Sexual assault of Savannah Dietrich

Last updated

Louisville teen sexual assault case
LocationLouisville, Kentucky
DateAugust 2011 (2011-08)
Attack type
Sexual assault
VictimSavannah Dietrich
PerpetratorsWill Frey and Austin Zehnder
Chargessexual abuse in the first degree and voyeurism

In August 2011, a female American high-school student named Savannah Dietrich was sexually assaulted by Will Frey and Austin Zehnder, lacrosse players from Trinity High School, an exclusive Catholic high school in Louisville, Kentucky. [1] [2] The assault was photographed by Frey and Zehnder and other observers, and images and comments from the incident went viral on the internet.

Contents

In a plea bargain, two 16-year-old boys Frey and Zehnder pleaded guilty to sexual abuse in the first degree, a felony, and voyeurism, a misdemeanor. Dietrich released the names of her attackers and argued publicly that they were not adequately punished despite being instructed not to discuss the case by the presiding judge. International controversy regarding the case developed when attorneys for the boys attempted to have her held in contempt, but the motion was subsequently dropped.

Afterwards, at the time of sentencing, the judge said that because of the "serious nature" of the crime, she would revise the punishment requested by the prosecutor. Accordingly, the judge removed a provision that would have expunged the defendants' records upon reaching age 19+1⁄2, and also ordered that their community service be served at a charity that deals with women's issues. [3]

Initial court proceedings, plea deal, and privacy law

The two defendants pleaded guilty to sexual abuse in the first degree, a felony and voyeurism, a misdemeanor. [2] The initial plea-deal agreed to by the prosecutor was 50 hours of community service, a diversion agreement, counseling, and a provision to expunge the defendants' criminal records—provided they maintained good behavior—at age 19+1⁄2. [4] Paul Richwalsky, the prosecutor in the case was a graduate and booster of Trinity High School, the same school the boys attended. [2]

On June 26, 2012, Judge Deana H. McDonald admonished the parties to the case that they must follow the statutes and laws regarding privacy and confidentiality of juvenile proceedings on the Commonwealth of Kentucky. [5] The state of Kentucky is one of 11 states which seal court cases if the accused is under 18 years of age. [6] Then Judge McDonald took an extra step, indicating that the crime itself should not be discussed and that no one should "speak about the incident to anyone for any reason," she said, according to court files. "No one is to talk or type anything." [2] This meant that Dietrich (the 16-year-old female victim) was not permitted to speak about the case, the charges, the facts and allegations therein, and the identities of the defendants. [7]

Statements by victim protesting leniency

Dietrich stated that she felt her concerns were not properly addressed and that the proposed deal was too lenient. Later that evening, she announced the names of the defendants on Twitter, tweeting "Will Frey and Austin Zehnder sexually assaulted me," and "There you go, lock me up. I'm not protecting anyone that made my life a living hell." [2]

The primary judge on the case, Angela McCormick Bisig, was away the day the controversial order of silence was issued by Judge McDonald. In 2013 Judge Bisig, then a circuit-court judge, went on record acknowledging Dietrich should have been allowed to discuss the crime itself, "We cannot tell a young crime victim that they cannot tell their personal story." [2]

Attorneys for the boys attempted to have Dietrich held in contempt for publishing their names, but the motion was subsequently dropped. [3] Notwithstanding Judge McDonald's admonitions forbidding anyone "talk or type anything", on August 28, 2012, Judge Bisig stated in her ruling that on July 30, 2012 "Judge McDonald ruled that there was no "gag order" in place and that her admonishment had been to comply with the law of confidentiality required by Kentucky Statutes." [8]

In an affidavit, Dietrich also stated that Paul Richwalsky, the chief prosecutor in the juvenile court division, said she should "get over it and see a therapist. ... The jail was for 'real' rapists, murderers and robbers". [9] Richwalsky denied the allegation and stated in an affidavit "Perhaps it is not so much she is trying to intentionally mislead and deceive this court, but rather the delusional assertions made in her affidavit are merely the byproduct of what she would like to believe happened and not what in actuality took place." [9]

