Joss Whedon run (2004–2008)
Whedon/Cassaday's Astonishing X-Men is a continuation of Grant Morrison's New X-Men title and features a similar line-up of characters, including Cyclops and Emma Frost (as co-team leaders), Beast, Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat, Colossus, and Wolverine. This team became the usual focus for a majority of issues during Whedon's run. The run introduced a number of original characters into the Marvel Universe including Kavita Rao, Special Agent Brand, S.W.O.R.D., Hisako Ichiki, Ord of the Breakworld and Blindfold. Whedon's run on the series was a critical and commercial success. The roster of the book was also the focus of various limited series at the time, such as X-Men: Phoenix—Endsong, X-Men: Phoenix—Warsong and World War Hulk: X-Men.
"Gifted" (issues #1–6)
The first story arc focused on the introduction of several key characters and their involvement on the team. Whedon introduced a "mutant cure" designed by Indian Benetech scientist Dr. Kavita Rao, who was secretly sponsored by warrior alien Ord. The prospect of "real" humanity arouses the interest of a heavily mutated Beast, who visits Rao only to discover that the drug is the product of illegal experimentation on an unknown victim(s). The X-Men raid Benetech and reunite with Colossus. With Colossus's help, the team takes down Ord, but not before it's revealed that a mutant (most likely an X-Man) would destroy Ord's home planet, the Breakworld, within the next three years.
With this 2005 arc, Whedon brought back Colossus four years after his comic book death in 2001.
"Dangerous" (issues #7–12)
This arc features a Sentinel attack with a mystery mastermind. The culprit is the Danger Room itself, which has become sentient and fights the X-Men in a robotic form called "Danger." The Sentinel that destroyed Genosha becomes aware of its actions and ceases its attack on the X-Men. It is revealed that Professor X imprisoned Danger and made it an unwilling servant, leaving the X-Men disgusted. It is also revealed that Emma Frost is aligned with the Hellfire Club.
"Torn" (issues #13–18)
The X-Men are manipulated by a new Hellfire Club, consisting of Cassandra Nova, Emma Frost, the enigmatic Perfection, Negasonic Teenage Warhead, and Sebastian Shaw. It is revealed that when Nova's mind was imprisoned by Emma into a biological "slug", Nova placed a subtle suggestion into Emma's mind to cause Emma to believe she had to help Nova destroy the X-Men and free Nova, and that Cyclops' inability to control his optic blasts is result of a childhood trauma. Nova initially defeats the X-Men by manipulating their greatest fears. In the end, Nova's plot is revealed to Emma by Cyclops, but it is unknown whether Emma returned the consciousness of Nova to the slug or if it went elsewhere. Moments later, Ord and Danger burst into the room, and they are all forcibly teleported away by S.W.O.R.D. to a spaceship headed for the Breakworld.
The final panel of issue 15, in which Shadowcat crouches in a sewer clenching her fists, was an homage to the final panel of Uncanny X-Men #132, in which Wolverine did the same.
"Unstoppable" (issues #19–24 and Giant-Size Astonishing X-Men #1)
The final arc takes place on the alien Breakworld. The X-Men square off against the Breakworld leaders, who intend to destroy Earth by firing a giant bullet at it. The Danger subplot is also resolved, and it is revealed that Danger is hard-coded not to kill. Shadowcat phases inside the Breakworld bullet, and when it reaches Earth, makes it intangible, so that the bullet passes through Earth. However, she is unable to remove herself from the bullet and vanishes with it into space.
