Rebirth (sculpture)

Last updated
Rebirth
Rendering of Rebirth, an unfinished sculpture by Seyed Alavi.jpg
Rendering of the proposed sculpture
ArtistSeyed Alavi
TypeSculpture
SubjectDeer with a child's face
Dimensions9.1 m(30 ft)

Rebirth, nicknamed "Deer Baby" and "Twilight Zone Bambi", [1] was a proposed outdoor sculpture by American artist Seyed Alavi, considered for installation at the MAX Orange Line's Southeast Park Avenue MAX Station in Oak Grove, an unincorporated area neighboring Milwaukie in Clackamas County, Oregon, in the United States. The design of the unfinished creative work, which featured a 30-foot (9.1 m) deer with a child's face, was met with a mixed reception. Unable to meet TriMet's standards and remain under budget, in November 2011 Alavi withdrew his design from the project.

Contents

Description

Seyed Alavi's Rebirth was a proposed sculpture considered for installation at the MAX Orange Line's Southeast Park Avenue MAX Station in Oak Grove, an unincorporated area neighboring Milwaukie. The design of the unfinished creative work called for a 30-foot (9.1 m) yellow-painted deer with a child's face and was intended to represent "the interaction between the nearby riparian forest and the people living in Oak Grove". [2] In its concept proposal, the art installation is described as:

A large, stylized deer with childlike face speaks to the community's vision of renewal and the proximity of the station to the new Trolley Trail. Drawn from many traditions from NW Coast Native American carvings to colossal roadside sculpture, Rebirth is a monumental icon that creates a link between the natural environment and the commercial strip of McLoughlin Boulevard. [3]

Alavi's second, more "humanized", rendering of the sculpture Seyed Alavi's second rendering of Rebirth.jpg
Alavi's second, more "humanized", rendering of the sculpture

Two renderings of Alavi's design were made available to the public; the first computer-generated image did not include context, which arguably provoked debate over its design, while the second was more "humanized" and illustrated how the installation could interact with people and the surrounding environment. [1] TriMet confirmed at least two changes to the sculpture's original design: a 15-foot (4.6 m) move to the southeast to avoid crossing into the Trolley Trail or Milwaukie's boundaries, and removal of its mosaic tile facade to reduce costs. [1] [2]

In October 2011, the artist presented a revised concept to TriMet's Public Art Advisory Committee. The sculpture's color and dimensions were unchanged, but it would be made of glass-reinforced concrete. Its surface treatment remained undetermined, but Alavi wanted one that would be "natural or inherent" to the material to achieve a "reflective, glowing, and magical" appearance. The committee preferred the reflective appearance seen in the artist's original design and requested material samples at his final presentation, which was scheduled to take place in December. [4]

History and public reaction

Upon public release, Rebirth's design became a "target for ridicule". [2] In June 2011, Milwaukie neighborhood association leaders sent a letter to the Public Art Advisory Committee expressing their disappointment with the proposed deer concept, hoping to see changes to its final design. Some residents thought the sculpture should be more accessible and less expensive; conversely, the Oak Lodge Community Council chairwoman, who also served as a member of the art committee, hoped the sculpture could serve as a community space and reach "icon" status. [2] In a formal letter, TriMet's general manager responded to the neighborhood associations by encouraging residents to "communicate directly with the art committee by inviting members to neighborhood association leadership meetings". The agency's spokeswoman also told committee leaders that the public was welcome to share their preferences regarding the work's dimensions, fabrication methods, form, and materials. Oak Grove and Milwaukie residents also disagreed about whether or not those in the latter city had a say about the sculpture, which would have been within the area's boundaries according to the first design. [2]

In October 2011, at a public meeting to address TriMet's projected budget gap, one Milwaukie resident asked the agency to abandon its plans to fund Rebirth, saying that "a lot of people think that thing's just ugly. Why are they spending money on something that's an unnecessary add-on at the same time they're talking about cutting bus routes again?" [5] The agency's general manager responded that all possibilities would be considered, though TriMet officials confirmed that cuts to its public art program were not an option and the MAX Orange Line's budget was separate from TriMet's financial problems. [5]

In November 2011, TriMet's public art coordinator confirmed Alavi's withdrawal from the project, saying, "The artist for Park (Avenue) did his due diligence. He did everything possible to make that a reality, but sometimes it's not realistic." [1] According to The Oregonian , Alavi was unable to meet the Public Art Advisory Committee's technical requirements and remain under budget. [1] [6] One committee member admitted, "The form itself was something a lot of people out in the community weren't happy with in the first place, so once the mosaic piece was taken away, it kind of devalued it." [1] Alavi released the following statement:

In honor of the death of the "Deer Baby/Twilight Zone Bambi", I thought a quote by Rod Serling, might be appropriate...

