Violence against LGBTQ people in Belize

Last updated

Christian right influence is deemed a primary reason for violence against LGBTQ people in Belize Man in Jesus Costume Counter-protesting Christian Anti-gay Protest.jpg
Christian right influence is deemed a primary reason for violence against LGBTQ people in Belize

LGBTQ people in Belize are particularly vulnerable to physical and non-physical violence, both from non-state and state actors. All physical (and some non-physical) forms of such violence are criminalised, but victims face multiple barriers to redress. Some non-physical forms are rather state-sanctioned and lawful. Most violence is thought to be driven by anti-LGBTQ prejudice (homophobia, biphobia, transphobia), which in turn is thought to be mainly stoked by the Christian right, Christian fundamentalism, or toxic masculinity. Such violence is deemed significantly detrimental to the health and welfare of over 22,000 LGBTQ individuals (including families with children) in the country. [1]

Contents

History

Violence against LGBTQ people may not have been so widespread in precolonial days, as buccaneers-turned-Baymen are thought to have been relatively liberal towards same-sex intimacy (ostensibly due to the scarcity of women back then). [2] Early Maya and Creole Baymen may have been similarly tolerant (ostensibly due to possibly liberal Mesoamerican and West African customs prior to European contact). [3] The establishment of Christian parishes in 1776 (Anglican, then others), [4] replacement of Baymen's custom with British common law in 1840, [5] and passing of the Criminal Code Act 1888 would have likely quashed any such tolerance by the late 19th century by formally criminalising non-heteronormative acts and expressions. [6] This state of lawful intolerance of and violence towards LGBTQ Belizeans is thought to have remained unchallenged through the 20th and into the 21st century.

The 2000s saw the country's earliest efforts to curb anti-LGBTQ violence, beginning with the founding of UNIBAM in 2006. Notable amongst these have been the 2013 gender policy, [7] public pride celebrations since 2015, the successful UNIBAM case in 2016, [8] Belize's acceptance of most LGBTQ-related UN UPR recommendations in 2018, [9] and the 2020 Equal Opportunities Bill. [10]

Types

Overt acts of violence against LGBTQ people by private citizens have been illegal since Belize's founding (as with overtly violent acts against any person), and seem to be frowned upon across the West Indies today (2020s). Such offences are nonetheless not unheard of, with LGBTQ Belizeans being subjected to physical or sexual assaults, and even murders. [11] For instance, UNIBAM recorded "over 80 murders of LGBT persons" in 1995–2021. [12] LGBTQ Belizeans are further subject to not-so-overt acts of violence, including verbal harrassment, emotional abuse, deprivation of services (housing, schooling, employment, healthcare), and exclusion from spaces (family, social, religious, business). [13] Altogether, a 2022 ReportOUT (UK charity) poll found 88 percent of LGBTQ Belizeans had experienced some form of violence, mostly verbal abuse (30 percent), online abuse (24), threats of violence (20), and violent physical or sexual assaults (11 percent). [14] Similarly, CVC (Jamaican charity) recorded 50 physical and non-physical violent incidents against LGBTQ people in Belize in 2018–2022 (mostly gender-based violence, physical abuse, verbal abuse, emotional abuse, in descending order), most of which occurred in the community or workplace, with victims overwhelmingly opting to forego official action against perpetrators. [15] This compared to 189 such incidents recorded by CVC for 2013–2018 (mostly physical violence, verbal harrassment, in descending order). [16]

State violence against LGBTQ citizens takes both physical (police brutality) and non-physical (police harrassment; abuse of authority; deprivation of rights, liberties, services) forms. For instance, eight percent of LGBTQ Belizeans reported having experienced police brutality in a 2022 poll, while a further thirteen percent reported having been blackmailed by police, and eight percent having been harrassed or harmed by other state actors (armed forces, social services). [17] Similarly, though Section 53 of the Criminal Code Act 1981 ostensibly applied to "every person who has carnal intercourse against the order of nature", the Supreme Court found in 2016 that the Crown had used it to disproportionately target LGBTQ people. [18] As of 2024, various of the rights, liberties, and services afforded to non-LGBTQ citizens are lawfully denied to their LGBTQ peers. [19]

Causes

Prejudice against LGBTQ people is widely deemed the primary cause of violence against them. Belizean society today (2020s) still presents relatively widespread levels of prejudice towards their LGBTQ members. Since the 2000s, the country has consistently scored in the 4–5 range (representing relatively middling acceptance of LGBTQ people) in the Global Acceptance Index (a standardised aggregate of global polls on attitudes towards LGBTQ people) by the Williams Institute. [20] A 2022 ReportOUT (UK charity) poll found only 16 percent of LGBTQ Belizeans were comfortable being openly themselves amongst their religious community, compared to with healthcare staff (37 percent), employers (45), family (69), and close friends (89 percent). [14] On the upside, some surveys indicate possibly diminishing prejudice. [21] For instance, a 2023 LAPOP poll found only 53 percent of Belizeans strongly disapproved of gay marriage (down from highs of 83 and 82 percent in 2012 and 2014, respectively), while only 37 percent strongly disapproved of gay candidates for office (down from highs of 59 and 67 percent in 2012 and 2014, respectively). [22] Early 2010s polls found similarly heightened levels of anti-LGBTQ sentiment as the early LAPOP surveys. A 2013 CADRES (Barbadian company) poll found 25 and 14 percent of Belizean men and women (respectively) hated gay people (when asked whether they "accept, tolerate or hate homosexuals", these respondents selected hate), while 47 and 28 percent of them (men and women respectively) would not socialise with gay people. [23] Similarly, a 2012 CARICOM poll found 81 percent of West Indian (including Belizean) teens "indicated that homosexuality was looked upon negatively by them". [24]

