Thein Naing | |
---|---|
Born | Thein Naing 1964 |
Died | 24 December 2005 (aged 41) |
Cause of death | Murdered |
Nationality | Burmese |
Occupation | Air conditioner repairman (former) |
Known for | Murder victim |
Children | 2+ |
On the Christmas Eve night of 24 December 2005, 41-year-old Myanmar national Thein Naing was brutally assaulted and murdered by a group of three Malaysians, who robbed him of S$40, on a footpath along Upper Boon Keng Road. The three killers, together with a fourth man who acted as a lookout, were all arrested and charged with murder. Although one of the robbers, Benedict Inyang Anak Igal, was sentenced to five years' jail and 12 strokes of the cane for robbery with hurt, the remaining three robbers - Hamir bin Hasim, Kamal bin Kupli and Abdul Malik bin Usman - who were identified as the ones responsible for fatally assaulting the victim, were all found guilty of murdering Thein and sentenced to death on 1 March 2007. The trio later lost their appeals in February 2008, and they were since hanged for the murder.
At about 1 am on the Christmas Day of 2005 (25 December 2005), a passer-by named Mohamed Sirat bin Mohamed Mokri discovered the body of a man lying on a concrete footpath between a HDB block of flats and the defunct campus of Boon Keng Primary School along Upper Boon Keng Road. [1] [2] Shocked by the gruesome discovery, [3] Mohamed Sirat reported the discovery to the police and the man was later confirmed to be dead. [4] [5] [6] There were also head injuries found on the man's head. [7]
The victim was identified as 41-year-old Thein Naing, a Myanmar national of Chinese ethnicity who worked as an air conditioner repairman in Singapore. [8] At the time of his death, Thein left behind a wife and at least two children; his eldest son was a university student and his youngest daughter was only one year old. [9] According to Dr Teo Eng Swee, the forensic pathologist who examined Thein's body, he found that there were six stab wounds on Thein's body and several facial and skull fractures on his head. Dr Teo determined that the severe head injuries were the cause of his death. [1]
The police classified the case as murder, and promtly conducted their investigations. Eu Ah Bar, the night watchman of Boon Keng Primary School, later told police that on the previous night of Christmas Eve, hours before the discovery of Thein's corpse, he saw a group of three men, who all appeared to be pushing and kicking something on the footpath along the fence of the school, after he was alerted by the barking sounds of his dog and therefore witnessed the sighting, which he presumed as an issue of older boys playing with each other. [10] [11] A trail of bloodstains measured about 300m long was discovered by the police, ending at the junction of Geylang Lorong 3 and Sims Avenue. [12] [13] Residents living nearby the murder scene were shocked to hear about the crime and some were awakened from their sleep when they heard possible screams from the victim, [14] and there were speculations on whether the blood from the bloody trail belonged to the victim or his killer(s); [15] residents also revealed that there were often instances of people fighting at the void decks. [16] The nearby residential areas along Upper Boon Keng Road were also cordoned by police while they were conducting investigations on the case. [17]
It was also theorized that Thein was probably attacked and assaulted to death outside the former school campus, and the police did not find any possible murder weapons nearby the crime scene. [18] [19] The area itself was also remote and near to a construction site, so there were no other witnesses to the crime. No one else also heard any sounds calling for help. [20] [21]
On 1 January 2006, a week after the murder of Thein Naing, it was reported that the police managed to arrest four Malaysians who were allegedly responsible for the killing. [22] [23] The four Malaysians - 25-year-old Abdul Malik bin Usman, 21-year-old Kamal bin Kupli, 20-year-old Hamir bin Hasim and 17-year-old Benedict Inyang Anak Igal (also spelt Benedict Inyang Anak Igai) - were charged with murder on 2 January 2006. Our of the four men, Hamir came from Johor and he worked as a gardener in Singapore, while both Abdul Malik and Kamal came from Sabah and they were both employed as cleaners in Singapore. [1] [24] A penknife and some clothes stained with blood were also recovered from the police during the four men's arrests. [25]
On 10 January 2006, days after the four suspects were charged with his murder, Thein Naing's body was cremated after a funeral, and his ashes and belongings were returned to his family in Myanmar. [26]
