Relocation service

Last updated

Relocation services, employee relocation, military permanent change of station (PCS) or workforce mobility include a range of internal business processes to transfer employees, their families, and/or entire departments of a business to a new location. Like other types of employee benefits, these processes are usually administered by human resources specialists within a corporation. In the military, these processes are administered by the Transportation Management Office (TMO) and Personal Property Shipping Office (PPSO). [1] [2]

Contents

Such business processes can include domestic residential services where an employee moves within a country or state as well as international relocation services which include planning for diplomats, managers, etc. working abroad. An agency providing relocation services directs and manages the process of relocation including arranging necessary documents (visa, long-term stay permissions), finding a new house (accommodation), finding a school for children (education), finding a job for the partner or "trailing spouse", arranging a teacher for the family (language training) and introduce expatriates to the local culture. Some companies are similarly offering financial incentives for their workers to return to specific city offices. [3]

International relocations

Dating back to the Dutch East India Company, sending an employee to work in another country (sometimes called a "global assignment" in current HR jargon) has carried considerable costs while theoretically opening the potential for financial returns for the employer. [4]

With tax equalization, housing allowance, cost-of-living adjustment, and other benefits, the typical expatriate compensation package is two to three times the home-country base salary. For example, an expatriate with a €100,000 annual salary will cost the employer €200,000-300,000 per year incl. the relocation costs. Shorter term assignments have lower costs, especially when they avoid taxation thresholds.

Reasons why a company might give an employee a global assignment include filling functional needs, developing the employee for upper management, and developing the company itself. Anne-Wil Harzing of the University of Melbourne further categorizes these employees as "bears, bumblebees and spiders". [5] Those playing the role of bears are the long arm of headquarters control. The bumblebees transfer (cross-pollinate) their corporate culture. Harzing's spiders weave the informal communication networks so important in connecting far-flung branches, subsidiaries and all strategic partners.

Responding to a 2005 survey of global assignment management practices commissioned by a US-based third-party relocation management company, 31 percent of surveyed employers indicated that they track exceptions on a per-assignment basis for budgetary purposes, 23 percent track exception on an overall basis in order to identify policy components that need review, and 39 percent do not track the cost or type of exceptions granted. (Seven percent were not able to answer the question.) [6]

Depending on the size and organization of a company, different departments, such as finance or human resources, may administer the relocation program. Some may lack any formal programs while others have highly structured processes. Moreover, different operating units may administer different aspects of the program.

Some may manage and execute all of their relocation processes in-house while others outsource them. This is done to save time, focusing internal resources on company workforce strengths, or for providing better service to each transferee.

Of the companies participating in the 2005 Survey of Global Assignment Management Practices, 43 percent indicated that they either outsource or co-source some assignment management services (staffing 1:58 assignees, 7 percent declined to answer).

Government programs

Around 2011, local philanthropists in Tulsa, Oklahoma noticed people who participated in Teach For America continued to live in Tulsa. [7] These philanthropists were then curious about how to replicate this retention of young knowledge workers to the state. The managing director of Tulsa program, Tulsa Remote, previously worked at Teach for America.

Below is a list of participating cities and associated benefits. [8]

List of cities and their incentives
Year establishedYear endedCityStateNameFinancial incentiveNotesReferences
2018 Tulsa Oklahoma Tulsa Remote$10,000 [8]
20182023 Vermont Think Vermont$7,500Initial cash incentive was $10,000 [8] [9] [10]
Multiple Indiana $5,000Cities include Noblesville and Evansville [8]
Multiple Kentucky $5,000Total of $8,800 package, with an additional $2,500 bonus who bring a spouse working in healthcare or education [8]
2019 Topeka Kansas Choose Topeka$5,000Up to $15,000 worth of incentives [8]
2019 The Shoals Alabama Remote Shoals$10,000Eligibility includes self-employment or full-time remote employees outside Colbert and Lauderdale counties, make over $52,000 annually [8]
20202023 Arkansas Life Works Here$10,000Includes a free bike [8]
2020 Savannah Georgia $2,000Incentive is intended to only reimburse moving costs [11]
2021Multiple West Virginia Ascend West Virginia$12,000$10,000 the first year, an additional $2,000 the second, outdoorsy perks include free passes for rock climbing, ziplining and golf, access to free co-working spaces [8] [12]

