Why Not Us

Last updated
"Why Not Us"
Why Not Us.jpg
Single by Monrose
from the album I Am
Released28 November 2008
Length3:29
Label Starwatch
Songwriter(s)
Producer(s) Guy Chambers
Monrose singles chronology
"Hit 'N' Run"
(2008)
"Why Not Us"
(2008)
"Like a Lady"
(2010)
Music video
"Why Not Us" on YouTube

"Why Not Us" is a song recorded by German pop trio Monrose. It was written by English songwriters Alexis Strum and Guy Chambers and produced by the latter along with frequent Monrose collaborator Pete Kirtley for the band's third studio album I Am (2008). A midtempo contemporary R&B-pop ballad with soft electro pop elements, "Why Not Us" is about a tumbling relationship which ultimately breaks up.

Contents

The song was released by Starwatch Music as the album's third and final single on 28 November 2008. It debuted and peaked at number 27 in Germany, becoming the group's lowest-charting single up to then, and failed to reach the upper half of the Austrian Singles Chart. An accompanying music video, directed by Markus Gerwinat, was filmed at the Orangery Palace in the Sanssouci Park of Potsdam.

Background

"Why Not Us" was written by British songwriters Guy Chambers and Alexis Strum, [1] and produced by the former, with frequent Monrose collaborator Pete Kirtley credited as a co-producer. [1] Recorded by Mandy Capristo, Senna Gammour, and Bahar Kızıl for the band's third studio album I Am (2008), "Why Not Us" is a midtempo contemporary R&B-pop ballad that is about a tumbling relationship which ultimately breaks up. [2] [3] Band member Bahar Kizil called "Why Not Us" a "winter song." [4]

Chart performance

"Why Not Us" was released by Starwatch Music as the album's third and final single on 28 November 2008. Initially selected by the label as the album's second single, [4] Monrose reportedly disliked the idea of ​​issuing the song as a single and only agreed to release it after Starwatch offered to release "Hit 'N' Run" as the album's second single beforehand. [5] "Why Not Us" eventually debuted and peaked at number 27 on the German Singles Chart in the week of 12 December 2008, becoming Monrose's first single to miss the top 20. [6] It also failed to reach the top 50 in Austria. [7]

Music video

Orangery Palace in the Sanssouci Park of Potsdam served as a filming location for the video. Westlicher Eckpavillon, Orangerieschloss Sanssouci, Potsdam-7583.jpg
Orangery Palace in the Sanssouci Park of Potsdam served as a filming location for the video.

A music video for "Why Not Us" was directed by frequent Monrose collaborator Oliver Sommer and produced by AVA Studios. [8] It was released online and through televion channels on 14 November 2008. [8] The visuelas show the trio in black dresses in an autumn set, featuring visual elements from the Baroque age. Portions of the video were filmed at the Orangery Palace in the Sanssouci Park of Potsdam, with Westlicher Eckpavillion and Jubiläumsterrasse serving as main filming locations. [8] Intercut are solo performances and group scenes that were filmed in front of a green screen and depict Capristo, Gammour, and Kızıl in various settings. [8]

Track listings

CD maxi-single
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Why Not Us"
3:29
2."Why Not Us" (Beathoavenz Cut)
  • Chambers
  • Strum
  • Chambers
  • Kirtley [a]
  • Beathoavenz [b]
3:34
3."Why Not Us" (Electrasonic RMX)
  • Chambers
  • Strum
  • Chambers
  • Kirtley [a]
  • Sacha Collisson [b]
3:15
4."Strike the Match" (fArHOt Remix)
  • Tedder
  • Andrew Murray [b]
  • Christian Ballard [b]
2:58
2-track CD single
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Why Not Us"
  • Chambers
  • Strum
  • Chambers
  • Kirtley [a]
3:29
4."Strike the Match" (fArHOt Remix)
  • Tedder
  • Epstein
2:58

Notes

Credits and personnel

Credits adapted from the liner notes of Strictly Physical. [1]

Charts

Chart performance for "Why Not Us"
Chart (2008)Peak
position
Austria (Ö3 Austria Top 40) [7] 53
Germany (Official German Charts) [6] 27

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Monrose</span> German pop band

Monrose was a German pop girl group, first established in November 2006. Formed on the fifth installment of the German adaption of the international television talent show Popstars, the trio consisted of singers Mandy Capristo, Senna Gammour, and Bahar Kızıl. They were signed to Starwatch Music and released their debut album Temptation in December 2006. It achieved major success throughout Central Europe, selling more than a 600,000 copies combined and produced two singles, including number-one breakthrough hit "Shame" and "Even Heaven Cries".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shame (Monrose song)</span> 2006 single by Monrose

"Shame" is a song by all-female German pop group Monrose, recorded for the band's debut studio album, Temptation (2006). It was written by Christian Ballard, Tim Hawes, Pete Kirtley and Andrew Murray, while joint production was helmed by British production teams Jiant and Snowflakers. Set against a heavy drum pattern and computerized synths sounds, "Shame" is a piano ballad arranged as a mid-tempo with pop and R&B influences. The song's lyrics are about the breakdown of a relationship with a man, with the protagonist blaming her own mistakes, including her ongoing call for independence, for their separation.