"For the record, prejudices can kill and suspicion can destroy; and a thoughtless, frightened search for a scapegoat has a fallout all of its own for the children, and the children yet unborn. And the pity of it is, that these things cannot be confined to the Twilight Zone."

From The Twilight Zone episode, "The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street", March 6, 1960

Thanks,

Seyed Alavi [7]

The debate over the sculpture's proposed design by TriMet, the art committee, and members of the public reached "near-yelling match" status, resulting in "animosity and general nastiness". Following Alavi's withdrawal, the art committee made plans to reconvene and consider other design proposals for the site. [1]

Critical response

In articles providing updates about the sculpture's status, The Oregonian called the work "larger-than-life style highway art" and "Twilight Zone Bambi". [1] [5] [8] Angela Webber of the Daily Journal of Commerce expressed her love for the sculpture and disappointment in the public's reaction. [7] She wrote, "This makes me so sad. [...] Apparently, this giant baby-faced deer statue isn't pretty enough for Milwaukie. [...] I imagine the folks of Milwaukie just don't get it." [9]

Following confirmation about the artist's withdrawal, the journal's Aaron Spencer said local residents are being deprived of the sculpture's "disturbing fantastical whimsy". In an article called "Let's save the giant baby-faced deer statue!", he wrote: "As we all know, I love this statue. I love it a lot. And I think we can save it. There are lots of places in Portland that could use some beautification, and a little public art can go a long way." [6] Spencer and a colleague compiled a gallery of images created using Adobe Photoshop to illustrate the sculpture's potential. [6]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">MAX Light Rail</span> Light rail system serving Portland, Oregon

The Metropolitan Area Express (MAX) is a light rail system serving the Portland metropolitan area in the U.S. state of Oregon. Owned and operated by TriMet, it consists of five lines that together connect the six sections of Portland; the communities of Beaverton, Clackamas, Gresham, Hillsboro, Milwaukie, and Oak Grove; and Portland International Airport to Portland City Center. Trains run seven days a week with headways of between 30 minutes off-peak and three minutes during rush hours. In 2019, MAX had an average daily ridership of 120,900, or 38.8 million annually. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which impacted public transit use globally, annual ridership plummeted, with only 14.8 million riders recorded in 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Milwaukie, Oregon</span> City in Oregon, United States

Milwaukie is a city mostly in Clackamas County, Oregon, United States; a very small portion of the city extends into Multnomah County. The population was 21,119 at the 2020 census. Founded in 1847 on the banks of the Willamette River, the city, known as the Dogwood City of the West, was incorporated in 1903 and is the birthplace of the Bing cherry. The city is now a suburb of Portland and also adjoins the unincorporated areas of Clackamas and Oak Grove.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">TriMet</span> Oregon government-owned corporation responsible for public transit in the Portland area

The Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon (TriMet) is a public agency that operates mass transit in a region that spans most of the Portland metropolitan area in the U.S. state of Oregon. Created in 1969 by the Oregon legislature, the district replaced five private bus companies that operated in the three counties: Multnomah, Washington, and Clackamas. TriMet started operating a light rail system, MAX, in 1986, which has since been expanded to five lines that now cover 59.7 miles (96.1 km), as well as the WES Commuter Rail line in 2009. It also provides the operators and maintenance personnel for the city of Portland-owned Portland Streetcar system. In 2023, the system had a ridership of 62,055,600, or about 196,900 per weekday as of the fourth quarter of 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gresham Central Transit Center</span> Transit center and MAX light rail station in Gresham, Oregon, U.S.

The Gresham Central Transit Center, also known as Gresham Transit Center, is a TriMet transit center and MAX light rail station in Gresham, Oregon, United States. The center is a connection point for several bus routes and the MAX Blue Line. The light rail station is the 25th stop eastbound on the eastside MAX line, which was the Portland metropolitan area's first light rail line.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fair Complex/Hillsboro Airport station</span> Light rail station on the Portland-area MAX Blue Line in northwest Oregon

Fair Complex/Hillsboro Airport is a light rail station on the MAX Blue Line in Hillsboro, Oregon, United States. It is the 16th stop westbound on the Westside MAX, and the last westbound stop prior to crossing the Main Street Bridge. The station is located close to the Westside Commons – the 2019-adopted new name for the Washington County Fair Complex – and Hillsboro Airport, a major general-aviation facility in Hillsboro, and the location of the Oregon International Airshow in the summer. Bus line 46-North Hillsboro serves the station.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quatama station</span>

