1941 Major League Baseball All-Star Game

1941 Major League Baseball All-Star Game

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E National League 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 2 0 5 10 2 American League 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 4 7 11 3
Date	July 8, 1941
Venue	Briggs Stadium
City	Detroit, Michigan
Managers	Bill McKechnie (CIN) Del Baker (DET)
Attendance	54,674
Ceremonial first pitch	None
Radio	CBS Mutual WWJ (DET) WXYZ (DET)
Radio announcers	Mel Allen and France Laux (CBS) Red Barber and Bob Elson (Mutual) Ty Tyson (WWJ) Harry Heilmann (WXYZ)
←  1940 Major League Baseball All-Star Game 1942  →

The 1941 Major League Baseball All-Star Game was the ninth playing of the mid-summer classic between the all-stars of the American League (AL) and National League (NL), the two leagues comprising Major League Baseball. The game was held on July 8, 1941, at Briggs Stadium in Detroit, Michigan, the home of the Detroit Tigers of the American League.

Result and key moments

The American League defeated the National League, 7–5. With the NL leading 5–4, two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning, and Joe Gordon and Joe DiMaggio of the New York Yankees on base; Ted Williams of the Boston Red Sox hit a walk-off home run off of Claude Passeau of the Chicago Cubs to win it for the AL. ^[1]

Prior to Williams' at-bat DiMaggio hit a potential game-ending double play groundball. However, Billy Herman’s relay throw pulled first baseman Frank McCormick off the bag, thus extending the game and setting up Williams' at-bat. ^[2]

In the end, the AL's dramatic 7–5 walk-off win overshadowed two home runs hit by Pittsburgh Pirates shortstop Arky Vaughan, which had given the NL 3–2 and 5–2 leads in the seventh and eighth innings, respectively.

Rosters

Players in italics have since been inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

National League Starters Position Player Team All-Star Games P Whit Wyatt Dodgers 3 C Mickey Owen Dodgers 1 1B Johnny Mize Cardinals 4 2B Lonny Frey Reds 2 3B Stan Hack Cubs 3 SS Arky Vaughan Pirates 8 LF Terry Moore Cardinals 3 CF Pete Reiser Dodgers 1 RF Bill Nicholson Cubs 2 Pitchers Position Player Team All-Star Games P Cy Blanton Phillies 2 P Paul Derringer Reds 5 P Carl Hubbell Giants 8 P Claude Passeau Cubs 1 P Bucky Walters Reds 4 P Lon Warneke Cardinals 5 Reserves Position Player Team All-Star Games C Harry Danning Giants 4 C Al López Pirates 2 1B Dolph Camilli [3] Dodgers 2 1B Frank McCormick Reds 4 2B Billy Herman Dodgers 8 SS Eddie Miller Braves 2 3B Cookie Lavagetto Dodgers 4 OF Bob Elliott Pirates 1 OF Hank Leiber [3] Cubs 3 OF Joe Medwick Dodgers 8 OF Mel Ott Giants 8 OF Enos Slaughter Cardinals 1

American League Starters Position Player Team All-Star Games P Bob Feller Indians 4 C Bill Dickey Yankees 8 1B Rudy York Tigers 2 2B Bobby Doerr Red Sox 1 3B Cecil Travis Senators 3 SS Joe Cronin Red Sox 7 LF Ted Williams Red Sox 2 CF Joe DiMaggio Yankees 6 RF Jeff Heath Indians 1 Pitchers Position Player Team All-Star Games P Al Benton Tigers 1 P Sid Hudson Senators 1 P Thornton Lee White Sox 1 P Red Ruffing Yankees 5 P Marius Russo Yankees 1 P Eddie Smith White Sox 1 Reserves Position Player Team All-Star Games C Frankie Hayes Athletics 3 C Birdie Tebbetts Tigers 1 1B Jimmie Foxx Red Sox 9 2B Joe Gordon Yankees 3 3B Ken Keltner Indians 2 SS Luke Appling White Sox 4 SS Lou Boudreau Indians 2 OF Roy Cullenbine Browns 1 OF Dom DiMaggio Red Sox 1 OF Charlie Keller Yankees 2

