The Allied military phonetic spelling alphabets prescribed the words that are used to represent each letter of the alphabet, when spelling other words out loud, letter-by-letter, and how the spelling words should be pronounced for use by the Allies of World War II. They are not a "phonetic alphabet" in the sense in which that term is used in phonetics, i.e. they are not a system for transcribing speech sounds.
The Allied militaries – primarily the US and the UK – had their own radiotelephone spelling alphabets which had origins back to World War I and had evolved separately in the different services in the two countries. For communication between the different countries and different services specific alphabets were mandated.
The last WWII spelling alphabet continued to be used through the Korean War, being replaced in 1956 as a result of both countries adopting the ICAO/ITU Radiotelephony Spelling Alphabet, with the NATO members calling their usage the "NATO Phonetic Alphabet".
During WWII, the Allies had defined terminology to describe the scope of communications procedures among different services and nations. A summary of the terms used was published in a post-WWII NATO memo: [1]
Thus, the Combined Communications Board (CCB), created in 1941, derived a spelling alphabet that was mandated for use when any US military branch was communicating with any British military branch; when operating without any British forces, the Joint Army/Navy spelling alphabet was mandated for use whenever the US Army and US Navy were communicating in joint operations; if the US Army was operating on its own, it would use its own spelling alphabet, in which some of the letters were identical to the other spelling alphabets and some completely different.
The US and UK began to coordinate calling alphabets by the military during World War II and by 1943 they had settled on a streamline communications that became known as the CCB. Both nations had previous independently developed alphabet naming system dating back to World War I. Subsequently, this second world war era letter naming became accepted as standard by the ICAO in 1947.
After the creation of NATO in 1949, modifications began to take place. An alternative name for the ICAO spelling alphabet, "NATO phonetic alphabet", exists because it appears in Allied Tactical Publication ATP-1, Volume II: Allied Maritime Signal and Maneuvering Book used by all navies of NATO, which adopted a modified form of the International Code of Signals . Because the latter allows messages to be spelled via flags or Morse code, it naturally named the code words used to spell out messages by voice its "phonetic alphabet". The name NATO phonetic alphabet became widespread because the signals used to facilitate the naval communications and tactics of NATO have become global. [2] However, ATP-1 is marked NATO Confidential (or the lower NATO Restricted) so it is not available publicly. Nevertheless, a NATO unclassified version of the document is provided to foreign, even hostile, militaries, even though they are not allowed to make it available publicly. The spelling alphabet is now also defined in other unclassified international military documents. [3] The NATO alphabet appeared in some United States Air Force Europe publications during the Cold War. A particular example was the Ramstein Air Base Telephone Directory, published between 1969 and 1973 (currently out of print). The US and NATO versions had differences, and the translation was provided as a convenience. Differences included Alfa, Bravo and Able, Baker for the first two letters.
The NATO phonetic spelling alphabet was first adopted on January 1, 1956, while the ICAO radiotelephony spelling alphabet was still undergoing final changes. [4]
Letter | 1943 CCB (US-UK) [5] [6] [7] (same as 1947 ICAO) | NATO | |
---|---|---|---|
Jan 1 – Feb 29, 1956 [8] | March 1, 1956 – present [9] | ||
A | Able | Alfa | |
B | Baker | Bravo | |
C | Charlie | ||
D | Dog | Delta | |
E | Easy | Echo | |
F | Fox | Foxtrot | |