Sentencing and revision of plea deal

During sentencing, Judge Angela Bisig emphasized the "serious nature" of the crime. She removed a provision of the plea deal that would have expunged the defendants' records when they reach age of 19+1⁄2. She also ordered that their community service be served at a charity that deals with women's issues. [3]

Terms of the sentences require supervision by the state's juvenile justice department, offender treatment and performance of 50 hours of community service at a women's facility. After three years of good behavior the two felony charges may be amended down to misdemeanors and after five years the boys may request that the convictions be expunged. [3]

Subsequent activities

Dietrich was reportedly satisfied with the revised punishment. [10] In March 2013, she took an active and public role in advocating legislation in the Kentucky legislature, as reported by The Courier-Journal : [11]

[S]he hopes that a law would prevent what happened to her from happening to anyone else. She said perhaps the law will make it clear to everyone that it is the victim's right to talk about what happened.

At the same time, Dietrich indicated that such a state law is not absolutely necessary, given the protections that she believes are already afforded by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. [11] First Amendment expert Eugene Volokh has commented about this Louisville case, saying that a pertinent U.S. Supreme Court precedent on this subject is Oklahoma Publishing v. District Court, 430 U.S. 308 (1977). "An order barring a victim from revealing the names of her assailants is, I think, clearly unconstitutional, even when the assailants are juveniles. Oklahoma Publishing Co. v. District Court (1977) expressly rejected the notion that courts or legislatures may bar the publication of the names of juvenile offenders; that case involved a newspaper's publishing the name of the juvenile offender, which it learned from a court hearing, but the rationale applies at least as strongly to a person's publishing a name that she learned from the attack itself." [12]

See also

Related Research Articles

A plea bargain is an agreement in criminal law proceedings, whereby the prosecutor provides a concession to the defendant in exchange for a plea of guilt or nolo contendere. This may mean that the defendant will plead guilty to a less serious charge, or to one of the several charges, in return for the dismissal of other charges; or it may mean that the defendant will plead guilty to the original criminal charge in return for a more lenient sentence.

The Central Park jogger case was a criminal case concerning the assault and rape of Trisha Meili, woman in Central Park in Manhattan, New York, on April 19, 1989. On the night of the attack, dozens of teenagers had entered the park, and there were reports of muggings and physical assaults.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Debra Lafave</span> American former teacher known for sexual battery against a teenager

Debra Jean Williams, better known under her former married name of Debra Lafave, is a convicted sex offender who formerly taught at Angelo L. Greco Middle School in Temple Terrace, Florida. In 2005, she pleaded guilty to lewd or lascivious battery against a teenager. The charges stemmed from a sexual encounter with a 14-year-old student in mid-2004. Lafave's plea bargain included no prison time, opting for three years of house arrest due to safety concerns, seven years of probation, and lifetime registration as a sex offender.

In the common law legal system, an expungement proceeding is a type of lawsuit in which an individual who has been arrested for or convicted of a crime seeks that the records of that earlier process be sealed or destroyed, making the records nonexistent or unavailable to the general public. If successful, the records are said to be "expunged". Black's Law Dictionary defines "expungement of record" as the "Process by which record of criminal conviction is destroyed or sealed from the state or Federal repository." While expungement deals with an underlying criminal record, it is a civil action in which the subject is the petitioner or plaintiff asking a court to declare that the records be expunged.

Anand Jon Alexander, better known as Anand Jon, is an Indian-born American celebrity fashion designer and convicted rapist who appeared on America's Next Top Model and was listed in Newsweek's ”Who’s Next in 2007?”. In November 2008, Jon was convicted at the Los Angeles Court on one count of rape and multiple counts of lesser sexual offenses. He was sentenced to 59 years to life. Jon was facing similar charges in New York, but before the trial began in 2013, the New York prosecutors accepted his guilty plea, and he was sentenced to time served.