Theories on what drives anti-LGBTQ prejudice in Belize vary. For West Indian (including Belizean) men, Rosina Wiltshire (of the aforementioned 2012 CARICOM poll) suggested their significantly greater (than women's) prejudice might stem from their (strongly socially-reinforced) fear of being ridiculed as sissies , and thus of being deemed not real men. [25] Authors of the 2013 CADRES study drew similar conclusions from their comparable findings. [26] A similar mechanism ( machismo ) has been suggested for Mestizo men. [27] More generally though (for Belizean men and women), some studies have suggested that the Crown (via discriminatory laws, policies, practices) and influential personalities and institutions in politics, media, and culture (via rhetoric) both sanction and foster such prejudice. [28] Further contributing factors may include HIV/AIDS stigma, classism, ignorance or misunderstanding of LGBTQ topics. [29] Nevertheless, the most often cited driver of anti-LGBTQ prejudice is religious (specifically Christian right or fundamentalist) intolerance or zealotry. [30]

Further causes of violence against LGBTQ people may include domestic or intimate partner violence. [31]

Polls

Legacy

Violence against LGBTQ people is deemed detrimental to their mental and physical health, safety of person, and financial security. [44] These negative outcomes are most acute amongst the most vulnerable classes within the LGBTQ community, like transgender people, HIV/AIDS patients, detainees. [45]

A number of measures (both official and unofficial) have been taken in an effort to curb said violence. Notable examples include the work of various LGBTQ charities (public awareness, political advocacy, support services), [46] that of several allied organisations (women's, HIV/AIDS, human rights), and even that of official bodies (several). As of 2022 though, a majority (57 percent) of LGBTQ Belizeans did not agree that there were enough support services available to them, with a further one in five reporting they had no support network (not even informal, like friends or family). [47]

In popular culture, this sort of violence first gained visibility via news coverage of the late 2010 filing of the UNIBAM case, followed by heated debate for and against LGBTQ rights in 2011. In scholarship, violence against LGBTQ Belizeans remains mostly within the purview of grey literature (like NGO reports).

