Trefa Banquet

Last updated

The so-called "Trefa Banquet" was an elegant and sumptuous dinner held on July 11, 1883, at the Highland House restaurant in Cincinnati, Ohio. Held in honor of the first graduating class of Hebrew Union College (including David Philipson, a major source on the event) and the delegates to the eighth annual meeting of the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, it offended a number of guests by featuring non-kosher ( treyf ) foods. [1] It became symbolic of the growing divide within American Reform Judaism, which would eventually lead to the birth of Conservative Judaism. [1]

Contents

The event

According to the elaborate menu, which has been reproduced several times[ where? ], it was "in honor of the Delegates to the Council of the Union of American Hebrew Congregations". Although not stated in the menu, the banquet was also honoring the first four graduates of the Hebrew Union College, whose ordination was being held at the same time as the convention. There were about 215 attendees, who were greeted by "a dinner orchestra". According to the menu, "an elegant French cuisine dinner composed of nine courses and five alcoholic drinks would be served.… By any standard, the party was lavish, even in an age of excess. For sure, the dinner was extremely costly." The cost was defrayed by wealthy Jews ("Cincinnati's leading Jewish families"), at the head of whom was Julius Freiberg, the business partner and neighbor of Samuel Levy, the husband of a daughter of Jacob Ezekiel, who was Secretary of the Board of Hebrew Union College. [2]

The Highland House was Cincinnati's leading venue, a "brilliantly lighted showplace where even political meetings and conventions could be held". [3] At the top of Mt. Adams (today's Eden Park), and served by funicular, it had a commanding view of the city, with upper and lower esplanades, on which concerts, parades, and picnics were held. The building no longer exists, having been razed in 1895. [3]

A non-kosher meal

The meal, while eschewing pork, [2] [4] did not conform to Jewish dietary laws (kashrut). It included the prohibited (treif) foods clams, crabs, shrimp, and frogs' legs. It also combined meat with dairy dishes (ice cream). [1] The meat was probably not kosher. This reflected the dining tendencies of Reform Jews at the time, who maintained the prohibition against pork but commonly ignored others, such as the one on shellfish. [2] [4]

The banquet received a long write-up in the Cincinnati Enquirer , under the title of "Jewish Jollification," which reproduced the menu completely, without comment, gave the program of the 12 numbers played by the orchestra (Brahms, Offenbach, von Suppé), and offered a long list of "the ladies present". [5] [6] In Rabbi Wise's American Israelite, the "collation" was "up to the standard"; besides a list of the ladies present, the article provides the texts of 7 toasts which were offered. [7] The banquet was also mentioned briefly in discussions of the meeting of the Council of the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, which lasted three days (July 10–12). [8] [9] [10] Nowhere is there any reference to objections or controversy in connection with the non-kosher dishes served.

Reactions

An eyewitness (the last living attendee, David Philipson) wrote, almost sixty years later, that "terrific excitement ensued when two rabbis rose from their seats and rushed from the room. Shrimp had been placed before them as the opening course of the elaborate menu." [11] If this is so, and his report has been described as "replete with misinformation" (among other things, shrimp was not the opening course), [2] these rabbis did so quietly, without confrontation or protest. Another eyewitness, Henrietta Szold, commented in a letter, published in The Jewish Messenger on July 27, that the number who were indignant was "surprisingly small. …Two rabbis left the table without having touched the dishes, and I am happy to state that I know of at least three more who ate nothing and were indignant but signified their disapproval in a less demonstrative manner." [2]

The first known complaint, however, is from a non-attendee, Sabato Morais, who would become the first president of the Jewish Theological Seminary of America. In a letter to the editor of the American Hebrew dated July 16, he complains:

The outrage perpetrated at last week's banquet was not an unheard of occurrence among the Hebrew clergy of America.
On several occasions of a public character, men notably supposed to champion the Revealed Law, sat at tables laden with the flesh of animals whose vital blood remained therein, and with that of loathsome things which creep in ponds and on the ground. What made the Cincinnati entertainment in its audacious effrontery most humiliating to the cause and vexatious to believers, is the remarkable event which principally brought it about.…
It is mortifying in the extreme, that the occasion in American Judaism which ought more especially to have gone down to posterity with the purest record, was stained by the unpardonable flippancy of a Hebrew Council, and the unrabbinical demeanor of American rabbis. It behooves the President of Union College to condemn what has evoked the remonstrances of the right-thinking. [12]

Morais did not use the name "Trefa Banquet", and its first use is unknown.