Game

Umpires

Position	Umpire	League
Home Plate	Bill Summers	American
First Base	Lou Jorda	National
Second Base	Bill Grieve	American
Third Base	Babe Pinelli	National

The umpires changed assignments in the middle of the fifth inning – Summers and Pinelli swapped positions, also Jorda and Grieve swapped positions. ^[1]

Starting lineups

National League				American League
Order	Player	Team	Position	Order	Player	Team	Position
1	Stan Hack	Cubs	3B	1	Bobby Doerr	Red Sox	2B
2	Terry Moore	Cardinals	LF	2	Cecil Travis	Senators	3B
3	Pete Reiser	Dodgers	CF	3	Joe DiMaggio	Yankees	CF
4	Johnny Mize	Cardinals	1B	4	Ted Williams	Red Sox	LF
5	Bill Nicholson	Cubs	RF	5	Jeff Heath	Indians	RF
6	Arky Vaughan	Pirates	SS	6	Joe Cronin	Red Sox	SS
7	Lonny Frey	Reds	2B	7	Rudy York	Tigers	1B
8	Mickey Owen	Dodgers	C	8	Bill Dickey	Yankees	C
9	Whit Wyatt	Dodgers	P	9	Bob Feller	Indians	P

Game summary

Tuesday, July 8, 1941 1:30 pm (ET) at Briggs Stadium in Detroit, Michigan

Team	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	R	H	E
National League	0	0	0	0	0	1	2	2	0	5	10	2
American League	0	0	0	1	0	1	0	1	4	7	11	3
WP: Eddie Smith (1–0)   LP: Claude Passeau (0–1) Home runs: NL: Arky Vaughan (2) AL: Ted Williams (1)

Bob Feller (Cleveland, AL) and Whit Wyatt (Brooklyn, NL) pitched three and two scoreless innings, respectively, to start the game. Neither team put a runner in scoring position until the fourth inning, when doubles by Cecil Travis (Washington) and Ted Williams off Paul Derringer (Cincinnati) put the AL ahead 1–0.

Bucky Waters (Cincinnati) led off the sixth inning with a double. A bunt by Stan Hack (Chicago Cubs) moved Waters to third and a sacrifice fly by Terry Moore (St. Louis Cardinals) tied the game at 1–1.

The AL answered in the bottom half of the same inning when Cleveland shortstop Lou Boudreau (who had entered the game for Joe Cronin) singled home Joe DiMaggio for a 2–1 AL lead.

The top halves of the seventh and eighth innings saw the heroics of Arky Vaughan, who hit a two-run home run in each to also score two St. Louis Cardinals players: Enos Slaughter, who had opened the seventh inning with a single, and Johnny Mize, who had preceded Vaughan's round-tripper in the eighth with a one-out double.

With the score now 5–2 in favor of the National League the first pair of brothers to ever appear together in an All-Star Game cut into the NL lead, when Dom DiMaggio – in his first plate appearance of the game – singled home Joe after his one-out double. ^[4]

In the ninth inning, White Sox pitcher Eddie Smith, who had given up one of Vaughan's home runs, retired the NL in order in his second inning of work. One of the three NL hitters to step to the plate that half-inning was pitcher Claude Passeau, who – with his team leading 5–3 – was not pulled for a pinch hitter, and thus returned to the mound in the bottom of the ninth for his third inning of work. (The only position player left on the NL bench, Cookie Lavagetto, was inserted as a pinch hitter one batter after Passeau's at-bat.)

