Too Bad You're Beautiful

Last updated
Too Bad You're Beautiful
Too Bad You're Beautiful.jpg
Studio album by
ReleasedAugust 14, 2001 [1]
March 8, 2005 (reissue)
RecordedMay 15 – May 23, 2001 [2]
StudioZing Studios in Westfield, MA
Label Ferret
From Autumn to Ashes chronology
Sin, Sorrow and Sadness
Too Bad You're Beautiful
The Fiction We Live
Singles from Too Bad You're Beautiful
  1. "The Royal Crown vs. Blue Duchess"
    Released: 2001
Reissue Cover
Too Bad You're Beautiful (Reissue).jpg
March 8, 2005 Reissue Cover

Too Bad You're Beautiful is the debut studio album by Long Island-based post-hardcore band From Autumn to Ashes. The album is unique in that it features the dual vocals of Benjamin Perri and drummer Francis Mark. Perri provides the hardcore-esque shouts while Mark sings and occasionally contributes background screams. The album was reissued in 2005 with the Sin, Sorrow, and Sadness demo as bonus tracks at the end.


A music video was released for the song "The Royal Crown vs. Blue Duchess."

Background and release

From Autumn to Ashes formed in 2000 with Benjamin Perri (vocals), Stephen Salvio (guitar), and Francis Mark (drums, clean vocals). [6] [7] The band spent its first few months touring and would record the EP Sin, Sorrow and Sadness , which would be released through Tribunal Records that same year. [8] Following the EP's release, the band would appear on Warped Tour over the summer. In early 2001, From Autumn to Ashes performed with Skycamefalling and Martyr AD, where Carl Severson, founder of Ferret Music, was in attendance; the band would be signed to the label the following day. [7] Around this time founding guitarist Stephen Salvio left the band and was replaced by Brian Denevee.

Production of Too Bad You're Beautiful lasted from May 15 to May 23 in 2001. [9] The album was produced by the band and Adam Dutkiewicz of Killswitch Engage at Zing Studios in Westfield, MA. Each song on Too Bad You're Beautiful is written about a relationship vocalist Benjamin Perri had. The album was released through Ferret Music on August 14, 2001. Too Bad You're Beautiful has sold over 100,000 units and remains one of Ferret's best-selling releases. [10] [11]

Track listing

All lyrics are written by Benjamin Perri and Francis Mark, except where noted; all music is composed by From Autumn to Ashes, except where noted.

1."The Royal Crown vs. Blue Duchess" 3:58
2."Cherry Kiss" 3:42
3."Chloroform Perfume" 4:29
4."Mercury Rising"Mark0:49
5."Capeside Rock" 4:04
6."Take Her to the Music Store" 4:18
7."The Switch" 4:16
8."Reflections" 7:30
9."Eulogy for an Angel" 4:18
10."Short Stories with Tragic Endings" (feat. Melanie Wills)Mark, Perri, Melanie Wills9:24
Total length:47:52
Reissue bonus tracks
11."Reflections of Anguish on a Face so Beautiful"Stephen Salvio, Perri, Mark, Gross, Pilato5:17
12."Trapped Inside the Cage of My Soul"Perri, Mark, Salvio, Gross, Pilato3:47
13."A Lie Will Always Defeat the Truth"Perri, Mark, Salvio, Gross, Pilato3:11
14."IV" (instrumental)Perri, Mark, Salvio, Gross, Pilato2:41
Total length:62:49

Reception and legacy

Professional ratings
Review scores
Chronicles of Chaos 8/10 [3]
Lambgoat7/10 [5]
Punk NewsStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svgStar full.svg [12]

Too Bad You're Beautiful has received highly positive reviews since its release.

Chronicles of Chaos reviewer Xander Hoose praised the band's ability to mix fast-paced hardcore with slower, melodic moments. Hoose criticized drummer Francis Mark's clean vocals noting his vocals were off-key at times and kept the album from being perfect. [3]

Lambgoat reviewer Mustapha Mond noted the band's ability to mix hardcore, metal, emo. Mond highlighted the songs "Cherry Kiss," "Capeside Rock," "Take Her to the Music Store," and "Reflections." Mond stated that "'The Royal Crown -vs.- Blue Duchess' took so many disparate elements, and yet somehow managed to keep a unified sound - it stayed one song the whole time.But over the course of 'Too Bad,' one cannot help but feel that too many things happen separately, and never quite gel." Mond concluded by calling Too Bad You're Beautiful one of the best albums of 2001, despite its flaws. [5]

In a 5/5 review, Punk News praised the album for its variety of musical styles and elements, from the hardcore of album opener "The Royal Crown vs. Blue Duchess" to the metal of "Cherry Kiss" to the acoustic emo of "Chloroform Perfume" and the spoken word of "Mercury Rising." The review highlighted "Take Her to the Music Store" and "Reflections" as examples of how the band can quickly change tempo and song structure. The review called closing track "Short Stories with Tragic Endings" a masterpiece, praising the use of violins and Melanie Wells's performance. [12]