In February 2007, three of the four suspects - Abdul Malik bin Usman, Kamal bin Kupli and Hamir Hasim - claimed trial at the High Court for the murder of Thein Naing back on the Christmas Eve night of 2005. [1] As for Benedict Inyang Anak Igal, the fourth perpetrator of the crime, he was found guilty of a reduced charge of robbery with hurt and sentenced to five years in prison and 12 strokes of the cane before the trio went on trial for Thein Naing's murder. [27]
The court was told of the forensic evidence that helped reveal the cause of death. Aside from the autopsy report, a forensic scientist Dr Lim Chin Chin also presented her laboratory reports that there were shoe imprints on the forehead of Thein, and these imprints matched to those of the shoe patterns on Kamal's shoe. DNA tests were also conducted, and traces of the victim's DNA were discovered on the penknife belonging to Hamir, and the bloodstains on the shoes belonging to Abdul Malik were also found to have matched Thein's DNA. [1]
In their defence, the men denied that they had the intention to cause Thein Naing's death, and according to them, the trio and the fourth man Benedict were having drinks at Geylang on the night of the murder, and as they were short of money, they decided to go and commit robbery. They spotted Thein walking alone on the footpath at Upper Boon Keng Road, and with Benedict acting as a lookout, the three accused sprung their attack on Thein, stabbing him and assaulting him as he tried to resist the trio's blows. But eventually, Thein was overpowered and he was grievously assaulted and died from the head injuries he sustained; the six knife wounds sustained by Thein, which were caused by Hamir during the assault, were also fatal in nature, but the head injuries were more severe and were the immediate cause of Thein's death. After they assaulted Thein until he could no longer get up, the trio therefore stole his wallet and got S$40 in cash, and the trio, together with Benedict, divided the money equally among themselves. [28] [1]
On 28 February 2007, the trial judge, Justice Kan Ting Chiu, delivered his judgement. He rejected the trio's respective defences that they only intend to rob but not to kill. Justice Kan found that there was no doubt that the trio shared a common intention to rob Thein, and assaulted him in furtherance of the same common intention. Although he accepted that the knife wounds were not fatal, Justice Kan nonetheless made a finding that the trio had intentionally inflicted the serious head injuries on Thein when they kicked him repeatedly, such that the head injuries caused were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, and these were inflicted while in furtherance of their common intention, there were sufficient grounds to return with a verdict of murder in the trio's case. [29]
As a result, the three men - Hamir bin Hasim, Kamal bin Kupli and Abdul Malik bin Usman - were found guilty of murder and sentenced to death. For all four degrees of murder offences under Singaporean law, the death penalty was prescribed as the mandatory punishment upon an offender's conviction. [30]
On 19 February 2008, the three condemned - Abdul Malik bin Usman, Kamal bin Kupli and Hamir Hasim - lost their appeals against their convictions and sentences. [31] [32] The Court of Appeal, having heard their cases, found that there was no doubt that the trio had intentionally inflicted the fatal head injuries on Thein Naing for the purpose of committing robbery. [33] [34]
One of the appellate judges, Justice V K Rajah, commented in his own words while dismissing the appeals, "It doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that stomping on a person's head could be fatal". [35] Reportedly, Hamir's father and one of his brothers were present to hear the appeal verdict. [36]
After receiving news that the appeals of the trio were dismissed, international human rights group Amnesty International filed a public plea to the Singapore government for clemency, asking that the death sentences of the trio should be commuted to life imprisonment, [37] and similarly, both the Malaysian Bar and Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) also sought to appeal for mercy on the lives of the trio and urged Singapore to not carry out their executions. [38] [39] Human rights lawyer M Ravi also posted that the death penalty for the trio should be commuted and claimed that there was no fair trial for the three Malaysians and a fourth convicted killer Tan Chor Jin, who was sentenced to hang for fatally shooting a nightclub owner after he claimed trial while unrepresented by counsel; [40] Tan was put to death on 9 January 2009 after his petition for clemency was rejected. [41]
