The Greatest of All Plagues

Last updated
The Greatest of All Plagues
Cover art for 2024 book The Greatest of All Plagues.gif
AuthorDavid Lay Williams
Subject Economic inequality
Publisher Princeton University Press
Publication date
2024
ISBN 9780691171975

The Greatest of All Plagues is a 2024 book by David Lay Williams, tracking how economic inequality has been treated by great thinkers of the Western canon.

Contents

The title is a reference to Plato, who mentioned "the greatest of all plagues" in his dialogue Laws . [1] [a] Williams wrote the book in part as he believes commentary on economic inequality has long missed the fact that the West's top political thinkers, not just its lowly workers, have been persistent critics of accumulated wealth. [2]

At least in the advanced economies, from the late 1940s to mid 1970s, economic growth delivered benefits which were broadly shared across the earnings spectrums, with inequality falling as the poorest sections of society increased their incomes at a faster rate than the richest. But this trend did not hold, with economic inequality rising in recent decades. [3] [b]

Synopsis

The book has an introduction, a conclusion, and seven main chapters: each dedicated to one great thinker and their thoughts on inequality.

In the Introduction, Williams cites the findings of Thomas Piketty and his associates to state that after an anomalous short period after World War II, economic inequality has been rising for the last five decades (pp. 1–2). In contrast to the Austrian School economists Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman, who claimed that the Western canon supported the ­inequality existing throughout history (p. 6), he argues for a "long Western tradition of criticizing economic ­inequality" (p. 3). He chooses to present "seven central figures in this tradition", selected for their familiarity (p. 3). He explains that these thinkers not only considered economic inequality a problem, but took pains to elaborate why that was the case (p. 4). He notes that the concern is not restricted to the Western tradition as Confucius, for example, wrote that a wise ruler "worries not about poverty, but about uneven distribution" (pp. 8–9).

Chapter one focuses on Plato, who Williams considers the first major philosopher of the western tradition. He concedes that Plato is often considered an elitist, but notes this did not prevent him from being deeply concerned about economic inequality. Williams says Plato's over-arching goals were on promoting civil harmony, friendship and fraternal bonds – which he considered were incompatible with too much economic inequality. Williams relates various ideal and practical ideas Plato had for improving economic egalitarianism, such as restricting "the wealthiest class of citizens [to] have no more than four times the property of the poorest citizens" (p. 42).

Chapter two focuses on Jesus Christ. Williams sketches some of the background useful for understanding what Jesus had to say on inequality, such as Hebrew laws relating to Sabbatical and to jubilee where debts were to be forgiven.

Chapters three to six respectively cover the views of Thomas Hobbes, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith and John Stuart Mill. Hobbes is shown to regard concentration of wealth as a threat to political stability. Noted are Adam Smith's concerns about the collusion of capitalists in keeping wages low, about the effects of repetitive menial labour on civic competencies, and about the morally corrupting influence of admiring the rich. [4]

Chapter seven considers the work of Karl Marx, who Williams says is widely understood to be the West's greatest critic of inequality.

The Conclusion starts with a discussion of various prominent commentators of the 20th & 21st century who had inaccurately asserted that concern about inequality was a recent development. It summarises the lessons of previous work on inequality, drawing from the seven selected thinkers and also the work of other historic and contemporary experts.

Reception

The book met with positive reception. Lilly Goren described it as "a magnum opus." [5] Nick Romeo for the The Washington Post calls the book impressive, noting that the author doesn't just track intellectual history related to economic inequality, he "makes a persuasive case that these thinkers were right to be so troubled". [1] Samuel Moyn for the The Nation described the book as "an excellent new survey", noting that a central question it addresses is why anger on economic inequality has become "pivotal not just for small groups like the Levellers but also for millions in modern times—or why Occupy, "Pikettymania", and Sanders helped revive a consciousness of it". [2] Arab News noted that the book demonstrates that economic inequality "has been a central preoccupation of some of the most eminent political thinkers of the Western intellectual tradition." [6]

In a largely positive review, Ben Burgis regrets that Williams did not spend more time explain the differences between the different thinkers, especially regarding Plato and Marx. [7] Similarly, political scientist Matt McManus, writing for the Jacobin magazine, criticised the book for restricting itself to the received canon and thus missing a chance to introduce "important socialist and social democratic thinkers" to the general public. [4]

New Statesman reported that the author describes how "Plato, Hobbes, Rousseau, Marx and others saw inequality as a clear and present threat to both personal character and political stability." [8]