Timeline

See also

References

Citations

  1. Official LGBTQ population estimates not available (Emp, p. iv). Cre estimated the 2021 "likely LGBT+" population at 5.6 percent (totalling circa 22,365 individuals; p. 65). Wat estimated the 2018 MSM men and trans women population at 5.0–5.9 and 0.4–0.5 percent, respectively (totalling circa 10,487 individuals; pp. 132–133; Cre, pp. 65–66). Cac estimated "over 100" children being raised by LGBTQ families in 2019 (pp. i, iii).
  2. Rep, p. 10.
  3. Rep, p. 11.
  4. "About the Diocese". Anglican Diocese of Belize. Archived from the original on 9 April 2014.
  5. Rep, p. 10; Burdon JA. Archives of British Honduras. Vol. 2. London: Sifton, Praed & Co. p. 411. LCCN   33013317.
  6. Rep, pp. 10, 14; Equ.
  7. Orb, pp. 5–8.
  8. Cra, pp. 75–77, 84–85; Rep, pp. 11, 18.
  9. Rep, p. 18; Emp, p. ii; Tra, p. ii.
  10. Ora, pp. 8–9; Emp, p. ii; Rep, p. 12.
  11. Rep, p. 34; Emp, p. iv.
  12. Orb, p. 11. And 17 of gay men in 1997–2012 in "UNIBAM says 17 gay men killed since 1997". 7 News. 19 June 2012.
  13. Ram, p. vi; Rep, pp. 13, 26, 28–32; Emp, pp. iv, vi–vii; Tra, pp. iii–vi.
  14. 1 2 Rep, p. 8.
  15. Ram, pp. iii, vi–viii.
  16. Ram, pp. xiv–xvi.
  17. Rep, p. 35.
  18. Cra, pp. 81–82.
  19. Rep, pp. 11–13; Equ; Emp, pp. ii, iv–viii; Tra, pp. iii–iv, vi–vii; Orb, pp. 8–10, 13–14, 17–18; Cac, pp. i–ii, iv.
  20. "Global Acceptance Index". Williams Inst.; Flores AR (2021). Social acceptance of LGBTI people in 175 countries and locations (Report). Williams Inst. pp. 2, 11, 16, 36.
  21. Rep, pp. 13, 38; Lib, p. 1; Lia, p. i.
  22. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Laa.
  23. Bec, pp. 1558–1559, 1561, 1563.
  24. Wil, pp. 15–16, 21–22, 61.
  25. Wil, pp. 4, 21–22, 29, 49–50, 60–63.
  26. Bec, pp. 1557, 1560, 1562, 1564.
  27. Rep, p. 15.
  28. Cra, pp. 33–34; Rep, p. 14.
  29. Rep, pp. 15, 18.
  30. Wil, p. 13; Bec, p. 1564; Cra, pp. 78, 82–83; Rep, pp. 15–16, 32; Cre, p. 55; Laz, pp. 569–370, 377–381.
  31. Caa, pp. 14–15.
  32. This column lists the percentage of reponses indicating prejudiced or negative attitudes towards LGBTQ people. Rounded to nearest integer.
  33. This column lists the percentage of reponses indicating non-prejudiced or positive attitudes towards LGBTQ people. Rounded to nearest integer.
  34. Rep, pp. 4, 8, 20–23.
  35. 1 2 3 Rep, pp. 20–23, 32.
  36. Lib, pp. 4, 6.
  37. Lib, pp. 5–6.
  38. Lib, p. 4; Lia, pp. v–vi.
  39. Lib, p. 6; Lia, pp. v–vi.
  40. 1 2 Lia, pp. ii, vi.
  41. 1 2 Bec, pp. 1558–1559, 1563.
  42. 1 2 Bec, pp. 1558–1559, 1561.
  43. Wil, pp. 15–16, 21, 61.
  44. Rep, pp. 13, 25–26, 28, 32, 34; Tra, p. ii; Orb, pp. 11–13, 25; Cre, p. 19.
  45. Rep, p. 19.
  46. Rep, pp. 17, 36.
  47. Rep, p. 36.
  48. This column flags whether an entry is an act of physical harm or violence to a person.
  49. "PCC submits 129 paged recommendation report, Unibam calls it 'shameful'". 7 News. 26 March 2025.; "PCC rep. says, 'Draft report is a contradiction unto itself'". News 5. 27 March 2025.
  50. "Budna says homophobic security guard assaulted him". 7 News. 11 July 2024.; "Security guard arraigned for common assault days after theft charge". News 5. 11 July 2024.
  51. "Police under fire: Controversial video emerges of officers ridiculing mentally ill man". Love News. 22 January 2024.; "Disabilities advocates call for ComPol to fire abusive officers". 7 News. 23 January 2024.; "BAPDA calls for termination of cops who mocked mentally ill man". Amandala. 28 January 2024.
  52. "Tanya Lopez's future is looking bright after PETAL's intervention". Love News. 24 January 2023.; "Minister Balderamos-Garcia speaks on hate crime legislation". Love News. 25 January 2023.
  53. "Hate crime in San Pedro?". 7 News. 20 December 2022.; "San Pedro resident is victim of alleged hate crime". News 5. 20 December 2022.; "Three men charged in connection with San Pedro beat down". News 5. 20 December 2022.
  54. "Human rights defenders concerned about Religious Affairs Minister's statement". News 5. 12 January 2022.; "Minister Usher clarifies statement on 'Christian principle;' emphasizes inclusion". News 5. 13 January 2022.
  55. "'Our Circle' responds to San Pedro stabbing". News 5. 18 August 2021.; "Former BDF captain stabs woman at LGBT event". Amandala. 21 August 2021.
  56. Emp, p. vii; "Pickstock Street residents attack police officer during arrest, two injured as rubber bullets ricochet". BBN. 1 March 2021. An 11 year old girl also injured, likewise not rushed to hospital (BBN).
  57. "NEAB slams appointment of pro-LGBT judges". 7 News. 15 July 2020.; "Those two judges are troo-troo advocates". Amandala. 5 August 2020.
  58. Rep, p. 13; "Gay man dies, family says police abuse played a role". 7 News. 20 April 2020.; "An investigation is launched into the death of fashion designer Ulysease Roca". News 5. 20 April 2020.; "Unibam on Ulysease". 7 News. 21 April 2020.; "PM's wife & NAC demand rights for Roca". 7 News. 21 April 2020.; "Was a post-mortem done to determine cause of death of Ulysease Roca?". News 5. 21 April 2020.; "Ulysses Terry found dead in Willows Bank". Amandala. 22 April 2020.; "COMPOL says cop charged for shooting mocking video of Roca". 7 News. 22 April 2020.; Alza C, Saadi F (13 October 2021). Institutional violence against LGBT+ activists and organisations during Covid (Report). Kaleidoscope Intl. p. 9.
