1858 Utica train wreck

Last updated
1858 Utica train wreck
1858 Utica train wreck.jpg
Engraving of the accident in Frank Leslie's Illustrated Magazine
1858 Utica train wreck
Details
DateMay 11, 1853;172 years ago (1853-05-11)
Location Utica, New York
Coordinates 43°07′12″N75°16′48″W / 43.12000°N 75.28000°W / 43.12000; -75.28000
Operator New York Central Railroad
Incident typeBridge collapse
CausePoor quality of materials
Statistics
Trains2
Deaths9
Injured55
List of rail accidents (before 1880)

The 1858 Utica train wreck was a rail disaster that occurred as the result of a bridge collapse. 9 passengers were killed as a result of the tragedy. [1]

Incident

On May 11, 1858, an eastbound Cincinnati express passenger train was crossing a wooden bridge over the Sauquoit creek in Utica, New York. At this same time, a westbound freight train was also crossing this bridge on the opposite line. The freight train had barely made it past the creek when the bridge gave way and collapsed. Several of the passenger cars shattered as they stacked upon each other. Nine were killed and 55 were injured; the injuries were described in Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper:

"Among the wounded, S. S. Horton of Birminghamton had his throat cut ear to ear, as completely as though it had been done with a knife... Mrs. Broderick was completely scalped..." [2]

Personal accounts from survivors stated that the bridge collapse was a result of poor wood quality. These personal accounts also reveal that the New York Central Rail Company made out of court settlements, with some receiving $2,000 (equivalent to around $79,000 today). [3] [4]

References

  1. Hoey, Mike (June 6, 2017). "Hidden History: Train Wrecks". CNY Homepage. Retrieved October 10, 2025.
  2. Reed, Robert (1968). Train Wrecks: A Pictorial History of Accidents on the Main Line. Seattle: Superior Pub. Co. p.  86. ISBN   0-517-328976.
  3. "Three Court Documents Re: The Whitesboro New York Train Wreck, 1858". University Archives. Retrieved October 10, 2025.
  4. "Value of $2,000 from 1858 to 2025". CPI Inflation Calculator. Retrieved October 10, 2025.