Seed Provenancing

Last updated

Seed provenance refers to the geographic location of a parent plant, from which seeds were collected. In the context of ecological restoration and forestry, seed provenancing refers to a seed-sourcing strategy that focuses on the geographic location of seed sources, as each provenance can describe the genetic material from that location. [1] Selecting the appropriate provenance is a highly important decision to ensure the long-term success of restoration efforts by maintaining local genetic-environmental relationships, adaptive potential, and to avoid the risks of an outbreeding depression or other deleterious genetic effects. [1] The traditional approach to provenancing has been to source seed from within the restoration site (local provenancing), but the threats of climate change have sparked debate on whether the use of nonlocal provenances may be beneficial to the longevity of broadscale restoration efforts under specific circumstances.

Contents

Provenancing Strategies

Local provenancing

Local provenancing is a provenancing strategy that relies on the sole use of seed sourced either within the restoration site (strict local provenance) or near the restoration site (relaxed local provenance) and has long remained the focus of restoration guidelines. [1] [2] This strategy is grounded in the concept of local adaptation, maintaining that the use of locally adapted seed is best for the longevity of restoration projects because of their increased fitness in the local environment, decreasing the risk of maladaptation to local conditions and outbreeding depression. [3] [4] [5] It has also been found that the use of local seed can be important to protect important biotic interactions, including pollinator interactions and pathogen resistance. [6]

In the use of local provenancing for broadscale restoration, it can be difficult to define a "local" provenance. It has been argued that the most useful approach to defining a local provenance is one that is genetically informed, such as using significant genetic differentiation (e.g. differentiation in neutral or adaptive genetic markers) to describe provenances. [1] However, this may not be feasible for all restoration practitioners due to the time and costs required of this approach.

Nonlocal provenancing strategies

Although it has been long-maintained that the use of local provenance is best since local seed will be best adapted to the conditions, arguments have been made to move away from the strict use of local provenance for populations that are expected to face rapidly changing environmental conditions in the face of climate change. This is because the use of local provenancing can establish a population that does not have sufficient adaptive genetic variation to cope with future environmental changes, thus compromising the longevity of broadscale restoration efforts. [7] Additionally, the strict use of local provenance has the potential to encourage inbreeding and low genetic variation in a population, further threatening a population's ability to persist long-term. [8] With this, many new provenancing strategies have been proposed to supplement local provenances with nonlocal ones to maximize evolutionary potential to increase the long-term success of restored populations that are facing changing environmental conditions; these proposed strategies include admixture, composite, climate-adjusted, and predictive provenancing. [9]

These proposed provenancing techniques are not applicable to all restoration efforts, and the success of each one depends on the contextual factors of each population, which include: [1]

It should be noted that these recently proposed techniques are more so based upon a theoretical foundation, as there has been limited experimental testing done. Thus, there is much future research needed to create a framework to guide a practical application of these proposed provenancing techniques in restoration contexts; this research may focus on gathering evidence-based restoration practices via field testing, furthering knowledge of adaptive processes, and assessing potential risks and benefits of each provenancing technique. [1]

Admixture provenancing

Admixture provenancing mixes a wide variety of provenances across a species range, providing seed from each provenance in equal proportions. [6] The purpose of this provenancing technique is to increase standing genetic variation in a population, thus increasing the adaptive potential. [6]

Composite provenancing

Composite provenancing aims to mimic gene flow dynamics as a way to build adaptive potential into a restored population; this is done by mixing seed from both local and non-local provenances but with a larger proportion of local seed and progressively smaller amounts of seed from more distant provenances. [5]

Climate-adjusted provenancing

Climate-adjusted provenancing aims to enhance the climate resilience of a restored population. It incorporates a mix of local and non-local provenances from a climatic gradient, using more seeds from environments more likely to be encountered in the future. [10] This strategy would introduce pre-adapted genotypes into the population, maintaining genetic variation and improving the evolutionary resilience of the population. [10]

Predictive provenancing

Predictive provenancing is a strategy designed to increase a restored population's adaptive capacity in the face of a changing climate. In this strategy, it is proposed to source seed from plants that are naturally adapted to future climatic conditions the target population is predicted to face, introducing pre-adapted genotypes. [11]

Practical Applications

Established seed transfer zones in the east coast of the US, by the Eastern Seed Zone Forum (a unit of the US Forest Service) USDA eastern seed-collection zones.jpg
Established seed transfer zones in the east coast of the US, by the Eastern Seed Zone Forum (a unit of the US Forest Service)

