Twilight Sleep (novel)

Last updated

Twilight Sleep is a novel by American author Edith Wharton and was first published in 1927 as a serial in the Pictorial Review before being published as a novel in the same year. The story, filled with irony, is centered around a socialite family navigating the New York of the Jazz Age and their relationships. This novel landed at number one on the best-selling list just two months after its publication and finished the year at number 7. [1] Even as a best selling novel Twilight Sleep was not well received by critics at the time, who, while appreciating Wharton as a writer, struggled with the scenarios and characters she had created in the novel. While it was not considered as such in its own time period, today Twilight Sleep is widely considered to be a modernist novel as it employs modernist literary devices, such as an ever changing narration among the novel's characters and a close examination of the characters' self-identities and relationships with one another. [2]

Contents

Summary

Twilight Sleep is a satirical novel about the lives and relationships of an extended and dysfunctional family in New York in the 1920s. The most prominent storyline follows the family’s combined efforts to keep the marriage of Jim and Lita Wyant intact, as Lita has become bored with the relationship and is seeking a divorce from Jim. While this storyline threads itself through the novel, the reader is taken into the different characters' own storylines and perspectives as the narrative is passed from one character to the next. There is Pauline’s self-inflicted busy schedule, Nona’s love interest in a married man, Arthur’s infirmity, Lita’s partying, dancing, and movie star aspirations, and Dexter’s affairs. Dexter’s affair with Lita is what brings the reader to the climax of the story where Arthur arrives at the families' cottage and attempts to shoot the man whom Lita is having an affair with (Dexter). He misses and instead hits Nona, who presumably came to Lita’s room to confront her father and Lita about the affair. The novel ends with Nona recovering and the rest of the family all taking trips out of the country as a way to physically and emotionally escape what had happened. The novel is left unresolved, as none of the characters have seemed to grow or change from their experiences and continue to live a life of avoidance.

Background

Twilight Sleep was serialized in the Pictorial Review and illustrated by C.J. McCarthy beginning in February 1927. [3] It was published in four parts: once a month from February- May of that year. [3] [4] [5] [6]

At the time of her writing and publishing Twilight Sleep, Edith Wharton was living in France and had ceased living in or visiting the United States. [7]

Edith Wharton (1915) Edith Wharton.jpg
Edith Wharton (1915)

Historical context

Twilight Sleep

In 1920s American Literature the motif of escape is ever present, and in Wharton’s Twilight Sleep this theme drives a melodramatic plot. Twilight sleep was a medical procedure in which pregnant women would be given a mixture of the drugs scopolamine and morphine as a way to simultaneously reduce the pain of childbirth and allow the mother to forget the experience altogether. In the novel, Lita experiences twilight sleep with the birth of her child, but she also uses twilight sleep as a metaphor for the way American’s in the 1920s seemed to do everything in their power to avoid pain and to search for quick fixes to their problems. She does this through her depictions of her characters and their own avoidances of pain and suffering.

Twilight Sleep is one of the ways that Wharton expressed her objections to modern science and its goal of relieving humans from suffering. The 1920s was a time of industrialization and Fordist thinking, where everything should be made easy and that one’s personal life could be organized to be made more efficient in the same way that one’s working life could be. Wharton was also very critical of this new way of thinking in America and her criticism plays out in Pauline’s character who subscribes to this kind of lifestyle, but is still left feeling all the pains and sorrows of human life no matter how hard she works to avoid it. [8]

Characters

Nona Manford

Nona is the daughter of Pauline and Dexter Manford and half-sister to Jim Wyant. Nona is a flapper of the jazz age (though she identifies herself in this way more out of societal expectation then of a true want for that lifestyle) [9] and stands as the novel’s protagonist as she begins and ends the narrative. She is the driving force for the novel’s biggest plot thread, which is trying to save Jim and Lita Wyant’s marriage. Nona’s unhappiness in the novel comes from her own struggle with relationships as she is in love with the married Stanley Heuston, whose wife will not grant him a divorce.