<i>Temptation</i> (Monrose album) 2006 studio album by Monrose

Temptation is the debut studio album by German girl band Monrose. It was released by Starwatch Music on 8 December 2006 in German-speaking Europe, following the band's formation on Popstars – Neue Engel braucht das Land, the television talent show's fifth season. Pre-recorded with all six Popstars finalists throughout October and November 2006, the majority of the album was produced by Popstars jury member Dieter Falk. Additional collaborators include Jiant, Jonas Jeberg, Toni Cottura and Mozart & Friends.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Even Heaven Cries</span> 2007 single by Monrose

"Even Heaven Cries" is a song by all-female German pop trio Monrose. It was written by Robbie Nevil, Jens Lumholt, Lauren Evans, Philip Denker, and Jonas Jeberg and recorded for the band's debut studio album, Temptation (2006), while production was overseen by Jeberg. Built upon a boom clap percussion and a strummed-harp sample, reminiscent of other Jeberg productions, the sentimental midtempo R&B ballad contains lyrics about personality and body-image issues as well as self-esteem and insecurity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hot Summer (song)</span> 2007 single by Monrose

"Hot Summer" is a song by German pop group Monrose. It was written and produced by Danish musicians Remee Sigvardt and Thomas Troelsen and recorded by the trio for their second studio album, Strictly Physical (2007). A dance-pop song with heavy elements of electropop, house and sprechgesang, it was selected out of sereral hundreds of songs and set much of the tone of its parent album, which was chiefly produced by Remee and Troelsen. "Hot Summer" also introduced a stronger dance pop edge to Monrose's overall sound. Lyrically, it features a female protagonist expressing her desire for her love interest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bahar Kizil</span> German singer

Bahar Kizil is a German singer and songwriter of Turkish descent, best known as one of the founding members of the girl group Monrose, which won the fifth season of the German version of Popstars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mandy Capristo</span> German pop singer

Mandy Grace Capristo, also known mononymously as Mandy, is a German singer and songwriter.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Strictly Physical (song)</span> 2007 single by Monrose

"Strictly Physical" is a song by German pop girl group Monrose. It was written by British musicians Tim Hawes, Pete Kirtley, Obi Mhondera, Christian Ballard, and Andrew Murray and recorded by the trio for their same-titled second studio album (2007). Production was helmed by Mhondera along with duo Hawes and Kirtley as well as duo Ballard and Murray under their production monikers Jiant and Snowflakers. A dark and spooky, synthesizer–driven contemporary R&B record, it contains lyrics that reference to a celebration of sexual lust and conquest, leading up to a desire to get physical with a love interest.

<i>Strictly Physical</i> (album) 2007 studio album by Monrose

Strictly Physical is the second studio album by all-female German pop trio Monrose. It was released by Starwatch Music in association with Cheyenne Records and Warner Music on 21 September 2007 in German-speaking Europe and on 8 October 2007 in parts of Eastern Europe. Released only nine months after its best-selling predecessor Temptation (2006), the album took Monrose's work further into dance and electro music, featuring main production by Danish producers Remee, Thomas Troelsen, and Peter Biker, as well as British composers from production collectives Jiant, and Snowflakers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">What You Don't Know (Monrose song)</span> 2007 single by Monrose

"What You Don't Know" is a song by all-female German pop band Monrose. It was written by American songwriter Billy Mann along with Swedish musicians Mattias Lindblom and Anders Wollbeck and recorded for the band's second studio album, Strictly Physical (2007). Production on the track was helmed by Christian Ballard, Tim Hawes, Pete Kirtley, Obi Mhondera, and Andrew Murray from British production teams Jiant and Snowflake. A guitar-led pop ballad was released as

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Strike the Match</span> 2008 single by Monrose

"Strike the Match" is a song by German pop trio Monrose. It was written by OneRepublic frontman Ryan Tedder and singer Deborah "SoShy" Epstein and recorded for the group's third studio album I Am (2008). Production on the track was helmed by Tedder, with additional production provided by Christian Ballard, Pete Kirtley, and Andrew Murray.

<i>I Am</i> (Monrose album) 2008 studio album by Monrose

I Am is the third studio album by German pop trio Monrose. It was first released by Starwatch Music, Cheyenne Records and Warner Music on 26 September 2008 in German-speaking Europe. The band reunited with frequent contributors Jiant and Snowflakers and Danish producer Jonas Jeberg to work on the bulk of the album, though several new collaborators were consulted to hand in music, including Ronny Svendsen and Nermin Harambasic from Norwegian music collective Dsign Music, Oscar Gorres, Didrik Thott, Carl Björsell, JoelJoel, Guy Chambers, and OneRepublic frontman Ryan Tedder.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Monrose discography</span> Cataloging of published recordings by Monrose