Seed transfer guidelines

The use of provenancing is important for seed transfer guidelines in the field of forestry and ecological restoration, as it is important to match planting sites with well-adapted seed provenances to develop healthy, productive plantings. Seed transfer guidelines establish general rules that apply when planting on sites where the species naturally occurs, but may also establish rules for specific species. They also establish seed transfer zones, which are areas within which plant materials can be transferred with little risk of maladaptation due to climatic similarities. [12] Seed transfer zones consider the distinctive habitats that are found within the range of a species, and are divided up based on this since certain individuals within the species are better suited for that site. [12] They may also consider genetic differences among populations, assuming that local populations are best adapted to their local environment. [13] The size of a tree seed zone can range from a few thousand acres to many thousand square miles since differences in topography influence the quantity of environmental heterogeneity seen in an area. [13]

Historically, tree seed zone maps were based on climatic, topographic, and vegetative information, assigning the general transfer guidelines and seed zones to all species. [13] However, it is now recognized that species differ in their response to general seed zones due to genetic differences and environmental influences. For example, forest tree species exhibit large genetic differences in survival, growth rate, frost hardiness, and other traits. [13] Thus, tree seed zones and transfer guidelines are now assigned for specific forest tree species by the US Forest Service, in addition to general guidelines that apply when planting on seed zones where the species naturally occurs. [13]

Development of seed transfer zones

Because it is difficult to gather comprehensive geo-genetic data for each species used in a restoration project due to time and resource constraints, there are different types of seed transfer zones developed for restoration projects. Some types of seed transfer zones are broadly apply to all plant species, while others apply to a specific species if enough data is available. Of these types of seed transfer zones are provisional, climate-matched, and empirical seed transfer zones.

Provisional seed transfer zones

Provisional seed transfer zones are the most generalized seed zones, and can be applied to any plant species to guide seed plantings; they are used when there is not any genetic information available for a species of interest. [14] They use geospatial climate data to derive regions of relative climatic similarity, predicting regions of local adaptation across a climate gradient. [14]

Climate-based seed transfer zones

Climate-based seed transfer zones provide species-specific guidance for seed zones, utilizing both species-distribution models and climatic information to predict the relative performance of seed at the target site. [15] Because these seed transfer zones apply to specific species, they can decrease the number of estimated seed sources per species needed, helping managers balance both ecological and economic considerations. [15]

Empirical seed transfer zones

Empirical seed transfer zones are the most accurate seed transfer zones for species-specific guidance since are derived from empirical data gathered from field-based experiments. [16] In the development of these seed zones, provenance trials are used to identify provenances that are well-adapted to the target region, which are common-garden experiments that evaluate plants for morphology, phenology, production, and physiological related traits. [17] With this data, statistical analyses are applied to develop models that link genetic variation across the target region, allowing seed zones to be assigned. [15]