Pauline Manford

Pauline is the mother of Nona Manford and Jim Wyant. She was previously married to Arthur Wyant with whom she got a divorce. She went on to marry her divorce attorney and current husband Dexter Manford. Pauline is an incredibly busy woman, though this busyness is entirely self-inflicted. She prefers to have every hour of her life mapped out in a schedule and when she is left with an empty hour she is pained by the prospect of trying to spontaneously fill this hour. Diane Lichtenstein asserts that Pauline’s self-proclaimed efficiency is really just a shield she uses against the pains and sufferings of life. [1]

Lita Wyant

Lita is the wife of Jim Wyant and the mother of a child, though she is seeking a divorce from Jim in the novel. Lita is the epitome of the 1920s flapper image. She’s athletic, with her favorite pass time being to go out to clubs and to dance. Her greatest aspiration is to become a movie star. She is an orphan and some critics of the novel assert that her origins are purposefully left a mystery as Lita’s character is firmly placed alongside Harlem culture and this connection and her unknown origins may hint at Lita being of a race other than white. However, some critics speak on Wharton’s use of Harlem in Twilight Sleep as nothing more than a metaphor for the oft reviled sexual liberation of white flapper women, [9] which can also be seen being represented through Lita’s character.

Arthur Wyant

Arthur is Pauline's ex-husband and Jim's father. His character is viewed by the others as infirm and old-fashioned. Arthur is of the old New York society and his character and his relationship to Pauline (a character representative of new wealth) Serve as a representation of new wealth invading the old wealth of New York. [9]

Themes

Body image

During the 1920s, media platforms such as advertisements and film began to surface with the goal of popularizing this new idea of the perfect female body. With the trending use of cosmetics, as well as cosmetic surgery, becoming more available during this time, women, in particular, pounced on the idea of altering their bodies accordingly to fit in with these standards. [10] Edith Wharton’s 1927 novel Twilight Sleep, reflects these similar trends in a number of ways.

The novel essentially has three main female protagonists, and readers follow their daily lives throughout the novel. These main characters being Pauline, Lita and Nona. Each of these female characters has a different relationship with their body, and each has taken on a different literary role concerning 1920s technology of the female body. Beginning with Pauline, she has used new technological advances of the time, in order to work on tailoring her body to the 1920s idea of perfection. From the very beginning of the novel we see how Pauline Manford has an extremely busy schedule, full of techniques that she believes will alter her body and mind. [11] As she makes her many attempts at rejuvenating her body, she often forgets about her own children and has very little time for them as a result. In addition to this Pauline’s body is constantly on the move, making her one of the most efficient characters in this sense. Her body is consistently at work and goes from either running her home to achieving her many public duties outside of the home. As a female character set in the 1920s, Pauline spends a huge amount of time working and improving on her body and image.

On the other hand, Lita is the character within the novel who serves as the overall image of these new beauty standards. While this does come with a downfall as well, as the women in Lita’s life try to prevent her body from being used to attract men. For example, Nona follows Lita to multiple parties with the idea of keeping an eye on her. While Pauline attempts to talk Lita out of getting involved in movies and dancing, and instead pushes her towards focusing on being a housewife. Whereas Nona undergoes the pain of always comparing herself to Lita, and feeling as though she is hidden behind Lita’s shadow. Although at the end of the novel, this is the same body that saves her family, as she essentially takes a bullet for them. [12] Unlike her mother, Nona remains skeptical of these new technologies used on women’s exterior, and is the character who ends up staying most true to herself.

Marriage, relationships, and divorce

The most prominent theme in Twilight Sleep is the dysfunctional relationships that the characters have with one another. This is especially significant in terms of romantic relationships, marriage, and divorce. In the 1920s, marriage was a key life goal for women, but divorce was becoming more acceptable and the number of divorced couples was on the rise. This cultural shift is what Wharton chooses to focus on in Twilight Sleep. Through her characters, Wharton seemingly asserts that these breakdowns in relationships are tied to a lack of communication and sense of identity within the characters. All of the characters in this novel struggle to understand themselves and this makes it nearly impossible for them to understand each other. [2] This lack of communication and moments of misunderstanding can be most clearly seen with Pauline and her interactions with others, especially with her husband Dexter. During a dinner party she feels that she’s done something special for Dexter when she sets him next to Mrs. Toy, believing that Dexter gains pleasure from flirting with her. In reality Dexter has no social interest in Mrs. Toy and it isn’t until later that he has a purely sexual interest and has an affair with her.

Wharton’s characters are a display of the modern personalities of the 1920s, personalities that are often dull, shallow, and selfish. The characters’ need for a stronger sense of self identity leads them to be selfish and hold no loyalties to those they have relationships with Lita is a perfect example of this as she becomes increasingly bored with her life and her relationships. [2] She wants more for herself and continuing to be married to Jim does not fit into the identity she is seeking for herself.