Notes

  1. Strictly, it's civil war that Plato called "the greatest of all plagues", but according to Williams in the introduction of his book, Plato considered economic inequality to be the main cause of civil war (p. 11).
  2. Williams uses the data gathered by Thomas Blanchet, Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman in their Realtime Inequality project, available online at https://realtimeinequality.org/. The starting point of the dataset is 1976.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean-Jacques Rousseau</span> Genevan philosopher, writer, and composer (1712–1778)

Jean-Jacques Rousseau was a Genevan philosopher (philosophe), writer, and composer. His political philosophy influenced the progress of the Age of Enlightenment throughout Europe, as well as aspects of the French Revolution and the development of modern political, economic, and educational thought.

Political philosophy, or political theory, is the philosophical study of government, addressing questions about the nature, scope, and legitimacy of public agents and institutions and the relationships between them. Its topics include politics, justice, liberty, property, rights, law, and authority: what they are, if they are needed, what makes a government legitimate, what rights and freedoms it should protect, what form it should take, what the law is, and what duties citizens owe to a legitimate government, if any, and when it may be legitimately overthrown, if ever.

In Western anthropology, philosophy, and literature, the Myth of the Noble savage refers to a stock character who is uncorrupted by civilization. As such, the "noble" savage symbolizes the innate goodness and moral superiority of a primitive people living in harmony with Nature. In the heroic drama of the stageplay The Conquest of Granada by the Spaniards (1672), John Dryden represents the noble savage as an archetype of Man-as-Creature-of-Nature.

Social justice is justice in relation to the distribution of wealth, opportunities, and privileges within a society where individuals' rights are recognized and protected. In Western and Asian cultures, the concept of social justice has often referred to the process of ensuring that individuals fulfill their societal roles and receive their due from society. In the current movements for social justice, the emphasis has been on the breaking of barriers for social mobility, the creation of safety nets, and economic justice. Social justice assigns rights and duties in the institutions of society, which enables people to receive the basic benefits and burdens of cooperation. The relevant institutions often include taxation, social insurance, public health, public school, public services, labor law and regulation of markets, to ensure distribution of wealth, and equal opportunity.

Will, within philosophy, is a faculty of the mind. Will is important as one of the parts of the mind, along with reason and understanding. It is considered central to the field of ethics because of its role in enabling deliberate action.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Civil society</span> Third sector of society, distinct from government and business

Civil society can be understood as the "third sector" of society, distinct from government and business, and including the family and the private sphere. By other authors, civil society is used in the sense of 1) the aggregate of non-governmental organizations and institutions that advance the interests and will of citizens or 2) individuals and organizations in a society which are independent of the government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leo Strauss</span> American political philosopher (1899–1973)

Leo Strauss was an American scholar of political philosophy. Born in Germany to Jewish parents, Strauss later emigrated from Germany to the United States. He spent much of his career as a professor of political science at the University of Chicago, where he taught several generations of students and published fifteen books.

In ethics, political philosophy, social contract theory, religion, and international law, the term state of nature describes the hypothetical way of life that existed before humans organised themselves into societies or civilisations. Philosophers of the state of nature theory propose that there was a historical period before societies existed, and seek answers to the questions: "What was life like before civil society?", "How did government emerge from such a primitive start?", and "What are the hypothetical reasons for entering a state of society by establishing a nation-state?".

In philosophy, economics, and political science, the common good is either what is shared and beneficial for all or most members of a given community, or alternatively, what is achieved by citizenship, collective action, and active participation in the realm of politics and public service. The concept of the common good differs significantly among philosophical doctrines. Early conceptions of the common good were set out by Ancient Greek philosophers, including Aristotle and Plato. One understanding of the common good rooted in Aristotle's philosophy remains in common usage today, referring to what one contemporary scholar calls the "good proper to, and attainable only by, the community, yet individually shared by its members."

<i>The Open Society and Its Enemies</i> 1945 book by Karl Popper

The Open Society and Its Enemies is a work on political philosophy by the philosopher Karl Popper, in which the author presents a "defence of the open society against its enemies", and offers a critique of theories of teleological historicism, according to which history unfolds inexorably according to universal laws. Popper indicts Plato, Hegel, and Marx for relying on historicism to underpin their political philosophies.

<i>Discourse on Inequality</i> 1755 treatise by Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men, also commonly known as the "Second Discourse", is a 1755 treatise by philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, on the topic of social inequality and its origins. The work was written in 1754 as Rousseau's entry in a competition by the Academy of Dijon, and was published in 1755.

