Occupied Territories Bill

Last updated

The Control of Economic Activity (Occupied Territories) Bill 2018 [1] (commonly known as the Occupied Territories Bill [2] ) is a proposed Irish law that would ban and criminalise "trade with and economic support for illegal settlements in territories deemed occupied under international law", most notably Israeli settlements in Israeli-occupied territories. [3] Violators would face fines of up to €250,000 and up to five years in prison. [1] [4]

Contents

Support and opposition

The bill was tabled in the Oireachtas by independent senator Frances Black in January 2018, who stated that "trade in settlement goods sustains injustice". [3] She consulted Sadaka, Trócaire, Christian Aid, Amnesty International, the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU) and the Global Legal Action Network (GLAN) during the drafting process. [5] It was supported by the parties Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin, the Labour Party, Solidarity–People Before Profit, the Green Party, the Social Democrats, and independents. [5] [6] It has also been supported by the Ireland Palestine Solidarity Campaign. [7] [8] The bill has been passed by majorities in both the Seanad (upper house) and the Dáil (lower house). [2] Fianna Fáil foreign affairs spokesperson Niall Collins introduced the bill in the Dáil, [9] saying that his party's support was due to "[increasing concern] about the actions of Israel and its continued and blatant disregard for international law". [10] Sinn Féin's strong showing in the 2020 Irish general election led to speculation that the bill would be advanced by the new government, although the bill was not an election issue. [11] Sinn Fein and Fianna Fail both indicated in their manifestos that they wish to see the Occupied Territories Bill enacted. [12] [13]

The Fine Gael party has opposed the bill. [14] Former Irish Fine Gael politician Alan Shatter, in an opinion piece for the Jerusalem Post noted that, even if the bill is passed, the foreign ministry could decline to implement it. [8] In December 2019, Foreign Minister Simon Coveney, on a trip to Israel, said that the government had "effectively blocked" the bill. [15]

There was renewed impetus in the Bill in 2024 when the government sought legal advice from the Attorney General following the International Court of Justice's ruling on Israel's occupation of the Palestinian territories. [16] Following the Attorney General's advice the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs, Micheál Martin confirmed on 22 October 2024 that the Bill would be "reviewed and amendments prepared in order to bring in into line with the Constitution and EU Law". [17] This move was strongly criticised by the Israeli Ambassador to Ireland, Dana Erlich, who claimed the Bill was a "discriminatory attempt to target Israel" and that the proposed legislation was "anti-Israel". [18] On 31 October 2024, it was reported that a technical blockage of the Bill would be removed to allow it to proceed to committee stage, however the Bill was not passed before the Dáil was suspended sine die on the 7 November 2024 marking the end of the 33rd Dáil. [19] It was later reported that the US Ambassador to Ireland, Claire Cronin, had written to the government expressing concern about the Bill saying that "American companies located in Ireland could be inadvertently caught up in this legislation, and could be damaged as a result of that", however Minister Martin said that the intervention would not stop Ireland from passing the legislation. [20]

At a televised general election debate ahead of the 2024 Irish general election, all ten party leaders voiced support for passing the Occupied Territories Bill. [21] In January 2025, a Programme for Government agreed between Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and a group of Independent TDs committed to "Progress legislation prohibiting goods from Occupied Palestinian Territories following the July 2024 International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion." This was seen as a watering down of the pre-election commitment as it only refers to goods and not services, and falls short of committing to pass or enact the bill. [22] On 19 January 2025, incoming Taoiseach, Micheál Martin confirmed that the existing bill would be scrapped and replaced by new legislation. [23] This move was criticised by the author of the bill, Senator Frances Black, and by campaigners for the bill who protested outside the Dáil later that week. [24]

Potential effects

Purchasing products of the Golan Heights Winery could be punishable by up to five years in jail. Golan Heights Winery 03.jpg
Purchasing products of the Golan Heights Winery could be punishable by up to five years in jail.