On 9 April 2008, the Singapore government responded to the United Nations Human Rights Office (OHCHR) that the death penalty was not arbitrarily or unfairly imposed in the cases of Tan and the three Thein Naing murderers, stating that the four men had been accorded full due process and except for Tan who represented himself, the trio had been represented by legal counsel throughout and they emphasized that the international law did not prohibit the mandatory death penalty and it was only reserved for the most serious of crimes, and the use of capital punishment in Singapore was what contributes to its reputation as one of the safest countries in the world. [42]
After the Singaporean authorities refused to review or commute their death sentences, the three men - Kamal bin Kupli, Abdul Malik bin Usman and Hamir bin Hasim - were eventually hanged later that same year for murdering Thein Naing. The trio were among the four people executed in Singapore for murder during the year of 2008; [43] the fourth and final person to be put to death for murder was Mohammed Ali bin Johari, who was convicted and hanged on 19 December 2008 for the rape-murder of his stepdaughter Nonoi. [44]
In March 2012, about four years after the trio's executions, Singaporean crime show Crimewatch re-enacted the Upper Boon Keng Road murder and aired it as the first episode of the show's annual season. It was revealed through this episode that the group responsible for Thein's murder were previously involved in at least two other robberies during that same year before killing Thein, and the victims (all were male) in these cases were assaulted and knocked out after having their valuables stolen, but unlike Thein, none of the victims in these other cases died. The actors portraying the killers in this episode were also depicted to be conversing in Malay with English subtitles provided to translate their corresponding dialogues. [45]
On the evening of 12 December 1993, Lee Kok Cheong was at his home in Greenleaf Place along Holland Road, when three youths entered his house to commit robbery. Two of the attackers stabbed Lee, then strangled him, which caused his death. Lee, an associate professor at the National University of Singapore, was 54 years old at the time of his death.
On 28 January 1989, 26-year-old Lim Lee Tin, a Chinese Singaporean woman who was often dressed like a male, was found murdered at a Chinese cemetery in Choa Chu Kang, Singapore. She was initially mistaken as a man before the autopsy revealed her true gender. The perpetrators of her murder were Lim's gambling partner and married housewife Chin Seow Noi, Chin's brother Chin Yaw Kim and the siblings' friend Ng Kim Heng. The three suspects, who were all Malaysians, were said to have plotted the murder in order to get rid of Lim, who often harassed Chin Seow Noi for money.
On 26 August 1998, 50-year-old Tan Eng Yan, a fruit stall assistant working at a market in Tampines, was found brutally murdered at the toilet of her Tampines flat. Tan, also known as Lily or Tan Ah Leng, was stabbed and slashed 58 times and four of the knife wounds were fatal. Her money, amounting to over S$2,200 in cash and S$6,000 in coins, were also being stolen from her flat. It took five days before the police arrested a fishmonger named Lau Lee Peng, who was a close friend of Tan, after he confessed during witness questioning that he killed Tan and led the police to where he hid the money.
On 11 April 1989, 56-year-old goldsmith Phang Tee Wah was kidnapped by two men before he was murdered. Despite his death, the kidnappers demanded ransom from Phang's family, who were kept in the dark about Phang's death as they contacted the police about their predicament and the crime. Subsequently, four days after Phang was killed, his corpse was discovered and the police were able to nab the two kidnappers - Phang's former employee Liow Han Heng and security guard Ibrahim bin Masod, who was Liow's friend and driver.
Between April 1992 and December 1992, there were two cases of taxi drivers being killed in Singapore, specifically in secluded areas of Yishun. The first was Seing Koo Wan, a 58-year-old taxi driver who was found with several stab wounds on his body. Despite a police appeal, Seing's killer(s) was never found and the case remained unsolved for eight months before another taxi driver, Teo Kim Hock, was allegedly kidnapped by two men who demanded a ransom from his family. However, in truth, 59-year-old Teo was killed before the calls for ransom arrived.
