What happens after Nora leaves home | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Traditional Chinese | 娜拉走後怎樣? | ||||||
Simplified Chinese | 娜拉走后怎样? | ||||||
|
"What Happens After Nora Leaves Home?" is a speech given by Chinese writer Lu Xun at Beijing Women's Normal College in 1923. In his speech,Lu Xun evaluated the ending of A Doll's House by Norwegian playwright Henrik Ibsen,where the heroine Nora leaves home to search for her selfhood. Concerned with the blind following of Nora's rebel,Lu Xun spoke to address its potential danger.
Lu Xun takes a pessimistic view on Nora's departure,stating that her follow-up options are either prostitution or a humiliating return because of her economic incapability. As his critique of Nora furthers,Lu Xun expands to discuss the general political and economic oppression facing Chinese society. He believes economic independence is the foundation of a liberated mind,and could only be achieved through radical social revolution,which will free China from all forms of enslavement. Nevertheless,he is ambiguous as to when and how the revolution will take place. [1]
Lu Xun's emphasis on economic independence and its connection with political liberation shows his insightful observation on contemporary Chinese society. [2] [3] However,as later academics point out,his argument is still flawed as it overlooks the story's other characters,overemphasizes material needs over internal change and marginalizes women's issues for nationalistic purposes. [2] [3] [4] Lu Xun's 1925 short story,'Regret for the Past('伤逝','Shangshi')',is considered as the literary spiritual successor of his take on Nora. [2] [5]
Henrik Ibsen's 1879 play A Doll's House follows the individual awakening of Nora Helmer,wife to a bank employee named Torvald Helmer. When a scandal breaks out that threatens the livelihood of the Helmers,Torvald accuses Nora of ruining his life,contrary to his earlier promise to take on everything himself as the man of the family. After learning the scandal would be resolved secretly,Torvald is overjoyed and forgives Nora. However,Nora,who has seen Torvald's true selfish character,decides to leave. She tells Torvald that like her father,he had never known her—even she doesn't know who she really is herself. She states that she felt like a 'puppet' under Torvald's control and she needs some time to live alone to understand herself. The play ends as Nora leaves Torvald,with the door slamming on her exit from the house. [6] The play is considered one of the best works depicting female predicament of the Western bourgeois class. [7] Scholar Joan Templeton praised the ending,noting it 'constitutes nineteenth-century feminism's universally agreed-upon base for women's emancipation". [7]
In the speech,Lu Xun reexamines Nora's prospect and addresses the importance of economic freedom. At first,Lu Xun gives a summary of A Doll's House and describes it as 'social drama' that depicts the ugliness of social reality. [1] Next,Lu Xun calls to rethink the ending of A Doll's House:'What happens after Nora walks out?'. [1] He suggests two possible outcomes:'Logically,however,Nora really has only two options:to fall into degradation (prostitution) or to return home'. In his reasoning,Nora is compared to a 'caged bird' who no longer knows how to fly or what danger lies outside. [1] Similar to someone who wakes up from a dream and realizes 'there is no way out',Lu Xun believes Nora will inevitably fall into tragic outlooks. [1]
After envisioning the destined failure of Nora's future,Lu Xun continues to evaluate the psychological effectiveness of living in ignorance. [1] [3] At first,he affirms that it is reassuring to live in ignorance and sometimes it is essential to do so,noting that 'People who dream are fortunate. If there isn't a way out,it is important not to wake them'. [1] [3] To Lu Xun,to make people aware of a desperate reality only means more suffering for themselves,as there is nothing for them to do other than 'to witness their own rotting corpses'. [1] However,he also admits that a dreamer awakened can no longer return to his dream calmly. As Nora becomes aware of her husband's manipulation,her awakening is inevitable and so is her departure. [1] [3]
Lu Xun then proposes that in order for Nora to avoid her destined failure,she will have to need money. [6] He argues that a liberated mind can go nowhere without the support of material possessions. [1] [3] In doing so,he shifts from predicting Nora's future to emphasizing the importance of economic freedom. [2] He writes:
'So for Nora,money (or to put it more elegantly,economic means) is crucial. It is true that freedom cannot be bought,but it can be sold. Human beings have one major defect:they are apt to get hungry.' [1]
