2017 Humboldt University lecture incident

Last updated
Stavit Sinai during a BDS protest in 2019 BDS activist Stavit Sinai.jpg
Stavit Sinai during a BDS protest in 2019

On June 20, 2017, BDS activists, including at least two Israeli Jews and at least one Palestinian, disrupted a lecture by Israeli politician Aliza Lavie taking place at Humboldt University of Berlin. Humboldt University was not the organizer of the lecture. The activists expressed accusations against Israel and Lavie, including accusations of war crimes and apartheid. The activists were then removed from the lecture hall.

Contents

On August 3, 2020, a Berlin court sentenced Stavit Sinai, one of the BDS activists, to a 450 euro fine for assault, related to the fact that she pounded on the door of the lecture hall, which reportedly caused injuries to two people. Her fellow activists claimed Sinai had been punched in the face while being ejected from the lecture hall, and tried to get back in to find out the identity of the person who had hit her. [1] [2] Two other BDS activists charged in relation to the incident, Ronnie Barkan and Majed Abusalama, were found not guilty. [3]

The conviction of Stavit Sinai for assault was used as an argument for calling BDS a violent movement. [3]

Incident

Aliza Lavie, Member of Knesset Aliza Lavie.jpg
Aliza Lavie, Member of Knesset

On June 20, 2017, an event was taking place in one of the lecture halls at Humboldt University in Berlin. The organizers were DIG (die Deutsch-Israelische Gesellschaft) and Mideast Freedom Forum Berlin (the executive director of which is also a DIG member) [4] [5] [6] The event took place in English. The title of the event was Leben in Israel - Terror, Voreingenommenheit und die Chancen für eine Friedenslösung (Life in Israel - Terror, Bias and the Chances for Peace).

The announcement of the event also mentioned BDS and their "questionable" purpose (boycott of Israel). [6]

It was advertised as lecture and discussion with Aliza Lavie, Knesset MP, Yesh Atid, Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense, and members of the delegation of Yesh Atid and Young Yesh Atid. [6] Aliza Lavie was also the chair of the Knesset Caucus for the Struggle Against the Delegitimization of the State of Israel; one BDS activist characterized her as the "chair of anti-BDS lobby".

Besides members of Yesh Atid and the party's youth organization, an 82-year-old Holocaust survivor, Dvora Weinstein, was also present (she was not speaking, at least at the time of the incident). [7] [note 1]

Among the audience were at least three BDS activists: Stavit Sinai (an Israeli Jewish university lecturer), Ronnie Barkan (an Israeli Jewish math teacher) and Majed Abusalama (a Gaza Palestinian born in the Jabalia refugee camp, shot in a leg by an Israeli soldier during a nonviolent protest [8] ).

According to Michael Spaney from DIG, "several minutes" or "about 10 minutes" into Aliza Lavie's lecture, one of the activists started shouting at her before being removed from the hall, and then two others started speaking and/or shouting against Lavie and against Israel before being removed too. The activists were accusing Israel of apartheid and accusing Israel, and Aliza Lavie specifically, of war crimes in Gaza.

Lavie said the activists told her "the blood of the Gaza Strip is on your hands" and called the politician a "child murderer" (a reference to the 2014 bombardment and airstrikes in Gaza). Lavie and her group reportedly left the hall through a back exit to avoid a group of about 20 protesters at the main entrance. [4] [5] [9]

Describing the way the activists were removed from the hall by DIG members, Michael Spaney from DIG said they were "nicely maneuvered out" of the hall (though they were "lashing out"), while the BDS activists said Stavit Sinai was punched in the face. [1] [2] Ronnie Barkan said that a video shown to the judge during the trial showed the moment Sinai was punched. [3]

Criminal proceedings

The Berlin branch of DIG filed a criminal complaint against the three BDS activists. The complaint says the BDS activists launched tirades exceeding their permitted speaking time and interrupted Lavie's talk.

The compaint also alleges Stavit Sinai "swung [her fists] wildly around her and attendees" as she was escorted from the university room for disrupting the event; and that she "continuously attempted to reenter the lecture hall and pounded on the door", and that a member of DIG positioned himself by the door to block her reentry. [10]

In August 2017, the spokesman for Humboldt University told the press that the university had filed a criminal complaint as early as June 27, following the DIG complaint from June 26.