G | George | Golf | |
H | How | Hotel | |
I | Item | India | |
J | Jig | Juliett | |
K | King | Kilo | |
L | Love | Lima | |
M | Mike | ||
N | Nan | Nectar | November |
O | Oboe | Oscar | |
P | Peter | Papa | |
Q | Queen | Quebec | |
R | Roger | Romeo | |
S | Sugar | Sierra | |
T | Tare | Tango | |
U | Uncle | Uniform | |
V | Victor | ||
W | William | Whiskey | |
X | Xray | X-ray | |
Y | Yoke | Yankee | |
Z | Zebra | Zulu | |
0 | Zero | ||
1 | Wun | ||
2 | Too | ||
3 | Thuh-ree | ||
4 | Fo-wer | ||
5 | Fi-yiv | ||
6 | Six | ||
7 | Seven | ||
8 | Ate | ||
9 | Niner |
Letter | 1904 [10] [11] [12] | 1904 [13] | 1914 [10] | 1914–1918 [13] | 1918 [13] | 1956–present [9] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | Ack | Ack | Ack | Apples | Ack | Alfa |
B | Beer | Beer | Beer | Butter | Beer | Bravo |
C | C | Cork | C | Charlie | Cork | Charlie |
D | D | Don | Don | Duff | Don | Delta |
E | E | Eddy | E | Edward | Eddy | Echo |
F | F | Freddy | F | Freddie | Freddy | Foxtrot |
G | G | George | G | George | George | Golf |
H | H | Harry | H | Harry | Harry | Hotel |
I | I | Ink | I | Ink | Ink | India |
J | J | Jug | J | Johnnie | Jug | Juliett |
K | K | King | K | King | King | Kilo |
L | L | London | L | London | London | Lima |
M | Emma | Emma | Emma | Monkey | Emma | Mike |
N | N | Nuts | N | Nuts | Nuts | November |
O | O | Orange | O | Orange | Orange | Oscar |
P | Pip | Pip | Pip | Pudding | Pip | Papa |
Q | Q | Quad | Q | Queenie | Quad | Quebec |
R | R | Robert | R | Robert | Robert | Romeo |
S | Esses | Esses | Esses | Sugar | Esses | Sierra |
T | Toc | Toc | Toc | Tommy | Toc | Tango |
U | U | Uncle | U | Uncle | Uncle | Uniform |
V | Vic | Vic | Vic | Vinegar | Vic | Victor |
W | W | William | W | William | William | Whisky |
X | X | Xerxes | X | X-Ray | Xerxes | X-ray |
Y | Y | Yellow | Y | Yorker | Yellow | Yankee |
Z | Z | Zebra | Z | Zebra | Zebra | Zulu |
Letter | 1914–1918 [10] | 1921 [13] | 1956–present [9] |
---|---|---|---|
A | Apples | Ac | Alfa |
B | Butter | Beer | Bravo |
C | Charlie | Charlie | Charlie |
D | Duff | Don | Delta |
E | Edward | Edward | Echo |
F | Freddy | Fox | Foxtrot |
G | George | George | Golf |
H | Harry | How | Hotel |
I | Ink | Ink | India |
J | Johnnie | Johnnie | Juliett |
K | King | King | Kilo |
L | London | Love | Lima |
M | Monkey | Monkey | Mike |
N | Nuts | Nan | November |
O | Orange | Orange | Oscar |
P | Pudding | Pip | Papa |
Q | Queenie | Queen | Quebec |
R | Robert | Robert | Romeo |
S | Sugar | Sugar | Sierra |
T | Tommy | Toc | Tango |
U | Uncle | Uncle | Uniform |
V | Vinegar | Vic | Victor |
W | William | William | Whisky |
X | Xerxes | X-ray | X-ray |
Y | Yellow | Yoke | Yankee |
Z | Zebra | Zebra | Zulu |
The RAF radiotelephony spelling alphabet, sometimes referred to as the "RAF Phonetic Alphabet", was used by the British Royal Air Force (RAF) to aid communication after the take-up of radio, especially to spell out aircraft identification letters, e.g. "H for Harry", "G for George", etc. Several alphabets were used, before being superseded by the adoption of the NATO/ICAO radiotelephony alphabet.
During World War I battle lines were often static and forces were commonly linked by wired telephone networks. Signals were weak on long wire runs and field telephone systems often used a single wire with earth return, which made them subject to inadvertent and deliberate interference. Spelling alphabets were introduced for wire telephony as well as on the newer radio voice equipment. [14]
The British Army and the Royal Navy had developed their own quite separate spelling alphabets. The Navy system was a full alphabet, starting: Apples, Butter, Charlie, Duff, Edward, but the RAF alphabet was based on that of the "signalese" of the army signallers. This was not a full alphabet, but differentiated only the letters most frequently misunderstood: Ack (originally "Ak"), Beer (or Bar), C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, eMma, N, O, Pip, Q, R, eSses, Toc, U, Vic, W, X, Y, Z.