  59. Ora, pp. 8–9; Emp, p. ii; Rep, p. 12; "Evangelicals fear hate speech". 7 News. 7 January 2020.; "Equal opportunities for 19 different forms of discrimination". 7 News. 9 January 2020.; "Will gays get special treatment under Equal Opportunities Bill?". 7 News. 9 January 2020.; "The AG and Equal Opportunity". 7 News. 10 January 2020.; "Equal Opps Bill, the other side of the argument". 7 News. 15 January 2020.; "Candid comments from non-supporters of the Bill". News 5. 17 January 2020.; "The road to equal opportunity". Amandala. 18 January 2020.; "We want a referendum on the anti-freedom 'Equal Opportunities Bill'". Amandala. 22 January 2020.; "Over 5,000 signatures in objection to Equal Opportunities Bill". News 5. 5 February 2020.; "More flack for the Equal Opportunities Bill". Amandala. 8 February 2020.; "EOB: Tyranny or freedom". Amandala. 15 February 2020.; "The hardline against Equal Opportunity Bill". 7 News. 14 September 2020.; "NEAB supports equal opportunities for all, but has issue with LGBT". News 5. 15 September 2020.; "UNIBAM Executive Director reacts to Cabinet decision". News 5. 15 September 2020.; "House to introduce controversial Equal Opportunities Bill 2020 on Wednesday". Amandala. 16 September 2020.; "Catholic Church rejects Equal Opportunities Bill". News 5. 16 September 2020.; "The bill was killed!". 7 News. 16 September 2020.; "Chair of the NAC reacts to withdrawal of Equal Opportunities Bill". News 5. 17 September 2020.; "GOB pulls the Equal Opportunities Bill (EOB)". Amandala. 19 September 2020.; "The Equal Opportunities Bill should never have even seen the inside of the Cabinet room". Amandala. 19 September 2020.; "NEAB says no to EOB". 7 News. 24 September 2020.; "UNIBAM scolds NEAB". 7 News. 28 September 2020.; "CEO laments the non-passage of Equal Opps Bill". 7 News. 2 October 2020.
  60. Ora, pp. 15–16; "The tomb of an Orange Walk resident is vandalized and his body exhumed". News 5. 13 January 2020.; "Family's grieving disrupted by broken grave". 7 News. 13 January 2020.; "Emil Escalante's tomb vandalized in Orange Walk Cemetery, and open coffin left on the ground". Amandala. 15 January 2020.
  61. "Belize Court of Appeal affirms LGBT freedom of expression". Amandala. 1 January 2020.; "Evangelicals criticize courts". 7 News. 7 January 2020.; "Section 53 ruling will lead to higher number of HIV cases says NEAB". News 5. 7 January 2020.
  62. "The tomb of an Orange Walk resident is vandalized and his body exhumed". News 5. 13 January 2020.; "Emil Escalante's tomb vandalized in Orange Walk Cemetery, and open coffin left on the ground". Amandala. 15 January 2020.
  63. "Video of beatdown of LGBT man being circulated". 7 News. 1 November 2019.
  64. "Young man in video identified as police officer". BBN. 1 July 2019.; "Cops investigating PC Gillett incident". 7 News. 1 July 2019.; "Hate crime or just halari business on the high seas?". 7 News. 1 July 2019.; "UNIBAM Exec. Dir. says PC Gillett's rights were infringed". News 5. 1 July 2019.; "UNIBAM: No room for homophobia in Belize Police Department". News 5. 1 July 2019.; "Police officer used unsanctioned chokehold to subdue PC Gillett". News 5. 2 July 2019.; "Cop gets 'woman fum-fum' aboard water taxi". Amandala. 3 July 2019.
  65. Orb, p. 10; Ora, p. 28; "Pair of severed legs discovered in Ontario; is it that of missing teen?". News 5. 1 October 2018.; "Searching for clues to missing Gerardo". 7 News. 25 October 2018.; "Severed legs confirmed to be that of Gerardo Vasquez". News 5. 9 June 2020.; "After 2 years, DNA results say dismembered legs in river belonged to boy, 17". Amandala. 13 June 2020.
  66. "President Mose sticking with stevedores". 7 News. 9 April 2018.
  67. "Haitian LGBT denied visas; Foreign Affairs intervenes". News 5. 3 November 2017.; "Immigration Department resolving LGBT controversy". News 5. 7 November 2017.
  68. "US hoists rainbow flag". 7 News. 21 June 2017.; "NEAB says gay flag at Embassy is a case of Obama leftovers". 7 News. 23 June 2017.
  69. "Two detained for questioning in the murder of San Pedro resident Felix Ayuso". San Pedro Sun. 3 February 2017.; "Beloved resident savagely stabbed to death on San Pedro". 7 News. 3 February 2017.; "Man found guilty of San Pedro murder". 7 News. 5 August 2020.; "Vildo Westby found guilty of murder for the death of Jose Ayuso of San Pedro". Amandala. 12 August 2020.
  70. "Evangelical Association petitions President Trump for ambassador with 'Biblical values'". News 5. 20 January 2017.
  71. "Belize Action frowns on UN turnaround over LGBT expert". News 5. 22 December 2016.
  72. "Faber says no to LGBT spin on Minister's award". 7 News. 8 November 2016.
  73. "Speaker Peyrefitte apologizes to UNIBAM's Orozco". Amandala. 26 October 2016.
  74. "Man-man business in court". 7 News. 19 August 2016.; "Homosexual lover charged with assaulting his partner". Amandala. 24 August 2016.