Warren Ellis run (2008–2011)
Marvel announced at San Diego Comicon 2007 that following completion of the Whedon/Cassaday run on Astonishing X-Men, the series would continue with the new creative team of Warren Ellis and Simone Bianchi. Ellis later confirmed this story on his website, saying the series would be retitled Astonishing X-Men: Second Stage. He also mentioned that, like Whedon, he would be given complete creative freedom without having to pay mind to the franchise's sprawling continuity. [7]
This run was expected to debut in early 2008, but was pushed back to July 2008, with the "Second Stage" subtitle dropped. [8] A sketchbook was released before the first issue and showed costume redesigns by Bianchi. The characters showcased were Dazzler, Beast, Nightcrawler, Archangel, Cyclops, Emma Frost, Colossus, Storm, and Wolverine. While some of the characters did not appear in the book, Ellis had mentioned earlier that a majority of Bianchi's drawings were made public to promote the title, and that upon his run's announcement the final cast had not been set. [7]
Ellis and Bianchi's first issue, Astonishing X-Men #25, featured the team relocated to San Francisco, with a base in the Marin headlands. The story takes place in the aftermath of the House of M story arc, which put mutants on the verge of extinction. The initial "Ghost Box" arc was printed under the Manifest Destiny label, but did not feature any crossovers with other titles. The only addition to the team was Storm, with Colossus and Kitty Pryde having left the team. [9]
"Ghost Box" (issues #25–30)
Now based in San Francisco, Ellis established the X-Men as protectors of the city. The new team consisted of Cyclops, Emma Frost, Beast, Wolverine and Armor, and later, Storm arrived. The X-Men uncovered a plot of mutant synthesis from an unusual murder. The killer (designated 'X') was located, fixing and restarting the eponymous "ghost box" in a spaceship. X was defeated but killed himself rather than surrender information about his intentions and "the Annex."
The team returned to San Francisco with Suspect X's "mysterious box" (actually a "Ghost Box") in tow and gave it to Hank along with a syringe filled with Suspect X's blood. After analyzing the box and blood and reviewing Suspect X's file, Hank told Scott that there appears to be talk about a secret war between Suspect X's people and the murdered mutant from the beginning of the story arc. There is also talk about a mysterious place called Tian, China, which piques the interest of Wolverine. After analyzing Suspect X's blood, Hank finds that Suspect X is a normal mutant but with his X-gene on a different chromosome. Just like the murder victim, Hank believes that Suspect X is a manufactured mutant. Hank wants to bring in Abigail Brand from S.W.O.R.D. to help investigate this matter, but Scott disagrees. In the end, against Scott's wishes, Brand is brought in and tells the X-Men that the Ghost Box is a dimensional portal between different realities. Hank concludes that Suspect X is not a manufactured mutant after all; in Suspect X's reality the x-gene is normally located on a different chromosome. Brand wants this case to fall under S.W.O.R.D.'s jurisdiction, but Scott objects. Brand gives Scott and the X-Men time to investigate before she brings in S.W.O.R.D.. The X-Men locate Tian, an uncharted area of China that no surveillance or satellite system can access, not even the Chinese government. The X-Men sneak into Tian and discover the headquarters of a secret group of mutants informally referred to by Hank as the "Chinese X-Men." Sadly, they seem to have died because of M-Day's associated effects.
As Storm and Emma investigate the grounded temple, Emma notices they are not alone and that she will have to switch to her diamond form, leaving her without her telepathy. She relays this to Cyclops, who is with Beast, Armor and Wolverine. As Armor and Wolverine search the temple for anyone else, Scott and Beast discuss Forge, M-Day and its effects on the multiverse. Armor and Wolverine come across a man who can fire lasers from his fingers, Storm and Emma lose their powers in the presence of the mutant hiding from them, and Cyclops and Beast take on a mutant with a strange chameleon mutation. After the X-Men take down their foes, they reveal to the X-Men they have a mutual friend, Forge. [10] Emma continues to interrogate the X-Men's captives, and the team discovers that Forge created the manufactured mutants (including the victim in the beginning of the arc), for a counter-strike against the Annexation using a Ghost Box that he acquired.
