Thinopus

Last updated

Thinopus
Temporal range: Late Devonian
Thinopus antiquus marsh.png
Outline drawing of the fossil by Othniel Charles Marsh, 1896
Trace fossil classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Ichnogenus: Thinopus
Marsh, 1896
Type ichnospecies
Thinopus antiquus
Marsh, 1896
Ichnospecies
  • Thinopus antiquus

Thinopus is the name given to a trace fossil (ichnotaxon) found in late Devonian rocks in Pennsylvania. The only specimen was described by paleontologist Othniel Charles Marsh in a brief note published in 1896, with the only ichnospecies Thinopus antiquus. Marsh interpreted it as the fossil footprints of an early amphibian, making it the oldest evidence for tetrapods (land vertebrates) known at the time. Later research, however, argued that the fossil is better interpreted as the impressions of coprolites (fossilized feces) of fish. This would make Thinopus the earliest published name of a fish coprolite.

Contents

Description

The only specimen attributed to Thinopus is a slab containing two concave impressions, a complex impression and part of a second impression. The complex impression is 84.3 millimetres (3.32 in) in length and 64 millimetres (2.5 in) in width, and has a depth of up to 9 millimetres (0.35 in). Its margins are sharply defined and slightly overhanging the impression. The complex impression is horseshoe-shaped, with two elongated impressions joined at their bases, which early workers interpreted as digit impressions. These two impressions taper at one end, and are segmented by constrictions which resemble constrictions between toe pads. A concavity bordering one of the "digit" impressions has been interpreted as a possible third digit impression. The slab is composed of brown-gray sandstone of fine grain size, but also contains fewer coarser grains. [1]

History of research

Cast of the fossil as published by Dudley J. Morton in 1926. A) shows the cast of the original, while B) shows a reconstruction of an assumed missing area (outlined by black dotted line), which adds two additional digit impressions. Thinopus morton 1926 cast.png
Cast of the fossil as published by Dudley J. Morton in 1926. A) shows the cast of the original, while B) shows a reconstruction of an assumed missing area (outlined by black dotted line), which adds two additional digit impressions.

The fossil was discovered by paleontologist Charles Emerson Beecher south of the Allegheny River in Pleasant, Warren County, in Pennsylvania. After acquiring the fossil from Beecher, Othniel Charles Marsh of the Yale Museum published a brief note naming the new ichnotaxon Thinopus antiquus on October 16, 1896. [2] The note was accompanied by a simple outline drawing. The specimen is part of the collection of the Yale Museum under the specimen number YPM 784. [1]

Marsh interpreted the impressions as the footprints of an amphibian, with the complex, two or three-toed impression pertaining to a left hind foot and the partial impression to a probable fore foot. [2] This find was therefore the first fossil ascribed to a tetrapod (land vertebrate) from the Devonian, and therefore the oldest such fossil known. [3] Marsh's interpretation was widely accepted until the 1930s. American Paleontologist Samuel Wendell Williston, in 1917, used Thinopus as the basis of his basal tetrapod group Protopoda, which fell into disuse since. [1] [4]

American physician Dudley J. Morton, in 1926, argued that the foot of Thinopus was clearly separated from its leg, indicating an elevated position of the body and limbs, and a clear adaptation to locomotion on land. He stated that these features "remove Thinopus by a wide margin from the earliest stages of the transition from an aquatic to a terrestrial habitation", [5] :409 which pushes back the origin of tetrapods well into the Devonian, and possibly even Silurian. Morton noted that Thinopus only showed three digit impressions, which is at odds with the five-toed condition inferred for the original tetrapod. He consequently argued that the five-toed stage might have evolved only later during tetrapod evolution. Alternatively, he suggested that two additional digits might have originally been impressed between the two larger digits but were not preserved, resulting in a five-toed foot. Morton further suggested that the digits would have been outwards directed during walking. [5]

Outline drawing (left) and superimposition of a foot skeleton of an early tetrapod (right), by Dudley J. Morton, 1926. This interpretation shows a five-toed configuration of the assumed footprint. Thinopus morton 1926 drawing.png
Outline drawing (left) and superimposition of a foot skeleton of an early tetrapod (right), by Dudley J. Morton, 1926. This interpretation shows a five-toed configuration of the assumed footprint.

