The Sikh Diaspora in Vancouver

Last updated

The Sikh Diaspora in Vancouver: Three Generations Amid Tradition, Modernity, and Multiculturalism is a 2004 book by Kamala Elizabeth Nayar published by the University of Toronto Press. The book discusses three generations of the Sikh diaspora, a subset of the Indo-Canadians, in Greater Vancouver. [1] [2]

Contents

Background

Nayar is a sociologist, [3] and was an employee of Kwantlen University College. [4] As part of her research she conducted about 100 interviews, some in Punjabi and some in English, using a semi-structured format. [5] Nayar interviewed 80 Sikhs living in Vancouver, including first, second, and third generation individuals. [3] Most of the interview subjects originated from families who arrived in Canada in the late 1960s and early 1970s. [6] Nayar also interviewed six persons who are considered to be public figures and twelve professionals. [3] In addition she analyzed religious texts and other documents. [5] Nayar originally intended to chronicle assimilation, but as she conducted the interviews she decided to shift focus to generational differences. [6]

The author states that members of the public, Sikhs, and social scientists were the intended audiences, with the first group including counselors, educators, policymakers, and social workers. Verne A. Dusenbery of Hamline University wrote that in regards to the Sikhs, the only group that would "fully appreciate" the book's thesis would be the third generation and that this was based on the book's own arguments. [7]

Her source on literacy and orality is a work by Walter J. Ong, [6] Orality and Literacy: The Technologizing of the World . [8] Her sources on modernity are a work by Talcott Parsons and Edward A. Shils, [6] Toward a General Theory of Action , [9] and a work by Alex Inkeles, [6] One World Emerging? Convergence and Divergence in Industrial Societies . [9]

Content

The first chapter discusses the initial immigration, while the second chapter discusses differences in the methods of communication used by the different generations. [1] There is also a chapter specifically about the history of Sikhism. [10]

The book emphasizes the present and often repeats key points; Patricia E. Roy of the University of Victoria stated that these traits are a "sometimes textbook-like style". [11] Dusenbery wrote that the "words of advice and admonitions" throughout the book were intended for the wider public. [7]

Nayar argues that that "interaction between tradition and modernity" is the root of intergenerational conflict in the Vancouver Sikh community. [3] The book has a perspective opposed to Canada's multiculturalism policy. Several second generation persons interviewed by Nayar argued that the multiculturalism policy encourages racism. [12] The third generation interviewees are critical of aspects of Canadian Sikh culture, [6] and they argued that the multicultural policy isolates them into a "Punjabi Bubble". [11] Nayar herself argued that the policy prevents the Sikhs from becoming a part of mainstream Canadian society. [12] Dusenbery described Nayar as "a sympathetic advocate for the "modern" and "integrative aspirations" of the third generation Punjabi Sikhs. [7]

Reception

Mandeep Kaur Basran, a professor of the Department of Sociology of the University of Saskatchewan, wrote that the book has "refreshing arguments" and that it complements The Sikhs in Canada: Migration: Race, Class, and Gender by Gurcharn S. Basran and B. Singh Bolaria. [13]

Dusenbery argued that Nayar's analysis may incorrectly make recent Punjabi Sikh immigrants "stand-ins for all immigrants from "traditional," "agricultural," or "preliterate" societies, who presumably experience the same problems of "adaptation to modernity."" [14] Despite that reservation, Dusenbery wrote that persons in Punjabi and Sikh studies should find the book "worth reading". [7]

Connie Ellsberg of Northern Virginia Community College concluded that the book "provides an interesting view of three generations’ experience of the North American environment". [15]

Doris R. Jakobsh of Canadian Literature wrote that the book tries to inappropriately place members of the three generations of Sikhs "into the "blueprint" offered" without accounting for individuals who differ from the "blueprint," and she stated that "Nayar's framework delineating communication patterns of the three generations of Canadian Sikhs tends to be rather too rigidly established, to the point of prototyping". [16] She also stated The Sikh Diaspora in Vancouver did not give "due consideration" to "the centrality of Sikh women's role and status in Canadian society". [16] Despite the criticisms, Jakobsh concluded it "is without doubt an important and highly sophisticated contribution in its unique approach to the study of Sikhs in Canada" that "articulates and chronicles important and, in many cases, heretofore unheard voices from within the Sikh community." [16]

Roy stated that the book is "a good, clear introduction to the Sikhs" and a "provocative commentary on multiculturalism" that "can profitably be read by historians today." [11]