Trócaire estimates that, as of 2019, Irish imports from Israeli settlements amount to between €500,000 and €1,500,000 each year, out of €50 million total Irish imports. [26] Ireland has a $1 billion trade surplus with Israel, exporting more than $1.2 billion to the country in 2018. [27]

The bill would ban any goods or services produced, even partially, in the Israeli-occupied territories—including the Golan Heights—or by Israelis who travel, even temporarily, beyond the Green Line. It affects goods or services imported to Ireland as well as the transactions of Irish citizens, Irish companies, and companies with Irish subsidiaries worldwide. [28] The effects of this would cause companies operating in Israel, Ireland and the United States to choose between obeying the Irish law or United States anti-boycott legislation. [4] [29] Especially considering that Ireland is a tax haven for many tech companies, from which the Irish government collects billions in corporate tax, the legislation has the potential to encourage some of them to relocate operations, according to a Bloomberg editorial and the Lawfare Project. [4] [28]

According to foreign minister Simon Coveney—relying on legal advice from the Attorney General of Ireland, Séamus Woulfe—the law could result in Ireland being fined by the European Union for violating EU trade regulation. [8] [30] Woulfe also said that the law would be "quite vague" and impractical to enforce. [30] The Lawfare Project is already preparing a lawsuit against the legislation on the grounds that it violates European Union law. [28] The Ireland Palestine Alliance, Sadaka, noting that one key argument by Coveney and the Government is that the Bill is not compatible with EU law, point to a legal opinion by Takis Tridimas, Professor of EU law at King's College London and practising EU lawyer, that the Bill is compatible with EU law. [31] Other legal authorities, including former Attorney General Michael McDowell argue that the bill would not contravene existing law or international obligations. [6] Trócaire cites two formal legal opinions that the bill is legal and permissible under EU law. [32]

Jackie Goodall of the Ireland Israel Alliance stated that Christian pilgrims could be adversely affected, as taking tours guided by Jews based in the West Bank or buying souvenirs from Jews in the West Bank would be a criminal action. [33]

International reaction

Various American officials contacted Coveney, warning that commercial relations between their countries could be adversely affected by the passage of the bill. [34] Several politicians from Massachusetts—a state with a large Irish-American population—have criticised the bill. This includes criticism from Steven S. Howitt, a state representative, Boston Mayor Marty Walsh, and Mintz Levin chairman Robert Popeo, who characterised the bill as antisemitic. [34] [35] Indiana's Secretary of Commerce, James A. Schellinger, expressed concern that the bill would "unfairly target certain countries or groups of people" and harm Indiana businesses. [34] In a letter signed by ten United States Members of Congress, signatories warned of "potentially severe implications" to Ireland's economy. Fianna Fáil foreign affairs spokesman Niall Collins characterised this as a "veiled threat to Ireland". [36] In response, the Taoiseach Leo Varadkar wrote to members of the House of Representatives emphasizing his government's opposition to the bill. [34] Following the revival of the Bill in 2024 a senior US diplomat had reportedly warned Tánaiste Micheál Martin of "consequences" if the Bill was enacted. [37]

The Israeli embassy in Ireland called the bill "immoral" and stated that "Closing doors will not in any way facilitate Ireland's role and influence." [38] Defence minister Avigdor Lieberman proposed shuttering Israel's embassy in Dublin. [39] Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel, stated that the bill is "utterly contrary to the principles of free trade and justice". [3] Isaac Herzog wrote to Coveney, stating that the legislation "sets a dangerous precedent which is detrimental to the relations between our countries and to the chances of resolving the Israel Palestinian conflict by a negotiated compromise". He warned that the boycott might extend into Israel's 1948 borders, as most Irish people are not familiar with the intricacies of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. [34]

It has been characterised as "BDS bill" in Jewish and Israeli media. [29] [33] [27] An editorial in The Jerusalem Post criticised the omission of other territories considered occupied under international law in the debate over the bill, such as Turkish Cyprus, Western Sahara, and the Crimea. [27] According to Trocaire the legislation would apply to territories where there is a clear international legal consensus on the status of the occupation. Currently only the occupied Palestinian territories have been confirmed as occupied by the International Court of Justice but it allows for other territories to be included so long as there is consensus between the Minister for Foreign Affairs & Trade and both houses of the Oireachtas. [40]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Micheál Martin</span> Taoiseach (2020–2022, 2025–present)