  75. "More Church disquiet about Supreme Court judgment". 7 News. 11 August 2016.; "Streets not happy with Supreme Court". 7 News. 11 August 2016.; "Thoughts on the UNIBAM decision". Amandala. 13 August 2016.; "UNIBAM grand slam: Gay sex law struck out". 7 News. 16 August 2016.; "B.P.P leader says homosexuality is a life choice, not a human rights issue". News 5. 18 August 2016.; "B.P.P. says 'Take it to the people!'". News 5. 18 August 2016.; "BPP wants omnibus referendum". 7 News. 18 August 2016.; "V.I.P. maintains support for Section 53 despite court decision". News 5. 19 August 2016.; "Carnival, cable television, and the churches". Amandala. 20 August 2016.; "Stirm: Church leading, not misleading". 7 News. 23 August 2016.; "Christians march against Section 53 judgment, GOB non-appeal". 7 News. 23 August 2016.; "Powerful teachers' union urges GOB to appeal". 7 News. 24 August 2016.; "COLA, Evangelicals back to Belmopan on Friday". News 5. 24 August 2016.; "Anti-Christs". Amandala. 24 August 2016.; "The sound and the fury: Belizeans rally against LGBT and corruption". News 5. 26 August 2016.; "PM says he has some flexibility on Section 53 appeal". 7 News. 26 August 2016.; "P.U.P. does about turn on Section 53; it now wants appeal". News 5. 29 August 2016.; "Christians protest in 'Pan, to no great effect". 7 News. 30 August 2016.; "'I want my country back!!'". Amandala. 31 August 2016.; "Agitation and hysteria". Amandala. 31 August 2016.; "Utility unions commend PM". 7 News. 8 September 2016.; "Will UNIBAM have a place on Morality Commission?". News 5. 14 September 2016.; "Evangelical Churches appeal Section 53 judgment". 7 News. 16 September 2016.; "Withdrawal from church-state commission is not sabotage, says Rev. Papouloute". Amandala. 14 June 2017.; "Caleb Orozco upbraids 'Morality Commission'". News 5. 21 June 2017.
  76. "Gender politics invades Youth Advocacy Movement". 7 News. 23 June 2016.; "Ugly meme sparks outrage against youth leader". 7 News. 23 June 2016.
  77. "US Embassy hoists gay flag over Belize". 7 News. 23 June 2016.; "Evangelical Church reacts to observation of Gay Pride Month". News 5. 23 June 2016.
  78. "Did Bze pharmacist lose his job for homophobe post on Facebook?". 7 News. 13 June 2016.; "Pharmacist axed for supporting deadly LGBT attack in Florida". Amandala. 14 June 2016.
  79. "Vanessa Champagne Paris dead at twenty-one". News 5. 6 June 2016.; "Champagne Paris passes, suicide suspected". 7 News. 6 June 2016.; "Was it food poisoning or suicide?". News 5. 6 June 2016.; "LGBT activist remembers Champagne Paris". News 5. 6 June 2016.; "Did famous drag queen die of poisoning?". Amandala. 7 June 2016.; "Police: Paris Champagne didn't die from poison". 7 News. 7 June 2016.; "So what really killed Champagne Paris?". News 5. 7 June 2016.
  80. "San Pedro to host LGBT pride week". News 5. 18 June 2015.; "San Pedro resort owner courts gay tourists". 7 News. 19 June 2015.; "Gay-day in September". 7 News. 22 June 2015.; "San Pedro hotelier courting controversy with gay guests". 7 News. 23 June 2015.; "The Church and the gay bash on San Pedro". 7 News. 7 July 2015.
  81. "Government and gays". Amandala. 19 August 2014.
  82. "Loathe thy neighbour?". 7 News. 9 July 2015.; "Caleb Orozco's neighbour found guilty of gay bashing and throwing missiles". News 5. 9 July 2015.
  83. "U.S. Ambassador is greeted with a protest". News 5. 24 June 2014.; "Small protest by anti-LGBT crowd as new US Ambassador is sworn in". 7 News. 24 June 2014.
  84. "'Occupy Belmopan' draws 40 on first day". 7 News. 17 June 2014.
  85. "Cross-dresser robbed in Belmopan; robber shot by police". Amandala. 13 June 2014.; "Transgender woman, Vanessa Champagne Paris, is robbed". News 5. 24 June 2014.; "Vanessa Champagne was robbed; robber shot by police". 7 News. 24 June 2014.
  86. "The fuss over Prof Bain". 7 News. 22 May 2014.; "A protest for Professor Bain". 7 News. 23 May 2014.; "Spineless UWI!". Amandala. 23 May 2014.; "Belize Council of Churches stands up for Professor Bain". 7 News. 27 May 2014. Plus a further protest on 31 May per "Another protest for Prof Bain". 7 News. 2 June 2014.
  87. Tra, p. vi; Rep, p. 34; "Street mob attacks transgender Vanessa Paris". 7 News. 9 April 2014.; "Transgender woman is stoned and beaten by an angry mob". News 5. 9 April 2014.; "Did famous drag queen die of poisoning?". Amandala. 7 June 2016.
  88. "The churches divided on the women's rally". News 5. 6 March 2014.; "Catholic Bishop opposes '20,000 Strong' march". Amandala. 7 March 2014.
  89. "Church blacklists BFLA, UNIBAM, NAC, Red Cross". 7 News. 13 March 2014.; "Bishop Wright flogs BFLA, UNIBAM, NAC and Red Cross!". Amandala. 14 March 2014.; "Red Cross issues release on comments made by Roman Catholic Bishop". News 5. 17 March 2014.
  90. Tra, p. vi; "18 year old transgender youth killed, was it a hate crime?". 7 News. 14 January 2014.
  91. "Amendment to Criminal Code; is legal language favorable to gay rights cause?". News 5. 1 October 2013.; "The amended Criminal Code … does it further the LGBT agenda?". News 5. 4 October 2013.; "Touchy rape bill stirs trouble". Amandala. 8 October 2013.; "Child rights advocates ask for media support". 7 News. 9 October 2013.; "Amendment to Criminal Code: Progressive or pro-gay?". 7 News. 9 October 2013.; "From Jamaica: Tomlinson says he had no influence on Deputy Sol Gen Daly". 7 News. 13 November 2013.