The team head towards Forge's location and are apprehensive about the upcoming meeting. After some discussion with Forge, Cyclops and Storm try to reason with him but he is strongly determined to see his plan through. Forge's insistence seems to stem from years of being ignored and neglected and he desires to leave behind a legacy and save the world. Beast has Brand send an immensely powerful laser beam into the Ghost Box's portal. Storm urges Forge to escape, but he would rather face death than humiliation, and the team escapes as the beam destroys both the Ghost Box and the world from which the invaders came. [11]
"Ghost Boxes" (Astonishing X-Men: Ghost Boxes #1–2)
During a four-month hiatus in the middle of Ghost Box's publication schedule, Ellis published Astonishing X-Men: Ghost Boxes. The two-issue spin-off series featured four short stories, with each revolving around Ghost Boxes. The first story, "Agent X-13's Report on the Emergency Annexation of Earth-616," is the only one of the four that does not take place in a parallel universe. Rather, it is an "alternate ending" to the Ghost Box arc where the Annexation of Earth-616 is successful.
The second story, "Being an Journal By Miss Emma Frost of New Portsmouth Bay in the State of New Albion," takes place on Earth-889, a steampunk parallel universe. In this story the X-Men, here known as X-Society, investigate parallel events similar to what happened on Earth-616 and inadvertently cause the Hindenburg disaster. The Emma Frost of this reality would later return in the "Exalted" storyline and be featured on the team in the X-Treme X-Men title.
The third story, "The Last Testament of Scott Summers," deals with a parallel Earth where the Annexation is successful and the X-Men are eliminated, save for Cyclops.
The final story, "4," focuses on a parallel Armor, Beast, and Wolverine five years after a catastrophic attack wiped out nearly all of the mutants and humanity. With barely any resources left, the three spend a year marching towards Kalispell, clinging onto the hope of a sanctuary where the resistance can make a final stand.
"Exogenetic" (issues #31–35)
Agent Brand's investigation of an orbiting laboratory in space ends with it self-destructing, damaging her escape ship. As the craft falls toward Earth, she radios the X-Men for help, and they save her before the craft can crash into San Francisco. In the crowd, Emma notices deceased former student Wallflower and follows after her. Wallflower immediately transforms into a bio-sentinel and the team destroy it. Brand reveals that an individual called Kaga hacked into the X-Men's files, using Beast's work on deriving a live x-gene from dead mutants to recreate some of the X-Men's greatest foes, such as the Brood, and bio-sentinels masquerading in cloned bodies of their former allies.
Brand's explanation is interrupted when a Brood-Krakoa hybrid attacks, attempting to destroy any physical evidence of the bio-sentinel. The X-Men destroy it and locate the hidden ship that dropped the hybrid, boarding it. They find another dead mutant, Paradigm, whom Kaga used to hack into the X-Men's files. Away from the team, Cyclops destroys the remnants of Paradigm, killing him, while the X-Men fight off and destroy a Brood-Sauron hybrid. The X-Men fly the ship into Kaga's base, finding an army of genetically engineered monstrosities meant to attack them. They destroy all the experimental creatures and confront Kaga.
Kaga is revealed to be a deformed elderly man with numerous genetic abnormalities and disorders, a mutant born from a mother who survived the atomic bombing of Hiroshima. He reveals that he hates the X-Men for their perfect bodies and incredible superhuman abilities despite being labeled "mutants," whereas he is deformed, trapped in a deteriorating body. In retaliation, Cyclops decides that he will not kill Kaga but will ensure that "Mutantes Sans Frontières" gives Kaga the care and medical attention he needs for the rest of his natural life.
"Xenogenesis" (Astonishing X-Men: Xenogenesis #1–5)
A miniseries that takes the X-Men to Africa to deal with a mysterious mutagen that is causing mutations amongst newborn children.
Storm leaves her home in Wakanda to visit the X-Men. They reunite and go to Africa to investigate a series of mutant births, which excites the hope of mutants replenishing their species.
They find that the area set up for Mutantes Sans Frontieres has been overtaken by soldiers. The X-Men defeat the troops, and Emma Frost kisses the staff in order to let them download the native language for 48 hours so they may be able to communicate with the locals.