After more than three years, on August 3, 2020, the court dismissed the trespassing charges. Barkan and Abusalama were acquitted of all charges; however, Sinai was found guilty of assault because of her pounding on the door of the lecture hall, which reportedly caused injuries to two people, and sentenced to a fine of 450 euro. [3] Barkan and Abusalama said Sinai was trying to reenter the hall to find out the identity of the person who had punched her in the face. [1] [2]

Reactions

Media

The day after the verdict, Berliner Zeitung published an article titled Disgusting hatred of Jews in and in front of the Berlin courtroom (Widerlicher Judenhass in und vor Berliner Gerichtssaal). The article portrayed the lecture disruption as "sheer hatred of Jews" and the entire 2017 event as an "event with a Holocaust survivor". Aliza Lavie was not mentioned. Ronnie Barkan was described as "Slovak, according to his own information also in possession of Israeli citizenship" and Stavit Sinai as "Romanian, allegedly also an Israeli citizen". [11] (in fact both of them are Israeli Jews)[ citation needed ]

The Jerusalem Post followed suit with an article titled BDS ‘Jew-hater’ convicted for violent assault in Germany. The article reads: "A Berlin court convicted on Monday a Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions activist for assaulting people during a presentation by an Israeli survivor of the Holocaust at Humboldt University in the capital". [12] The article continues to say, "In a dramatic setback to the claim of the BDS campaign that it is a nonviolent initiative targeting the Jewish state, the Berlin court declared Stavit Sinai guilty for her violent conduct".

Officials

Uwe Becker, who is the Hesse commissioner to combat antisemitism and also the deputy mayor of Frankfurt, praised the conviction of Sinai as "an important success against the violent character of BDS and its supporters". "It unmasks the violent character of the BDS movement, because it shows that even Holocaust survivors are attacked by BDS when they speak out for the Jewish state", said Becker. [3] (the Holocaust survivor was neither attacked nor criticized during the incident)

Notes

  1. Dvora Weinstein, or any participants being Holocaust survivors, were not mentioned in the announcement of the event. The announcement did however mention that Aliza Lavie and members of Young Yesh Atid will talk about how Israel was created after the Holocaust.

Related Research Articles

Moshe Yaalon Israeli general and politician

Moshe "Bogie" Ya'alon is an Israeli politician and former Chief of Staff of the Israel Defense Forces, who also served as Israel's Defense Minister under Benjamin Netanyahu from 2013 until his resignation on 20 May 2016. Ya'alon ran for Knesset in 2019 as the number three member of the Blue and White party, a joint list created by the merging of the Israel Resilience Party, led by former IDF chief of staff Benny Gantz, and Yesh Atid, led by Yair Lapid. Ya'alon briefly served as the number 2 on the Yesh Atid-Telem list that was created following the 2020 Israeli legislative election. Ya'alon retired from politics in the lead up to the 2021 election after testing the waters splitting his Telem party from Yesh Atid.

Jewish Museum Berlin Jewish museum in Berlin, Germany

The Jewish Museum Berlin was opened in 2001 and is the largest Jewish museum in Europe. On 3,500 square metres of floor space, the museum presents the history of Jews in Germany from the Middle Ages to the present day, with new focuses and new scenography. It consists of three buildings, two of which are new additions specifically built for the museum by architect Daniel Libeskind. German-Jewish history is documented in the collections, the library and the archive, and is reflected in the museum's program of events.

Yair Lapid Prime Minister of Israel since 2022

Yair Lapid is an Israeli politician and former journalist who has been serving as the 14th prime minister of Israel since 1 July 2022. He previously served as the alternate prime minister of Israel and minister of Foreign Affairs from 2021 to 2022. Lapid is the chairman of the centrist Yesh Atid party, and was Leader of the Opposition from 2020 to 2021, and Minister of Finance from 2013 to 2014.