To compensate for this defect,as Lu Xun continues,individual economic freedom must be achieved. [1] However,he believes the pursuit for economic rights will be met with more hindrance than the advocation of political rights,as material needs are more basic for human survival than the distribution of power. [1] In his ideal vision,economic equality should be achieved in peace within the family,as parents equally distribute family property to their offsprings to live as they will. [1] Nevertheless,he admits this is 'rather a distant dream',and the only way for its realization would be for everyone to keep track of their past mistakes so they don't repeat them in the future. [1]
Next,Lu Xun expands his emphasis on economic freedom from individual to society. He asks if individual economic freedom is the solution to the broader systematic hierarchy of subjugation between class and gender. [1] He argues that economic freedom is only an 'intermediate goal' leading to a more overall solution. [1] [3] Therefore,Lu Xun contends that the only way to obtain political and economic freedom is revolution--'to fight for them' with extreme audacity and tenacity. [1] [3]
However,Lu Xun notes in dismal that 'it's too difficult to change China'. [1] He launches attacks on the passive inaction of the Chinese masses,criticizing that they have been nothing more than 'spectators at a play'. [1] In consideration of this,Lu Xun urges his listeners to fight carefully and enduringly,rather than resorting to the brief sacrifice which will soon be forgotten. [1] Nevertheless,he still bears expectations for China's future. With a mixed undertone,Lu Xun predicts a revolution will come eventually,but how and when he cannot tell. [1]
Four years before Lu Xun gave his speech on Ibsen's A Doll's House ,one of the most significant social movements in China,the May Fourth Movement,took place in Beijing. On 4 May 1919,students gathered to protest against the signing of Versailles Peace Treaty and imperial Japan's 'Twenty-one Demands',which quickly culminated into the rise of public awareness of China's national identity. [8] The May Fourth Movement represents 'the beginning of China's modern revolutionary era,and a new stage after the Republican Revolution of 1911'. [8] Culturally,the May Fourth Movement advocates for gexing jiefang (个性解放),or in English,'the emancipation of individuality'. It urges for reexamination of traditional Chinese values in favour of individuality. [9] For this reason,Chinese intellectuals looked to the West for new models of ideas. [2]
Among these ideological inspirations are the works of Norwegian playwright Henrik Ibsen. As early as 1907,Lu Xun has noticed Ibsen's appeals and wrote essays to praise his play, An Enemy of the People (1882). [2] But it was not until ten years later that Ibsen's works found broader appeal among the Chinese readers. In 1918,the influential New Youth magazine dedicated an entire special issue to introduce Ibsen and his works. [3] Comprising Ibsen's biography,reflexive essays and translation of his works (including A Doll's House,An Enemy of the People and Little Eyolf),the issue served as a systematic guide for Ibsen's works and was enthusiastically received by Chinese readers. [2] His plays,performed in Beijing and Shanghai,won critical and mass acclaims alike. [3] [2] The character of Nora,especially,sparked discussions on marital freedom as many considered her as the symbol of individuality,and a refusal to the repressive Confucian traditions. Inspired by her spirit,many young Chinese rebelled against their family and left home for the sake of individual liberation,a phenomenon coined by some as the 'Nora Compulsion' (or 'Ibsen-fever'/'Chinese Nora-ism'). [7] [3]
Accompanying the New Youth special issue was an essay written by editor Hu Shi,leading intellectual of the May Fourth Movement. The essay was entitled 'Ibsenism' ('易卜生主义',Yipushengzhuyi),where he analyzed the motifs of Ibsen's works. [2] In Hu Shi's opinion,Ibsen's works are 'realistic',as they eloquently expose the dark side of social reality. [2] Hu Shi incorporates Ibsen's revolutionary ideals into his critique against traditional Confucian values,denouncing 'immoral' feudal practices which hinder the liberation of individuality. [10] Inspired by A Doll's House,Hu wrote a play named The Greatest Event in Life (1919), deemed by some as the Chinese iteration of 'the Nora-problem',with the same emphasis on individual autonomy over familial oppression. [7] However,Hu's vision was slowly overshadowed by Lu Xun,whose interpretation of Nora would spark a series of debates on individualism,the ideology most valued by Hu and the May Fourth Movement. [2]