By 1921, the RAF "Telephony Spelling Alphabet" had been adopted by all three armed services, and was then made mandatory for UK civil aviation, as announced in Notice to Airmen Number 107. [15]
In 1956, the NATO phonetic alphabet was adopted due to the RAF's wide commitments with NATO and worldwide sharing of civil aviation facilities. [16]
Letter | 1921–1942 [15] [17] | 1942–1955 [16] [13] | 1956–present [9] |
---|---|---|---|
A | Apple | Able/Affirm | Alfa |
B | Beer | Baker | Bravo |
C | Charlie | Charlie | Charlie |
D | Don | Dog | Delta |
E | Edward | Easy | Echo |
F | Freddie | Fox | Foxtrot |
G | George | George | Golf |
H | Harry | How | Hotel |
I | Ink | Item/Interrogatory | India |
J | Jug/Johnnie | Jig/Johnny | Juliett |
K | King | King | Kilo |
L | London | Love | Lima |
M | Monkey | Mike | Mike |
N | Nuts [a] | Nan/Nab/Negat/Nectar | November |
O | Orange | Oboe | Oscar |
P | Pip | Peter/Prep | Papa |
Q | Queen | Queen | Quebec |
R | Robert | Roger | Romeo |
S | Sugar | Sugar | Sierra |
T | Toc | Tare | Tango |
U | Uncle | Uncle | Uniform |
V | Vic [b] | Victor | Victor |
W | William | William | Whiskey |
X | X-ray | X-ray | X-ray |
Y | Yorker | Yoke | Yankee |
Z | Zebra | Zebra | Zulu |
a The choice of Nuts following Monkey is probably[ citation needed ] from "monkey nuts" (peanuts); likewise Orange and Pip can be similarly paired, as in "orange pip".
b "Vic" subsequently entered the English language as the standard "Vee"-shaped flight pattern of three aircraft.
Letter | 1916 Signal Book [18] 1916–1939 | FM 24-5 [19] 1939–1941 | FM 24-5 [20] 1941–1943 | FM 24-12 [21] 1943–1955 | ICAO 1956–present [9] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | Able | Afirm | Afirm | Able | Alfa |
B | Boy | Baker | Baker | Baker | Bravo |
C | Cast | Cast | Cast | Charlie | Charlie |
D | Dock | Dog | Dog | Dog | Delta |
E | Easy | Easy | Easy | Easy | Echo |
F | Fox | Fox | Fox | Fox | Foxtrot |
G | George | George | George | George | Golf |
H | Have | Hypo | Hypo | How | Hotel |
I | Item | Inter | Inter† | Item | India |
J | Jig | Jig | Jig | Jig | Juliett |
K | King | King | King | King | Kilo |
L | Love | Love | Love | Love | Lima |
M | Mike | Mike | Mike | Mike | Mike |
N | Nan | Negat | Negat | Nan | November |
O | Opal | Option | Option | Oboe | Oscar |
P | Pup | Prep | Prep | Peter | Papa |
Q | Quack | Queen | Queen | Queen | Quebec |
R | Rush | Roger | Roger | Roger | Romeo |
S | Sail | Sail | Sail | Sugar | Sierra |
T | Tare | Tare | Tare | Tare | Tango |
U | Unit | Unit | Unit | Uncle | Uniform |
V | Vice | Victor | Victor | Victor | Victor |
W | Watch | William | William | William | Whiskey |
X | X-ray | Xray | Xray | Xray | X-ray |
Y | Yoke | Yoke | Yoke | Yoke | Yankee |
Z | Zed | Zed | Zed | Zebra | Zulu |
0 | Zero | Zero | Zero | Zero | |
1 | Wun | Wun | Wun | Wun | |
2 | Too | Too | Too | Too | |
3 | Th-r-ee | Th-r-ee | Thuh-ree | Tree | |
4 | Fo-wer | Fo-wer | Fo-wer | Fow-er | |
5 | Fi-iv | Fi-yiv | Fi-yiv | Fife | |
6 | Siks | Siks | Six | Siks | |
7 | Sev-ven | Sev-ven | Seven | Seven | |
8 | Ate | Ate | Ate | Ate | |
9 | Ni-yen | Ni-yen | Niner | Niner |
† 'Interrogatory' was used in place of 'Inter' in joint Army/Navy Operations.