Roy Todd of the University of Leeds concluded that the book was "a richly detailed interpretation of a community here but the theoretical framing and the analysis of the evidence leads to questions about alternative interpretations." [17] Todd stated that the author did not make her research role clear, [17] used methodologies that had some faults, [18] and had an "uncritical dependence upon the dichotomy between tradition and modernity". [5] In regards to the methodologies Todd stated that Nayar did not give enough details about the interview questions, [5] and that she did not give a "precise quantitative analysis" of answers and instead only used "crude tallies" to present results of the interviews. [18]

See also

Related Research Articles

The Punjabis, are an Indo-Aryan ethnolinguistic group associated with the Punjab region, comprising areas of eastern Pakistan and northwestern India. They generally speak Standard Punjabi or various Punjabi dialects on both sides.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">3HO</span> Sikh sect founded in 1969 in the West

3HO , also known as Sikh Dharma of the Western Hemisphere or Sikh Dharma International, is a controversial American organization founded in 1969 by Harbhajan Singh Khalsa, also called "Yogi Bhajan". Its adherents are popularly referred to as the Sikh Dharma Brotherhood. While referred to as the 3HO movement, "3HO" is strictly speaking the name only of the movement's educational branch. Scholars have defined 3HO as a new religious movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punjabi Hindus</span> Ethnic group of the Indian subcontinent

Punjabi Hindus are adherents of Hinduism who identify ethnically, linguistically, culturally, and genealogically as Punjabis and are natives of the Punjab region of the Indian subcontinent. Punjabi Hindus are the second-largest religious group of the Punjabi community, after the Punjabi Muslims. While Punjabi Hindus mostly inhabit the Indian state of Punjab, as well as Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Delhi, and Chandigarh today, many have ancestry across the greater Punjab region, which was partitioned between India and Pakistan in 1947.

The Sikhs engage in various rites and services. Sikh rites include activities they consider essential to the group practice of Sikhism or the expression of egalitarianism, such as kirtan or taking karah parshad. Many rites in Sikhism involve prayer (ardas) or reciting scripture (paath). Some Sikh rites are meant to be practiced in a gurdwara congregation, while others are practiced at home or in other contexts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sikhism in Canada</span> Religious community

Sikhism in Canada has nearly 800,000 adherents who account for 2.1% of Canada's population as of 2021, forming the country's fastest-growing and fourth-largest religious group. The largest Sikh populations in Canada are found in Ontario, followed by British Columbia and Alberta. As of the 2021 Census, more than half of Canada's Sikhs can be found in one of four cities: Brampton (163,260), Surrey (154,415), Calgary (49,465), and Edmonton (41,385).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Asian Canadians</span> Ethnic group in Canada

Asian Canadians are Canadians who were either born in or can trace their ancestry to the continent of Asia. Canadians with Asian ancestry comprise both the largest and fastest growing group in Canada, after European Canadians, forming approximately 20.2 percent of the Canadian population as of 2021. Most Asian Canadians are concentrated in the urban areas of Southern Ontario, Southwestern British Columbia, Central Alberta, and other large Canadian cities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Khalsa Diwan Society Vancouver</span> Church in British Columbia, Canada

The Khalsa Diwan Society Vancouver is a Sikh gurdwara organization in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sikh diaspora</span> Sikh migration from historical homeland

The Sikh diaspora is the modern Sikh migration from the traditional area of the Punjab region of South Asia. Sikhism is a religion native to this region. The Sikh diaspora is largely a subset of the Punjabi diaspora.

KVRI is a commercial radio station licensed to Blaine, Washington, United States, and serving Greater Vancouver in British Columbia, Canada. It airs a radio format of Bollywood music, news and talk in Hindi, Punjabi and other South Asian languages. It is owned by Multicultural Broadcasting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Indo-Canadians</span> Community of Canadians of Indian descent or with Indian citizenship

Indo-Canadians or Indian Canadians are Canadians who have ancestry from India. The term East Indian is sometimes used to avoid confusion with the Indigenous peoples of Canada. Categorically, Indo-Canadians comprise a subgroup of South Asian Canadians which is a further subgroup of Asian Canadians. According to Statistics Canada, Indians are one of the fastest growing communities in Canada, and one of the largest non-European ethnic groups.

