Alternative historical interpretations of Joan of Arc

Last updated
Joan of Arc drawing by Clement de Fauquembergue, 1429. The artist never saw Joan. Contemporaine afb jeanne d arc.png
Joan of Arc drawing by Clément de Fauquembergue, 1429. The artist never saw Joan.

There are a number of revisionist theories about Joan of Arc which contradict the established account of her life. These include the theories she was an illegitimate royal child; that she was not burned at the stake; that most of her story is a fabrication; and that she escaped death at the stake. These theories have not gained significant acceptance among academic historians.

Contents

These alternate historical interpretations are distinct from avowedly fictional representations of Joan in art, literature, and popular culture.

Royal bastard

Coat of Arms of Domremy-la-Pucelle.svg
Arms granted to Joan of Arc and her family by Charles VII of France
Batonsinister.jpg
An actual baton sinister from an old heraldry manual. In 1805 Pierre Caze claimed the sword in Joan's coat of arms was a baton of bastardy.

In 1819, Pierre Caze published La Vérité sur Jeanne d'Arc, which argued that Joan of Arc was the illegitimate daughter of the Queen, Isabeau of Bavaria, and Duke Louis of Orléans. [2] According to Caze's reasoning, the queen hid their daughter in the countryside with the d'Arc family. When Joan of Arc met the future King Charles VII, she would have given him a private sign that she was his half-sister. It has been theorized that the coat of arms he later granted her included a sword as a baton of bastardy.

Although this would provide an explanation for how she gained the trust of Charles VII in early 1429, this hypothesis has too many other difficulties to be taken seriously. Foremost among them is that the duke of Orléans died on November 23, 1407. Isabeau of Bavaria delivered a son on November 10, 1407. The likelihood of conceiving a daughter in the interim is exceedingly small. Assuming Joan of Arc was born the following year, she would have been 23 years old at her trial in 1431. She estimated her own age at 19.

Furthermore, if the sword in Joan of Arc's coat of arms represented a baton of bastardy, then it would be unique in heraldry; it is inconsistent with the laws of heraldry that a sword party per pale (see "Coat of Arms of Jeanne d'Arc" [3] ) be considered a sign of illegitimacy. It would also mean that Joan of Arc and several witnesses perjured themselves about her birth. In the words of Regine Pernoud and Marie-Veronique Clin, "Yet amateur historians still insist that all these people – as well as Charles VII, the duke of Alençon, Dunois, Bertrand de Poulengy – carried out an intricate plot to disguise Joan's authentic royal parents. This thesis lacks credible documentation." [4]

Survival

Several impostors claimed to be Joan of Arc after the execution date. The most successful was Jeanne (or Claude) des Armoises. Claude des Armoises married the knight Robert des Armoises and claimed to be Joan of Arc in 1436. She gained the support of Joan of Arc's brothers. She carried on the charade until 1440, gaining gifts and subsidies. One chronicle states, "In this year there came a young girl who said she was the Maid of France and played her role so well that many were duped by her, and especially the greatest nobles."

Some modern authors attempt to revive this claim by asserting that some other victim was substituted for Joan of Arc at the stake. The likelihood of this is extremely thin, since the trial of nullification records sworn testimony from numerous witnesses who were present at the execution and confirmed her identity. [5] [6]

E. Cobham Brewer wrote in his 1870 volume Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable :

M. Octave Delepierre has published a pamphlet, called Doute Historique, to deny the tradition that Joan of Arc was burnt at Rouen for sorcery. He cites a document discovered by Father Vignier in the seventeenth century, in the archives of Metz, to prove that she became the wife of Sieur des Armoise, with whom she resided at Metz, and became the mother of a family. Vignier subsequently found in the family muniment-chest the contract of marriage between "Robert des Armoise, knight, and Jeanne D'Arcy, surnamed the Maid of Orleans." In 1740 there were found in the archives of the Maison de Ville (Orléans) records of several payments to certain messengers from Joan to her brother John, bearing the dates 1435, 1436. There is also the entry of a presentation from the council of the city to the Maid, for her services at the siege (dated 1439). M. Delepierre has brought forward a host of other documents to corroborate the same fact, and show that the tale of her martyrdom was invented to throw odium on the English. [7]

The revisionist theory described by Brewer has been criticized on a number of grounds, including the significant number of eyewitnesses to Joan's execution, as well as the fact that Claude des Armoises subsequently confessed before a number of witnesses on multiple occasions to being an impostor.

