The Coming Conflict with China

Last updated

The Coming Conflict With China
Front cover of The Coming Conflict With China.png
Front cover of the 1997 edition of the book
Author Richard Bernstein
Ross H. Munro
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
SubjectChina
Genre Strategic foresight
Publisher Knopf Publishing Group
Publication date
1997
ISBN 978-0-679-45463-2

The Coming Conflict With China is a 1997 book by Richard Bernstein and Ross H. Munro. The book argued that conflict between the United States and the People's Republic of China would dominate the early decades of the 21st century and advocated various steps to counter what the authors saw as the Chinese threat to the US. [1] [2]

Contents

Development

Richard Bernstein originally started talking about his ideas for the book in 1996. At the time Bernstein was working as a book critic for the New York Times , though he had previously been the Time magazine bureau chief in Beijing. Bernstein had called up Munro to discuss his ideas for the book, and ended up deciding to collaborate on the writing of the book. Munro, a friend of Bernstein's, was the former Toronto Globe and Mail correspondent in Beijing, and had been expelled from China in 1978 for writing about human rights, after which he had worked for Time in Hong Kong. The text of the book was written by Bernstein from beginning to end so as to maintain a consistent writing style, with Munro contributing factual content for inclusion in it. [3]

Summary

The book opens with a quotation from Chinese general Mi Zhenyu quoting him as saying: "[As for the United States] for a relatively long time it will be absolutely necessary that we quietly nurse our sense of vengeance . . . We must conceal our abilities and bide our time". [4]

Bernstein and Munro argue in the book, based on a 1994 declaration that the Chinese Communist Party regards the US as a "hegemonist power", that the Chinese government sees the US as an enemy power and wishes to supplant it in Asia. Whilst Bernstein and Munro characterised China as not ideologically communist, or expansionist per se, they also stated that China's rulers wished to establish a hegemony of their own and to obtain US military technologies to strengthen themselves, and also sought to support opponents of the US globally. The authors describe China as an "unsatisfied and ambitious power whose goal is to dominate Asia". [5] Additionally Bernstein and Munro expressed the view that China's rulers blamed the US for the actions of the student demonstrators prior to the Tiananmen square massacre. [6]

The authors expressed the view that a war between the US and China was possible, with Taiwan being the most likely "flashpoint". [6] The book includes a chapter describing a potential future conflict over Taiwan in which China attempts military conquest of the island. [3] Bernstein and Munro predicted that "within the next decade or two, China will become the second-most-powerful military power on Earth, with economic power to match". [7]

Bernstein and Munro heavily criticised the policies of the administration of Bill Clinton towards China, criticising especially Clinton's failure to strip China of its most favoured nation (MFN) status having promised to do so if human rights in China did not improve during the 1992 presidential election campaign. Bernstein and Munro described this as "one of the most complete turnabouts in recent American diplomatic history". The authors also stated that the threat to link MFN status to human rights had been "a bad idea in the first place". The authors did, however, positively assess the Clinton administration's handling of the 1996 Taiwan Straits crisis. [8]

Regarding Japan, the authors advocated that the US should stop opposing Japanese rearmament, and instead characterised a weak Japan as a potential danger for the US. The authors saw the Chinese' government's goal as being to reduce Japan to a pacifist, neutralised, and subordinate status, whilst fostering anti-Japanese sentiment domestically. The authors opposed China being allowed to join the World Trade Organisation as a developing nation. [6]

Reception

Publishers Weekly Magazine described the book as "farsighted, chilling" and praised the book as a "hard-hitting critique" and a "wake-up call". [1] Donald Zagoria, writing in the May/June 1997 edition of Foreign Policy , described the book as "pessimistic" and criticised it for "overlook[ing] the common interests that both the United States and China have in maintaining regional peace in Asia". [2] Paul Kengor reviewing the book in the Summer 1998 issue of Presidential Studies Quarterly praised it for "provid[ing] a well-documented contribution to our understanding of how President Clinton handled one of the most critical, nettlesome issues facing U.S. foreign policy in the 1990's". [8] Harry S. Rowen reviewing the book in the Summer 1997 issue of The National Interest criticised what he saw as the "primitive" economic analysis deployed by Bernstein and Munro in the book, and also regard what he saw as the book's failure to sufficiently take account of Chinese democratisation and increasing internet freedom as a "crucial omission". [6]

Steven Goldstein writing in the Fall 1997 issue of Harvard International Review condemned the book as a "polemic" and even "a parody of a polemic, doing little to advance either debate or understanding". [9]

Legacy

In 1998 the book was described by Daniel Burstein in Big Dragon: The Future of China as having become "the bible of the China Threat school". [10] Munro lost his position as director of the Asia program at the Philadelphia Foreign Policy Research Institute (FPRI) subsequent to publication of the book. According to The Weekly Standard , this was due to pressure from the China Lobby, and particularly Alexander Haig, who was a trustee of FPRI and had "hated" the book. [11] [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

A superpower is a state with a dominant position characterized by its extensive ability to exert influence or project power on a global scale. This is done through the combined means of economic, military, technological, political and cultural strength as well as diplomatic and soft power influence. Traditionally, superpowers are preeminent among the great powers. While a great power state is capable of exerting its influence globally, superpowers are states so influential that no significant action can be taken by the global community without first considering the positions of the superpowers on the issue.

