Yuba City bus disaster

Last updated
Yuba City bus disaster
Yuba City bus disaster
Details
DateMay 21, 1976
10:55 AM
OperatorStudent Transportation Lines, Inc
CauseBrake failure due to insufficient maintenance, driver training, driver proficiency
Statistics
Passengers53
Deaths29
Injured24

The Yuba City bus disaster occurred on May 21, 1976, in Martinez, California. A chartered school bus transporting 52 passengers on an elevated offramp left the roadway, landing on its roof. [1] Of the 52 passengers (not including the driver), 28 students and an adult adviser were killed in the crash. [1]

Contents

It remains the deadliest highway disaster ever investigated by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) since its creation. [2]

Incident

On May 21, 1976, Yuba City High School chartered a school bus from Student Transportation Lines, Inc. to transport its a cappella choir from Yuba City, California, to Miramonte High School in Orinda for a friendship day involving the choirs of the two schools. [3] The company supplied a Crown bus, dating from 1950. [3] [2]

The accident occurred at 10:55 a.m., as the driver, Evan Prothero, 49, of Olivehurst, took the Marina Vista Avenue off-ramp (exit 56) from I-680 southbound from the Benicia–Martinez Bridge. Prothero was unfamiliar with this bus, and mistook the low air pressure warning (for the air brakes) for a warning of low engine oil pressure. Intending to stop for oil, [3] the driver exited the freeway at the aforementioned off ramp; the air brake system failed due to lack of air pressure. With no braking capability, the bus struck the mounted bridge rail and left the elevated roadway. After falling 21.6 feet (6.6 meters), the bus landed on its roof, crushing it to the base of the window line.

Victims

Out of 52 passengers on board, twenty-eight students and an adult adviser were killed. [1] All of the surviving passengers were injured, most critically. [3] The driver survived the crash but was seriously hurt. [2]

  1. Larry R. Shearer, 14 [4]
  2. Carrie Emmirch, 15
  3. Danielle Cote, 15 [5]
  4. Joanne A. Matson, 15 [4]
  5. Marla Azim, 15 [4]
  6. Bobby R. Ortega, 16 [5]
  7. Catherine R. Mudge, 16 [4]
  8. Kris Huston, 16 [5]
  9. Larry H. Rooney, 16 [5]
  10. Rachel Carlson, 16 [5]
  11. Ruth A. Bowen, 16 [6]
  12. Carlene Engle 17 [4]
  13. Constance Adkins, 17 [7]
  14. Cynthia Graham, 17 [8]
  15. Jim Frantz, 17 [5]
  16. Seth Rosebrough, 17 [5]
  17. Sharlene Engle, 17 [4]
  18. Steven Gust, 17 [4]
  19. Robert Randolph, 17 [5]
  20. Robert J. Stafford, 17 [4]
  21. Amy Hicks, 18 [5]
  22. Bonnie Barfield, 18 [5]
  23. Jodie L. McCoy, 18 [4]
  24. Lori Killingsworth, 18 [5]
  25. Marti A. Melani, 18 [4]
  26. Pamela S. Engstrom, 18 [4]
  27. Tom Brooks, 18 [8]
  28. Christina E. Cadena Estabrook, 25, wife of Dean Estabrook, who was driving his own vehicle in front of the bus when the disaster occurred. [8] [9]

The crash claimed one additional victim. Daniel I. Wright, 15, died on May 24, 1976, at the Highland Hospital in Oakland, California due to the injuries he sustained in the crash. [6]

Investigation

The accident was investigated by the National Transportation Safety Board, which it attributed to the unfamiliarity and inexperience of the driver with the design of the 26-year-old bus and his confusion of oil pressure and air pressure warnings. [10] Contributing to the accident were:

  1. The failure of the air compressor drivebelt
  2. The failure of the maintenance program and pre-trip inspection to detect and replace the deteriorated air compressor drivebelt
  3. The failure of the signing system to adequately alert the driver to the critical geometrics of the ramp
  4. The severe radius of the curvature of the ramp
  5. The design of the curb as part of the ramp railing
  6. A bridge rail system that did not redirect the bus. [10]

The upside of the accident is that the training and testing for school bus drivers has been improved, plus the design and construction of school buses has been improved. Additionally pre-trip and post-trip inspections and repairs are now more refined and more regulated.

