses Zuma's final bid to force Downer removal and demand corruption acquittal". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  11. ↑ "Concourt denies Zuma leave to appeal Downer ruling". The Mail & Guardian. 9 December 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  12. ↑ "Judge Koen must go, says Jacob Zuma". Sunday Times. 7 November 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  13. ↑ Erasmus, Des (6 November 2022). "Judge Koen should recuse himself from Arms Deal corruption trial – Jacob Zuma". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  14. ↑ "Piet Koen recuses himself from Jacob Zuma's arms deal trial". Business Day. 30 January 2023. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  15. ↑ Erasmus, Des (30 January 2023). "Zuma graft trial judge recuses himself, citing 'conscience', 'strong views'". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  16. ↑ "Judge Koen recuses himself from Zuma corruption trial". The Mail & Guardian. 30 January 2023. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  17. ↑ "Police not liable for continued judicial detention after forced confession: SCA". Sunday Times. 22 April 2020. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  18. ↑ "JSC shortlists candidates for judicial positions". News24. 2 February 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  19. 1 2 "Mogoeng Mogoeng lashes 'rude and discourteous' Supreme Court hopeful". Sunday Times. 14 April 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  20. ↑ February, Judith (24 April 2021). "Default or design: What game is Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng playing?". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  21. ↑ "Casac takes JSC to court over 'political' interview process for judges". Business Day. 3 June 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  22. ↑ "KZN advocates slam poor treatment of two judges at recent JSC interviews". Sunday Times. 19 May 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  23. ↑ "Was Judge Koen wrongly accused by the chief justice?". The Mail & Guardian. 14 August 2021. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  24. ↑ "No ConCourt candidates as Judicial Service Commission shortlists judges". The Citizen. 28 July 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  25. ↑ "Judge Piet Koen says he was devastated by Mogoeng's attack". The Mail & Guardian. 4 October 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  26. ↑ "It's politics as usual at the JSC". The Mail & Guardian. 6 October 2022. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  27. 1 2 Chabalala, Jeanette (3 October 2022). "SCA interviews: Judge Piet Koen tells JSC he was 'gutted' by Mogoeng's criticism". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  28. ↑ Maughan, Karyn (6 October 2022). "Judge presiding over Zuma corruption case misses out on appointment to Supreme Court of Appeal". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  29. ↑ Bhengu, Cebelihle (5 October 2022). "Judicial Service Commission recommends five candidates for SCA Bench". News24. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
  30. ↑ Merten, Marianne (16 March 2020). "Judges reveal their financial interests". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 5 January 2024.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
The Honourable
Piet Koen
Judge of the High Court
Assumed office
1 November 2006