<i>The Social Contract</i> 1762 book by Jean-Jacques Rousseau

The Social Contract, originally published as On the Social Contract; or, Principles of Political Right, is a 1762 French-language book by the Genevan philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau. The book theorizes about how to establish legitimate authority in a political community, that is, one compatible with individual freedom, in the face of the problems of commercial society, which Rousseau had already identified in his Discourse on Inequality (1755).

<i>A History of Western Philosophy</i> 1946 book by Bertrand Russell

History of Western Philosophy is a 1946 book by British philosopher Bertrand Russell (1872–1970). A survey of Western philosophy from the pre-Socratic philosophers to the early 20th century, each major division of the book is prefaced by an account of the historical background necessary to understand the currents of thought it describes. When Russell was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1950, A History of Western Philosophy was cited as one of the books that won him the award. Its success provided Russell with financial security for the last part of his life. The book was criticised, however, for over-generalizations and omissions, particularly from the post-Cartesian period, but nevertheless became a popular and commercial success, and has remained in print from its first publication.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Clastres</span> French anthropologist and ethnologist (1934–1977)

Pierre Clastres was a French anthropologist, ethnographer, and ethnologist. He is best known for his contributions to the field of political anthropology, with his fieldwork among the Guayaki in Paraguay and his theory of stateless societies. An anarchist seeking an alternative to the hierarchized Western societies, he mostly researched Indigenous peoples of the Americas in which the power was not considered coercive and chieftains were powerless.

Crawford Brough Macpherson was an influential Canadian political scientist who taught political theory at the University of Toronto.

The history of political thought encompasses the chronology and the substantive and methodological changes of human political thought. The study of the history of political thought represents an intersection of various academic disciplines, such as philosophy, law, history and political science.

Criticism of democracy, or debate on democracy and the different aspects of how to implement democracy best have been widely discussed. There are both internal critics and external ones who reject the values promoted by constitutional democracy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pre-Marxist communism</span> Overview of communist-oriented ideologies and practices prior to the works of Karl Marx

While Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels defined communism as a political movement, there were already similar ideas in the past which one could call communist experiments. Marx himself saw primitive communism as the original hunter-gatherer state of humankind. Marx theorized that only after humanity was capable of producing surplus did private property develop.

<i>A Theory of Justice: The Musical</i> 2013 musical comedy by Eylon Levy

A Theory of Justice: The Musical is a musical comedy by Eylon Levy, Ramin Sabi, Tommy Peto and Toby Huelin. Billed as a "time-travelling romp through 2,500 years of political philosophy", the musical tells a fictionalised account of the writing of A Theory of Justice (1971), the classic philosophical treatise by the American political philosopher John Rawls.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Class conflict</span> Concept in political and social science

In political science, the term class conflict, or class struggle, refers to the economic antagonism and political tension that exist among social classes because of clashing interests, competition for limited resources, and inequalities of power in the socioeconomic hierarchy. In its simplest manifestation, class conflict refers to the ongoing battle between rich and poor.

References

  1. 1 2 Romeo, Nick (September 22, 2024). "Debating economic inequality, with help from Jesus, Plato and Rousseau". The Washington Post . Retrieved November 2, 2024.
  2. 1 2 Moyn, Samuel (August 27, 2024). "Zig and Zag: The surprising origins and politics of equality". The Nation . Retrieved November 2, 2024.
  3. Reich, Robert B. (September 3, 2011). "The Limping Middle Class". The New York Times . Retrieved 2011-09-06. During periods when the very rich took home a larger proportion—as between 1918 and 1933, and in the Great Regression from 1981 to the present day—growth slowed, median wages stagnated and we suffered giant downturns. ...
  4. 1 2 McManus, Matt (November 14, 2024), The Pathologies of Inequality Are an Age-Old Preoccupation, Jacobin, archived from the original on November 15, 2024
  5. Goren, Lilly (September 3, 2024). "The Greatest of All Plagues". New Books Network . first 10 secs of podcast. Retrieved November 2, 2024.
  6. "What We Are Reading Today: The Greatest of All Plagues". Arab News . October 31, 2024. Retrieved November 2, 2024.
  7. Ben Burgis (October 31, 2024). "The Ancient Curse of Inequality". Compact (American magazine) . Retrieved November 16, 2024.
  8. "The best of the academic presses for autumn 2024". New Statesman . October 16, 2024. Retrieved November 2, 2024.