Isaac Wise replied on August 3 to "our Philadelphia friend" (Morais) who "chastises the American Israelite because it did not condemn or at least denounce that terrible misdeed of that said unscrupulous caterer". Disclaiming responsibility for the menu, Wise added: "It is about time to stop that noise over the culinary department of Judaism. The American Hebrew's religion confers not in kitchen and stomach. The American Israelite begs to be excused, it does not deal in victuals." [13]

"Word of the Trefa Banquet spread quickly throughout the Jewish press." [2] : 35 

Our Jewish contemporaries seem to be a good deal exercised in mind over the menu of a dinner recently given by Cincinnati Israelites to visiting rabbis and laymen. The trouble is, it appears, that it included clams, frogs' legs and crabs. The American Hebrew speaks of these dishes as "the abomination of Talmud and Poskim", and wants to know whether the eleventh chapter of Leviticus is omitted from the edition of the Pentateuch in use in Cincinnati. The Jewish Record, Jewish Herald, Jewish Tribune, and Hebrew Standard are equally indignant. But, on the other band, the American Israelite affirms that not one of the 300 or 400 guests exhibited the slightest dissatisfaction. [14]

The Jews of Cincinnati recently tendered a banquet to the Jewish ministers and laymen of that city at which many articles of diet forbidden by the Jewish ritual were served and eaten. Clams, soft-shell crabs and frog-legs were among the forbidden articles on the table. The affair has excited no end of comment and criticism on the part of Jewish journals. The Jewish Record says: "We coincide with those who censure this committee and all concerned in the affair. We doubt much if a society of Gentiles would not have paid more respect to a Jewish guest, than to set before him food which they know his religious convictions would not permit him to eat, as did this organization for the education of the Jewish rabbis." The Jewish Tribune calls it an "unmitigated disgrace." The Jewish Herald says: "The American Hebrew from its standpoint justly complains of the disregard to dietary laws at the Cincinnati banquet. The Jewish Herald in its leader warned the Cincinnatians in due time on that question." But, on the contrary, the American Israelite affirms that "Not a murmur, not a word of displeasure, not a sign of disappointment was observable among the 300 or 400 ladies and gentlemen who partook of the entertainment." [15]

Impact on American Judaism

Whether Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise, the president of Hebrew Union College and leader of American Reform Judaism, was aware of the menu plans of the banquet committee is not known. [1] "Determining Wise’s personal food policy is not easy. Frequently inconsistent, he readily changed or revised his views for opportunistic purposes." [2] : 39  He declined to apologize and condemn the banquet, and instead dismissed "kitchen Judaism" and argued that the dietary laws were obsolete and cheapened the religion in the eyes of others. [1] [4]

A tradition that dates back to attendee Philipson credits outrage over the banquet as a key turning point in the path of Conservative Judaism later forming as an alternative to the larger Reform Judaism movement. It "furnished the opening to the movement that culminated in the establishment of a rabbinical seminary of a Conservative birth," [2] : 30  as the Jewish Theological Seminary, founded shortly after the Trefa Banquet, eventually became the foundation of the Conservative movement.

"Kashrut was one of a cluster of interrelated issues that first caused a broad coalition of American Jewish traditionalists to withdraw from the Reform movement." [2] : 43  After Wise's death the American Israelite said:

The often-repeated claim that the so-called 'trefa' banquet at Cincinnati was the cause of the withdrawal of the Eastern Orthodox congregations from the Union of American Hebrew Congregations is without any foundation in fact. They had become members of the Union most unwillingly, and the association with the congregations that held more modern views being most distasteful to them, they were looking almost from the very start for some pretext to at least excuse, if not justify, their withdrawal. This the 'trefa' banquet offered them, and it was seized upon with avidity. [16]

On January 7, 2018, a group of Reform Jews in the San Francisco Bay Area, including members of the "Illuminoshi", an organization of Jewish food professionals, commemorated the original banquet with a "Trefa Banquet 2.0." It was an educational event, where they listened to a professor of Jewish history talk about the original Trefa Banquet, and ate treyf dishes made by Jewish chefs, including treyf meat. [17]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Judaism</span> Ethnic religion of the Jewish people

Judaism is an Abrahamic monotheistic ethnic religion that comprises the collective spiritual, cultural, and legal traditions of the Jewish people. Judaism evolved from Yahwism, an ancient Semitic religion of the late Bronze Age to early Iron Age, likely around the 6th/5th century BCE. Along with Samaritanism, to which it is closely related, Judaism is one of the two oldest Abrahamic religions.