Micheál Martin is an Irish Fianna Fáil politician serving as Taoiseach since January 2025, having previously held the position from 2020 to 2022. Martin was also Tánaiste, Minister for Foreign Affairs, and Minister for Defence from December 2022 to January 2025. He has been Leader of Fianna Fáil since January 2011. He has been a TD for Cork South-Central since 1989. He served as Leader of the Opposition from 2011 to 2020 and held various Cabinet offices under Bertie Ahern and Brian Cowen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government of Ireland</span> Executive authority in Ireland

The Government of Ireland is the executive authority of Ireland, headed by the Taoiseach, the head of government. The government – also known as the cabinet – is composed of ministers, each of whom must be a member of the Oireachtas, which consists of Dáil Éireann and Seanad Éireann. Most ministers have a portfolio of specific responsibilities such as departments or policy areas, although ministers without portfolio can be appointed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Simon Coveney</span> Irish former politician (born 1972)

Simon Coveney is an Irish former Fine Gael politician who served as Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment from 2022 to 2024. He served as deputy leader of Fine Gael from 2017 to 2024. He has been in the cabinet since 2011, holding a range of ministerial portfolios, including as Tánaiste from 2017 to 2020.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marc MacSharry</span> Irish former politician (born 1973)

Marc MacSharry is an Irish former politician who served as a Teachta Dála (TD) for Sligo–Leitrim from 2016 to 2024. From 2002 to 2016, he was a Fianna Fáil Senator on the Industrial and Commercial Panel. He resigned from Fianna Fáil's parliamentary party in September 2021, alleging double standards. He resigned his Fianna Fáil membership in November 2022, amid claims he had bullied colleagues.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael McGrath (Irish politician)</span> Irish politician (born 1976)

Michael McGrath is an Irish Fianna Fáil politician and EU Commissioner for Democracy, Justice, the Rule of Law and Consumer Protection. He served as Minister for Finance from December 2022 to June 2024. He served as Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform from 2020 to 2022. He was a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Cork South-Central constituency from 2007 to 2024.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leo Varadkar</span> Taoiseach (2017–2020, 2022–2024)

Leo Eric Varadkar is an Irish former Fine Gael politician who served as Taoiseach from 2017 to 2020 and from 2022 to 2024, as Tánaiste from 2020 to 2022, and as leader of Fine Gael from 2017 to 2024. A TD for the Dublin West constituency from 2007 to 2024, he held a range of other ministerial positions during his time in government. Described as centre-right economically, he advocated free markets, lower taxes, and welfare reform. On social issues, he supported successful constitutional referendums to legalise same-sex marriage and to liberalise Ireland's abortion laws.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mattie McGrath</span> Irish politician (born 1958)

Matthew McGrath is an Irish independent politician and a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Tipperary South constituency since the 2024 general election, and previously from 2007 to 2016. He was a TD for the Tipperary constituency from 2016 to 2024.

Fine Gael is a political party in Ireland, formed in 1933 as a merger of Cumann na nGaedheal, the National Centre Party, and the Blueshirts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ireland–Israel relations</span> Bilateral relations

Ireland–Israel relations are foreign relations between Ireland and the State of Israel. Relations between the two countries have been complex and generally strained due to their conflicting positions on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.

The Thirtieth Amendment of the Constitution Act 2012 amended the Constitution of Ireland to permit Ireland to ratify the 2012 European Fiscal Compact and to preclude measures taken under the Compact from being held to be inconsistent with the Irish constitution. It was approved by referendum on 31 May 2012, by 60.3% to 39.7%, on a turnout of 50% and was signed into law by President Michael D. Higgins on 27 June 2012.

The 32nd Dáil was elected at the 2016 general election on 26 February and first met at 10.30 a.m. on 10 March 2016. The members of Dáil Éireann, the house of representatives of the Oireachtas (legislature) of Ireland, are known as TDs. It sat with the 25th Seanad as the two Houses of the Oireachtas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jim O'Callaghan</span> Irish politician (born 1968)

Jim O'Callaghan is an Irish Fianna Fáil politician who has served as Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration since January 2025. He has been a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Dublin Bay South constituency since the 2016 general election.