Beast witnesses the mutations and studies the babies, discovering they are not mutants but are simply affected by a type of radiation in the area. Before they can investigate, a cyborg arrives, claiming to be in charge of the area, and his armed troops take everyone hostage. Cyclops distracts the cyborg while Emma controls all of his troops, and they discover that they must work together in order to find out the cause of the radiation.
In the woods, they find a man running for his life. Wolverine, Beast, and two of the cyborg's best men track him into the jungle. A ghost box opens, and armed troops known as Furies emerge to kill the running man. Wolverine and Beast take them down, but the Ghost Box unleashes larger Furies that can morph their arms into weapons, and regenerate. Beast is shot, the cyborg's men are eviscerated, and Wolverine is almost killed when Cyclops and the others rescue them.
Emma scans the running man and discovers he is a multiverse teleporter. He escaped from his world, which was overrun by the Furies, who had killed every super-powered individual. The Furies were sent after him via the Ghost Box. Emma tells Cyclops that during their fight, they must keep one Fury alive or else everyone will die.
A single Fury is left for Emma, who nearly kills her. She takes control of its mind and performs a "psychic surgery", which alters its programming. Emma changes its orders to say it completed the mission and returned because it had no other commands. Without any reason to pursue further, the outside forces would leave Earth alone.
Emma also reveals to Cyclops that the man they have helped emits a burst of radiation when he teleports between universes, which is the cause of the babies' mutations. The cyborg kills the teleporter, saying he cannot have a volatile human dirty bomb walking around able to hurt everyone in the area. He says he doesn't like doing these kinds of things, but he has to, since it is his job.
Daniel Way and Christos Gage runs (2011)
During New York City Comic Con, Marvel editors announced that following Warren Ellis' run, Daniel Way would take over writing duties for the series with Jason Pearson illustrating. [12] Shortly after, it was announced that Christos Gage would also be writing for Astonishing X-Men, with Juan Bobillo as illustrator. Gage's arc would alternate with Way's over the course of seven issues. [13] Way later revealed that this format was done due to illustrator Jason Pearson not being available on a monthly basis, and called the decision to alternate stories "brilliant." Though Pearson was the original artist for "Monstrous", he would only end up working on one-and-half issues, with artists Sara Pichelli and Nick Bradshaw doing the illustration for the rest of the arc. [14]
Daniel Way's "Monstrous" arc would take a team of Cyclops, Emma Frost, Wolverine and Armor to Japan and Monster Island. Christos Gage's "Meanwhile" arc would feature an outer space rescue mission with Storm, Kitty Pryde, Colossus, Lockheed, Abigail Brand and Beast (who was with the Avengers during that time).
"Monstrous" and "Meanwhile" (issues #36–42)
During "Monstrous", Armor learns that her mother and brother have died in an accident in Japan. Cyclops, Emma Frost and Wolverine accompany her to Tokyo to attend their wakes. Meanwhile, Mentallo is dispatched by Roxxon Corporation to Monster Island, on which the corporation intends to drill for oil. However, Mentallo psychically enslaves the monsters on the island in order to extort cash from Roxxon, and sets one of the monsters to attack Tokyo. The monster is defeated by the team, including Armor, who had left the wake earlier to rejoin them.
Cyclops, Emma, Wolverine, and Armor then make their way to Monster Island. Wolverine and Emma are captured by Mentallo, who intends to bury them alive when the volcano erupts, but they are freed by Cyclops. The X-Men pursue Mentallo, and though he manages to escape, he is crushed alive when one of the giant monsters dropped a cargo container directly on top of him, which contained the entire billion dollars in cash.
Armor reunites with her father, who admits that he was upset when she left the wake, but after seeing her nobly set aside her grief to show great strength and protect the city, he tells her that he has never been prouder of her than that day. The two then say their goodbyes.