Graeme Donald also argues that Joan was not executed for witchcraft and that much of the story of Joan of Arc is a myth. He says there are no accounts or portraits of Joan of Arc's victories during her time period, nor is she mentioned as a commander of the French army by Chastellain. He states that the most definitive work of her trial and rehabilitation trial, which are the basis for her story, was created by Jules Quicherat between 1841 and 1849, after he discovered a cache of documents relating to her trial. [8] Quicherat did compile one of the first valid edition of her trial and the rehabilitation trial proceedings, but the existence of the records of Joan's trial and retrial were known before Quicherat collected and collated them. [9] The original sources of the rehabilitation sources have been further verified, edited and amplified by Pierre DuParc's translation published in 1988. [10]

Witch

In 1921, anthropologist Margaret Murray argued that Joan was correctly identified as a witch by the religious authorities who condemned her to death, but that what they called witchcraft was, in fact, a survival of the pagan "old religion" of pre-Christian Europe. She claimed that Joan and Gilles de Rais were leaders of a pagan witch-cult that was a rival to the Catholic church. [11] Joan was the "incarnate God" of a cult derived from the worship of the virgin huntress Diana. [12] Murray claimed that this was still the religion of most of the common people and the reason Joan inspired the ordinary soldier:

The men-at-arms, drawn from the lower orders, followed without hesitation one whom they believed to have been sent by their God, while the whole army was commanded by Marshal Gilles de Rais, who apparently tried to belong to both religions at once. [13]

According to Murray, the destruction of Joan was orchestrated by the Catholic Church itself and was its first major victory against the surviving pagan cult:

The fifteenth century marks the first great victories of the Church. Beginning with the trials in Lorraine in 1408 the Church moved triumphantly against Joan of Arc and her followers in 1431, against Gilles de Rais and his coven in 1440, against the witches of Brescia in 1457. [14]

Murray's views have been dismissed by later scholars as pseudo-historical fantasy. [15] One historian called her ideas "vapid balderdash". [16] Her claims about Joan of Arc were dismissed by historians based on the extensive evidence of Joan's actual religious views, such as the letters she dictated in which she defines her faith in "King Jesus, King of Heaven and of all the earth, my rightful and sovereign Lord." [17] and the many eyewitness accounts of her beliefs and behaviour.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joan of Arc</span> French folk heroine and saint (1412–1431)

Joan of Arc is a patron saint of France, honored as a defender of the French nation for her role in the siege of Orléans and her insistence on the coronation of Charles VII of France during the Hundred Years' War. Claiming to be acting under divine guidance, she became a military leader who transcended gender roles and gained recognition as a savior of France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Orléans</span> Turning point in the Hundred Years War

The siege of Orléans marked a turning point of the Hundred Years' War between France and England. The siege took place at the pinnacle of English power during the later stages of the war, but was repulsed by French forces inspired by the arrival of Joan of Arc. The French would then regain the initiative in the conflict and began to recapture territories previously occupied by the English.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canonization of Joan of Arc</span> Mass of granting sainthood to Joan of Arc

Joan of Arc (1412–1431) was formally canonized as a saint of the Roman Catholic Church on 16 May 1920 by Pope Benedict XV in his bull Divina disponente, which concluded the canonization process that the Sacred Congregation of Rites instigated after a petition of 1869 of the French Catholic hierarchy. Although pro-English clergy had Joan burnt at the stake for heresy in 1431, she was rehabilitated in 1456 after a posthumous retrial. Subsequently, she became a folk saint among French Catholics and soldiers inspired by her story of being commanded by God to fight for France against England. Many French regimes encouraged her cult, and the Third Republic was sympathetic to the canonization petition prior to the 1905 separation of church and state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joan of Évreux</span> Queen consort of France and Navarre

Joan of Évreux was Queen of France and Navarre as the third wife of King Charles IV of France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles II, Duke of Lorraine</span> Duke of Lorraine

Charles II, called the Bold was the Duke of Lorraine from 1390 to his death and Constable of France from 1418 to 1425.