The events surrounding the formation of Ireland's government in 2016 took place during March, April and May of that year, following the general election held on 26 February, which failed to produce an overall majority for any of the country's outgoing political alliances and resulted in a hung parliament.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thirty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland</span> 2018 amendment liberalising abortion laws

The Thirty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution of Ireland is an amendment to the Constitution of Ireland which permits the Oireachtas to legislate for abortion. The constitution had previously prohibited abortion, unless there was a serious risk to the life of the mother.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joe O'Brien (politician)</span> Irish former politician

Joe O'Brien is an Irish Green Party politician who has served as a Minister of State since July 2020. He was a Teachta Dála (TD) for the Dublin Fingal constituency from 2019 to 2024.

The 33rd Dáil was elected at the 2020 general election on 8 February 2020 and first met on 20 February 2020. The members of Dáil Éireann, the house of representatives of the Oireachtas (legislature) of Ireland, are known as TDs. It sat with the 26th Seanad as the Houses of the Oireachtas. There were 160 TDs in the 33rd Dáil, an increase of 2.

There were three governments of the 33rd Dáil, being coalition governments of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Green Party. This followed the 2020 general election to Dáil Éireann held on 8 February, and negotiations on a programme for government that lasted till June. The parties agreed on a rotation, with the two major party leaders alternating as Taoiseach. The makeup of the parties resulted in a centre-right coalition. It was the first time that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have participated in the same government, which Leo Varadkar described as the end of what has often been referred to as Civil War politics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on politics in the Republic of Ireland</span> Consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic on politics in the Republic of Ireland

The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted and affected the political system of the Republic of Ireland, causing suspensions of legislative activities and isolation of multiple politicians due to fears of spreading the virus. Several politicians have tested positive for COVID-19 in 2020, 2021 and 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Katherine Zappone controversy</span> Political scandal in Ireland

The Katherine Zappone controversy, also known as the Merrion Hotel controversy or Merrion Gate, was a political scandal in Ireland involving associates and former colleagues of former Minister for Children Katherine Zappone who attended an outdoor gathering at the Merrion Hotel in Dublin, on 21 July 2021, six days prior to her controversial appointment as UN special envoy.

Dana Erlich is an Israeli diplomat who succeeded Lironne Bar-Sade as Israeli ambassador to Ireland in August 2023. On 22 May 2024, the Israeli Minister of Foreign Affairs, Israel Katz, recalled Israel's Ambassador to Ireland following the recognition of the state of Palestine by the Irish government. On 15 December 2024, the Israeli Minister for Foreign Affairs Gideon Sa'ar announced the closure of the Israeli embassy in Dublin following the Irish government's decision to support South Africa's genocide case against Israel in the International Court of Justice.