Elazar Stern Israeli politician and former soldier

Elazar Stern is an Israeli politician and military general. He was a major general (res.) in the Israel Defense Forces, serving as Head of the Manpower Directorate, commander of the IDF Officers Training School, and Chief Education Officer, as well as a combat soldier and commander in the Paratroopers Brigade. He has served as a Member of Knesset for eight years, first, as a member of the Hatnuah party, and then in 2015 he joined the Yesh Atid, and since 2021 is serving as the Minister of Intelligence.

Independent Jewish Voices (Canada) (IJV) is an organization that describes itself as representing Canadian Jews who have a strong commitment to social justice and universal human rights. The organization was founded in 2008 as a result of a national conference called on behalf of the Alliance of Concerned Jewish Canadians.

Germany–Israel relations Bilateral relations

Germany–Israel relations refers to the diplomatic relationship between the Federal Republic of Germany and the State of Israel. After the end of World War II and the Holocaust, relations gradually thawed as West Germany offered to pay reparations to Israel in 1952 and diplomatic relations were officially established in 1965. Nonetheless, a deep mistrust of the German people remained widespread in Israel and the Jewish diaspora communities worldwide for many years after. Relations between East Germany and Israel never materialised. Israel and Germany now maintain a "special relationship" based on shared beliefs, Western values, and a combination of historical perspectives. Among the most important factors in their relations is Nazi Germany's genocide of Jews in Europe during the Holocaust.

Hedy Epstein

Hedy Epstein was a German-born Jewish-American political activist and Holocaust survivor known for her support of the Palestinian cause through the International Solidarity Movement.

Sara M. Roy is an American political economist and scholar. She is a Senior Research Scholar at the Center for Middle Eastern Studies at Harvard University.

Norman Finkelstein American political scientist

Norman Gary Finkelstein is an American political scientist, activist, former professor, and author. His primary fields of research are the Israeli–Palestinian conflict and the politics of the Holocaust. He is a graduate of Binghamton University and received his Ph.D. in political science at Princeton University. He has held faculty positions at Brooklyn College, Rutgers University, Hunter College, New York University, and DePaul University, where he was an assistant professor from 2001 to 2007.

Antisemitic incidents escalated worldwide in frequency and intensity during the Gaza War, and were widely considered to be a wave of reprisal attacks in response to the conflict.

Antisemitism in Canada is the manifestation of hostility, prejudice or discrimination against the Canadian Jewish people or Judaism as a religious, ethnic or racial group. This form of racism has affected Jews since Canada's Jewish community was established in the 18th century.

Inge Deutschkron was a German and Israeli journalist and author. She experienced the Nazi regime as a girl and young woman, living in Berlin first working in a factory, then hiding with her mother.

Gaza Freedom March was a plan for a political march, intended to be non-violent, in 2009 to end the blockade of the Gaza Strip. The march planned to depart on 31 December from Izbet Abed Rabbo, an area devastated during Operation Cast Lead, and head towards Erez, the crossing point to Israel at the northern end of the Gaza Strip. This march was intended to be one year after the Israeli Assault on Gaza which saw over 1,400 Palestinian casualties. The BDS movement stated that the march itself was “inspired by decades of nonviolent Palestinian resistance from the mass popular uprisings of the first Intifada to the West Bank villagers currently resisting the land grab of Israel’s annexationist wall.”

Smadar Lavie

Smadar Lavie is a Mizrahi U.S.-Israeli anthropologist, author, and activist. She specializes in the anthropology of Egypt, Israel and Palestine, emphasizing issues of race, gender and religion. Lavie is a Professor Emerita of Anthropology at the University of California, Davis, and a Visiting Scholar at the Department of Ethnic Studies, University of California, Berkeley. Lavie received her doctorate in Anthropology from the University of California at Berkeley (1989) and spent nine years as Assistant and Associate Professor of Anthropology at the University of California, Davis. She authored The Poetics of Military Occupation, receiving the 1990 Honorable Mention of the Victor Turner Award for Ethnographic Writing, and Wrapped in the Flag of Israel: Mizrahi Single Mothers and Bureaucratic Torture receiving the 2015 Honorable Mention of the Association of Middle East Women's Studies Book Award Competition. Wrapped in the Flag of Israel's first edition was also one of the four finalists in the 2015 Clifford Geertz Book Award Competition of the Society for the Anthropology of Religion. She also co-edited Creativity/Anthropology and Displacement, Diaspora, and Geographies of Identity. Lavie won the American Studies Association's 2009 Gloria Anzaldúa Prize for her article, “Staying Put: Crossing the Palestine-Israel Border with Gloria Anzaldúa,” published in Anthropology and Humanism (2011). In 2013, Smadar Lavie won the “Heart at East” Honor Plaque for lifetime service to Mizraḥi communities in Israel-Palestine.