William Roscoe Kintner was an American soldier, foreign policy analyst, and diplomat.

Sino-Soviet split Cold War schism between communist states

The Sino-Soviet split was the breaking of political relations between the People's Republic of China and the Soviet Union caused by doctrinal divergences that arose from their different interpretations and practical applications of Marxism–Leninism, as influenced by their respective geopolitics during the Cold War of 1947–1991. In the late 1950s and early 1960s, Sino-Soviet debates about the interpretation of orthodox Marxism became specific disputes about the Soviet Union's policies of national de-Stalinization and international peaceful coexistence with the Western Bloc, which Chinese founding father Mao Zedong decried as Marxist revisionism. Against that ideological background, China took a belligerent stance towards the Western world, and publicly rejected the Soviet Union's policy of peaceful coexistence between the Western Bloc and Eastern Bloc. In addition, Beijing resented the Soviet Union's growing ties with India due to factors such as the Sino-Indian border dispute, and Moscow feared that Mao was too nonchalant about the horrors of nuclear warfare.

In international economic relations and international politics, most favoured nation (MFN) is a status or level of treatment accorded by one state to another in international trade. The term means the country which is the recipient of this treatment must nominally receive equal trade advantages as the "most favoured nation" by the country granting such treatment. In effect, a country that has been accorded MFN status may not be treated less advantageously than any other country with MFN status by the promising country.

The Foreign Policy Research Institute (FPRI) is an American think tank based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, that conducts research on geopolitics, international relations, and international security in the various regions of the world as well as on ethnic conflict, U.S. national security, terrorism, and on think tanks themselves. It publishes a quarterly journal, Orbis, as well as a series of monographs, books, and electronic newsletters.

In American politics, the China lobby consisted of advocacy groups calling for American support for the Republic of China during the period from the 1930s until US recognition of the People's Republic of China in 1979, and then calling for closer ties with the PRC thereafter.

Rich Lowry American writer and editor of the National Review

Richard Lowry is an American writer who is the former editor and now editor-in-chief of National Review, an American conservative news and opinion magazine. Lowry became editor of National Review in 1997 when selected by its founder, William F. Buckley, Jr., to lead the magazine. Lowry is also a syndicated columnist, author, and political analyst who is a frequent guest on NBC News and Meet the Press. His most recent book, The Case for Nationalism: How It Made Us Powerful, United, and Free, was released in 2019.

Robert Kagan American historian (born 1958)

Robert Kagan is an American neoconservative scholar, critic of U.S. foreign policy, and a leading advocate of liberal interventionism.

Peter Schweizer American writer

Peter Franz Schweizer is an American political consultant and writer. He is the president of the Government Accountability Institute (GAI), senior editor-at-large of far-right media organization Breitbart News, and a former fellow at the conservative Hoover Institution.

Robert D. Kaplan American author (born 1952)

Robert David Kaplan is an American author. His books are on politics, primarily foreign affairs, and travel. His work over three decades has appeared in The Atlantic, The Washington Post, The New York Times, The New Republic, The National Interest, Foreign Affairs and The Wall Street Journal, among other newspapers and publications.

<i>Red Star Over China</i> 1937 book by Edgar Snow

Red Star Over China is a 1937 book by Edgar Snow. It is an account of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) that was written when it was a guerrilla army and still obscure to Westerners.

The diplomatic history of Australia refers to the historical events surrounding Australian foreign relations. Following the global change in the dynamics of international state of affairs in the 20th century, this saw a transition within Australia's diplomatic situation to broaden outside of exclusively commonwealth and western European nations. Its core relationship was with Great Britain until 1941, and with the United States and New Zealand since then as represented by ANZUS. In the 21st century trade has soared with China. However relations have cycled back and forth from friendly to strained. For recent relations see also Foreign relations of Australia.

Hillary Clinton American politician and First Lady of the United States (1993-2001)

Hillary Diane Clinton is an American politician, diplomat, and former lawyer who served as the 67th United States secretary of state from 2009 to 2013, as a United States senator representing New York from 2001 to 2009, and as First Lady of the United States from 1993 to 2001 as the wife of President Bill Clinton. A member of the Democratic Party, she was the party's nominee for president in the 2016 presidential election, becoming the first woman to win a presidential nomination by a major U.S. political party; Clinton won the popular vote, but lost the Electoral College vote, thereby losing the election to Donald Trump.