Quatama, formerly Quatama/Northwest 205th Avenue, is a light rail station in Hillsboro, Oregon, United States, that is served by TriMet as part of the MAX Light Rail system. Situated between Orenco station and Willow Creek/Southwest 185th Avenue Transit Center, it is the seventh eastbound station on the Blue Line. The two-track, island platform station includes a park-and-ride lot. Quatama Station is named after the area which includes Quatama Road to the south of the station. Opened in 1998, the stop is near high-tech industries and the Amberglen business park, which includes Oregon Health & Science University's West Campus and the Oregon National Primate Research Center. With the renaming of Northwest 205th Avenue to Northeast John Olsen Avenue by the city of Hillsboro in 2017, TriMet changed the station's name from its original, longer name.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Orenco station (TriMet)</span> Light rail station in Hillsboro, Oregon, United States

Orenco is a light rail station in Hillsboro, Oregon, United States, served by TriMet as part of the MAX Light Rail system. It is the seventh station eastbound on the Blue Line, situated between the Quatama and Hawthorn Farm stations. The two-track, island platform station serves the Orenco Station neighborhood, which is considered a model for smart growth and transit-oriented development. It features a 125-space park and ride, a bike and ride, and connections to TriMet bus route 47–Baseline/Evergreen and Ride Connection's North Hillsboro Link.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">MAX Green Line</span> Light rail line in Portland, Oregon

The MAX Green Line is a light rail service in Portland, Oregon, United States, operated by TriMet as part of the MAX Light Rail system. It is 15 miles (24.1 km) long and serves 30 stations from the PSU South stations to Clackamas Town Center Transit Center; it connects Portland State University (PSU), Portland City Center, Northeast Portland, Southeast Portland, and Clackamas. The Green Line is the only service that shares parts of its route with the four other MAX services, sharing the Portland Transit Mall with the Orange and Yellow lines and the Banfield segment of the Eastside MAX with the Blue and Red lines. Southbound from Gateway/Northeast 99th Avenue Transit Center, it operates the Interstate 205 (I-205) segment through to Clackamas Town Center. Service runs for approximately 211⁄2 hours daily with a headway of 15 minutes during most of the day. It is the third-busiest line in the system, carrying an average of 19,160 riders per day on weekdays in September 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">MAX Orange Line</span> Light rail line in Portland, Oregon

The MAX Orange Line is a light rail line serving the Portland metropolitan area in the U.S. state of Oregon. Operated by TriMet as part of the MAX Light Rail system, it connects Portland City Center, Portland State University (PSU), Southeast Portland, Milwaukie, and Oak Grove. The line serves 17 stations and runs for 201⁄2 hours per day with headways of up to 15 minutes. It averaged 3,480 daily weekday riders in September 2020.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tilikum Crossing</span> Bridge over the Willamette River, Portland, OR, USA

Tilikum Crossing, Bridge of the People is a cable-stayed bridge across the Willamette River in Portland, Oregon, United States. It was designed by TriMet, the Portland metropolitan area's regional transit authority, for its MAX Orange Line light rail passenger trains. The bridge also serves city buses and the Portland Streetcar, as well as bicycles, pedestrians, and emergency vehicles. Private cars and trucks are not permitted on the bridge. It is the first major bridge in the U.S. that was designed to allow access to transit vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians but not cars.

<i>Kvinneakt</i> Statue in Portland, Oregon, U.S.

Kvinneakt is an abstract bronze sculpture located on the Transit Mall of downtown Portland, Oregon. Designed and created by Norman J. Taylor between 1973 and 1975, the work was funded by TriMet and the United States Department of Transportation and was installed on the Transit Mall in 1977. The following year Kvinneakt appeared in the "Expose Yourself to Art" poster which featured future Mayor of Portland Bud Clark flashing the sculpture. It remained in place until November 2006 when it was removed temporarily during renovation of the Transit Mall and the installation of the MAX Light Rail on the mall.

<i>Talos No. 2</i> Sculpture in Portland, Oregon, U.S.

Talos No. 2 is an outdoor 1959–1977 bronze sculpture created by the American artist James Lee Hansen. It is located in the Transit Mall of downtown Portland, Oregon, in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southeast Tacoma/Johnson Creek station</span> Light rail station on Oregon, US

Southeast Tacoma/Johnson Creek is a light rail station and park and ride for the MAX Orange Line. Service began on September 12, 2015. It is the third stop northbound on the Orange Line. The station was built for residents of the Sellwood and Ardenwald neighborhoods of Portland and Milwaukie. The station is located adjacent to Oregon Route 99E and can be directly accessed by northbound traffic and by traffic from the portion of SE Tenino Street that connects SE Tacoma to SE Johnson Creek Boulevard.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southeast Bybee Boulevard station</span> MAX Orange Line station in Portland, Oregon, U.S.