  92. Rey; "Belize Can will protest concept of Gender Studies Dept". News 5. 19 August 2013.; "Belize Can protests Gender Policy in front of National Assembly". News 5. 20 August 2013.
  93. "Miss Gay Goddess Belize 2013". News 5. 22 July 2013.; "Female impersonator crowned Miss Gay Goddess 2013–2014". 7 News. 23 July 2013.
  94. "Christian activists march against gays & gender policy". 7 News. 2 July 2013.; "Religious denominations protest Gender Policy in Orange Walk". News 5. 3 July 2013.; "Mammoth march in PG". 7 News. 5 July 2013.; "Massive protest for 'public morality' in Toledo – Cayo today!". Amandala. 9 July 2013.; "Constitution March brings hundreds to Cayo". 7 News. 9 July 2013.; "Gender Policy Protest hits Cayo in thousands". News 5. 9 July 2013.; "Constitutional March going to 'Griga'". 7 News. 11 July 2013.; "The anti-LGBT march comes to town". Star. No. 368. 14 July 2013. p. 1.; "Are the churches promoting hate crimes?". Star. No. 368. 14 July 2013. p. 9.; "Christians take to the city streets". 7 News. 16 July 2013.; "Churches take over the city!". Amandala. 16 July 2013.; "Hon. Alamilla fears anti-gay hate protests could escalate into violence". 7 News. 19 July 2013.; "Miss Gay Goddess Belize 2013". News 5. 22 July 2013.
  95. Orb, pp. 5–8; "Barrow administration's new gender policy opens door for gays?". Amandala. 24 May 2013.; "Government backpedals, appeases churches on gender policy". 7 News. 28 May 2013.; "Gender Policy wanted to legalize prostitution and then some". News 5. 28 May 2013.; "PM says Gender Policy not law". 7 News. 30 May 2013.; "LGBT influence dominates Cabinet?". Amandala. 31 May 2013.; "Barrow: Gender Policy not going anywhere". 7 News. 5 June 2013.; "Gender Policy resolution highly debated at O.A.S. General Assembly". News 5. 5 June 2013.; "More consultations on Gender Policy". 7 News. 6 June 2013.; "'Firestorm' over gender policy; Barrow doesn't blink". Amandala. 7 June 2013.; "Churches meet the P.M. to denounce gender policy". News 5. 7 June 2013.; "National Gender Policy issue: What's the Fuss? Part 1". Star. No. 364. 16 June 2013. pp. 11, 15.; "Church: What the Gender Policy really means". 7 News. 26 June 2013.; "PM 'hardheaded': Bishop Dorick Wright". Amandala. 19 July 2013.; "Churches: Ever watchful of the NGP". 7 News. 9 May 2014.; "PM/Church reconcile on NGP". 7 News. 3 October 2014.; "Churches and GOB break impasse over Revised Gender Policy". Amandala. 10 October 2014.
  96. "Is Audrey leaving Oceana because of homosexuality/bestiality comment?". 7 News. 29 May 2013.; "It's official, Audrey resigns from Oceana". 7 News. 30 May 2013.; "Audrey resigns!". Amandala. 31 May 2013.
  97. "UNIBAMer feels threatened because he's gay". News 5. 8 May 2013.; "UNIBAM boss's home burgled". 7 News. 9 May 2013.
  98. "Jamaican LBGT advocate won't travel to Belize because of restrictive anti-gay immig law". 7 News. 27 December 2012.; "Jamaican gay man takes Belize, Trinidad to court over discriminatory immig laws". 7 News. 17 July 2013.
  99. Ora, pp. 10–11; "Woman killed by lady lover in Santa Elena?". 7 News. 10 December 2012.; "Woman's life partner detained after her murder". News 5. 10 December 2012.; "Lily charged for killing her lady lover". 7 News. 11 December 2012.; "Rosalia Castillo charged for Palomas Del Norte Bar murder". News 5. 11 December 2012.; "Santa Elena woman facing murder charge". Star. No. 339. 16 December 2012. pp. 1–2.; "Court dismisses appeal of woman convicted for death of her lesbian lover". Amandala. 7 November 2018.
  100. 1 2 Rey.
  101. "Churches 'bex bad' with GOB!". Amandala. 31 August 2012.; "Church meets with Central Bank over 'spouse' definition". News 5. 31 August 2012.; "New banking law means more teeth and muscle for Central Bank". Amandala. 14 September 2012.
  102. "Failed homosexual sex attempt led to doctor's death". Amandala. 26 May 2018.; "Dwayne Davis tells court he's neither gay nor bisexual". 7 News. 14 June 2018.; "Dwayne Davis gets 14 years for manslaughter of Doctor Ivan Garcia". News 5. 20 June 2018.
  103. "Lead UNIBAM male attacked". News 5. 8 February 2012.; "Gay rights activist Caleb stoned with beer pint". 7 News. 8 February 2012.; "UNIBAM regains ground in court". 7 News. 5 December 2012.
  104. "Stand up for our children against homosexuals". Amandala. 1 December 2011.; "M/Education teaching students to be homosexuals?". Amandala. 12 December 2011.; "Ideas and opinions – Whither goest Belize?". Amandala. 15 December 2011.; "Minister of Education defends HFLE curriculum". News 5. 16 December 2011.; "Education Minister Faber dodges questions about in U.S.-sponsored HFLE manual". Amandala. 20 December 2011.; "Educ. Ministry pulls handbook". 7 News. 12 September 2012.; "Ministry of Education recalls manual that had pro-gay remarks". News 5. 13 September 2012.
  105. "UNIBAM divides Belize". Amandala. 9 December 2011. Further condemn UNIBAM in "Ideas and opinions – Unibam vs People of Belize". Amandala. 21 October 2011.; "Ideas and opinions – Concerning Unibam". Amandala. 25 November 2011.
  106. "From the publisher". Northern Star. No. 2. 28 November 2011. p. 4.