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Breed, Martin F; Harrison, Peter A; Bischoff, Armin; Durruty, Paula; Gellie, Nick J C; Gonzales, Emily K; Havens, Kayri; Karmann, Marion; Kilkenny, Francis F; Krauss, Siegfried L; Lowe, Andrew J; Marques, Pedro; Nevill, Paul G; Vitt, Pati L; Bucharova, Anna (2018-07-01). "Priority Actions to Improve Provenance Decision-Making". BioScience. 68 (7): 510–516. doi:10.1093/biosci/biy050. ISSN   0006-3568.
  2. ↑ Bucharova, Anna; Durka, Walter; Hölzel, Norbert; Kollmann, Johannes; Michalski, Stefan; Bossdorf, Oliver (December 2017). "Are local plants the best for ecosystem restoration? It depends on how you analyze the data". Ecology and Evolution. 7 (24): 10683–10689. Bibcode:2017EcoEv...710683B. doi:10.1002/ece3.3585. ISSN   2045-7758. PMC   5743477 . PMID   29299248.
  3. ↑ McKay, John K.; Christian, Caroline E.; Harrison, Susan; Rice, Kevin J. (September 2005). ""How Local Is Local?"—A Review of Practical and Conceptual Issues in the Genetics of Restoration". Restoration Ecology. 13 (3): 432–440. Bibcode:2005ResEc..13..432M. doi:10.1111/j.1526-100X.2005.00058.x. ISSN   1061-2971. S2CID   1267883.
  4. ↑ Mortlock, By Warren (August 2000). "Local seed for revegetation: Where will all that seed come from?". Ecological Management & Restoration. 1 (2): 93–101. Bibcode:2000EcoMR...1...93M. doi:10.1046/j.1442-8903.2000.00029.x. ISSN   1442-7001.
  5. 1 2 Broadhurst, Linda M.; Lowe, Andrew; Coates, David J.; Cunningham, Saul A.; McDonald, Maurice; Vesk, Peter A.; Yates, Colin (November 2008). "Seed supply for broadscale restoration: maximizing evolutionary potential". Evolutionary Applications. 1 (4): 587–597. Bibcode:2008EvApp...1..587B. doi:10.1111/j.1752-4571.2008.00045.x. ISSN   1752-4571. PMC   3352390 . PMID   25567799.
  6. 1 2 3 Breed, Martin F.; Stead, Michael G.; Ottewell, Kym M.; Gardner, Michael G.; Lowe, Andrew J. (February 2013). "Which provenance and where? Seed sourcing strategies for revegetation in a changing environment". Conservation Genetics. 14 (1): 1–10. Bibcode:2013ConG...14....1B. doi:10.1007/s10592-012-0425-z. ISSN   1566-0621. S2CID   254426835.
  7. ↑ Moritz, Craig (2004-05-06). "Conservation Units and Translocations: Strategies for Conserving Evolutionary Processes". Hereditas. 130 (3): 217–228. doi:10.1111/j.1601-5223.1999.00217.x.
  8. ↑ Lowe, Andrew (2015-02-21). "Local is Not Always Best". Biodiversity Revolution. Australian Centre for Evolutionary Biology and Biodiversity.{{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)
  9. ↑ Byrne, M; Prober, S; McLean, Liz; Steane, D; Stock, W; Potts, B; Vaillancourt, Rene (2013). Adaptation to Climate in Widespread Eucalypt Species. National Climate Change Adaptation Research Facility. ISBN   978-921609-98-5.{{cite book}}: Check |isbn= value: length (help)
  10. 1 2 Prober, Suzanne M.; Byrne, Margaret; McLean, Elizabeth H.; Steane, Dorothy A.; Potts, Brad M.; Vaillancourt, Rene E.; Stock, William D. (2015-06-23). "Climate-adjusted provenancing: a strategy for climate-resilient ecological restoration". Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. 3. doi: 10.3389/fevo.2015.00065 . ISSN   2296-701X.
  11. ↑ Woolridge, Christopher B.; Fant, Jeremie B.; Flores, Ana I.; Schultz, Kelly; Kramer, Andrea T. (January 2023). "Variation in overall fitness due to seed source: projections for predictive provenancing". Restoration Ecology. 31 (1). Bibcode:2023ResEc..3113717W. doi:10.1111/rec.13717. ISSN   1061-2971.
  12. 1 2 "WWETAC TRM Seed Zone Mapping". www.fs.usda.gov. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 Randall, William; Berang, Paul (2002). Washington Tree Seed Transfer Zones (PDF). Washington State Department of Natural Resources.
  14. 1 2 Shryock, Daniel F.; DeFalco, Lesley A.; Esque, Todd C. (October 2018). "Spatial decision-support tools to guide restoration and seed-sourcing in the Desert Southwest". Ecosphere. 9 (10). doi:10.1002/ecs2.2453. ISSN   2150-8925.
  15. 1 2 3 "WWETAC TRM Seed Zone Mapping". www.fs.usda.gov. Western Wildland Environmental Threat Assessment Center - US Forest Service. Retrieved 2024-03-12.
  16. ↑ "Seed Transfer Zones". Colorado Plateau Native Plant Program. Bureau of Land Management. 2021-06-07. Retrieved 2024-03-12.
  17. ↑ Risk, Clara; McKenney, Daniel W.; Pedlar, John; Lu, Pengxin (2021-01-26). "A compilation of North American tree provenance trials and relevant historical climate data for seven species". Scientific Data. 8 (1): 29. Bibcode:2021NatSD...8...29R. doi:10.1038/s41597-021-00820-2. ISSN   2052-4463. PMC   7838313 . PMID   33500421.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wetland</span> Land area that is permanently, or seasonally saturated with water