The Union for Reform Judaism (URJ), formerly known as the Union of American Hebrew Congregations (UAHC) until 2003, founded in 1873 by Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise, is the congregational arm of Reform Judaism in North America. The other two arms established by Rabbi Wise are the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion and the Central Conference of American Rabbis. The current president of the URJ is Rabbi Rick Jacobs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hebrew Union College – Jewish Institute of Religion</span> American graduate school of religion

The Hebrew Union College – Jewish Institute of Religion is a Jewish seminary with three locations in the United States and one location in Jerusalem. It is the oldest extant Jewish seminary in the Americas and the main seminary for training rabbis, cantors, educators and communal workers in Reform Judaism. HUC-JIR has campuses in Cincinnati, Ohio, New York City, Los Angeles, and Jerusalem. The Jerusalem campus is the only seminary in Israel for training Reform Jewish clergy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Isaac Mayer Wise</span> American rabbi, editor and author (1819–1900)

Isaac Mayer Wise was an American Reform rabbi, editor, and author. At his death he was called "the foremost rabbi in America".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacob Rader Marcus</span> American scholar of Jewish history and Reform rabbi

Jacob Rader Marcus was a scholar of Jewish history and a Reform rabbi.

Reform Zionism, also known as Progressive Zionism, is the ideology of the Zionist arm of the Reform or Progressive branch of Judaism. The Association of Reform Zionists of America is the American Reform movement's Zionist organization. Their mission “endeavors to make Israel fundamental to the sacred lives and Jewish identity of Reform Jews. As a Zionist organization, the association champions activities that further enhance Israel as a pluralistic, just and democratic Jewish state.” In Israel, Reform Zionism is associated with the Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the Jews in Cincinnati</span>

The history of the Jews in Cincinnati occupies a prominent place in the development of Jewish secular and religious life in the United States. Cincinnati is not only the oldest Jewish community west of the Allegheny Mountains but has also been an institutional center of American Reform Judaism for more than a century. The Israelite, the oldest American Jewish newspaper still (2019) being published, began publication in Cincinnati in 1854.

The history of Jews in Ohio dates back to 1817, when Joseph Jonas, a pioneer, came from England and made his home in Cincinnati. He drew after him a number of English Jews, who held Orthodox-style divine service for the first time in Ohio in 1819, and, as the community grew, organized themselves in 1824 into the first Jewish congregation of the Ohio Valley, the B'ne Israel. This English immigration was followed in the next two decades by the coming of German immigrants who, in contrast, were mostly Reform Jews. A Bavarian, Simson Thorman, settled in 1837 in Cleveland, then a considerable town, which thus became the second place in the state where Jews settled. Thorman was soon followed by countrymen of his, who in 1839 organized themselves into a congregation called the Israelitish Society. The same decade saw an influx of German Jews into Cincinnati, and these in 1841 founded the Bene Yeshurun congregation. To these two communities the Jewish history of Ohio was confined for the first half of the 19th century. In 1850 Ohio had six congregations: four in Cincinnati and two in Cleveland.

The Pittsburgh Platform is a pivotal 1885 document in the history of the American Reform Movement in Judaism that called for Jews to adopt a modern approach to the practice of their faith. While it was never formally adopted by the Union of American Hebrew Congregations (UAHC) or the Central Conference of American Rabbis founded four years after its release, and several rabbis who remained associated with Reform in its wake attempted to distance themselves from it, the platform exerted great influence over the movement in the next fifty years, and still influences some Reform Jews who hold classicist views to this day.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sabato Morais</span> Italian-American rabbi

Sabato Morais was an Italian-American rabbi of Portuguese descent, leader of Mikveh Israel Synagogue in Philadelphia, pioneer of Italian Jewish Studies in America, and founder of the Jewish Theological Seminary, which initially acted as a center of education for Orthodox Rabbis.

The Rockdale Temple, formally Kahal Kadosh Bene Israel, is an Ashkenazi Reform Jewish congregation and synagogue, located in Amberley Village, a suburb of Cincinnati, Ohio, in the United States. Founded in 1824, it is the oldest Jewish congregation west of the Allegheny Mountains, the oldest congregation in Ohio, the second oldest Ashkenazi congregation in the United States and one of the oldest synagogues in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Krauskopf</span>

Joseph Krauskopf was a prominent American Jewish rabbi, author, leader of Reform Judaism, founder of the National Farm School, and long-time (1887–1923) rabbi at Reform Congregation Keneseth Israel (KI), the oldest reform synagogue in Philadelphia which under Krauskopf, became the largest reform congregation in the nation.

Capers C. Funnye Jr. is an African-American Conservative rabbi, who leads the 200-member Beth Shalom B'nai Zaken Ethiopian Hebrew Congregation of Chicago, Illinois, assisted by rabbis Avraham Ben Israel and Joshua V. Salter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Philipson</span>

David Philipson was an American Reform rabbi, orator, and author.

<i>The American Israelite</i> Jewish weekly newspaper published in Cincinnati, Ohio

The American Israelite is an English-language Jewish newspaper published weekly in Cincinnati, Ohio. Founded in 1854 as The Israelite and assuming its present name in 1874, it is the longest-running English-language Jewish newspaper still published in the United States and the second longest-running Jewish newspaper in the world, after the London-based Jewish Chronicle.