Southeast Bybee Boulevard is a light rail station in Portland, Oregon, United States, served by TriMet as part of the MAX Light Rail system. It is the 14th station southbound on the Orange Line, which operates between Portland City Center, Southeast Portland, and Milwaukie. The grade-separated, island platform station adjoins Union Pacific Railroad (UP) freight tracks to the east and McLoughlin Boulevard to the west. Its entrances are located on the Bybee Bridge, which spans over the platform and connects Portland's Sellwood-Moreland and Eastmoreland neighborhoods. Nearby places of interest include Westmoreland Park, Eastmoreland Golf Course, Crystal Springs Rhododendron Garden, and Reed College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lincoln Street/Southwest 3rd Avenue station</span>

Lincoln Street/Southwest 3rd Avenue is a light rail station on the MAX Orange Line, located at 229 Southwest Lincoln Street in Portland, Oregon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Southeast Park Avenue station</span> Light rail station

Southeast Park Avenue is a light rail station on the MAX Orange Line located at Southeast McLoughlin Boulevard and Park Avenue in Oak Grove, an unincorporated area neighboring Milwaukie in Clackamas County, Oregon, in the United States. It is the terminus and southernmost stop on the Orange Line and has a 401-space park and ride facility.

<i>Passage</i> (sculpture) Sculpture series in Portland, Oregon

Passage is an outdoor 2014 art installation consisting of 38 weathered steel boat sculptures by Bill Will, installed along the MAX Orange Line in the Brooklyn neighborhood of southeast Portland, Oregon, in the United States.

<i>To Grandmothers House</i> Sculpture in Oak Grove, Oregon, U.S.

To Grandmother's House is an outdoor wooden sculpture by Patrick Gracewood, installed near the Southeast Park Avenue station in Oak Grove, an unincorporated area neighboring Milwaukie in Clackamas County, Oregon, in the United States. It depicts an older woman holding a rabbit in her arms and was carved from a 75-year-old cedar tree, cut down for construction of the MAX Orange Line, over three years. The sculpture was installed on April 29, 2015.

<i>Kerf</i> (sculpture) Sculpture in Portland, Oregon

Kerf is an outdoor series of two pigmented cast concrete sculptures by Thomas Sayre, installed at the MAX Orange Line's Southeast Tacoma/Johnson Creek station in the southeast Portland, Oregon portion of the Ardenwald-Johnson Creek neighborhood, which straddles the border between Portland and Milwaukie, Oregon.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Harbarger, Molly (November 10, 2011). "Milwaukie's Park Avenue light rail station 'deer baby' sculpture withdrawn by artist". The Oregonian . Portland, Oregon: Advance Publications. ISSN   8750-1317. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Harbarger, Molly (July 21, 2011). "Giant deer art starts debate about what is appropriate for Park Avenue light-rail station". The Oregonian. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  3. ↑ "Public Art Program Concept Proposals" (PDF). TriMet. June 27, 2011. pp. 2–5. Archived (PDF) from the original on October 2, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  4. ↑ "PMLR Public Art Advisory Committee: October 19, 2011 Meeting Summary" (PDF). TriMet. Archived (PDF) from the original on July 14, 2017. Retrieved September 10, 2015.
  5. 1 2 3 Rose, Joseph (October 26, 2011). "TriMet, facing another budget gap, looking for places to cut – with some exceptions". The Oregonian. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  6. 1 2 3 Spencer, Aaron (November 10, 2011). "Let's save the giant baby-faced deer statue!". Daily Journal of Commerce . Portland, Oregon: Dolan Company. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  7. 1 2 Harbarger, Molly (November 11, 2011). "Artist reacts to "deer baby" withdrawal via Twilight Zone quote, some mourn loss of proposed art". The Oregonian. Archived from the original on March 4, 2016. Retrieved September 10, 2015.
  8. ↑ Rose, Joseph (November 10, 2011). "TriMet's Twilight Zone Bambi light-rail sculpture in Milwaukie gets shooed away". The Oregonian. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.
  9. ↑ Webber, Angela (July 21, 2011). "What's not to love about this giant baby-faced deer statue?". Daily Journal of Commerce. Archived from the original on September 29, 2015. Retrieved September 9, 2015.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.