References

  1. 1 2 "Control of Economic Activity (Occupied Territories) Bill 2018 – No. 6 of 2018". Houses of the Oireachtas. 24 January 2018. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  2. 1 2 Mulligan, Suzanne (22 March 2019). "Economics should not trump ethics when it comes to Occupied Territories Bill". The Irish Times. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  3. 1 2 3 Holmes, Oliver (11 July 2018). "Irish senate approves ban on products from Israeli settlements". The Guardian . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  4. 1 2 3 Lake, Eli (23 January 2019). "How Much Is Ireland Willing to Pay to Boycott Israel?". Bloomberg News . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  5. 1 2 Black, Frances (22 July 2019). "July Update: Occupied Territories Bill". Senator Frances Black. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  6. 1 2 Finn, Christina (28 November 2018). "Seanad passes Occupied Territories Bill despite government opposition". TheJournal.ie . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  7. ↑ "Irish Parliament Votes on Banning Imports from Illegal Settlements". theGlobePost. 23 January 2019. Retrieved 20 September 2019.
  8. 1 2 3 Shatter, Alan. "Ireland's misguided 'settler bill' ignores Israel's security concerns". Jerusalem Post . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  9. ↑ O'Halloran, Marie (24 January 2019). "TDs back controversial occupied territories Bill, Independent Ministers abstain". The Irish Times . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  10. ↑ Oster, Marcy (24 January 2019). "Ireland advances bill on banning exports from 'occupied territories'". Jewish Telegraphic Agency . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  11. ↑ Harkov, Lahav (9 February 2020). "Will Sinn Féin's ascent hurt Israel-Ireland relations? – analysis". The Jerusalem Post . Retrieved 15 March 2020.
  12. ↑ "Ireland's biggest parties vow to ban goods made in illegal Israeli settlements". Middle East Eye. 3 February 2020. Retrieved 18 March 2020.
  13. ↑ "Settlement-boycotting parties win big in Irish election". Jerusalem Post. 10 February 2020. Retrieved 18 March 2020.
  14. ↑ "Varadkar resigns as Irish government enters stalemate report". Middle East Eye. 20 February 2020. Retrieved 18 March 2020.
  15. ↑ Ahren, Raphael (3 December 2019). "Visiting Israel, Irish FM says he's open for 'new thinking' on peace process". Times of Israel. Retrieved 3 December 2019.
  16. ↑ https://www.thejournal.ie/occupied-territories-bill-could-come-before-dail-next-week-6515572-Oct2024/
  17. ↑ https://www.gov.ie/en/press-release/dad83-statement-by-tanaiste-micheal-martin-on-the-occupied-territories-bill/
  18. ↑ https://www.thejournal.ie/israeli-ambassador-occupied-territories-bill-6523526-Oct2024/
  19. ↑ https://www.rte.ie/news/politics/2024/1030/1478293-occupied-territories-bill/
  20. ↑ https://www.thejournal.ie/micheal-martin-general-election-interview-6536492-Nov2024/
  21. ↑ http://www.rte.ie/news/election-24/2024/1118/1481512-election-tracker/
  22. ↑ https://www.thejournal.ie/programme-for-government-surprises-6594783-Jan2025/
  23. ↑ https://www.irishtimes.com/politics/2025/01/19/occupied-territories-bill-to-be-replaced-by-new-legislation-tanaiste-confirms/
  24. ↑ https://www.rte.ie/news/2025/0122/1492264-protest-occupied-territories-bill/
  25. ↑ Steven, Jaffe (7 February 2019). "I would be a criminal under proposed Irish bill to boycott Israel". The News Letter . Retrieved 19 September 2019.
  26. ↑ Badillo, Anna (23 January 2019). "Irish Parliament Votes on Banning Imports from Illegal Settlements". The Globe Post . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  27. 1 2 3 "The nefarious Irish bill". The Jerusalem Post. 3 December 2019. Retrieved 15 March 2020.
  28. 1 2 3 "Lawfare Project taking legal action against aggressive anti-Israel boycott legislation in Ireland". The Lawfare Project . 11 July 2018. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  29. 1 2 "Irish BDS bill anti- Semitic, bad for Ireland". San Diego Jewish World. 4 February 2019. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  30. 1 2 "Attorney General warns Israeli goods bill would be 'impractical' to enforce". Irish Legal News. 4 June 2020. Retrieved 8 June 2020.
  31. ↑ "The Occupied Territories Bill in Dáil Éireann". Sadaka. Retrieved 23 September 2019.
  32. ↑ "What you need to know about the Occupied Territories Bill". trocaire. 10 July 2018. Retrieved 20 September 2019.
  33. 1 2 "'Potentially massive losses' warned if Ireland approves BDS bill". Jewish News . 28 May 2019. Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  34. 1 2 3 4 5 McDermott, Stephen (17 May 2019). "Government told that Occupied Territories Bill could affect immigration status of Irish in US". TheJournal.ie . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  35. ↑ Cotter, Sean Phillip (23 January 2019). "Boston leaders rally against Irish proposal to ban goods from Israeli settlements". Boston Herald . Retrieved 19 September 2019.
  36. ↑ O'Halloran, Marie (27 February 2019). "Tánaiste declines to respond to US Congress 'veiled threat'". The Irish Times . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  37. ↑ https://www.ontheditch.com/us-ambassador-warned/
  38. ↑ Finn, Christina (3 July 2018). "Fianna Fáil to support trade ban with lands held by Israel, but embassy calls it 'immoral'". TheJournal.ie . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  39. ↑ Weiss, Mark (13 July 2018). "Israelis react to Seanad vote: 'We can manage happily without Ireland'". The Irish Times . Retrieved 17 September 2019.
  40. ↑ "What you need to know about the Occupied Territories Bill". 4 December 2019. Retrieved 21 March 2020.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.