The Punjabi diaspora refers to the descendants of ethnic Punjabis who emigrated out of the Punjab region in the northern part of the South Asia to the rest of the world. Punjabis are one of the largest ethnic groups in both the Pakistani and Indian diasporas. The Punjabi diaspora numbers around the world has been given between 2.5 and 10 million, mainly concentrated in Britain, Canada, United States, Western Europe, Southeast Asia, the Middle East, Australia and New Zealand.

South Asian Canadians in Metro Vancouver are the third-largest pan-ethnic group in the region, comprising 369,295 persons or 14.2 percent of the total population as of 2021. Sizable communities exist within the city of Vancouver along with the adjoining city of Surrey, which houses one of the world's largest South Asian enclaves.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">South Asian Canadians in British Columbia</span>

The South Asian community in British Columbia was first established in 1897. The first immigrants originated from Punjab, British India, a northern region and state in modern-day India and Pakistan. Punjabis originally settled in rural British Columbia at the turn of the twentieth century, working in the forestry and agricultural industries.

South Asian Canadians in the Greater Toronto Area form 19% of the region's population, numbering 1.1 million as of 2021. Comprising the largest visible minority group in the region, Toronto is the destination of over half of the immigrants coming from India to Canada, and India is the single largest source of immigrants in the Greater Toronto Area. South Asian Canadians in the region also include significant Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Sri Lankans, and Nepalis, all representing several different ethnolinguistic backgrounds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paldi, British Columbia</span> Historic site in British Columbia, Canada

Paldi is a former South Asian settlement and mill town near Duncan, on Vancouver Island in British Columbia. It is significant as a town founded by Sikh Canadians, and its early exemplification of multiculturalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sikhism in Greater Vancouver</span> Religious community

Sikhism in Greater Vancouver is one of the main religions across the region, especially among the Indo-Canadian population. The Sikh community in Vancouver is the oldest, largest and most influential across Canada, having begun in the late 19th century.

<i>The Punjabis in British Columbia</i>

The Punjabis in British Columbia: Location, Labour, First Nations, and Multiculturalism is a 2012 book by Kamala Elizabeth Nayar, published by the McGill-Queen’s University Press (MQUP). The book discusses Punjabi immigrants to northern British Columbia in the period after World War II, and several chapters have a focus on the Punjabis of Skeena Country. The book has information on the female Punjabi experience. The book also discusses anti-Punjabi sentiments found in the First Nations peoples of British Columbia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Punjabi Canadians</span> Canadian people of Punjabi descent

Punjabi Canadians number approximately 950,000 and account for roughly 2.6% of Canada's population, as per the 2021 Canadian census. Their heritage originates wholly or partly from the Punjab region of India and Pakistan.

Nikky-Guninder Kaur Singh, also known as Nikky Singh, is an Indian-born American scholar in Sikhism, and professor and chair of the Department of Religious Studies at Colby College in Waterville, Maine, USA.

References

Notes

  1. 1 2 Jakobsh, circa p. 119. "While acknowledging Sikhs' shared features within the broader category of South Asians in Canada, Nayar steers clear of the weaknesses inherent in generalizations about the wider Indo-Canadian community by focusing on the issues specific to the Sikh community in Canada,[...]"
  2. ↑ Basran, p. 151. "The authors implicitly recognize how discussions around the broad labels of Indo-Canadian, South Asian, or East Indian tend to gloss over the cultural, historical, and structural specificities affecting these Sikhs."
  3. 1 2 3 4 Dusenbery, p. 211.
  4. ↑ Reference and Research Book News , p. 1/2.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Todd, p. 372.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Elsberg, p. 1830. "Nayar tells us that she began her project with an interest in “the process of adaptation and integration” as experienced by this sizable and visible minority, but that her interviews soon led her to focus on relations between the three generations she was interviewing, as she discovered that each seemed to occupy a different cognitive world."
  7. 1 2 3 4 Dusenbery, p. 212.
  8. ↑ Nayar, p. 240.
  9. 1 2 Nayar, p. 237.
  10. ↑ Basran, p. 150.
  11. 1 2 3 Roy, p. 173.
  12. 1 2 Basran, p. 150-151.
  13. ↑ Basran, p. 151.
  14. ↑ Dusenbery, p. 211-212.
  15. ↑ Ellsberg, p. 1831.
  16. 1 2 3 Jakobsh, circa p. 120.
  17. 1 2 Todd, p. 373.
  18. 1 2 Todd, p. 372-373.

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.