<i>Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc</i> 1896 novel by Mark Twain

Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc, by the Sieur Louis de Conte is an 1896 novel by Mark Twain which recounts the life of Joan of Arc.

Joan of Arc By Herself and Her Witnesses (ISBN 0-8128-1260-3) is a translation of a 1962 book about Joan of Arc by Régine Pernoud. The translator, Edward Hyams, won the 1965 Scott Moncrieff Prize for his work on this book. Pernoud was the founder of the Centre Jeanne d'Arc at Orléans, France, and a noted historian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cultural depictions of Joan of Arc</span>

Joan of Arc has inspired artistic and cultural works for nearly six centuries. The following lists cover various media to include items of historic interest, enduring works of high art, and recent representations in popular culture. The entries represent portrayals that a reader has a reasonable chance of encountering rather than a complete catalog. Lesser known works, particularly from early periods, are not included. In this article, many of the excluded items are derivative of better known representations. For instance, Friedrich Schiller's 1801 play The Maid of Orleans inspired at least 82 different dramatic works during the nineteenth century, and Verdi's and Tchaikovsky's operatic adaptations are still recorded and performed. Most of the others survive only in research libraries. As another example, in 1894, Émile Huet listed over 400 plays and musical works about Joan of Arc. Despite a great deal of scholarly interest in Joan of Arc, no complete list of artistic works about her exists, although a 1989 doctoral dissertation did identify all relevant films including ones for which no copy survives.

Fresh Verdicts on Joan of Arc is an anthology of scholarly essays on Joan of Arc. First published by Garland publishing in 1996 (ISBN 0-8153-3664-0), it is 336 pages long.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Isabelle Romée</span> Mother of Joan of Arc

Isabelle Romée, also known as Isabelle de Vouthon and Isabelle d'Arc (1377–1458) and Ysabeau Romee, was the mother of Joan of Arc. She grew up in Vouthon-Bas and later married Jacques d'Arc. The couple moved to Domrémy, where they owned a farm consisting of about 50 acres (200,000 m2) of land. After their daughter's famous exploits in 1429, the family was granted noble status by Charles VII in December of that year. Isabelle moved to Orléans in 1440 after her husband's death and received a pension from the city. She petitioned Pope Nicholas V to reopen the court case that had convicted Joan of heresy, and then, in her seventies, addressed the opening session of the appellate trial at Notre Dame cathedral in Paris. The appeals court overturned Joan's conviction on 7 July 1456. Isabelle died two years later, probably at Sandillon near Orléans.

Pierronne, also known as Pierrone, Pierronne la Bretonne and Perrinaïc, was a Breton woman who said she saw visions of "God dressed in a long white robe with a red tunic underneath". Pierronne, who may have met Joan of Arc in 1429, tried to defend her reputation at Corbeil. For this, Pierronne was arrested by pro-English authorities in March 1430 and burned at the stake.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean Bréhal</span> French theologian and inquistor-general of France

Jean Bréhal OP was the inquisitor-general of France who led the effort to rehabilitate Joan of Arc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Name of Joan of Arc</span>

Due to inconsistent record keeping and different contemporary customs, the name of Joan of Arc at birth is not known for certain.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trial of Joan of Arc</span> 1431 trial and execution of French saint Joan of Arc for heresy

The Trial of Joan of Arc was a 15th century legal proceeding against Joan of Arc, a French military leader under Charles VII during the Hundred Years' War. During the siege of Compiègne in 1430, she was captured by Burgundian forces and subsequently sold to their English allies. She was prosecuted by a pro-English church court at Rouen, Normandy in 1431. The court found her guilty of heresy and she was burned at the stake. The verdict was later nullified at Joan's rehabilitation trial, which was overseen by the Inquisitor-General, Jean Bréhal, in 1456. Considered a French national heroine, she was declared a saint by the Roman Catholic Church in 1920. The trial is one of the most famous in history, becoming the subject of many books and films.