West Virginia's program launched in April 2021 and has had 20,000 applications. [12] The program spans across four regions of the state and welcomed new residents in the following order: Morgantown, Greenbrier County, Eastern panhandle, Greater Elkins, and New River Gorge. [13] The program is funded by a $25 million gift from Brad D. Smith and his wife, Alys Smith, to West Virginia University's Brad and Alys Smith Outdoor Economic Development Collaborative. The program aims to welcome 1,000 remote workers over the next five years since launching in 2021. Topeka's program, Choose Topeka, has had a yearly budget of $300,000, which is funded from an economic development sales tax. [9] In the first six months of the program, Choose Topeka received over 6,000 applications. Kentucky's program incentivizes individuals to move to Mayfield or Graves County. [8] Tulsa's program, Tulsa Remote, is funded by the George Kaiser Family Foundation and intends to continue funding the program "so long as it demonstrates to be a community-enhancing opportunity". [14]

Some motivations for applicants to apply for these relocation programs include lower cost of living, history of the city itself, volunteering opportunities, and access to sports leagues. [15] The cities themselves also have an incentive to offer these programs, including addressing brain drain of losing educated talent and boost a region's technology industry. [9] [16] Midsize, non-coastal cities like Tulsa have been struggling to retain younger professionals, and those who do move to Oklahoma were nearly all over the age of 45 and mostly had incomes below the state average. [14]

In December 2022, Tulsa, Oklahoma claims to have had 2,900 people be accepted into the relocation program and generating an established new sales tax revenue of $2.5 million for Tulsa County and $3.1 million for the state of Oklahoma. [8] Then in 2024, survey results show remote workers who moved to Tulsa saved $25,000 or more on average on annual housing costs than those who did not choose to relocate to Tulsa. [14] With more years to estimate from, researchers in 2024 estimate those who relocated brought in $14.9 million in annual income tax revenue and $5.8 million in sales tax. In 2022, West Virginia claims that they have welcomed 150 new people into the state with a 98% retention rate. [12] It is estimated that the city of Topeka has had a $3.8 million impact to its economy. [9]

These relocation incentive programs are not universally popular. [8] Some have reported that residents local to the regions with these programs feel overlooked for employment in favor of those who receive these incentives. It is also noted that this could "foster community divisions and potentially increase the cost of living, making it harder for long-term residents". [8] For example, the median price of a home in Tulsa increased 9 percent compared with the national average increase of 3.2 percent. [14]

See also

References

  1. "Preparing Financially for PCS Season". Military Times. 2017-08-08. Retrieved 2020-12-15.
  2. Bachelor, Blane (2024-03-05). "These US cities will pay you up to $15,000 to move there". CNN . Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  3. "Cameo giving all Chicago employees $10,000 raises to return to the office". Chicago Tribune. 2025-02-14. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  4. Rei, Claudia (2014-01-01). "Careers and wages in the Dutch East India Company" . Cliometrica. 8 (1): 27–48. doi:10.1007/s11698-013-0093-3. ISSN   1863-2513. S2CID   255345445.
  5. Harzing, Anne-Wil (2001-12-01). "Of bears, bumble-bees, and spiders: the role of expatriates in controlling foreign subsidiaries" . Journal of World Business. 36 (4): 366–379. doi:10.1016/S1090-9516(01)00061-X. ISSN   1090-9516.
  6. "US managers' willingness to accept a global assignment: Do expatriate benefits and assignment length make a difference?". ResearchGate. Retrieved 2021-04-12.
  7. Goldberg, Emma (2024-10-16). "Can Remote Workers Reverse Brain Drain?". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2025-02-25.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Bachelor, Blane (2024-03-05). "These US cities will pay you up to $15,000 to move there". CNN . Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Gaffney, Austyn. "Incentive programs have lured thousands of remote workers from major metro areas to small cities". Smart Cities Dive. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  10. "Vermont Worker Relocation Incentive Program Now Open for Applications for Relocating and Remote Workers – Vermont Technology Alliance". vtta.org. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  11. Musulin, Kristin (2020-06-12). "Savannah, GA offers $2K to attract remote tech workers". Smart Cities Dive. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  12. 1 2 3 "WVU Today | Ascend West Virginia expands into fourth community". wvutoday.wvu.edu. 2022-11-30. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  13. "WVU Today | Ascend West Virginia opens applications for New River Gorge area". wvutoday.wvu.edu. 2023-06-20. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  14. 1 2 3 4 Goldberg, Emma (2024-10-16). "Can Remote Workers Reverse Brain Drain?". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2025-02-25.
  15. Pandy, Jordan. "I got paid $10,000 to move to Tulsa. My mortgage for a whole house is about what I used to pay to rent one room". Business Insider. Retrieved 2025-02-24.
  16. Settembre, Jeanette (2020-06-09). "Post-coronavirus, Georgia city paying tech workers to move there". FOXBusiness. Retrieved 2025-02-24.