<i>Minhag America</i>

Minhag America is a siddur created in 1857 by Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise that was intended to address conflict between sides supporting and opposing traditionalism in early Reform Judaism in the United States. The prayer book was accepted by the majority of Reform congregations in the western and southern United States.

Har Sinai – Oheb Shalom Congregation is a Reform Jewish congregation and synagogue located at 7310 Park Heights Avenue, in Pikesville, Baltimore County, Maryland, in the United States. Established in 1842 in Baltimore and known as Har Sinai Congregation, and in 1853 near Camden Yards as Temple Oheb Shalom, the two congregations merged in 2019 and is the oldest Reform congregation in the United States that has used the same prayer rite since its inception.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reform Congregation Keneseth Israel (Philadelphia)</span> Reform Jewish synagogue in Philadelphia, USA

Reform Congregation Keneseth Israel, abbreviated as KI, is a Reform Jewish congregation and synagogue located at 8339 Old York Road, Elkins Park, just outside the city of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in the United States. Founded in Philadelphia in 1847, it is the sixth oldest Reform congregation in the United States, and, by 1900, it was one of the largest Reform congregations in the United States. The synagogue was at a number of locations in the city before building a large structure on North Broad Street in 1891, until 1956 when it moved north of the city to suburban Elkins Park.

Henry Berkowitz was a Reform rabbi, educator and author.

Jacob Ezekiel was an American merchant and leader of the Jewish community in antebellum Richmond, Virginia. In Cincinnati after the Civil War, he was for many years Secretary of the Board of Hebrew Union College. He was a charter member of B'nai B'rith, the first national Jewish organization in the United States. According to his son Moses, he was a good writer and a well-read man, "a man of cultivation", who possessed the complete works of Maimonides. He was the father of Moses Jacob Ezekiel (1844–1917), who became America's most famous sculptor.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Appel, John J. (February 1966). "The Trefa Banquet". Commentary. Archived from the original on 2011-06-09. Retrieved 2011-08-31.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Sussman, Lance J. (2005). "The Myth of the Trefa Banquet: American Culinary Culture and the Radicalization of Food Policy in American Reform Judaism" (PDF). American Jewish Archives Journal. Vol. 57, no. 1–2. pp. 29–52. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2014-10-17. Retrieved 2014-12-07.
  3. 1 2 "Cincinnati History - Mt Adams Incline". c. 2018. Archived from the original on March 26, 2019. Retrieved March 22, 2019.
  4. 1 2 3 Sarna, Jonathan D. (2005). American Judaism: A History . Yale University Press. p.  145. ISBN   0300109768.
  5. ↑ "Jewish Jollification". Cincinnati Enquirer . July 12, 1883. p. 4. Archived from the original on March 27, 2019. Retrieved March 26, 2019.
  6. ↑ "At Home". Fort Wayne Daily Gazette . July 15, 1883. p. 15. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved May 10, 2019.
  7. ↑ "The First Ripe Fruits Plucked From the Tree of Knowledge Planted on Our Virgin Soil". The American Israelite . July 20, 1883. p. 5. Archived from the original on March 27, 2019. Retrieved March 26, 2019.
  8. ↑ "American Hebrews". The Inter Ocean (Chicago, Illinois). July 13, 1883. p. 5. Archived from the original on March 30, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
  9. ↑ "Hebrew Congregations". Memphis Daily Appeal (Memphis, Tennessee). July 13, 1883. p. 1. Archived from the original on March 30, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
  10. ↑ "The Union of the Hebrew Congregations". Weekly Times-Democrat . New Orleans, Louisiana. July 14, 1883. Archived from the original on March 30, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
  11. ↑ Philipson, David (1941). My Life as an American Jew. Cincinnati: Kidd. p. 23.
  12. ↑ Morais, S[abato] (July 20, 1884). "The Trefa Jewish Banquet". The American Hebrew . Archived from the original on March 30, 2019. Retrieved March 30, 2019.
  13. ↑ Wise, Isaac (August 3, 1883). "Untitled editorial". The American Israelite . p. 4. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved May 10, 2019.
  14. ↑ "Current Comment". Hartford Courant . (Also in the Morning News (Wilmington, Delaware), August 9, 1883, p. 4.). August 6, 1883. p. 2. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved May 10, 2019.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: others (link)
  15. ↑ "Table Talk". Buffalo Commercial. August 7, 1883. p. 2. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved May 10, 2019.
  16. ↑ "The Union of American Hebrew Congregations". American Israelite . January 10, 1907. p. 4. Archived from the original on June 7, 2019. Retrieved May 10, 2019.
  17. ↑ Goldsmith, Ashley. Jews Feast On Forbidden Foods To Remember Rabbis' Radical Banquet Archived 2019-04-02 at the Wayback Machine : NPR, January 24, 2018

Further reading

On the 2018 "Trefa Banquet 2.0"

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.