German pop trio Monrose, consisting of singers Mandy Capristo, Senna Gammour, and Bahar Kızıl, was formed in November 2006 after winning Popstars – Neue Engel braucht das Land, the fifth installment of the talent show Popstars. The group released four studio albums and eleven singles until their disbanded in 2010, culminating in four top ten albums, seven top ten hit singles and overall sales in excess of 1.5 million singles and albums.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Too Young (Queensberry song)</span> 2009 single by Queensberry

"Too Young" is a song by all-female German pop band Queensberry. It was written by Swedish composer Eric Palmqvist and recorded for the deluxe edition of the group's debut studio album Volume I (2008). Production on the track was helmed by Erik "Kid Crazy" Nyholm and Pete Kirtley. A melancholic uptempo pop song, it is built upon 1980s synthesizer sounds. Lyrically, "Too Young" has the protagonist wondering whether her broken but still longed-for relationship fell apart because of their naivety and youth.

<i>Ladylike</i> 2010 studio album by Monrose

Ladylike is the fourth and final studio album by German pop trio Monrose. It was released by Starwatch Music in association with Cheyenne Records and the Warner Music Group on 11 June 2010 in German-speaking Europe. Conceived during a hiatus which allowed each member to launch solo projects, production of the album began in mid-2009. Unlike their previous material, recording of Ladylike was not rushed, with sessions also taking place in New York City. Monrose reteamed with frequent collaborators Pete Kirtley, Tim Hawes, and Obi Mhondera to work on the album, while upcoming producers such as Tuneverse and Alexander Geringas were also consulted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Like a Lady (Monrose song)</span> 2010 single by Monrose

"Like a Lady" is a song performed by German girl band Monrose. It was written by Risto Asikainen, Zippy Davis, Veikka "DJ Ercola" Erkola and Alexander Komlew and recorded for their fourth studio album Ladylike (2010), with production helmed by Davis, Erkola and Komlew under their production moniker Tuneverse. "Like Lady" is an uptempo dance pop song with elements of electropop, synth pop, and contemporary R&B and has lyrics which speak about a woman calling her love interest to recognize her worth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">This Is Me (Monrose song)</span> 2010 single by Monrose

"This Is Me" is a song performed by German girl band Monrose. It was written by Mich Hansen, Jonas Jeberg, Paul Barry and All Saints band member Shaznay Lewis and recorded for the trio's fourth studio album Ladylike (2010). Production was overseen by Pete Kirtley, Christian "TheFatRat" Buettner and Marcello "Cello" Pagin. Introduced by an a cappella solo by band member Mandy Capristo, who also serves as the song's leading vocalist during its chorus, "This Is Me" is a pumping dance-pop song with heavy elements of synthpop and electronic music; its lyrics explore themes of self-confidence, independence and stamina.

Popstars – Neue Engel braucht das Land was a new installment of the Popstars themed Neue Engel braucht das Land which started airing on 10 August 2006. The title of the show was a play on the status of the show's original winners No Angels, a group whose members had disbanded in 2003, with the declared goal of the show's season being to find their successors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Breathe You In</span> 2010 single by Monrose

"Breathe You in" is a song by German girl group Monrose. It was written by Thanh Bui, Rodney Mark Davies, and Gary Pinto and recorded by Monrose for their fourth studio album Ladylike (2010), while production was helmed by frequent collaborators Pete Kirtley as well as Andrew Murray and Christian Ballard from production duo Snowflakers. An uplifting piano-led ballad with minor contemporary R&B elements, "Breathe You In" is built upon a harp motif. Lyically, it chronicles a woman's love for a man.

<i>Grace</i> (Mandy Capristo album) 2012 studio album by Mandy Capristo

Grace is the debut studio album by German singer Mandy Capristo. It was released by Starwatch Entertainment and EMI Music on April 27, 2012 and marked Capristo's first solo release following the disbandment with her band Monrose in 2010. Recorded in Hamburg, Cologne and Berlin, she worked with a number of different musicians on material for the album, including German producers Toby Gad and David Jost as well as American producer Cainon Lamb and Swedish production team Twin.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Real Love (Media notes). Monrose. Starwatch Music. 2008.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
  2. Surauf, Kevin Dave. "Musik, Singles: Why Not Us". myfanbase.de. Retrieved 3 June 2024.
  3. Bartz, Christian. "Monrose – I Am". beatblogger.de. Retrieved 3 June 2024.
  4. 1 2 Kraus, Walter. "Interview mit Monrose-Chanteuse Bahar". beatblogger.de. Retrieved 3 June 2024.
  5. "Galerie Arschgeweih – Der Podcast (BONUS: Bahar von Monrose im Talk)". Galerie Arschgeweih. 3 June 2024. Retrieved 3 June 2024.
  6. 1 2 "Monrose – Why Not Us" (in German). GfK Entertainment charts. Retrieved 2011-05-06.
  7. 1 2 "Monrose – Why Not Us" (in German). Ö3 Austria Top 40. Retrieved 2011-05-06.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 "Monrose – Why Not Us". crew-united.com (in German). Retrieved 3 June 2024.