In 1935, Austrian paleontologist Othenio Abel became the first to question the interpretation of Thinopus as a footprint, after studying the specimen during a research visit in Yale University in 1925. Abel concluded that different interpretations are possible, and found that an identification as the impressions of coprolites (fossilized feces) of a fish would be as likely as its interpretation as a footprint. [1] [6] American zoologist and paleontologist William King Gregory, in 1951, instead interpreted the complex impression as that of the front fin of the lobe-finned fish Eusthenopteron . [1] [7] In a 2015 review, American paleontologist Spencer G. Lucas agreed with Abel's interpretation, noting that it closely resembles coprolites from the Early Mississippian of Nova Scotia, which were likely produced by fish. He further argued that Thinopus does not fit what is now known about the anatomy of early tetrapods; that it lacks symmetry and other features expected for a footprint; and that the overhanging margins rather indicate that it is an impression of a rounded object. Lucas argued that this makes Thinopus the earliest fish coprolite ichnotaxon that was named. [1]

Stratigraphy and paleoenvironment

According to Beecher, the fossil stems from the "Chemung Formation", a geological formation that has since fallen in disuse. Lucas, in his 2015 review, stated that the fossil is thought to come from the Scherr Formation, which is Frasnian in age, i.e. the older part of the Late Devonian, ca. 383–372 million years ago. [1] Beecher noted that ripple marks, mudcracks, rain drop impressions, and marine mollusks occur in the beds the fossil was found in, indicating that the impression formed in a shore environment. The fossil slab itself preserves the bivalve Nuculana . [2]

Related Research Articles

<i>Dilophosaurus</i> Genus of theropod dinosaur from Early Jurassic

Dilophosaurus is a genus of theropod dinosaurs that lived in what is now North America during the Early Jurassic, about 186 million years ago. Three skeletons were discovered in northern Arizona in 1940, and the two best preserved were collected in 1942. The most complete specimen became the holotype of a new species in the genus Megalosaurus, named M. wetherilli by Samuel P. Welles in 1954. Welles found a larger skeleton belonging to the same species in 1964. Realizing it bore crests on its skull, he assigned the species to the new genus Dilophosaurus in 1970, as Dilophosaurus wetherilli. The genus name means "two-crested lizard", and the species name honors John Wetherill, a Navajo councilor. Further specimens have since been found, including an infant. Fossil footprints have also been attributed to the animal, including resting traces. Another species, Dilophosaurus sinensis from China, was named in 1993, but was later found to belong to the genus Sinosaurus.

<i>Compsognathus</i> Genus of dinosaurs

Compsognathus is a genus of small, bipedal, carnivorous theropod dinosaur. Members of its single species Compsognathus longipes could grow to around the size of a chicken. They lived about 150 million years ago, during the Tithonian age of the late Jurassic period, in what is now Europe. Paleontologists have found two well-preserved fossils, one in Germany in the 1850s and the second in France more than a century later. Today, C. longipes is the only recognized species, although the larger specimen discovered in France in the 1970s was once thought to belong to a separate species and named C. corallestris.

Romer's gap is an example of an apparent gap in the tetrapod fossil record used in the study of evolutionary biology. Such gaps represent periods from which excavators have not yet found relevant fossils. Romer's gap is named after paleontologist Alfred Romer, who first recognised it in 1956. Recent discoveries in Scotland are beginning to close this gap in palaeontological knowledge.

<i>Hynerpeton</i> Extinct species of amphibian

Hynerpeton is an extinct genus of early four-limbed vertebrate that lived in the rivers and ponds of Pennsylvania during the Late Devonian period, around 365 to 363 million years ago. The only known species of Hynerpeton is H. bassetti, named after the describer's grandfather, city planner Edward Bassett. Hynerpeton is known for being the first Devonian four-limbed vertebrate discovered in the United States, as well as possibly being one of the first to have lost internal (fish-like) gills.