Kym Loren Worthy is an American lawyer and politician serving as the prosecutor of Wayne County, Michigan since 2004. A member of the Democratic Party, she is the first African-American woman to serve as a county prosecutor in Michigan. She is most noted for prosecuting then-Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick at the beginning of March 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ages of consent in the United States</span> U.S. law on age of consent to sexual activity

In the United States, each state and territory sets the age of consent either by statute or the common law applies, and there are several federal statutes related to protecting minors from sexual predators. Depending on the jurisdiction, the legal age of consent is between 16 and 18. In some places, civil and criminal laws within the same state conflict with each other.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angela Corey</span> American attorney

Angela Corey is a former Florida State's Attorney for the Fourth Judicial Circuit Court, which includes Duval, Nassau and Clay counties—including Jacksonville and the core of its metropolitan area. She was elected in 2008 as the first woman to hold the position, and was defeated on August 30, 2016 by Melissa Nelson, the second woman to hold the position. Corey was catapulted into the national spotlight on March 22, 2012, when Florida Governor Rick Scott announced that she would be the newly assigned State Attorney investigating the shooting death of Trayvon Martin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kids for cash scandal</span> Judicial kickbacks case in Pennsylvania

The "kids for cash" scandal centered on judicial kickbacks to two judges at the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, US. In 2008, judges Michael Conahan and Mark Ciavarella were convicted of accepting money in return for imposing harsh adjudications on juveniles to increase occupancy at the PA Child Care for-profit detention centers.

The Miryang gang rape, known in South Korea as the Miryang middle school girls rape incident, was a criminal incident that occurred in Miryang, South Korea in 2004. At least 44 to up to 120+ male high school students gang raped several middle school and high school girls over the course of 11 months. The case provoked controversy due to police mistreatment of the victims and lenient handling of the offenders.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 Vanderbilt Commodores football team</span> American college football season

The 2013 Vanderbilt Commodores football team represented Vanderbilt University during the 2013 NCAA Division I FBS football season. The Commodores played their seven home games at Vanderbilt Stadium at Dudley Field in Nashville, Tennessee, which has been Vanderbilt football's home stadium since 1922. The 2013 team was coming off back-to-back bowls for the first time in school history. The 2012 season was the best win percentage since 1955 (.692); the nine wins were the most since 1915, and the 5 SEC wins were the most since 1935. The 2013 team was headed by James Franklin who was in his 3rd and final year at Vanderbilt. It marked the Commodores 123rd overall season, 80th as a member of the Southeastern Conference (SEC) and its 22nd within the SEC Eastern Division. For the third straight year Vanderbilt had made it to a bowl game. Vandy defeated the Houston Cougars in the BBVA Compass Bowl 41–24. Vanderbilt finished with 9 wins in back to back seasons for the first time in school history.

The Steubenville High School rape occurred in Steubenville, Ohio on the night of August 11, 2012, when a high school girl, incapacitated by alcohol, was publicly and repeatedly sexually assaulted by her peers, several of whom documented the acts on social media. The victim was transported, undressed, photographed, and sexually assaulted. She was also penetrated vaginally by other students' fingers, an act defined as rape under Ohio law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Suicide of Rehtaeh Parsons</span> Suicide of a student in Canada

Rehtaeh Anne Parsons, was a 17-year-old Cole Harbour District High School student who attempted suicide by hanging at her home in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada, on April 4, 2013, leading to a coma and the decision to switch her life support machine off on April 7, 2013. Her death has been attributed to online distribution of photos of an alleged gang rape that occurred 17 months prior to her suicide, in November 2011. On a Facebook page set up in tribute to her daughter, Parsons' mother blamed the four boys who allegedly raped and released images of her, the subsequent constant "bullying and messaging and harassment", and the failure of the Canadian justice system, for her daughter's decision to die by suicide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shakti Mills gang rape</span> August 2013 gang rape in Mumbai, India

The 2013 Mumbai gang rape, also known as the Shakti Mills gang rape, refers to the incident in which a 22-year-old photojournalist, who was interning with an English-language magazine in Mumbai, was gang-raped by five people including a juvenile. The incident occurred on 22 August 2013, when she had gone to the deserted Shakti Mills compound, near Mahalaxmi in South Mumbai, with a male colleague on an assignment. The accused had tied up the victim's colleague with belts and raped her. The accused took photos of the victim during the sexual assault, and threatened to release them to social networks if she reported the rape. Later, an eighteen-year-old call centre employee reported that she too had been gang-raped, on 31 July 2013 inside the mills complex.