Memorials

The Yuba City bus disaster was the second-worst bus disaster in U.S. history, exceeded only by the 1963 train-bus collision in Chualar, California, which claimed the lives of 32 Mexican farmworkers.

In May 1996, on the twentieth anniversary of the accident, a memorial built near the water at the Martinez Marina was dedicated to the victims. Bearing the names of those who died, it was constructed by firefighters who had responded to the accident and their friends and largely funded by them and donations they obtained. [11] On the 35th anniversary of the accident in May 2011, Contra Costa County firefighters dedicated a monument in Yuba City. [12]

In 2015, the I-680 freeway off-ramp was replaced with one having a longer and flatter approach. [13]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Transportation Safety Board</span> US government investigative agency for civil transportation accidents

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is an independent U.S. government investigative agency responsible for civil transportation accident investigation. In this role, the NTSB investigates and reports on aviation accidents and incidents, certain types of highway crashes, ship and marine accidents, pipeline incidents, bridge failures, and railroad accidents. The NTSB is also in charge of investigating cases of hazardous materials releases that occur during transportation. The agency is based in Washington, D.C. It has four regional offices, located in Anchorage, Alaska; Denver, Colorado; Ashburn, Virginia; and Seattle, Washington. The agency also operates a national training center at its Ashburn facility.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transport in Thailand</span>

Transport in Thailand is varied, with no one dominant means of transport. For long distance travel, bus transport dominates. Low-speed rail travel has long been a rural long-distance transport mechanism, though plans are underway to expand services with high-speed rail lines extending to several major regions of Thailand. Road transportation is the primary form of freight transport across the country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Westchester County Airport</span> Public airport in Westchester County, New York

Westchester County Airport is a county-owned airport in Westchester County, New York, three miles (6 km) northeast of downtown White Plains, with territory in the towns of North Castle and Harrison, New York, and village of Rye Brook, New York. It is sometimes referred to as the White Plains Airport and is so identified by the Official Airline Guide (OAG).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroméxico Flight 498</span> 1986 mid-air aircraft collision and crash in Cerritos, California, US

Aeroméxico Flight 498 was a scheduled commercial flight from Mexico City, Mexico, to Los Angeles, California, United States, with several intermediate stops. On Sunday, August 31, 1986, the McDonnell Douglas DC-9 operating the flight was clipped in the tail section by N4891F, a Piper PA-28-181 Cherokee owned by the Kramer family, and crashed into the Los Angeles suburb of Cerritos, killing all 64 on the DC-9, all three on the Piper and an additional 15 people on the ground. Eight on the ground also sustained minor injuries. Blame was assessed equally on the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the pilot of the Cherokee. No fault was found with the DC-9 or the actions of its crew.

The Carrollton bus collision occurred on May 14, 1988, on Interstate 71 in unincorporated Carroll County, Kentucky. The collision involved a former school bus in use by a church youth group and a pickup truck driven by an alcohol-impaired driver. The head-on collision was the deadliest incident involving drunk driving and the third-deadliest bus crash in U.S. history. Of the 67 people on the bus, there were 27 fatalities in the crash, the same number as the 1958 Prestonsburg bus disaster, and behind the 1976 Yuba City bus disaster (29) and 1963 Chualar bus crash (32).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moorgate tube crash</span> 1975 train crash on the London Underground

The Moorgate tube crash occurred on 28 February 1975 at 8:46 am on the London Underground's Northern City Line; 43 people died and 74 were injured after a train failed to stop at the line's southern terminus, Moorgate station, and crashed into its end wall. It is considered the worst peacetime accident on the London Underground. No fault was found with the train, and the inquiry by the Department of the Environment concluded that the accident was caused by the actions of Leslie Newson, the 56-year-old driver.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1995 Fox River Grove bus–train collision</span> Grade crossing collision in Fox River Grove, Illinois