On 2 November 1980, two people – 31-year-old fish dealer Lee Cheng Tiong and 16-year-old Teo Keng Siang – were brutally murdered by one or more unknown assailants. The murders remained unsolved for two years before a suspect was finally nabbed in connection to the killings.
On 31 October 1983, a 66-year-old woman named Chong Kin Meng was found murdered inside her Clementi flat by her foster son's wife. The police investigated and they managed to arrest a suspect for her murder a month later. The 23-year-old suspect, Teo Boon Ann, was found to have entered the flat under the pretense of providing Chong's foster son a wedding invitation card and a gift in his father's name, before he proceeded to kill her during a robbery attempt.
On 14 July 1993, 50-year-old sub-contractor Sim Ah Lek, who was also a moneylender, was killed by 37-year-old Phua Soy Boon, who was his creditor, after he refused Sim's request to lend him S$10,000. After killing Sim, Phua stole Sim's Rolex watch, diamond ring and S$9,000 in cash, and even stuffed the dead body inside a gunny sack before disposing of it at Jurong Swimming Complex, where it was found the next morning.
On 22 November 1990, 20-year-old National Serviceman Lee Teck Sang, who deserted from his army and hid himself at the campus of Singapore Polytechnic for 17 days, used a knife to murder a 45-year-old lecturer during a robbery. The victim, Tan Chin Liong, died as a result of being stabbed thrice. Although Lee claimed that he only meant to rob and the stabbing was meant to incapacitate Tan, the High Court rejected Lee's defence and found Lee guilty of murdering Tan, and sentenced him to death. Lee's appeal was dismissed and he was hanged on 29 July 1994.
On 23 May 1996, a 38-year-old Indonesian businessman named Benny Probocemdana Oen was mortally wounded by an assailant during a stabbing incident at Pacific Plaza before he died in hospital. The suspect, identified as 19-year-old Sim Eng Teck, was arrested more than a year later and charged with murder. Sim, who put up a defence of alcohol intoxication and also put forward claims that he only intend to stab the victim's arm during the knife attack, but Judicial Commissioner Amerjeet Singh found that Sim had intentionally inflicted the fatal injuries on Oen and described the killing as a "daringly cold-blooded" murder, and sentenced Sim to death in May 1998. Sim lost his appeal on 1 August 1998, and he had since been hanged.
On 1 December 1990, at Singapore's Tanjong Katong Road, a 20-year-old Malaysian woman named Wong Mee Hiong was stabbed to death inside her rented house and her body was wrapped in a blanket before being hidden in a storeroom. Wong's corpse was discovered by her fiancé and ten days after her killing, Wong's killer Yap Biew Hian, a fellow tenant of the house and also a Malaysian, was arrested for the case and charged. Yap, who admitted to killing the victim with intent to rob her, was sentenced to death three years after he murdered Wong.
On 8 August 1995, a 26-year-old prostitute named Ching Bee Ing was stabbed seven times by her 35-year-old co-worker Teo Kim Hong at a brothel along Teck Lim Road. Ching, a Malaysian, died as a result of four fatal knife wounds to her liver and heart. Teo, a Singaporean, was charged with murder after she was arrested for the brutal stabbing. Teo was found guilty and sentenced to death in January 1996, and after the loss of her appeal, Teo was hanged on 30 August 1996.
On 2 April 2004, a 56-year-old Singaporean and scrap car dealer named Bock Tuan Thong was found dead inside the boot of his brother's car at a multi-storey carpark in Boon Keng, Singapore. According to witnesses, Bock was last seen with two to three men, who were inside the car with him and assaulted him.
On 8 October 1993, at his Jalan Berseh flat, an Indian moneychanger named Shamsul Hameed was killed by his friend Jahabar Bagurudeen. Bagurudeen, a businessman, was said to have killed Shamsul due to them having argued earlier about sharing a prostitute. Bagurudeen was sentenced to death after the trial court accepted the same prostitute's testimony that she saw Bagurudeen killing the victim, and rejected Bagurudeen's argument that he killed Shamsul out of anger for the victim's alleged mistreatment of Bagurudeen before the murder. After losing his appeal and clemency plea, Bagurudeen was hanged on 2 June 1995.