The characters’ inability to communicate and self-identify are key factors in the breakdown of their relationships and the divorce/want for a divorce that result. Twilight Sleep shows the shift in the cultural perception of marriage from a symbol of wholeness and personal completion to that of a burden on one’s self-identity. [2]  

Reception

When the Pictorial Review published Twilight Sleep as a serialized story, the headline proclaimed it “the finest novel of New York society,” [3] and the sales seem to agree. Twilight Sleep appears on many lists, such as Publishers Weekly , in the top ten bestsellers of 1927, but upon its release, the critics were largely underwhelmed. Percy Hutchison wrote in The New York Times that he did not believe Wharton could live up to Ethan Frome and The House of Mirth, but he mostly begins his review praising her and her past works. He uses these works to excuse certain shortcomings of Twilight Sleep: "But she maintains herself at so consistently high a level that any occasional faltering of the imagination may be charitably set down as nothing more serious than a change of pace, any lapse in artistry as a mere peccadillo of the pen." [13] Edmund Wilson of The New Republic is less critical of the novel, as well, and finds Wharton’s loss “of her old harshness” to be an acceptable turn and uses it to excuse her novel being “proportionately less vivid.” [14] Like Hutchison and Wilson, many of the other reviewers appear to have had a great appreciation for Wharton’s work in itself, but they had much to say about this one not quite adding up to the others.

America voiced a concern “that her latest novel “Twilight Sleep” is an inartistic abandonment of her former office of telling what ought to be known about well-bred people in order to describe the vagaries of the new war-made rich.” [15] The people are an issue for several reviewers, The Atlantic was disappointed with the characters, calling them “puppets, pulled at times by too inadequate strings.” [16] The puppet theme continues as Hutchison refers to the characters as "marionettes," but his bigger issue stems from the disconnect to America he feels from Wharton and that these puppets are being "operated from a distance rather than persons actually at our side." [13] The Atlantic then gives the verdict that there is a lack of “compelling naturalness in character and in situation.” [16] There is a fair amount of critique on the scenarios these characters are put in. America’s review counts them as “fantastic," particularly with the people Pauline manages to throw together at her dinner parties. [15] The finale of the novel is no exception. Wilson classified it this way: “when the catastrophe finally occurs, it is not quite dramatic enough.” [14]

Related Research Articles

Anne Desclos French journalist and novelist best known for her erotic novel Story of O

Anne Cécile Desclos was a French journalist and novelist who wrote under the pseudonyms Dominique Aury and Pauline Réage, and is best known for her erotic novel Histoire d'O.

<i>The Exploits of Elaine</i>

The Exploits of Elaine is a 1914 American film serial in the damsel in distress genre of The Perils of Pauline (1914).

Edith Wharton American novelist, short story writer, designer

Edith Wharton was an American novelist, short story writer, and designer. Wharton drew upon her insider's knowledge of the upper class New York "aristocracy" to realistically portray the lives and morals of the Gilded Age. In 1921, she became the first woman to win the Pulitzer Prize in Literature, for her novel The Age of Innocence. She was inducted into the National Women's Hall of Fame in 1996. Among her other well known works are the The House of Mirth and the novella Ethan Frome.

Willa Cather American writer (1873–1947)

Willa Sibert Cather was an American writer known for her novels of life on the Great Plains, including O Pioneers!, The Song of the Lark, and My Ántonia. In 1923 she was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for One of Ours, a novel set during World War I.

<i>The Sun Also Rises</i> Novel by Ernest Hemingway

The Sun Also Rises is a 1926 novel by American writer Ernest Hemingway, his first, that portrays American and British expatriates who travel from Paris to the Festival of San Fermín in Pamplona to watch the running of the bulls and the bullfights. An early and enduring modernist novel, it received mixed reviews upon publication. However, Hemingway biographer Jeffrey Meyers writes that it is now "recognized as Hemingway's greatest work", and Hemingway scholar Linda Wagner-Martin calls it his most important novel. The novel was published in the United States in October 1926 by Scribner's. A year later, Jonathan Cape published the novel in London under the title Fiesta. It remains in print.