Presented as a speech at a women's vocational school,Lu Xun warns against the danger of 'the Nora Compulsion'. [3] As Lu Xun affirms the revolutionary ideal embodied by Hu Shi's Nora,he appeals his listeners to rethink its feasibility. [2] [3] Like Hu Shi,Lu Xun recognizes Ibsen's plays as 'social drama',pinpointing that while Ibsen depicts social injustices,he is not obliged to provide ready-made solutions. [7] He argues that despite the feminist implication of Ibsen's works,he never wrote specifically to address the problem of women's liberation. Therefore,men and women alike should be alert of Nora's false promise. [2]
What makes Lu Xun's Nora distinct is his emphasis on economic freedom and radical revolution. [3] Departing form a 'socialist' perspective,Lu Xun's critique consists of three arguments:first,economic independence is most crucial to individual liberation;second,economic independence could only be achieved through radical revolution;and third,individual liberation could not be achieved unless the collective society is priorly liberated. [2] [3] Different from Hu Shi and Ibsen,Lu Xun highlights external factor (money) over internal awakening,expanding his argument from individual emancipation to general political liberation. As he vaguely suggests revolution as the solution,the implication is that only a comprehensive social change will liberate its individual member,not the other way around. [2] Lu Xun's inclination for external change over internal liberation is also shown in his 1934 essay,'On Women's Liberation(有关妇女解放,'Youguan funv jiefang')',in which he wrote,'when society is liberated,we ourselves will be liberated too'. [2]
Lu Xun also criticizes the destructive power of the blind crowd,noting its favour 'to spectate' instead of 'to act'. [9] While he believes the society will help Nora,its sympathy will expire in no time as Nora's 'novelty' wears out. [1] [11] In Lu Xun's opinion,Nora's departure is a show of fascination in the patriarchal eyes of the Chinese society,an actual spectacle the 'thrill-seeking masses' will eventually grow weary of. [11] Lu Xun's critique of Nora and her spectating value shows his ambivalence of female representation in contemporary Chinese society. Lu Xun's take on Nora,as Eileen Cheng argues,is 'tempered by a deeper reflection on the implications of promoting such public visibility for women in light of Chinese social realities and the continued currency of traditional gender norms'. [11]
However,some have pointed out the limitations of Lu Xun's critique. Several scholars argue that Nora is capable to survive without her husband's support. [2] [4] As Zheng Hansheng points out,Nora already exhibits traits of decisiveness as she refuses to succumb to the threat of her debtor. [4] Before she leaves the house,her independent character has already formed during the events of the play. [2] [4] Moreover,some note that a role model already exists in the play:Nora's old friend Mrs. Linde,whose self-reliance proves a life of independence is possible in the contemporary social climate. [2] [4] Additionally,Chien Ying-Ying contends against Lu Xun's favour for external change over internal awakening,arguing that 'without internal change,even if they have money,Chinese women would still be puppets and dolls,both at home and in society at large.' [2]
Another major flaw of Lu Xun's interpretation is his marginalization of women's issues in contemporary China. [2] [3] [5] As he diverts from a feminist interpretation of Nora,Lu Xun's consideration of women's fate is subordinate to the fate of contemporary China. [2] Like Hu Shi and many other May Fourth male writers,his criticisms on gender oppression are framed within the nationalistic presumption that women need to find their own agenda in order for China to advance. [2] Therefore,both Lu Xun and Hu Shi's interpretation suffers from a gendered nationalistic appropriation,making their Nora results of 'sympathetic male intuition'. [3] Last but not least,the lack of female intellectual opinions in the Nora debates calls for further consideration for gendered biases . [3]
In 1925,Lu Xun wrote a short story,'Regret for the Past (伤逝,'shangshi')',which follows a young couple's disillusionment of reality after they rebel against their own families.'Regret for the Past' is considered as a direct literary successor of Lu Xun's perspective on Nora. [2] [5] Instead of focusing on unequal marital relationship like Ibsen did,Lu Xun addresses the evil of Chinese feudal family system and emphasizes on the importance of economic independence. [2] The story shares similar problem of Lu Xun's Nora critique in its male-centered narrative. [2] As Stephen Chan points out,the heroine Zijun in 'Regret for the Past' is the empty 'other' that exits only to be objectified for the male self's(her husband Juanshen's)reflection,as 'no authentic discourse for the other is represented'. [5]
A Doll's House is a three-act play written by Norwegian playwright Henrik Ibsen. It premiered at the Royal Theatre in Copenhagen,Denmark,on 21 December 1879,having been published earlier that month. The play is set in a Norwegian town circa 1879.