The 1995 Fox River Grove bus–train collision was a grade crossing collision that killed seven students riding aboard a school bus in Fox River Grove, Illinois, on the morning of October 25, 1995. The school bus, driven by a substitute driver, was stopped at a traffic light with the rearmost portion extending onto a portion of the railroad tracks when it was struck by a Metra Union Pacific Northwest Line train en route to Chicago.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Martinair Flight 495</span> 1992 aviation accident

Martinair Flight 495 was a McDonnell Douglas DC-10 operated by Dutch airline Martinair, that crash-landed in severe weather conditions at Faro Airport, Portugal on 21 December 1992. The aircraft carried 13 crew members and 327 passengers, mainly holidaymakers from the Netherlands. 54 passengers and 2 crew members died. 106 of the other occupants were badly injured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yuba City High School</span> Public school in Yuba City, California

Yuba City High School is a public secondary school in Yuba City, California. It had roughly 3,000 students before River Valley High School opened in 2005. The school colors are brown and gold. Its mascot is the "Honker", a nickname for Canada geese.

The Bluffton University bus crash was an automobile crash that occurred during the early morning hours of March 2, 2007, on Interstate 75 in Atlanta, Georgia. A chartered motorcoach was carrying 33 members of the Bluffton University baseball team from Bluffton, Ohio, on their way to play Eastern Mennonite University during spring break in Sarasota, Florida. The group planned to travel without an overnight stop on the approximately 900-mile, 18-hour trip. The trip went without incident from Bluffton south to a motel in Adairsville, Georgia, at which time a relief driver began operating the bus for the second half of the trip.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prestonsburg, Kentucky, bus crash</span> 1958 accident involving a school bus and the drowning deaths of twenty six children

The collision and plunge into Big Sandy River involving a school bus near Prestonsburg, Kentucky, on February 28, 1958, resulted in the deaths of 26 students and the bus's driver. It was the third-deadliest bus crash in United States history, tied for fatalities with the Carrollton, Kentucky bus collision in 1988. The only deadlier crashes were a 1963 bus-train crash in Chualar, California and the 1976 Yuba City bus disaster, which claimed the lives of 29 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 Bathurst Boys in Red accident</span> Car accident in Canada

The Boys in Red accident occurred on January 12, 2008, just outside the city of Bathurst, New Brunswick, Canada. A semi-trailer truck and a van carrying the basketball team from Bathurst High School collided, which killed seven students, the wife of the coach, and injured four other occupants in the van. It was the deadliest transportation accident in New Brunswick since 1989, when a logging truck tipped onto a hayride in Cormier Village, killing 13. It was the deadliest bus accident involving a sports team in Canada until the Humboldt Broncos bus crash in April 2018.

The Snow Hill school bus collision was a vehicle accident that occurred on May 31, 1985, on US 13 near Snow Hill, North Carolina. Four vehicles were involved, including a school bus operated by the Greene County Schools. Driving the school bus was 18-year-old Sheila Dawn, a student at Greene Central High School. Six students and Carson Lee Conger, 27, of Norfolk, Virginia, were killed. The remaining 24 persons in the accident suffered injuries ranging from minor to critical.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 Ottawa bus–train crash</span>

The Ottawa bus–train crash was a collision that occurred between an OC Transpo double-decker bus and a Via Rail train in the Ottawa suburb of Barrhaven on September 18, 2013, that killed six people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1990 Interstate 75 fog disaster</span> 1990 multi-vehicle traffic collision in Tennessee, United States