<i>The Age of Innocence</i>

The Age of Innocence is a 1920 novel by American author Edith Wharton. It was her twelfth novel, and was initially serialized in 1920 in four parts, in the magazine Pictorial Review. Later that year, it was released as a book by D. Appleton & Company. It won the 1921 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, making Wharton the first woman to win the prize. Though the committee had initially agreed to give the award to Sinclair Lewis for Main Street, the judges, in rejecting his book on political grounds, "established Wharton as the American 'First Lady of Letters'". The story is set in the 1870s, in upper-class, "Gilded-Age" New York City. Wharton wrote the book in her 50s, after she had established herself as a strong author, with publishers clamoring for her work.

<i>The House of Mirth</i> 1905 novel by Edith Wharton

The House of Mirth is a 1905 novel by American author Edith Wharton. It tells the story of Lily Bart, a well-born but impoverished woman belonging to New York City's high society around the end of the 19th century. Wharton creates a portrait of a stunning beauty who, though raised and educated to marry well both socially and economically, is reaching her 29th year, an age when her youthful blush is drawing to a close and her marital prospects are becoming ever more limited. The House of Mirth traces Lily's slow two-year social descent from privilege to a tragically lonely existence on the margins of society. In the words of one scholar, Wharton uses Lily as an attack on "an irresponsible, grasping and morally corrupt upper class."

<i>The Buccaneers</i> 1938 novel by Edith Wharton

The Buccaneers is the last novel written by Edith Wharton. The novel is set in the 1870s, around the time Edith Wharton was a young girl. It was unfinished at the time of her death in 1937, and published in that form in 1938. Wharton's manuscript ends with Lizzy inviting Nan to a house party to which Guy Thwarte has also been invited. The book was published in 1938 by Penguin Books in New York. After some time, Marion Mainwaring finished the novel following Wharton's detailed outline of the novel in 1993.

Percy Lubbock, CBE was an English man of letters, known as an essayist, critic and biographer. His controversial book The Craft of Fiction was influential in the 1920s and after.

<i>Twilight</i> (Meyer novel) First novel in the Twilight Saga by Stephenie Meyer

Twilight is a 2005 young adult vampire-romance novel by author Stephenie Meyer. It is the first book in the Twilight series, and introduces seventeen-year-old Isabella "Bella" Swan, who moves from Phoenix, Arizona to Forks, Washington. She is endangered after falling in love with Edward Cullen, a 103-year-old vampire frozen in his 17-year-old body. Additional novels in the series are New Moon, Eclipse, and Breaking Dawn.

Pauline Garon Canadian actress

Marie Pauline Garon was a Canadian American silent film, feature film, and stage actress.

Summer is a novel by Edith Wharton, which was published in 1917 by Charles Scribner's Sons. While most novels by Edith Wharton dealt with New York's upper-class society, this is one of two novels by Wharton that were set in New England. Its themes include social class, the role of women in society, destructive relationships, sexual awakening and the desire of its protagonist, named Charity Royall. The novel was rather controversial for its time and is one of the less famous among her novels because of its subject matter.

<i>The Custom of the Country</i>

The Custom of the Country is a 1913 tragicomedy of manners novel by American Edith Wharton. It tells the story of Undine Spragg, a Midwestern girl who attempts to ascend in New York City society.

Katherine Corri Harris American socialite, golfer and actress

Katherine Corri Harris was an American actress and socialite. She appeared in several stage plays and three silent films, and was the first wife of actor John Barrymore.

Henry Symes Lehr

Henry Symes "Harry" Lehr was an American socialite during the Gilded Age who was dubbed "America's Court Jester".

<i>The Reef</i> (novel)

The Reef is a 1912 novel by American writer Edith Wharton. It was published by D. Appleton & Company. It concerns a romance between a widow and her former lover. The novel takes place in Paris and rural France, but primarily features American characters. While writing the novel, Edith Wharton visited England, Sicily, and Germany, among other locations. In a letter to Bernard Berenson in November 1912, Wharton expressed regret regarding her novel, calling it a “poor miserable lifeless lump”. She wrote, “Anyhow, remember it’s not me, though I thought it was when I was writing it—& that next time I’m going to do something worthwhile!!”

<i>One Day</i> (novel)

One Day is a novel by David Nicholls, published in 2009. Each chapter covers the lives of two protagonists on 15 July, St Swithin's Day, for 20 years. The novel attracted generally positive reviews and was named 2010 Galaxy Book of the Year. Nicholls adapted his book into a screenplay; the feature film, also titled One Day, was released in August 2011.