<i>Tiktaalik</i> Genus of extinct lobe-finned fish

Tiktaalik is a monospecific genus of extinct sarcopterygian from the Late Devonian Period, about 375 Mya, having many features akin to those of tetrapods. Tiktaalik is estimated to have had a total length of 1.25–2.75 metres (4.1–9.0 ft) based on various specimens.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fossil track</span> Fossilized footprint (ichnite)

A fossil track or ichnite is a fossilized footprint. This is a type of trace fossil. A fossil trackway is a sequence of fossil tracks left by a single organism. Over the years, many ichnites have been found, around the world, giving important clues about the behaviour of the animals that made them. For instance, multiple ichnites of a single species, close together, suggest 'herd' or 'pack' behaviour of that species.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Emerson Beecher</span> American paleontologist

Charles Emerson Beecher was an American paleontologist most famous for the thorough excavation, preparation and study of trilobite ventral anatomy from specimens collected at Beecher's Trilobite Bed. Beecher was rapidly promoted at Yale Peabody Museum, eventually rising to head that institution.

The Devonian Scherr Formation is a mapped bedrock unit in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and West Virginia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paleontology in New Jersey</span>

Paleontology in New Jersey refers to paleontological research in the U.S. state of New Jersey. The state is especially rich in marine deposits.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paleontology in Connecticut</span>

Paleontology in Connecticut refers to paleontological research occurring within or conducted by people from the U.S. state of Connecticut. Apart from its famous dinosaur tracks, the fossil record in Connecticut is relatively sparse. The oldest known fossils in Connecticut date back to the Triassic period. At the time, Pangaea was beginning to divide and local rift valleys became massive lakes. A wide variety of vegetation, invertebrates and reptiles are known from Triassic Connecticut. During the Early Jurassic local dinosaurs left behind an abundance of footprints that would later fossilize.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paleontology in Kansas</span>

Paleontology in Kansas refers to paleontological research occurring within or conducted by people from the U.S. state of Kansas. Kansas has been the source of some of the most spectacular fossil discoveries in US history. The fossil record of Kansas spans from the Cambrian to the Pleistocene. From the Cambrian to the Devonian, Kansas was covered by a shallow sea. During the ensuing Carboniferous the local sea level began to rise and fall. When sea levels were low the state was home to richly vegetated deltaic swamps where early amphibians and reptiles lived. Seas expanded across most of the state again during the Permian, but on land the state was home to thousands of different insect species. The popular pterosaur Pteranodon is best known from this state. During the early part of the Cenozoic era Kansas became a savannah environment. Later, during the Ice Age, glaciers briefly entered the state, which was home to camels, mammoths, mastodons, and saber-teeth. Local fossils may have inspired Native Americans to regard some local hills as the homes of sacred spirit animals. Major scientific discoveries in Kansas included the pterosaur Pteranodon and a fossil of the fish Xiphactinus that died in the act of swallowing another fish.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of paleontology in the United States</span>

The history of paleontology in the United States refers to the developments and discoveries regarding fossils found within or by people from the United States of America. Local paleontology began informally with Native Americans, who have been familiar with fossils for thousands of years. They both told myths about them and applied them to practical purposes. African slaves also contributed their knowledge; the first reasonably accurate recorded identification of vertebrate fossils in the new world was made by slaves on a South Carolina plantation who recognized the elephant affinities of mammoth molars uncovered there in 1725. The first major fossil discovery to attract the attention of formally trained scientists were the Ice Age fossils of Kentucky's Big Bone Lick. These fossils were studied by eminent intellectuals like France's George Cuvier and local statesmen and frontiersman like Daniel Boone, Benjamin Franklin, William Henry Harrison, Thomas Jefferson, and George Washington. By the end of the 18th century possible dinosaur fossils had already been found.

Blue Beach is a 2 kilometres (1.2 mi) stretch of cliff-bordered coastline at Avonport, Nova Scotia near the mouth of the along the Avon River in the southern bight of Minas Basin, Kings County, Nova Scotia, Canada. It is best known as a globally significant fossil location for Lagerstätte of the Tournaisian Stage period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">20th century in ichnology</span>

The 20th century in ichnology refers to advances made between the years 1900 and 1999 in the scientific study of trace fossils, the preserved record of the behavior and physiological processes of ancient life forms, especially fossil footprints. Significant fossil trackway discoveries began almost immediately after the start of the 20th century with the 1900 discovery at Ipolytarnoc, Hungary of a wide variety of bird and mammal footprints left behind during the early Miocene. Not long after, fossil Iguanodon footprints were discovered in Sussex, England, a discovery that probably served as the inspiration for Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's The Lost World.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">19th century in ichnology</span>

The 19th century in ichnology refers to advances made between the years 1800 and 1899 in the scientific study of trace fossils, the preserved record of the behavior and physiological processes of ancient life forms, especially fossil footprints. The 19th century was notably the first century in which fossil footprints received scholarly attention. British paleontologist William Buckland performed the first true scientific research on the subject during the early 1830s.