The 1990 Interstate 75 fog disaster was a transportation accident that occurred on the morning of December 11, 1990, on a section of Interstate 75 (I-75) near Calhoun, Tennessee, during dense fog which obscured the visibility of motorists. The accident occurred in an area where fog is common and had been the site of previous multi-vehicle accidents caused by poor visibility. It consisted of a series of multi-vehicle collisions that ultimately involved 99 vehicles, and resulted in 12 deaths and 42 injuries. It was reportedly the largest motor vehicle accident in United States history when it occurred, in terms of the number of vehicles, and was the largest and second deadliest vehicle accident in Tennessee history behind the 1972 Bean Station bus-truck collision, which killed 14. The disaster resulted in multiple safety improvements to the section of I-75 where the accident occurred.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Memphis tanker truck disaster</span> 1988 explosion and fire in the United States

The Memphis tanker truck disaster was a transportation disaster that occurred on December 23, 1988, when a tractor-trailer tanker truck hauling liquefied propane crashed on an exit ramp at the Interstate 40/Interstate 240 (I-40/I-240) interchange in downtown Memphis, Tennessee. The crash ruptured the tank, causing the leaking gas to ignite, which produced a large explosion that set multiple vehicles and structures on fire. The tank was then propelled 125 yards (114 m) from the site where it crashed into a residential complex and started additional fires. The accident resulted in nine deaths and ten injuries. The interchange where the accident occurred was considered unsafe and poorly designed, and had been the site of several previous accidents. It was completely rebuilt in the 2000s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1972 Bean Station bus-truck collision</span> Bus/semi-truck collision in Bean Station, Tennessee

The 1972 Bean Station bus-truck collision was a head-on collision involving a double-decker Greyhound bus and a tractor-trailer on U.S. Route 11W in Grainger County, Tennessee, that occurred near the town of Bean Station on the morning of May 13, 1972.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Erin Hallissy (1996-09-16). "20 Long Years Later, Martinez Remembers A School Bus Crash". San Francisco Chronicle . Retrieved 2013-11-19.
  2. 1 2 3 Hager, Philip & Lembke, Daryl (May 22, 1976). "School bus crash kills 28". LA Times (via St. Petersburg Times).
  3. 1 2 3 4 "28 Killed in Calif. School Bus Crash". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. AP. May 22, 1976.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Blaylock, Bill. "Survivor: 28 Perished in Snap of a Finger." The Sacramento Bee, May 23, 1976, pg 5. https://www.newspapers.com/clip/112653146/yuba-city-highschool-bus-crash/
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 "YCHS chois bus crash toll up to 29." The Gridley Herald. May 26, 1976, pg 1. https://www.newspapers.com/clip/112656061/yuba-city-bush-crash/
  6. 1 2 "Another bus crash victim dies as town begins burying dead." The San Bernardino County Sun, May 25, 1976, pg 16. https://www.newspapers.com/clip/112654728/yuba-city-bus-crash/
  7. "A Week of Sadness: Yuba City Commemorates Losses." The Petaluma Argus-Courier. May 29, 1976, pg 5.
  8. 1 2 3 "Casualty List Told." The Times. May 22, 1976, pg 2. https://www.newspapers.com/clip/112657510/yuba-city-bus-crash/
  9. "'It was like a bad dream,' Bus Crash Survivor Says." The Petaluma Argus-Courier. May 22, 1976, pg 1-2. https://www.newspapers.com/clip/112658396/yuba-city-bus-crash/
  10. 1 2 "Accident Investigation - NTSB". National Transportation Safety Board. 1977-09-29. Retrieved 2013-11-19.
  11. "The Worst Bus Crash in the Nation's History Happened 36 Years Ago in Martinez". Claycord.com. Retrieved 2013-11-19.
  12. Gerardo Recinos (2013-05-26). "Firefighters pay homage to bus accident victims : Martinez News-Gazette". Martinezgazette.com. Retrieved 2013-11-19.
  13. Laura Anthony (2015-05-21). "CALTRANS REPLACES DEADLY I-680 OFF-RAMP IN MARTINEZ : ABC & News". abc7news.com. Retrieved 2015-10-06.

38°01′28″N122°06′40″W / 38.0244°N 122.1110°W / 38.0244; -122.1110