On 28 June 2003, 68-year-old Chi Tue Tiong, a caretaker of one of the rental apartments in Geylang, was murdered by a couple who rented one of the rooms of the apartment. Chi, who had been bludgeoned on the head at least nine times, died as a result of brain injuries and extensive skull fractures. The police managed to trace the two suspects, but only the male assailant, 35-year-old Zailani bin Ahmad, was arrested and charged with murder, because the second suspect, who was Zailani's Indonesian girlfriend, had fled from Singapore to Batam and was not extradited to stand trial. Zailani, who argued that he suffered diminished responsibility and had killed Chi under the influence of sleeping pills, was found guilty of murder and sentenced to death in March 2004.
On 15 June 2000, 65-year-old part-time taxi driver Ong Huay Dee was brutally murdered by a passenger while he was driving along Pasir Ris. Ong's passenger and killer, 25-year-old Thai national Khwan-On Natthaphon, was arrested and charged for the murder. Even though Khwan-On raised a defence of diminished responsibility and also stated he never intended to kill Ong, the trial court nonetheless rejected his defences and regarded him as a "cold-blooded murderer" for having intentionally caused the fatal head injuries on Ong. Hence, Khwan-On was found guilty of murdering Ong and sentenced to death in August 2001, and after losing his appeal, Khwan-On was hanged on 27 September 2002.
On 25 October 1993, 34-year-old airport operation assistant Thampusamy Murugian Gunasekaran was murdered by three men while he and his friend were having supper at a coffee shop at Little India's Chander Road; the friend was also attacked but survived with minor injuries. Six months later, one of the assailants was charged with murder after he gave himself up to the police. The suspect, Anbuarsu Joseph, was found guilty of murdering Thampusamy and sentenced to death in August 1994, and he was hanged on 7 July 1995. Anbuarsu's two accomplices, who were yet to be identified, remained at large as of today.
On 11 August 1998, 43-year-old Ooi Ang Yen, a divorced mother of four and a factory production worker, was stabbed to death by her ex-boyfriend at a carpark nearby her workplace in Bukit Merah, Singapore. Her 41-year-old boyfriend and married father of two, Chan Chim Yee, was arrested 12 days later and charged with murder. According to court documents and media, Ooi wanted to leave Chan in favor of another man, and therefore, Chan went to the victim's workplace and attacked her with a knife. Although Chan raised two defences of an alibi and diminished responsibility, the trial court rejected his defences and therefore, Chan was found guilty of murdering Ooi and sentenced to death. Chan's appeal was dismissed and he was hanged on 15 September 2000.
On the night of 4 October 1996, at a carpark in Singapore's Yung Kwang Road, 23-year-old Phang Ai Looi, a Malaysian, was stabbed to death by her former boyfriend, who was caught on that same night after his suicide attempt failed. The suspect, 29-year-old Kwan Cin Cheng, who was a Malaysian working in Singapore, was charged with murder. Kwan, who first knew Phang in 1988 and dated her, found out some time before the murder that Phang was two-timing on him for another man, and when Kwan met her on that night with a threat to kill himself should Phang not return to him, Phang reportedly made a cold-blooded remark that she was much happier with the other man, which deeply provoked Kwan to stabbing Phang to death.
On 2 June 2001, at a vacant area in Kian Teck Road in Singapore, 23-year-old Thai national Saenphan Thawan was attacked by a gang of six Thai workers, after he had allegedly offended one of the attackers' girlfriend, who told her boyfriend about the victim's actions. Saenphan, who was the head operator of a drug trafficking and prostitution ring at Kian Teck Road, died as a result of the brutal assault, and out of the six killers, four of them were arrested and charged with murder, while the remaining two assailants remains on the run as of today. Out of the four captured, three of them were sentenced to death for murder and a fourth was given a jail term of nine years with caning for manslaughter.