Henrik Johan Ibsen was a Norwegian playwright and theatre director. As one of the founders of modernism in theatre,Ibsen is often referred to as "the father of realism" and one of the most influential playwrights of his time. His major works include Brand,Peer Gynt,An Enemy of the People,Emperor and Galilean,A Doll's House,Hedda Gabler,Ghosts,The Wild Duck,When We Dead Awaken,Rosmersholm,and The Master Builder. Ibsen is the most frequently performed dramatist in the world after Shakespeare,and A Doll's House was the world's most performed play in 2006.
Zhou Shuren,better known by his pen name Lu Xun,was a Chinese writer,literary critic,lecturer,and state servant. He was a leading figure of modern Chinese literature. Writing in vernacular Chinese and classical Chinese,he was a short story writer,editor,translator,literary critic,essayist,poet,and designer. In the 1930s,he became the titular head of the League of Left-Wing Writers in Shanghai during republican-era China (1912–1949).
Hu Shih (Chinese:胡適;pinyin:HúShì;Wade–Giles:Hu2 Shih4;17 December 1891 –24 February 1962),also known as Hu Suh in early references,was a Chinese diplomat,essayist and fiction writer,literary scholar,philosopher,and politician. Hu contributed to Chinese liberalism and language reform and advocated for the use of written vernacular Chinese. He participated in the May Fourth Movement and China's New Culture Movement. He was a president of Peking University. He had a wide range of interests such as literature,philosophy,history,textual criticism,and pedagogy. He was also a redology scholar.
New Youth was a Chinese literary magazine founded by Chen Duxiu and published between 1915 and 1926. It strongly influenced both the New Culture Movement and the later May Fourth Movement.
The New Woman was a feminist ideal that emerged in the late 19th century and had a profound influence well into the 20th century. In 1894,Irish writer Sarah Grand (1854–1943) used the term "new woman" in an influential article to refer to independent women seeking radical change. In response the English writer Ouida used the term as the title of a follow-up article. The term was further popularized by British-American writer Henry James,who used it to describe the growth in the number of feminist,educated,independent career women in Europe and the United States. Independence was not simply a matter of the mind;it also involved physical changes in activity and dress,as activities such as bicycling expanded women's ability to engage with a broader,more active world.
The New Culture Movement was a progressivist movement in China in the 1910s and 1920s that criticized classical Chinese ideas and promoted a new Chinese culture based upon progressive,modern ideals like elections and science. Arising out of disillusionment with traditional Chinese culture following the failure of the Republic of China to address China's problems,it featured scholars such as Chen Duxiu,Cai Yuanpei,Chen Hengzhe,Li Dazhao,Lu Xun,Zhou Zuoren,He Dong,Qian Xuantong,Liu Bannong,Bing Xin,and Hu Shih,many classically educated,who led a revolt against Confucianism. The movement was launched by the writers of New Youth magazine,where these intellectuals promoted a new society based on unconstrained individuals rather than the traditional Confucian system.
"Diary of a Madman",also translated as "A Madman's Diary" is a short story by the Chinese writer Lu Xun,published in 1918. It was the first and one of the most influential works written in vernacular Chinese in Republican era China,and would become a cornerstone of the New Culture Movement. Lu Xun's stories often critiqued early 20th century Chinese society,and "Diary of a Madman" established a new language and revolutionary figure of Chinese literature,an attempt to challenge conventional thinking and traditional understanding.