A wetland is a distinct ecosystem that is flooded or saturated by water, either permanently for years or decades or seasonally for a shorter periods. Flooding results in oxygen-free anoxic processes prevailing, especially in the soils. The primary factor that distinguishes wetlands from terrestrial land forms or water bodies is the characteristic vegetation of aquatic plants, adapted to the unique anoxic hydric soils. Wetlands are considered among the most biologically diverse of all ecosystems, serving as home to a wide range of plant and animal species. Methods for assessing wetland functions, wetland ecological health, and general wetland condition have been developed for many regions of the world. These methods have contributed to wetland conservation partly by raising public awareness of the functions some wetlands provide. Constructed wetlands are designed and built to treat municipal and industrial wastewater as well as to divert stormwater runoff. Constructed wetlands may also play a role in water-sensitive urban design.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Genetic diversity</span> Total number of genetic characteristics in a species

Genetic diversity is the total number of genetic characteristics in the genetic makeup of a species, it ranges widely from the number of species to differences within species and can be attributed to the span of survival for a species. It is distinguished from genetic variability, which describes the tendency of genetic characteristics to vary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Species reintroduction</span> Wildlife conservation technique

Species reintroduction is the deliberate release of a species into the wild, from captivity or other areas where the organism is capable of survival. The goal of species reintroduction is to establish a healthy, genetically diverse, self-sustaining population to an area where it has been extirpated, or to augment an existing population. Species that may be eligible for reintroduction are typically threatened or endangered in the wild. However, reintroduction of a species can also be for pest control; for example, wolves being reintroduced to a wild area to curb an overpopulation of deer. Because reintroduction may involve returning native species to localities where they had been extirpated, some prefer the term "reestablishment".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ecosystem diversity</span> Diversity and variations in ecosystems

Ecosystem diversity deals with the variations in ecosystems within a geographical location and its overall impact on human existence and the environment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Biological dispersal</span> Movement of individuals from their birth site to a breeding site

Biological dispersal refers to both the movement of individuals from their birth site to their breeding site, as well as the movement from one breeding site to another . Dispersal is also used to describe the movement of propagules such as seeds and spores. Technically, dispersal is defined as any movement that has the potential to lead to gene flow. The act of dispersal involves three phases: departure, transfer, settlement and there are different fitness costs and benefits associated with each of these phases. Through simply moving from one habitat patch to another, the dispersal of an individual has consequences not only for individual fitness, but also for population dynamics, population genetics, and species distribution. Understanding dispersal and the consequences both for evolutionary strategies at a species level, and for processes at an ecosystem level, requires understanding on the type of dispersal, the dispersal range of a given species, and the dispersal mechanisms involved. Biological dispersal can be correlated to population density. The range of variations of a species' location determines expansion range.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Restoration ecology</span> Scientific study of renewing and restoring ecosystems

Ecological restoration is the process of assisting the recovery of an ecosystem that has been degraded, damaged, or destroyed. It is distinct from conservation in that it attempts to retroactively repair already damaged ecosystems rather than take preventative measures. Ecological restoration can reverse biodiversity loss, combat climate change, and support local economies. The United Nations named 2021-2030 the Decade on Ecosystem Restoration.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Revegetation</span>

Revegetation is the process of replanting and rebuilding the soil of disturbed land. This may be a natural process produced by plant colonization and succession, manmade rewilding projects, accelerated process designed to repair damage to a landscape due to wildfire, mining, flood, or other cause. Originally the process was simply one of applying seed and fertilizer to disturbed lands, usually grasses or clover. The fibrous root network of grasses is useful for short-term erosion control, particularly on sloping ground. Establishing long-term plant communities requires forethought as to appropriate species for the climate, size of stock required, and impact of replanted vegetation on local fauna. The motivations behind revegetation are diverse, answering needs that are both technical and aesthetic, but it is usually erosion prevention that is the primary reason. Revegetation helps prevent soil erosion, enhances the ability of the soil to absorb more water in significant rain events, and in conjunction reduces turbidity dramatically in adjoining bodies of water. Revegetation also aids protection of engineered grades and other earthworks.