Early elections for the nineteenth Knesset were held in Israel on 22 January 2013. Public debate over the Tal Law had nearly led to early elections in 2012, but they were aborted at the last moment after Kadima briefly joined the government. The elections were later called in early October 2012 after failure to agree on the budget for the 2013 fiscal year.

Miko Peled

Miko Peled is an Israeli-American activist, author, and karate instructor. He is author of the books The General’s Son: The Journey of an Israeli in Palestine and Injustice: The Story of the Holy Land Foundation Five. He is also an international speaker.

Aliza Lavie Israeli academic and politician

Aliza Lavie is an Israeli academic and politician. She served as a member of the Knesset for Yesh Atid between 2013 and 2019, and is a senior lecturer at the School of Communication at Bar-Ilan University. She is also an author, publicist, media personality, and social activist. Her work focuses on gender issues and multiculturalism in Judaism and Israeli society.

Ali Abunimah Palestinian-American journalist

Ali Hasan Abunimah is a Palestinian-American journalist who has been described as "the leading American proponent of a one-state solution to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict." A resident of Chicago who contributes regularly to publications such as the Chicago Tribune and the Los Angeles Times, he has served as the Vice-President on the Board of Directors of the Arab American Action Network, is a fellow at the Palestine Center, and is a co-founder of The Electronic Intifada website. He has appeared on many television discussion programs on CNN, MSNBC, PBS, and other networks, and in a number of documentaries about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including Collecting Stories from Exile: Chicago Palestinians Remember 1948 (1999).

BOYCOTT! Supporting the Palestinian BDS Call from Within, commonly known as Boycott from Within, is an association of Jewish and Arab Israelis who support the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement. Founded in 2008, it describes itself as following the guiding principles and sharing the goals of the Palestinian BDS movement, as delineated by Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI).

Campaign Against Antisemitism

Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA) is a British non-governmental organisation established in August 2014 by members of the Anglo-Jewish community.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Victory for the Humboldt 3!". Mondoweiss. August 20, 2020.
  2. 1 2 3 barkan, ronnie (August 6, 2020). "Victory in the Humboldt3 Trial". Medium.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 "BDS Activist Convicted of Assault in Berlin Court". Jewish Journal. August 13, 2020.
  4. 1 2 "Humboldt-Uni in Berlin: Knesset-Abgeordnete auf Podium niedergebrüllt". June 23, 2017 via www.welt.de.
  5. 1 2 Zeitung, Berliner. "Humboldt-Uni: Veranstaltung mit Holocaust-Überlebender gestört". Berliner Zeitung.
  6. 1 2 3 e.V, Mideast Freedom Forum Berlin. "Yesh Atid: Mideast Freedom Forum Berlin". www.mideastfreedomforum.org.
  7. "Holocaust-Überlebende "war geschockt" von Störern". www.tagesspiegel.de.
  8. "Israel: Stop Shooting at Gaza Civilians". Human Rights Watch. April 24, 2014.
  9. "Watch: BDS activists storm lecture by MK in Berlin - Europe". Israel National News.
  10. "FDD | Criminal Complaint Filed Against BDS Activists For Disrupting MK's Talk". FDD. July 3, 2017.
  11. "Widerlicher Judenhass in und vor Berliner Gerichtssaal". www.bz-berlin.de.
  12. Benjamin Weinthal: BDS ‘Jew-hater’ convicted for violent assault in Germany, The Jerusalem Post, August 5, 2020