The US Navy's first phonetic spelling alphabet was not used for radio, but was instead used on the deck of ships "in calling out flags to be hoisted in a signal". There were two alternative alphabets used, which were almost completely different from each other, with only the code word "Xray" in common. [22]
The US Navy's first radiotelephony phonetic spelling alphabet was published in 1913, in the Naval Radio Service's Handbook of Regulations developed by Captain William H. G. Bullard. The Handbook's procedures were described in the November 1917 edition of Popular Science Monthly. [23]
Letter | 1908 [22] | 1913–1926 [25] | 1927–1937 [26] | 1938 | WWII [27] | ICAO 1956–present [9] | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | Actor | Ash | Able | Afirm | Afirm | AFIRM | Alfa |
B | Baker | Back | Boy | Baker | Baker | BAKER | Bravo |
C | Canteen | Chain | Cast | Cast | Cast | CHARLIE | Charlie |
D | Diver | Dog | Dog | Dog | Dog | DOG | Delta |
E | Eagle | Egg | Easy | Easy | Easy | EASY | Echo |
F | Fisher | Fox | Fox | Fox | Fox | FOX | Foxtrot |
G | Gangway | Gig | George | George | George | GEORGE | Golf |
H | Halliard | Horse | Have | Hypo | Hypo | HOW | Hotel |
I | Insect | Ice | Item | Int | Int | INT | India |
J | Jockey | Jake | Jig | Jig | Jig | JIG | Juliett |
K | Knapsack | King | King | King | King | KING | Kilo |
L | Lugger | Lash | Love | Love | Love | LOVE | Lima |
M | Musket | Mule | Mike | Mike | Mike | MIKE | Mike |
N | Neptune | Net | Nan | Negat | Negat | NEGAT | November |
O | Oyster | Oak | Oboe | Option | Option | OPTION | Oscar |
P | Pistol | Page | Pup | Prep | Prep | PREP | Papa |
Q | Quadrant | Quail | Quack | Quack | Queen | QUEEN | Quebec |
R | Reefer | Raft | Rush | Roger | Roger | ROGER | Romeo |
S | Shipmate | Scout | Sail | Sail | Sail | SUGAR | Sierra |
T | Topsail | Tide | Tare | Tare | Tare | TARE | Tango |
U | Unload | Use | Unit | Unit | Unit | UNCLE | Uniform |
V | Vessel | Vast | Vice | Vice | Victor | VICTOR | Victor |
W | Windage | Winch | Watch | William | William | WILLIAM | Whiskey |
X | Xray | Xray | X-ray | X-ray | X-ray | XRAY | X-ray |
Y | Yeoman | Yacht | Yoke | Yoke | Yoke | YOKE | Yankee |
Z | Zebra | Zoo | Zed | Zed | Zed | ZEBRA | Zulu |
The Joint Army/Navy (JAN) spelling alphabet was developed by the Joint Board on November 13, 1940, and it took effect on March 1, 1941. [28] [29] It was reformulated by the CCB following the entrance of the US into World War II by the CCB "Methods and Procedures" committee, [29] and was used by all branches of the United States Armed Forces until the promulgation of its replacement, the ICAO spelling alphabet (Alfa, Bravo, etc.), in 1956. Before the JAN phonetic alphabet, each branch of the armed forces had used its own radio alphabet, leading to difficulties in interbranch communication.
The US Army used this alphabet in modified form, along with the British Army and Canadian Army from 1943 onward, with "Sugar" replacing "Sail".
The JAN spelling alphabet was used to name Atlantic basin storms during hurricane season from 1947 to 1952, before being replaced with a new system of using female names.
Vestiges of the JAN spelling system remain in use in the US Navy, in the form of Material Conditions of Readiness, used in damage control. Dog, William, X-Ray, Yoke, and Zebra all reference designations of fittings, hatches, or doors. [30] The response "Roger" for "· – ·" or "R", to mean "received", also derives from this alphabet.
The names Able to Fox were also widely used in the early days of hexadecimal digital encoding of text, for speaking the hexadecimal digits A to F (equivalent to decimal 10 to 15), although the written form was simply the capital letters A to F.