A genetic isolate is a population of organisms with little genetic mixing with other organisms within the same species due to geographic isolation or other factors that prevent reproduction. Genetic isolates form new species through an evolutionary process known as speciation. All modern species diversity is a product of genetic isolates and evolution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Effects of climate change on plant biodiversity</span>

There is an ongoing decline in plant biodiversity, just like there is ongoing biodiversity loss for many other life forms. One of the causes for this decline is climate change. Environmental conditions play a key role in defining the function and geographic distributions of plants, in combination with other factors, thereby modifying patterns of biodiversity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forest migration</span>

Forest migration is the movement of large seed plant dominated communities in geographical space over time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forest restoration</span>

Forest restoration is defined as “actions to re-instate ecological processes, which accelerate recovery of forest structure, ecological functioning and biodiversity levels towards those typical of climax forest” i.e. the end-stage of natural forest succession. Climax forests are relatively stable ecosystems that have developed the maximum biomass, structural complexity and species diversity that are possible within the limits imposed by climate and soil and without continued disturbance from humans. Climax forest is therefore the target ecosystem, which defines the ultimate aim of forest restoration. Since climate is a major factor that determines climax forest composition, global climate change may result in changing restoration aims. Additionally, the potential impacts of climate change on restoration goals must be taken into account, as changes in temperature and precipitation patterns may alter the composition and distribution of climax forests.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Assisted migration</span> Intentional transport of species to a different habitat

Assisted migration is "the intentional establishment of populations or meta-populations beyond the boundary of a species' historic range for the purpose of tracking suitable habitats through a period of changing climate...." It is therefore a nature conservation tactic by which plants or animals are intentionally moved to geographic locations better suited to their present or future habitat needs and climate tolerances — and to which they are unable to migrate or disperse on their own.

Climate change in Mexico is expected to have widespread impacts on Mexico: with significant decreases in precipitation and increases in temperatures. This will put pressure on the economy, people and the biodiversity of many parts of the country, which have largely arid or hot climates. Already climate change has impacted agriculture, biodiversity, farmer livelihoods, and migration, as well as water, health, air pollution, traffic disruption from floods, and housing vulnerability to landslides.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Annual vs. perennial plant evolution</span>

Annuality and perenniality represent major life history strategies within plant lineages. These traits can shift from one to another over both macroevolutionary and microevolutionary timescales. While perenniality and annuality are often described as discrete either-or traits, they often occur in a continuous spectrum. The complex history of switches between annual and perennial habit involve both natural and artificial causes, and studies of this fluctuation have importance to sustainable agriculture.

Landscape genomics is one of many strategies used to identify relationships between environmental factors and the genetic adaptation of organisms in response to these factors. Landscape genomics combines aspects of landscape ecology, population genetics and landscape genetics. The latter addresses how landscape features influence the population structure and gene flow of organisms across time and space. The field of landscape genomics is distinct from landscape genetics in that it is not focused on the neutral genetic processes, but considers, in addition to neutral processes such as drift and gene flow, explicitly adaptive processes, i.e. the role of natural selection.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Climate change and invasive species</span> Increase of invasive organisms caused by climate change

Climate change and invasive species refers to the process of the environmental destabilization caused by climate change. This environmental change facilitates the spread of invasive species — species that are not historically found in a certain region, and often bring about a negative impact to that region's native species. This complex relationship is notable because climate change and invasive species are also considered by the USDA to be two of the top four causes of global biodiversity loss.

Victoria Louise Sork is an American scientist who is Professor and Dean of Life Sciences at University of California, Los Angeles. She studies tree populations in California and the Eastern United States using genomics, evolutionary biology and conservation biology. Sork is a Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mixed mating systems</span> Plants which reproduce in multiple ways

A mixed mating system, also known as “variable inbreeding” a characteristic of many hermaphroditic seed plants, where more than one means of mating is used. Mixed mating usually refers to the production of a mixture of self-fertilized (selfed) and outbred (outcrossed) seeds. Plant mating systems influence the distribution of genetic variation within and among populations, by affecting the propensity of individuals to self-fertilize or cross-fertilize . Mixed mating systems are generally characterized by the frequency of selfing vs. outcrossing, but may include the production of asexual seeds through agamospermy. The trade offs for each strategy depend on ecological conditions, pollinator abundance and herbivory and parasite load. Mating systems are not permanent within species; they can vary with environmental factors, and through domestication when plants are bred for commercial agriculture.

Urban evolution refers to the heritable genetic changes of populations in response to urban development and anthropogenic activities in urban areas. Urban evolution can be caused by mutation, genetic drift, gene flow, or evolution by natural selection. Biologists have observed evolutionary change in numerous species compared to their rural counterparts on a relatively short timescale.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Assisted migration of forests in North America</span> Human-facilitated forest migration process

Assisted migration is the movement of populations or species by humans from one territory to another in response to climate change. This is the definition offered in a nontechnical document published by the United States Forest Service in 2023, suggesting that this form of climate adaptation "could be a proactive, pragmatic tool for building climate resilience in our landscapes."

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.