There are several cases of reported trackways of the earliest land-going vertebrates, also known as tetrapods. These trackways provide crucial insights to the study of the transition of aquatic to terrestrial lifestyles in vertebrate evolution. Such fossils help to illuminate not only the timing of this keystone transition of evolutionary history but also what the earliest forms of tetrapod locomotion may have entailed.

Gwyneddichnium is an ichnogenus from the Late Triassic of North America and Europe. It represents a form of reptile footprints and trackways, likely produced by small tanystropheids such as Tanytrachelos. Gwyneddichnium includes a single species, Gwyneddichnium major. Two other proposed species, G. elongatum and G. minore, are indistinguishable from G. major apart from their smaller size and minor taphonomic discrepancies. As a result, they are considered junior synonyms of G. major.

<i>Brachychirotherium</i> Ichnogenus of reptile footprints

Brachychirotherium is an ichnogenus, a form taxon based on footprints. It is a type of chirothere, a term referring to the footprints of five-toed Triassic reptiles with a short fifth digit, leaving an appearance similar to a reverse human hand print. Brachychirotherium was first characterized from fossils found in Triassic beds in Germany, but has since been found in France, South Africa, Argentina, Peru, Bolivia, and North America.

The Zachelmie trackways are a series of Middle Devonian-age trace fossils in Poland, purportedly the oldest evidence of terrestrial vertebrates (tetrapods) in the fossil record. These trackways were discovered in the Wojciechowice Formation, an Eifelian-age carbonate unit exposed in the Zachełmie Quarry of the Świętokrzyskie Mountains (Holy Cross Mountains]. The discovery of these tracks has complicated the study of tetrapod evolution. Morphological studies suggest that four-limbed vertebrates are descended from a specialized type of tetrapodomorph fish, the epistostegalians. This hypothesis was supported further by the discovery and 2006 description of Tiktaalik, a well-preserved epistostegalian from the Frasnian of Nunavut. Crucial to this idea is the assumption that tetrapods originated in the Late Devonian, after elpistostegalians appear in the fossil record near the start of the Frasnian. The Zachelmie trackways, however, appear to demonstrate that tetrapods were present prior to the Late Devonian. The implications of this find has led to several different perspectives on the sequence of events involved in tetrapod evolution.

Farlowichnus is an ichnogenus of small theropod dinosaur footprint. It includes a single species, F. rapidus, known from prints found in the Early Cretaceous Botucatu Formation of Brazil. Farlowichnus is known from several fossil trackways that indicate that it was likely a cursorial animal that was well-adapted to desert environments.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Lucas, Spencer G. (2015). "Thinopus and a critical review of Devonian tetrapod footprints". Ichnos. 22 (3–4): 136–154. doi:10.1080/10420940.2015.1063491. S2CID   130053031.
  2. 1 2 3 Marsh, Othniel Charles (1896). "Amphibian Footprints from the Devonian". American Journal of Science. 2 (11): 374–375. Bibcode:1896AmJS....2..374M. doi:10.2475/ajs.s4-2.11.374.
  3. Osborn, Henry Fairfield (1916). "The origin and evolution of life upon the earth". The Scientific Monthly. 3 (2): 170–190. ISSN   0096-3771. JSTOR   6141.
  4. Williston, Samuel Wendell (1917). "The phylogeny and classification of reptiles". The Journal of Geology. 25 (5): 411–421. Bibcode:1917JG.....25..411W. doi:10.1086/622507. S2CID   140645335.
  5. 1 2 Morton, Dudley J. (1926). "Notes on the footprint of Thinopus antiquus". American Journal of Science. 12 (71): 409–414. Bibcode:1926AmJS...12..409M. doi:10.2475/ajs.s5-12.71.409.
  6. Abel, O. (1935). Vorzeitliche Lebensspuren (in German). Jena: Gustav Fischer Verlag. p. 77.
  7. Evolution Emerging. New York: The MacMillan Company. 1951. p. 1013.