Letter | Joint Army/Navy [31] 1941–1943 | CCB [5] 1943–1955 | ICAO 1956–present [9] |
---|---|---|---|
A | Able | ABLE | Alfa |
B | Baker | BAKER | Bravo |
C | Charlie | CHARLIE | Charlie |
D | Dog | DOG | Delta |
E | Easy | EASY | Echo |
F | Fox | FOX | Foxtrot |
G | George | GEORGE | Golf |
H | How | HOW | Hotel |
I | Item (or Interrogatory) [32] | ITEM | India |
J | Jig | JIG | Juliett |
K | King | KING | Kilo |
L | Love | LOVE | Lima |
M | Mike | MIKE | Mike |
N | Nan | NAN | November |
O | Oboe | OBOE | Oscar |
P | Peter | PETER | Papa |
Q | Queen | QUEEN | Quebec |
R | Roger | ROGER | Romeo |
S | Sail/Sugar | SUGAR | Sierra |
T | Tare | TARE | Tango |
U | Uncle | UNCLE | Uniform |
V | Victor | VICTOR | Victor |
W | William | WILLIAM | Whisky |
X | X-ray | XRAY | X-ray |
Y | Yoke | YOKE | Yankee |
Z | Zebra | ZEBRA | Zulu |
0 | Zero | Zero | Zero |
1 | One | Wun | Wun |
2 | Two | Too | Too |
3 | Three | Thuh-ree | Tree |
4 | Four | Fo-wer | Fower |
5 | Five | Fi-yiv | Fife |
6 | Six | Six | Siks |
7 | Seven | Seven | Seven |
8 | Eight | Ate | Ate |
9 | Nine | Niner | Niner |
The International Radiotelephony Spelling Alphabet or simply Radiotelephony Spelling Alphabet, commonly known as the NATO phonetic alphabet, is the most widely used set of clear-code words for communicating the letters of the Roman alphabet. Technically a radiotelephonic spelling alphabet, it goes by various names, including NATO spelling alphabet, ICAO phonetic alphabet and ICAO spelling alphabet. The ITU phonetic alphabet and figure code is a rarely used variant that differs in the code words for digits.
A radiotelephone, abbreviated RT, is a radio communication system for conducting a conversation; radiotelephony means telephony by radio. It is in contrast to radiotelegraphy, which is radio transmission of telegrams (messages), or television, transmission of moving pictures and sound. The term is related to radio broadcasting, which transmit audio one way to listeners. Radiotelephony refers specifically to two-way radio systems for bidirectional person-to-person voice communication between separated users, such as CB radio or marine radio. In spite of the name, radiotelephony systems are not necessarily connected to or have anything to do with the telephone network, and in some radio services, including GMRS, interconnection is prohibited.
The APCO phonetic alphabet, a.k.a. LAPD radio alphabet, is the term for an old competing spelling alphabet to the ICAO radiotelephony alphabet, defined by the Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials-International from 1941 to 1974, that is used by the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) and other local and state law enforcement agencies across the state of California and elsewhere in the United States. It is the "over the air" communication used for properly understanding a broadcast of letters in the form of easily understood words. Despite often being called a "phonetic alphabet", it is not a phonetic alphabet for transcribing phonetics.
The radiotelephony message PAN-PAN is the international standard urgency signal that someone aboard a boat, ship, aircraft, or other vehicle uses to declare that they need help and that the situation is urgent, but for the time being, does not pose an immediate danger to anyone's life or to the vessel itself. This is referred to as a state of "urgency". This is distinct from a mayday call, which means that there is imminent danger to life or to the continued viability of the vessel itself. Radioing "pan-pan" informs potential rescuers that an urgent problem exists, whereas "mayday" calls on them to drop all other activities and immediately begin a rescue.
A signal strength and readability report is a standardized format for reporting the strength of the radio signal and the readability (quality) of the radiotelephone (voice) or radiotelegraph signal transmitted by another station as received at the reporting station's location and by their radio station equipment. These report formats are usually designed for only one communications mode or the other, although a few are used for both telegraph and voice communications. All but one of these signal report formats involve the transmission of numbers.
Radiotelephony procedure includes various techniques used to clarify, simplify and standardize spoken communications over two-way radios, in use by the armed forces, in civil aviation, police and fire dispatching systems, citizens' band radio (CB), and amateur radio.