  107. "Forum addressing UNIBAM lawsuit next week". Plus TV. 28 October 2011.; "Rallying against the international homosexual agenda". Amandala. 22 November 2011.; "Church holds discussion on UNIBAM". News 5. 22 November 2011.; "Decriminalizing homosexuality will have dire ripple effects: Churches". Amandala. 25 November 2011.; "Christians 'Take A Stand' against UNIBAM". 7 News. 5 December 2011.; "Churches 'Take A Stand' rally against UNIBAM". News 5. 5 December 2011.; "Christians 'stand firm' against UNIBAM!". Amandala. 5 December 2011.; Perkins AK (2016). "More than words: Evangelicals, the rhetoric of battle and the fight over gay rights in the Caribbean". Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies. 41 (1): 31–34.
  108. Rep, p. 14; Williams Z (13 September 2011). "Gay rights: A world of inequality". Guardian.; "Minister Boots Martinez catfight 'tooth and nail' with UNIBAM". News 5. 14 September 2011.
  109. "Belizeans, stand up and say no to the homosexual agenda". Star. No. 277. 19 June 2011. p. 9. Repeated in "Belize Action ad". Star. No. 357. 28 April 2013. p. 4.
  110. "We invite you to join Belize Action mailout this time against the homosexual agenda". Star. No. 275. 5 June 2011. p. 4.
  111. Rep, p. 16; "Belize churches join GOB in court battle against homosexuals". Amandala. 22 May 2011.; "More Belize churches condemn UNIBAM!". Amandala. 22 July 2011. And allegedly link being gay to paedophilia per "Diminishing reason, diminishing respect". Amandala. 20 December 2011.; "Irony of our counsel". Amandala. 29 December 2011.
  112. "Belize transgender claims mistreatment in Trini". 7 News. 13 April 2011.; "Transgender Belizean cries discrimination". Trinidad Express. 13 April 2011.
  113. "Stabbed, castrated, then set on fire in a quiet village". News 5. 27 July 2010.; "Murder suspect Rafael Mencias is caught". News 5. 28 July 2010.; "Stabbed to death, then set on fire". Amandala. 30 July 2010.
  114. "A cruel killing in Corozal". 7 News. 31 May 2010.; "Jealous common-law-husband kills his wife". News 5. 1 June 2010.; "'Ah jus stab up mi gial …'". Amandala. 1 June 2010.
  115. "Francis Figueroa stabbed to death in Friday night fight". Amandala. 18 May 2010.
  116. "Gay student accuses Baptist High School of discrimination". 7 News. 23 October 2009.; "Gay student Jose Garcia's future in limbo". 7 News. 27 October 2009.; "Principal offers spiritual counselling to expelled gay student". 7 News. 4 November 2009.; "Baptist High threatens Jose Garcia with arrest". 7 News. 11 November 2009.
  117. "Walter Beaton, 35, charged with the murder of Leroy Rhaburn, 28". Amandala. 25 August 2009.
  118. "Brutal murder in Orange Walk; throat slit & beaten with bat". 7 News. 13 February 2009.; "Man brutally murdered in Orange Walk". News 5. 13 February 2009.; "Slaughtered by gay lover for $$$". Amandala. 17 February 2009.; "Caleb Orozco lied to the OAS". Amandala. 11 April 2014.
  119. "Corozal family planning New Year's Day funeral for murdered son". 7 News. 31 December 2007.
  120. "San Joaquin teens charged for beastly murder". 7 News. 20 November 2007.; "Two charged in brutal Corozal murder". News 5. 20 November 2007.; "Arturo Eck convicted of murder". News 5. 17 June 2010.; "Murder most foul". 7 News. 17 June 2010.
  121. "Understanding the homosexual factor – part IV: Homosexuality, pedophilia, and bestiality — the deadly connection". Amandala. 27 May 2007. Repeated in "The homosexual high school administrator". Amandala. 20 January 2007.; "Of pedophiles and hypocrites". Amandala. 1 February 2007.; "The homosexual factor". Amandala. 16 February 2007.; "Ferment and fire". Amandala. 3 June 2011.; "Of this and that". Amandala. 7 November 2011. Archived from the original on 30 May 2015.; "Of this and that". Amandala. 25 November 2011. Archived from the original on 30 May 2015.; "Homosexuality is not a human rights issue – it is downright disgusting!". Amandala. 29 November 2011.; "Homosexuality now; sex with animals next?". Amandala. 16 December 2011. Further anti-LGBTQ rhetoric in "Medical and economic consequences of what homosexuals do". Amandala. 13 April 2007.; "They do". Amandala. 8 April 2008.; "Sir Paul discusses homosexuality and Bishop Robinson". Amandala. 22 January 2009.; "Ludicrous same sex marriage in Christian lands". Amandala. 23 April 2009.; "Dealing with the real of homosexuality". Amandala. 18 November 2009.; "Homosexuals 'deprive the nation … of the creation of new citizens' – Paul Rodriguez". Amandala. 9 August 2011.; "No Battle of Britain". Amandala. 8 November 2011.; "Of this and that, part 2". Amandala. 25 November 2011.; "Don't let the Christians do it alone". Amandala. 25 November 2011.; "'A happily married man' writes on homosexuality". Amandala. 29 November 2011.; "The LGBTs should be last to cite hate". Amandala. 15 December 2011.; "Of this and that". Amandala. 16 December 2011. Archived from the original on 30 May 2015.
  122. "Was tear gas attack against homosexual revellers?". 7 News. 6 September 2006.
  123. "Bishop Dorick Wright's holy caution". 7 News. 18 June 2004.
  124. "Former BDF captain cleared of sexual misconduct". 7 News. 22 July 2004.
  125. "Belizeans protest cruise". Out and About. 27 January 1998.; "Gay cruise arrives Sunday". News 5. 30 January 1998.; "Gay cruise visits Belize City; protesters demonstrate at dock". News 5. 2 February 1998.; "Cruise OK in Belize, UK confab". Out and About. 4 February 1998.
  126. 1 2 Equ.