A Doll's Life was a 1982 musical with music by Larry Grossman,and a book and lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph Green. A sequel to the 1879 Henrik Ibsen play A Doll's House,it told the story of what happened to the lead character,Nora,after she left her husband and her old life behind to face the world on her own;in doing so,it examined several aspects of feminism and the ways in which women are treated.
The culture that led to the founding of the Republic of China and that flourished immediately afterwards was informed by two main concerns:the weakness of the government in the face of pressure by Western powers,including the United Kingdom,the United States,Germany,France,and Japan,and the seeming backwardness of the political system,which previously had held primacy over East Asia. It was this climate that led to the rapid changes and quick questioning of thousand year old traditions.
A Doll's House is an American drama television film that premiered on NBC on November 15,1959,as part of the Hallmark Hall of Fame anthology series. It is directed and produced by George Schaefer,from a teleplay by James Costigan,based on Henrik Ibsen's classic play of the same name. The film stars Julie Harris and Christopher Plummer,who previously co-starred in Little Moon of Alban.
A Doll's House is a 1973 drama film directed by Joseph Losey,based on the 1879 play A Doll's House by Henrik Ibsen. It stars Jane Fonda in the role of Nora Helmer and David Warner as her domineering husband,Torvald.
A Doll's House is a 1992 videotaped television production of the 1879 play of the same name by Henrik Ibsen. It was directed by David Thacker and first broadcast on BBC 2 on 21 November 1992,and was later shown on PBS's Masterpiece Theatre in the United States.
A Doll's House is a 1917 American silent drama film based on the eponymous 1879 play by Henrik Ibsen. The film was written and directed by Joe De Grasse,and stars Lon Chaney,William Stowell and Dorothy Phillips. Film historian Jon C. Mirsalis stated that director De Grasse's wife Ida May Park wrote the screenplay,but most sources attribute both the writing and directing of the film to De Grasse himself. The film is today considered lost.
Feminism in China refers to the collection of historical movements and ideologies aimed at redefining the role and status of women in China. Feminism in China began in the 20th century in tandem with the Chinese Revolution. Feminism in modern China is closely linked with socialism and class issues. Some commentators believe that this close association is damaging to Chinese feminism and argue that the interests of the party are placed before those of women.
Nora is a theatre show directed by Haris Pasovic and produced by the East West Theatre Company based in Sarajevo,Bosnia and Herzegovina. The show is based on Henrik Ibsen's 1879 play A Doll's House,which was translated into Bosnian by Munib Delalic. Nora is the story of a young successful couple who seemingly live a perfect life but suffer from marital problems under the surface.
A Doll's House is a 1922 American silent drama film produced by and starring Alla Nazimova and directed by her husband Charles Bryant. The couple released the film through United Artists. It is based on the 1879 play A Doll's House by Henrik Ibsen with the scenario written by Nazimova under the pseudonym Peter M. Winters. The film was the fourth silent version filmed of the play,being preceded by a 1918 Paramount film directed by Maurice Tourneur. The film is classified as being lost.
Rou Shi was a prominent left-wing Chinese writer and member of the May Fourth Movement. Executed on either 7 or 8 February 1931 by the Kuomintang government in Shanghai for his pro-Communist activities,he is considered one of the Five Martyrs of the League of Left-Wing Writers.
Lu Yin (1898–1934) was a Chinese feminist writer of the 20th-century. Her extensive body of work includes novels,short story collections and essays that explore the lives and hardships of Chinese women in the 20th century. Lu Yin is often associated with the May Fourth movement due to her support and espousing of its ideals during her academic career and its influences that are found in her literary works. During her writing career Lu Yin advocated for women's liberation through education and wrote many critical essays on what the steps to women's emancipation in China should look like. Due to the content of her work often reflecting feminist theory and her May Fourth movement involvement,Lu Yin is cited as a prominent figure in both the canon of May Fourth writers and notable women writers of China.
Bai Wei ( 白薇) was the pen name of Huang Zhang,born in 1894 in Zixing,in the south-east of Hunan. She also went by other names including Li,Ying,Su Ru,Chong,Laokao,Sufei,Lady Baiwei,Huang Yufa and Lady Suru. Bai Wei was a revolutionary playwright,poet,and fiction and essay writer. Most of her notable works remain plays.