In current military use, combined operations are operations conducted by forces of two or more allied nations acting together for the accomplishment of a common strategy, a strategic and operational and sometimes tactical cooperation. Interaction between units and formations of the land, naval and air forces, or the cooperation between military and civilian authorities in peacekeeping or disaster relief operations is known as joint operations or interoperability capability.
The International Code of Signals (INTERCO) is an international system of signals and codes for use by vessels to communicate important messages regarding safety of navigation and related matters. Signals can be sent by flaghoist, signal lamp ("blinker"), flag semaphore, radiotelegraphy, and radiotelephony. The International Code is the most recent evolution of a wide variety of maritime flag signalling systems.
In broadcasting and radio communications, a call sign is a unique identifier for a transmitter station. A call sign can be formally assigned by a government agency, informally adopted by individuals or organizations, or even cryptographically encoded to disguise a station's identity.
The Combined Communications-Electronics Board (CCEB) is a five-nation joint military communications-electronics (C-E) organisation whose mission is the coordination of any military C-E matter that is referred to it by a member nation. The member nations of the CCEB are Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The CCEB is the Sponsoring Authority for all Allied Communications Publications (ACPs). ACPs are raised and issued under common agreement between the member nations. The CCEB Board consists of a senior Command, Control, Communications and Computer (C4) representative from each of the member nations.
A Radio code is any code that is commonly used over a telecommunication system such as Morse code, brevity codes and procedure words.
A spelling alphabet is a set of words used to represent the letters of an alphabet in oral communication, especially over a two-way radio or telephone. The words chosen to represent the letters sound sufficiently different from each other to clearly differentiate them. This avoids any confusion that could easily otherwise result from the names of letters that sound similar, except for some small difference easily missed or easily degraded by the imperfect sound quality of the apparatus. For example, in the Latin alphabet, the letters B, P, and D sound similar and could easily be confused, but the words "bravo", "papa" and "delta" sound completely different, making confusion unlikely.
A radiogram is a formal written message transmitted by radio. Also known as a radio telegram or radio telegraphic message, radiograms use a standardized message format, form and radiotelephone and/or radiotelegraph transmission procedures. These procedures typically provide a means of transmitting the content of the messages without including the names of the various headers and message sections, so as to minimize the time needed to transmit messages over limited and/or congested radio channels. Various formats have been used historically by maritime radio services, military organizations, and Amateur Radio organizations.
Procedure words are words or phrases limited to radio telephone procedure used to facilitate communication by conveying information in a condensed standard verbal format. Prowords are voice versions of the much older procedural signs for Morse code which were first developed in the 1860s for Morse telegraphy, and their meaning is identical.
A plain-language radio check is the means of requesting and giving a signal strength and readability report for radiotelephony (voice) communications, and is the direct equivalent to the QSA and QRK code used to give the same report in radiotelegraph communications. SINPEMFO code is the voice signal reporting format developed by the ITU in 1959, but sees little use outside of shortwave listeners.
16-line message format, or Basic Message Format, is the standard military radiogram format for the manner in which a paper message form is transcribed through voice, Morse code, or TTY transmission formats. The overall structure of the message has three parts: HEADING, TEXT, and ENDING. This heading is further divided into procedure, preamble, address, and prefix. Each format line contains pre-defined content. An actual message may have fewer than 16 actual lines, or far more than 16, because some lines are skipped in some delivery methods, and a long message may have a TEXT portion that is longer than 16 lines by itself.
The QSA code and QRK code are interrelated and complementary signal reporting codes for use in wireless telegraphy. An enhanced format, SINPO code, was published in the ITU Radio Regulations, Geneva, 1959, but is longer and unwieldy for use in the fast pace of Morse code communications.
Allied Communication Procedures is the set of manuals and supplements published by the Combined Communications Electronics Board that prescribe the methods and standards to be used while conducting visual, audible, radiotelegraph, and radiotelephone communications within NATO member nations. These procedures relate to procedure words, radiotelephony procedure, Allied Military phonetic spelling alphabets, plain language radio checks, the 16-line message format (radiogram), and others.
Allied Communications Publications are documents developed by the Combined Communications-Electronics Board and NATO, which define the procedures for communicating in computer messaging, radiotelephony, radiotelegraph, radioteletype (RATT), air-to-ground signalling, and other forms of communications used by the armed forces of the five CCEB member countries and/or NATO.