<i>The House of Mirth</i> (1918 film) 1918 film by Albert Capellani

The House of Mirth is a 1918 American silent melodrama film directed by French film director Albert Capellani, starring Katherine Harris Barrymore as Lily Bart. It is a cinema adaptation of Edith Wharton's 1905 novel The House of Mirth and the first-ever cinema adaptation of any of her work. Metro Pictures put many efforts into the film in order to turn the original novel into an "All-star cast" film to earn popularity, as Metro Pictures itself announced that the film was "one of the most important productions" during 1918, and that the film contained "the strongest and the most distinguished cast ever selected for the screen". Initially, Emmy Wehlen starred in the role of Lily Bart in the film. Later, she was replaced by Katherine Harris Barrymore. The film contributed to the huge success of Metro Pictures that year. It is not known whether the film currently survives.

Julia Grinnell Storrow Cruger was an American novelist. Because many of her books examined the American social world, she was known as the Edith Wharton of her day.

The Age of Innocence is a 1924 American silent film directed by Wesley Ruggles. It is the first film adaptation of Edith Wharton’s 1920 novel The Age of Innocence. It was produced and distributed by Warner Brothers.

References

  1. 1 2 Lichtenstein, Diane (2013). "Domestic Novels of the 1920s: Regulation and Efficiency in The Home-Maker, Twilight Sleep, and Too Much Efficiency". American Studies. 52 (2): 65–88, 189. doi:10.1353/ams.2013.0048. S2CID   144202763 via ProQuest.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Haytock, Jennifer (2002). "Marriage and modernism in Edith Wharton's Twilight Sleep". Legacy: A Journal of American Women Writers. 19 via Gale General OneFile.
  3. 1 2 3 Wharton, Edith. “Twilight Sleep.” Pictorial Review, vol. 28, Feb. 1927, pp. 8-11.
  4. Wharton, Edith. “Twilight Sleep.” Pictorial Review, vol. 28, Mar. 1927, pp. 19–21, 96-110.
  5. Wharton, Edith. “Twilight Sleep.” Pictorial Review, vol. 28, Apr. 1927, pp. 14–15, 85-102.
  6. Wharton, Edith. “Twilight Sleep.” Pictorial Review, vol. 28, May 1927, pp. 24-25, 91-104, 120-128.
  7. "Edith Wharton". The Mount | Edith Wharton's Home. Retrieved 2020-12-06.
  8. Miller, Cheryl (2007). "The Painless Peace of Twilight Sleep". The New Atlantis. The Center for the Study of Technology and Society.
  9. 1 2 3 Griffith, Jean (2006). ""Lita is--jazz": the Harlem renaissance, cabaret culture, and racial amalgamation in Edith Wharton's Twilight Sleep". Studies in the Novel. 38 via Gale General OneFile.
  10. HAIKEN, BETH (1994). "Plastic Surgery and American Beauty at 1921". Bulletin of the History of Medicine. 68 (3): 429–453. ISSN   0007-5140. JSTOR   44444408. PMID   7950286.
  11. Beer, Janet; Horner, Avril (2007). "Wharton the 'Renovator': 'Twilight Sleep' as Gothic Satire". The Yearbook of English Studies. 37 (1): 177–192. doi:10.2307/20479285. ISSN   0306-2473. JSTOR   20479285.
  12. Melanie Dawson (2008). "Memorial Boxes and Guarded Interiors: Edith Wharton and Material Culture (review)". Legacy. 25 (2): 341–343. doi:10.1353/leg.0.0037. ISSN   1534-0643. S2CID   162220624.
  13. 1 2 Hutchison, Percy A. (22 May 1927). "MRS. WHARTON TILTS AT 'SOCIETY'; Her New Novel Satirizes New York's Fashionable World TWILIGHT SLEEP. By Edith Wharton. 372 pp. New York: D. Appleton & Co. $2.56. Mrs. Wharton's New Novel". The New York Times. Retrieved 6 Dec 2020.
  14. 1 2 Wilson, Edmund. “Twilight Sleep.” Review of Twilight Sleep. The New Republic, 8 June 1927, p. 78.
  15. 1 2 “Twilight Sleep. Islanders. Moonraker. Midsummer Music. The Amazing Chance. Bold Bendigo.” Review of Twilight Sleep. America, 2 July 1927, p. 287.
  16. 1 2 Chase, Mary Ellen. “Twilight Sleep, by Edith Wharton.” Review of Twilight Sleep. The Atlantic, 1927.