With one out in the bottom of the ninth, three consecutive AL batters reached base, putting the tying and go-ahead runs on base and bringing Joe DiMaggio to the plate. The “Yankee Clipper” then hit what some sources describe as a routine double-play groundball, which would have ended the ballgame. However, the relay throw from second to first by Billy Herman pulled first baseman Frank McCormick off the bag and extended the game. ^[2]

With the NL still leading 5–4 (a run had scored on DiMaggio's groundout), the AL now had the tying run on third and the winning run on first. Not electing to walk Ted Williams, which would have advanced the winning run to second base and brought Dom DiMaggio to the plate, NL manager Bill McKechnie let Passeau pitch to Williams. ^[2] With the count two balls and one strike Williams hit a three-run home run off the third deck of the right field stands of Detroit's Briggs Stadium for a 7–5 American League victory. ^[5]

Context and aftermath

The 1941 All-Star Game took place in the midst of Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak (but did not count towards it, as the All-Star Game is regarded as an exhibition game). DiMaggio had equaled the all-time record of 44 games, set by Willie Keeler in 1897, seven days prior to the All-Star Game and broken it the day after that (July 1 and 2, respectively). ^[6] The streak would end nine days after the All-Star Game, when DiMaggio went hitless on July 17 against the Cleveland Indians. ^[7]

Ted Williams, whose batting average was at .405 at the time of the All-Star Game, would even slightly improve on that hitting pace for the rest of the season and end the 1941 campaign at .406, making him the last hitter to reach the .400 mark for a season. ^[8]

The 1941 Major League Baseball season, of which the All-Star Game marked the midway point, was the last played prior to the United States' entry into World War II. The juxtaposition of that memorable season taking place with the war looming is illustrated in the 1991 book Baseball in ’41 by renowned sportswriter Robert Creamer. ^[9] Although the Major League season and the World Series would continue to be played during the war years, the All-Star Game was cancelled in 1945 due to wartime travel restrictions.

The fact that Arky Vaughan was eventually denied the accolades of being the player of the game despite his two home runs can be seen as symbolic of his entire career: Despite arguably being the preeminent offensive shortstop of his time, hitting .300 or higher in 12 of his 14 Major League seasons, ^[10] Vaughan was not inducted into the Hall of Fame until 1985 (posthumously, by the Veterans Committee, nearly four decades after his last major league appearance) and is not remembered as vividly as many of the other stars of this era. ^[11]

References

1. "American League 7, National League 5". Retrosheet . July 8, 1941. Retrieved October 23, 2016.
2. Talbot, Gayle. “Arky Vaughan’s Two Home Runs Overshadowed By Ted Williams As Americans Win In Ninth, 7-5“, Fitchburg Sentinel, July 9, 1941.
3. Player declined or was unable to play.
4. http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/history/all_star_event.jsp?story=15 There would be five more instances of the DiMaggio brothers being selected to the same All Star Game: 1942, ’46, ’49, ’50, ’51.
5. WWJ radio broadcast, July 8, 1941, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-nuBd9uPRY
6. "Joe DiMaggio Hitting Streak by Baseball Almanac".
7. Thomas, Robert. "Ken Keltner, 75, Indians Infielder Who Helped End DiMaggio Streak" New York Times, December 14, 1991. – That game featured two defensive plays on groundballs hit by DiMaggio by Indians third baseman Ken Keltner, who was the player who scored on DiMaggio’s fielder’s choice groundball in the ninth inning of the All Star Game.
8. "Ted Williams 1941 Batting Game Logs".
9. "BASEBALL IN '41 | Kirkus Reviews".
10. "Arky Vaughan Stats".
11. Moses, Ralph. "Arky Vaughan" Society for American Baseball Research: “[…] Arky Vaughan remains relatively unknown in comparison to his fellow Hall of Famers. Overlooked and underappreciated, Vaughan ranks among the top shortstops and offensive stars of his or any era.”

Further reading

• "Arky Vaughan's Two Home Runs Overshadowed By Ted Williams As Americans Win In Ninth, 7-5". Fitchburg Sentinel . Fitchburg, Massachusetts. AP. July 9, 1941. p. 8. Retrieved June 24, 2018– via newspapers.com.

External links

• 1941 All-Star Game Box Score, July 8 at Baseball-Reference.com
• 1941 All-Star Game at Baseball Almanac
• July 8, 1941: Ted Williams hits ‘most thrilling’ home run to win All-Star Game in Detroit - Society for American Baseball Research (SABR Games Project)