In 2020, Brooklyn Vegan included Too Bad You're Beautiful on its list of "15 albums that defined the 2000s post-hardcore boom." [4]


From Autumn to Ashes
Additional personnel

Related Research Articles

Poison the Well (band) band

Poison the Well is an American metalcore band from Miami, Florida who were last signed to Ferret Music. In 2010, they announced a hiatus to explore other interests. Guitarist Ryan Primack and drummer Chris Hornbrook were the only remaining founding members, although vocalist Jeffrey Moreira featured on all five of their full-length albums.

From Autumn to Ashes band

From Autumn to Ashes is a post-hardcore band based in Long Island, New York. The group formed in 2000 originally under the name Who's to Blame. While the band had gone through many line-up changes, the members include Francis Mark, Scott Gross (guitars), Benjamin Perri, Brian Deneeve, Stephen Salvio (guitars), Josh Newton, Mike Pilato, Rob Lauritsen (guitars), Jonathan Cox (guitars) and Jeff Gretz.

<i>Last Night in Town</i> 2001 studio album by Every Time I Die

Last Night in Town is the first studio album by the American metalcore band Every Time I Die. After recording a demo, the band signed with the independent label Goodfellow Records in 2000 and released The Burial Plot Bidding War EP. The band signed to Ferret Music in mid-2000 and was planning to record its first album later in the year. After writing was completed in December of that year, the band went on several US tours until March 2001. In March and April, Last Night in Town was recorded with the Killswitch Engage guitarist Adam Dutkiewicz at Zing Studios in Westfield, Massachusetts. Following recording, the band went on tour with Killswitch Engage and Santa Sangre.

<i>Hot Damn!</i> (Every Time I Die album) 2003 studio album by Every Time I Die

Hot Damn! is the second studio album by American metalcore band Every Time I Die.

<i>No Wings to Speak Of</i> 2001 EP by Hopesfall

No Wings to Speak Of is an EP by melodic hardcore band Hopesfall. The EP was first released on Takehold Records in 2001, and was re-released in 2002 by Trustkill Records and on vinyl in 2008 by One Day Savior Recordings.

<i>Abandon Your Friends</i> 2005 studio album by From Autumn to Ashes

Abandon Your Friends is the third studio album by American post-hardcore band, From Autumn to Ashes. Released on August 30, 2005, it is the band's second album on Vagrant Records.

<i>The Satellite Years</i> 2002 studio album by Hopesfall

The Satellite Years is the second studio album by the melodic hardcore band Hopesfall. It was released in 2002 on Trustkill Records, the group's first for the company. The album was also released on vinyl by One Day Savior Recordings. The album was produced by Matt Talbott of HUM, who also provided vocals on the track "Escape Pod for Intangibles".

<i>The Fiction We Live</i> 2003 studio album by From Autumn to Ashes

The Fiction We Live is the second studio album By the American post-hardcore band From Autumn to Ashes. It was produced by Garth Richardson and released September 9, 2003, through Vagrant Records. Melanie Wills of One True Thing makes a guest appearance once again, contributing to the vocals on "Autumns Monologue." This is the last album to feature Scott Gross and Mike Pilato. It peaked at number 73 on the US Billboard 200 charts.

<i>Sin, Sorrow and Sadness</i> 2000 EP by From Autumn to Ashes

Sin, Sorrow and Sadness is the debut EP by From Autumn to Ashes. It was released under independent label Tribunal Records. The track "A Reflection of Anguish on a Face So Innocent" was re-recorded for their debut album Too Bad You're Beautiful, shortened to simply "Reflections". The new version of the song features an extended acoustic intro. All 4 of the album's tracks appear as bonus tracks on the re-release of Too Bad You're Beautiful.

<i>Petitioning the Empty Sky</i> 1996 studio album / compilation album by Converge

Petitioning the Empty Sky is an album by American metalcore band Converge. While many sources catalog the release as a studio album, the band considers this a compilation album as it's a collection of songs recorded at different times. While tracklists differ between releases, this album features studio recorded tracks along with live recordings of three songs. Petitioning the Empty Sky was released and distributed through several different labels beginning in the mid 90s.

Age of Ruin is an American metalcore band from Fairfax, Virginia. The group formed in 1998 and released a demo album the following year. The band's first full-length album was self-released in 2000.

<i>Holding a Wolf by the Ears</i> 2007 studio album by From Autumn to Ashes

Holding a Wolf by the Ears is the fourth studio album by the American post-hardcore band From Autumn to Ashes. It is also the only album without the band's original singer, Ben Perri, as well as the band's first album recorded with Rob Lauritson on 2nd guitar, and their last with Josh Newton on bass.