Works cited

  1. "LGBT rights in Belize". Equaldex.
  2. "AmericasBarometer Data Playground". LAPOP.
  3. UNIBAM/SRI submission for the 1st UN UPR for Belize (Report). 2009.
  4. Report on homophobia (Report). UNIBAM. 26 February 2009. Archived from the original on 9 July 2025.
  5. Quetzal M (2010). Baseline research on transgender population (Report). CRTA. Archived from the original on 9 July 2025.
  6. "Belizean LGBT Rights Violations". UNIBAM. 2011–2022.
  7. Chanona J (28 July 2011). "The homosexuality debate in Belize: Should the state legislate morality?". 7 News.
  8. Chanona J (12 October 2011). "The homosexuality debate in Belize: Can you pray away gay?". 7 News.
  9. Wiltshire R (2012). Youth masculinities and violence in the Caribbean (PDF) (Report). CARICOM.
  10. Adomakoh S, Chase M (28 August 2012). Report on SD among key community groups (Report). UK Aid/PANCAP. Archived from the original on 9 July 2025.
  11. Belize country report (Report). ARC. 14 November 2012.
  12. Evans CM (2013). "Challenging 'unnatural crimes': The connection between LGBTI rights and gender-specific sexual violence laws in Belize". Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights. 11 (2): 189–206.
  13. UNIBAM/Heartland Alliance submission for Belize to the 107th UN HRC session (Report). 2013.
  14. Beirich H (10 July 2013). Dangerous liaisons: The American religious right and the criminalization of homosexuality in Belize (Report). SPLC.
  15. Reynolds L (29 August 2013). "The long battle to eradicate homophobia in Belize". NotiCen.
  16. "A dollar amount linked to homophobia, a lack of security and dignity in Belize". UNIBAM. 14 January 2014.
  17. Homophobia and transphobia in Caribbean media (Report). Outright Intl. 15 August 2015.
  18. Belize LGBT community needs assessment (Report). Our Circle. 2016.
  19. Beck EJ, Espinosa K, Ash T, Wickham P, Barrow C, Massiah E, Alli B, Nunez C (2017). "Attitudes towards homosexuals in seven Caribbean countries: Implications for an effective HIV response". AIDS Care. 29 (12): 1557–1566. doi:10.1080/09540121.2017.1316355.
  20. Nicol N, Jjuuko A, Lusimbo R, Mule NJ, Ursel S, Wahab A, Waugh P, eds. (2018). Envisioning Global LGBT Human Rights: (Neo)colonialism, Neoliberalism, Resistance and Hope. London: University of London. doi:10.14296/818.9780993110283. ISBN   978-0-9931102-8-3.
  21. Waters J, Budhwani H, Habun J, Hearld KR (1 August 2018). Estimation of key population size of men who have sex with men (MSM) and transgender women in Belize (Report).
  22. Carrillo K (2019). Country report (Report). Stigma Index.
  23. Demographic survey of same-sex couples in Belize (Report). Our Circle. 2019.
  24. Lazarus L (2020). "Enacting citizenship, debating sex and sexuality: Conservative Christians' participation in legal processes in Jamaica and Belize". Commonwealth & Comparative Politics. 58 (3): 366–386. doi:10.1080/14662043.2020.1773115.
  25. Castillo D (2020). The impact of Covid-19 on the LGBT community in Belize (Report). Our Circle.
  26. Public opinion survey on national values and discrimination in Belize (Report). Live & Let Live. 14 September 2020.
  27. Crehan P, Rezende L, Wolf J, Jordan P, Altincekic C, Miller J, Dovey K (2021). The economic case for LGBT+ inclusion in the Caribbean (Report). Open For Business.
  28. Orozco C (31 March 2021). Situational analysis of investigative practices in law enforcement that undermine justice in Belize (Report). UNIBAM.
  29. Orozco C (2 May 2021). Barriers to justice: LGBT systemic violence report (Report). UNIBAM.
  30. Public opinion survey on national values and discrimination in Belize (Report). Live & Let Live. 28 July 2021.
  31. BTC submission for the 4th UN UPR for Belize (Report). 2023.
  32. EYBM/UNIBAM/PETAL submission for the 4th UN UPR for Belize (Report). 2023.
  33. OUT in Belize (Report). ReportOUT. 2024.
  34. Rambarran N (17 October 2024). Shared Incident Database analysis – Belize report (Report). CVC.
  35. Crawford C (2025). Gender, Sexual Citizenship and Epistemic Injustice in the Caribbean. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Pivot. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-83493-6. ISBN   978-3-031-83493-6.