Pierre d'Arc (1408–1467) was a French soldier whose place in history is due to his service in the army made famous by his younger sister Joan of Arc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cross-dressing, gender identity, and sexuality of Joan of Arc</span>

Joan of Arc, a French historical figure executed by the English for heresy in 1431, is a national heroine of France and a Roman Catholic saint. Joan accompanied an army during the Hundred Years War, adopting the clothing of a soldier, which ultimately provided a pretense for her conviction and execution. Whether her crossdressing and lifestyle have implications for her sexuality or gender identity is debated.

Régine Pernoud was a French historian and archivist. Pernoud was one of the most prolific medievalists in 20th century France; more than any other single scholar of her time, her work advanced and expanded the study of Joan of Arc.

Jean de Metz was a French nobleman who is known primarily for his role in the exploits of Joan of Arc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Witch-cult hypothesis</span> Discredited theory about witchcraft trials

The witch-cult hypothesis is a discredited theory that the witch trials of the Early Modern period were an attempt to suppress a pagan religion that had survived the Christianization of Europe. According to its proponents, accused witches were actually followers of this alleged religion. They argue that the supposed 'witch cult' revolved around worshiping a Horned God of fertility and the underworld, whose Christian persecutors identified with the Devil, and whose followers held nocturnal rites at the witches' Sabbath.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rehabilitation trial of Joan of Arc</span> Posthumous appeal of Joan of Arcs conviction

The conviction of Joan of Arc in 1431 was posthumously investigated on appeal in the 1450s by Inquisitor-General Jean Bréhal at the request of Joan's surviving family – her mother Isabelle Romée and two of her brothers, Jean and Pierre. The appeal was authorized by Pope Callixtus III.

References

  1. ↑ Alain-Gilles Minella (2012). Jeanne d'Arc pour les Nuls, First Gründ, Paris, (online French)
  2. ↑ Caze, Pierre (1819). La Vérité sur Jeanne d'Arc (in French). Paris.
  3. ↑ "Coat of Arms of Jeanne d'Arc".
  4. ↑ Pernoud and Clin, p. 222.
  5. ↑ Pernoud and Clin, pp. 234–35.
  6. ↑ Pernoud, Regine. Joan of Arc by Herself and her Witnesses, pp. 228–34.
  7. ↑ Dr E, Cobham Brewer, Dictionary of Phrase and Fable, 1898.
  8. ↑ Graeme, Donald (2009). Lies, damned lies, and history. pp. 99–103.
  9. ↑ Margolis, Nadia (1997). "Trial by passion: Philology, film, and ideology in the portrayal of Joan of Arc (1900-1930)" (PDF). Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies. 27 (3): 448—450]. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 Apr 2022.
  10. ↑ Pinzino, Jane Marie. Heretic or holy woman? Cultural representation and gender in the trial to rehabilitate Joan of Arc (PhD). University of Pennsylvania.
  11. ↑ Sheppard, Kathleen L. (2013). The Life of Margaret Alice Murray: A Woman's Work in Archaeology. New York: Lexington Books, p. 170
  12. ↑ Karen Sullivan, The Interrogation of Joan of Arc. Contributors, University of Minnesota Press, 1999, p. 19.
  13. ↑ Murray, M., The Witch-Cult in Western Europe, Appendix IV, 1921.
  14. ↑ Charles Alva Hoyt, Witchcraft, Southern Illinois University Press, 1989, p. 44.
  15. ↑ Michael Bailey. "Witchcraft Historiography" (review) in Magic, Ritual, and Witchcraft - Volume 3, Number 1, Summer 2008, pp. 81–85.
  16. ↑ C. L'Estrange Ewen (1938) "Some Witchcraft Criticism: A Plea for the Blue Pencil".
  17. ↑ Pernoud, Regine; and Clin, Marie-Veronique. "Joan of Arc: Her Story", p. 67.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.