<i>These Speakers Dont Always Tell the Truth</i> 2007 EP by From Autumn to Ashes

These Speakers Don't Always Tell the Truth is a limited edition EP released by American post-hardcore band From Autumn to Ashes. It was on sale for a limited time at Hot Topic stores. This is the band's first release to feature drummer Francis Mark as the group's lead vocalist.

Francis Mark is an American drummer, singer, guitarist, songwriter and artist known as a member of the bands From Autumn to Ashes, Warship, Biology, and Tidal Arms. Mark currently resides in Brooklyn, New York and plays with Tidal Arms. Before From Autumn To Ashes, he was in a local band called "Who's To Blame" with Scott Gross.

<i>The Tropic Rot</i> 2009 studio album by Poison the Well

The Tropic Rot is the fifth studio album by American hardcore punk band Poison the Well. The album was released on July 7, 2009 through Ferret Music. The album was originally intended to be produced by J. Robbins, however due to a family emergency he had to be replaced by Steve Evetts.

Scott Gross American musician

Scott Gross is an American musician, guitarist, composer, producer, audio engineer and writer known as a member of the band From Autumn To Ashes and owner and founder of Hit And Run Studios in Long Island, New York. Before From Autumn To Ashes he was in a local band called Who's To Blame with Francis Mark. Gross was one of the songwriters in From Autumn To Ashes and also wrote lyrics for the first two albums along with Perri and Mark.

Twelve Gauge Valentine is an American post-hardcore band from Bastrop and Monroe, Louisiana, with their debut album Shock Value released on October 3, 2006. The band was initially supported by the Sound Vs. Silence label, with whom they released their debut EP, Exclamationaire. They have toured with bands, such as Haste the Day, From Autumn to Ashes, It Dies Today, Alesana, War of Ages, Demise of Eros, Maylene and the Sons of Disaster, Inhale Exhale, Anam Cara, Vanna, Once Nothing, Gwen Stacy, Society's Finest, The Handshake Murders, and Memphis May Fire.

Disembodied is an American hardcore punk band, formed in 1995 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Originally featuring Aaron Weseman (vocals), Justin James Kane (drums), Tara Johnson (bass), Joel Andrew Johnson (guitar) and Mario Diaz de León (guitar), the band split up in 1999 and reunited in 2008 and 2018, respectively.

Tribunal Records is a heavy metal and hardcore punk label that started in 1999. The label also has a subsidiary entitled Divebomb Records. Tribunal has hosted bands such as From the Shallows, Scarlet, and Century, while Divebomb hosts bands such as Wulfhook, Zephaniah, and Helion Prime.

Heavy hardcore is a subgenre of hardcore punk that incorporates more music elements of heavy metal than traditional hardcore punk. Heavy hardcore features aggressive vocals, down-tuned electric guitars, gang vocals, and heavy breakdowns. Heavy hardcore bands tend to often get labelled as simply "hardcore", causing the term "hardcore" to be a vague term because the term "hardcore" also is used as a label on traditional hardcore punk, a genre played by bands like Minor Threat and Bad Brains.


  1. "Too Bad You're Beautiful by From Autumn to Ashes". MTV . Retrieved September 29, 2014.
  2. "Too Bad You're Beautiful - From Autumn to Ashes". AllMusic . Retrieved September 29, 2014.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Hoose, Xander (May 31, 2005). "Chronicles of Chaos Review". Chronicles of Chaos . Retrieved February 27, 2018.
  4. 1 2 Sacher, Andrew (March 31, 2020). "15 albums that defined the 2000s post-hardcore boom". Brooklyn Vegan. Retrieved April 2, 2020.
  5. 1 2 3 Mond, Mustapha (March 2, 2002). "Lambgoat Review". Lambgoat. Retrieved February 27, 2018.
  6. "From Autumn To Ashes". Archived from the original on December 27, 2007. Retrieved 2007-12-07.
  7. 1 2 Francis Mark; Brian Deneeve; Scott Gross (February 2002). "An interview with From Autumn To Ashes". (Interview). Interviewed by Mark Keraly. Retrieved 2007-12-07.
  8. "Sin, Sorrow & Sadness - Tribunal Records". Tribunal Records. Retrieved February 24, 2014.
  9. "Too Bad You're Beautiful - From Autumn to Ashes". AllMusic . Retrieved April 2, 2020.
  10. Lawless, Andrew (December 2004). "From Autumn to Ashes". Retrieved 2007-12-30.
  11. "From Autumn to Ashes Biography". Retrieved 2007-12-30.
  12. 1 2 Duk (May 7, 2002). "Punknews Review". Retrieved February 24, 2014.