Richard Bernstein is an American journalist, columnist, and author. He wrote the Letter from America column for the International Herald Tribune. He has been a book critic at The New York Times and a foreign correspondent for both Time magazine and The New York Times in Europe and Asia.

Frank Bray Gibney was an American journalist, editor, writer and scholar. He learned Japanese while in the American Navy during World War II, then was stationed in Japan. As a journalist in Tokyo, he wrote Five Gentlemen of Japan, a popular book about the Japanese, welcomed for its humanism and for transcending the bitterness of war. A half dozen more books followed on Japan and East Asia. He also wrote on communism in Europe. At the Encyclopædia Britannica, he directed translations, and he was the founder of the Pacific Basin Institute.

<i>A Great Wall: Six Presidents and China</i>

A Great Wall: Six Presidents and China: An Investigative History (1999) is a history of international relations written by journalist Patrick Tyler. The book details high level relations between the United States and China from the Nixon administration to the Clinton Administration. Primarily focused on the actions and motives of members of the president's cabinet and their counterparts in China, the book illustrates the large role personal politics and bureaucratic infighting had on the direction of China policy in the United States. Well received in the popular press, the book garnered mixed reviews in scholarly journals. However, the book won both the Lionel Gelber Prize and the New York Public Library's Helen Bernstein Book Award in 2000.

<i>On China</i> Book by Henry Kissinger

On China is a 2011 non-fiction book by Henry Kissinger, former National Security Adviser and United States Secretary of State. The book is part an effort to make sense of China's strategy in diplomacy and foreign policy over 3000 years and part an attempt to provide an authentic insight on Chinese Communist Party leaders. Kissinger, considered one of the most famous diplomats of the 20th century, played an integral role in developing the relationship between the United States and the People's Republic of China during the Nixon administration, which culminated in Nixon's 1972 visit to China.

Arthur Waldron American historian (born 1948)

Arthur Waldron is an American historian. Since 1997, Waldron has been the Lauder Professor of International Relations in the department of history at the University of Pennsylvania. He works chiefly on Asia, China in particular, often with a focus on the origins and development of nationalism, and the study of war and violence in general.

China became a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO) on 11 December 2001, after the agreement of the Ministerial Conference. The admission of China to the WTO was preceded by a lengthy process of negotiations and required significant changes to the Chinese economy. China's membership in the WTO has been contentious, with substantial economic and political effects on other countries, and controversies over the mismatch between the WTO framework and China's economic model.

<i>The Coming War with Japan</i> 1991 strategic foresight book

The Coming War with Japan is a book by geopolitical analyst George Friedman and Meredith LeBard, published in 1991, in which they argue that another conflict between the United States and Japan was inevitable as the latter was becoming an economic threat to the former. The Japanese title of the book translates as The Coming War with Japan: A 'Second Pacific War' is inevitable.

References

  1. 1 2 "The Coming Conflict with China". Publishers Weekly. February 2, 1997. Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  2. 1 2 Zagoria, Donald (May–June 1997). "The Coming Conflict with China". Foreign Policy. 3 (73). Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 "Booknotes (transcript)". CSPAN2. National Cable Satellite Corporation. May 11, 1997. Retrieved March 27, 2021.
  4. ↑ Scobell, Andrew (2001). "Playing to Win: Chinese Army Building in the Era of Jiang Zemin". Asian Perspective. 25 (1): 92. doi:10.1353/apr.2001.0033. JSTOR   42704300 . Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  5. ↑ Jian, Chen (June 1998). "The China Challenge in the Twenty-first Century Implications for U.S. Foreign Policy". Peaceworks. U.S. Institute of Peace. 31 (21): 2. Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Rowen, Harry S. (Summer 1997). "Off-Center on the Middle Kingdom". The National Interest (48): 101–104. JSTOR   42897131 . Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  7. ↑ Bernstein, Richard; Munro, Ross H. (1997). The Coming Conflict With China. A.A. Knopf. p. 21. ISBN   978-0-679-45463-2 . Retrieved March 27, 2021.
  8. 1 2 Kengor, Paul (Summer 1998). "Reviewed Work: The Coming Conflict with China by Richard Bernstein, Ross H. Munro". Presidential Studies Quarterly. 28 (3): 704–706. JSTOR   27551914 . Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  9. ↑ Goldstein, Steven (Fall 1997). "Conflict with China? Serious Concern or Inflammatory Polemic". Harvard International Review. 19 (4): 54–55. JSTOR   42762343 . Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  10. ↑ Burstein, Daniel (1998). Big Dragon: The Future of China: What It Means for Business, the Economy, and the Global Order. Simon & Schuster. p. 69. ISBN   9780684853666 . Retrieved March 25, 2021.
  11. ↑ "The Empire Strikes Back". The Weekly Standard. Vol. 2, no. 28. March 31, 1997. p. 5. Retrieved March 27, 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.