People v. Turner, formally The People of the State of California v. Brock Allen Turner (2015), was a criminal case in which Brock Allen Turner was convicted by jury trial of three counts of felony sexual assault.

After a sexual assault or rape, victims are often subjected to scrutiny and, in some cases, mistreatment. Victims undergo medical examinations and are interviewed by police. If there is a criminal trial, victims suffer a loss of privacy and their credibility may be challenged. Victims may also become the target of slut-shaming, abuse, social stigmatization, sexual slurs and cyberbullying.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Daisy Coleman</span> American advocate for victims of sexual abuse

Catherine Daisy Coleman was an American sexual assault victim advocate who was the subject of the 2016 documentary film Audrie & Daisy, for which she received a Cinema Eye Honor. Coleman co-founded the non-profit organization SafeBAE, which was aimed at preventing sexual assault in schools. She died by suicide at the age of 23.

Kathy Shelton is an American sexual assault survivor. One of the defendants in her 1975 case was represented by Hillary Clinton, which caused controversy when Clinton stood as the Democratic Party candidate in the 2016 US presidential election.

The Vanderbilt rape case is a criminal case of sexual assault that occurred on June 23, 2013, in Nashville, Tennessee, in which four Vanderbilt University football players carried an unconscious 21-year-old female student into a dorm room, gang-raped and sodomized her, photographed and videotaped her, and one urinated on her face.

Angela McCormick Bisig is an American lawyer from Kentucky who serves as a justice of the Kentucky Supreme Court. She previously served as chief judge of the Jefferson County Circuit Court from 2020 to 2023.

References

  1. ↑ Chinn, Valerie (2012-09-01). "Parents of juveniles accused of sexual assault upset that names are public". wdrb.com. Archived from the original on 2016-06-05. Retrieved 2016-05-18.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Pesta, Abigail (2013-06-04). "Fighting Back: One Girl's Mission to End Cyberbullying". Cosmopolitan.com. Archived from the original on 2016-06-10. Retrieved 2016-05-19.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Riley, Jason (September 15, 2012). "Savannah Dietrich attackers get slightly tougher sentence". The Courier-Journal . Louisville, Kentucky: Wes Jackson. Retrieved 9 August 2013.
  4. ↑ "Savannah Dietrich comes face-to-face with admitted abusers". Louisville, Kentucky: WDRB. September 19, 2012. Archived from the original on 5 February 2013. Retrieved 4 January 2013.
  5. ↑ Plait, Phil (2012-07-23). "Savannah Dietrich outs her rapists on Twitter and Facebook". Slate.com. Archived from the original on 2013-01-02. Retrieved 2013-01-07.
  6. ↑ Chang, Juju (2012-08-20). "Kentucky Teen Sexually Assaulted, Then Threatened With Jail Time - ABC News". Abcnews.go.com. Archived from the original on 2012-09-13. Retrieved 2013-01-07.
  7. ↑ Pesta, Abigail (December 10, 2012). "Thanks for Ruining My Life". Newsweek. The Daily Beast. Archived from the original on 3 January 2013. Retrieved 3 January 2013.
  8. ↑ Jefferson District Court, Juvenile Division, "Opinion and Order" Archived 2013-09-03 at the Wayback Machine , p. 4 (August 28, 2012), obtained via Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.
  9. 1 2 Riley, Jason; Wolfson, Andrew (August 31, 2012). "Teens who assaulted 16-year-old thought it would be 'funny'". USA Today . Louisville, Kentucky: Gannett. Archived from the original on 2012-12-31. Retrieved 4 January 2013.
  10. ↑ Weiss, Jaimie. "Judge changes plea deal after teen Tweets displeasure", Archived 2013-09-27 at the Wayback Machine WAVE News (September 14, 2012).
  11. 1 2 Halladay, Jessie. "Kentucky House advances bill to allow juvenile court victims to discuss case", The Courier-Journal (March 4, 2013).
  12. ↑ Volokh, Eugene (2012-07-22). "The Dark Side of Privacy". The Volokh Conspiracy. Archived from the original on 2016-05-17. Retrieved 2016-05-20.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.