In "Meanwhile", Agent Brand leads a rescue mission to the Pandora's Box space station, where some of the universe's most dangerous experiments are conducted. Only one person has been retrieved from the station, but he leaves Brand for dead. As a result, Beast recruits Storm, Colossus, Kitty Pryde and Lockheed to rescue her. The team find Brand and members of S.W.O.R.D. still alive, but they have been infected by the Brood. The station's scientists had been trying to extract the larvae without killing the hosts.
The X-Men get back to the ship and have an opportunity to destroy the space station and eliminate the Brood for good. Brand argues against this, stating that in the galaxy's larger ecosystem, the Brood are necessary to take out the larger, more dangerous species. They decide to take out the Brood Queens (multiple being allowed to exist to allow species survival), to sever the mental connection between the species and allow the rest of the Brood to return home without any consequence.
While the X-Men attack the Brood, the team becomes infected and gradually mutate into the Brood themselves, the only exception being Kitty Pryde, still in her intangible state. The team find another unnamed Brood teenager, who became an outcast due to his compassion for mammals. Eventually, the X-Men are able to regain their human memories mid-battle and eliminate the Brood Queens. The Brood are given the option to go home, which they accept. The Brood teenager accompanies the X-Men to S.W.O.R.D.'s headquarters and observes the new Brood larvae that have been extracted from the infected X-Men. He remarks that with no ties to the hive mind or the Brood Queen, the future Brood under the S.W.O.R.D.’s care have a bright future. Storm says that it is now up to him to look after the new Broodlings, and that if he were ever to come to Earth, he would have a place on the X-Men.
Greg Pak run (2011–2012)
Marvel would announce that Greg Pak and Mike McKone would be the next creative team to take over Astonishing X-Men. A teaser image was released of Cyclops and Storm kissing, fueling speculation that the run would feature a romantic arc between the two. [16] On a Q&A on Marvel's website, Pak revealed that his story would take place in the aftermath of the Schism event, and that he would be writing a more emotional arc. [17] Pak's story would later be continued and spun-off into the X-Treme X-Men title. [18]
"Exalted" (issues #44–47)
In the "Exalted", the focus lies mostly on Scott Summers as a lead character. Through the use of a Ghost Box, a device which allows characters to enter into a parallel universe, an alternate reality in the X-Men continuity is explored. In the timeline featured here, the X-Men have waged war on Magneto to free the subjugated human race. In his dying breath, Magneto cracks the planet causing certain doom. Xavier, recast as Savior in this timeline, and other Marvel super-geniuses create a device to save their planet by harnessing the powers of mutants.
Savior scours the multiverse with a Ghost Box collecting various incarnations of X-Men, favoring Cyclops, and using them until they burn out. That is until his Storm finds "our" Cyclops. Scott wakes to find himself imprisoned in the device along with alternate versions of mutant teammates James Howlett, Emmeline Frost, Shadow(cat), and a young Kurt Wagner (Nightcrawler). They escape, learn the truth about Savior and his plans, and make the hard humanity-at-stake decisions of heroes.
Along the way it becomes apparent that a single Cyclops can provide immense power for the device, and that many of them have chosen to self-sacrifice to preserve Savior's world. When Scott refuses and destroys the device telling Savior to "Find another way!", Savior reveals that he indeed has a permanent solution that requires the sacrifice of an entire universe, and claiming that this Scott's aberrant behavior proves he is from a flawed universe that he will not feel guilty about consuming with the help of a modified Ghost Box.
This combined with Savior's willingness to sacrifice some of the humans from his own reality is enough for Storm to side with the former captives. Together (and with Scott's Storm and Emma brought in by young Kurt) this makeshift team of X-Men defeat Savior. As his Emma and Storm depart through a failing Ghost Box portal, Scott tells them that his decisions doomed that Earth and he should stay to help fix it. Howlett pushes him through saying he had been worried momentarily about Scott's non-self-sacrifice, but now was reassured, and that Scott wouldn't be the last person they save today.
The alternate universe Howlett, Kurt and others would later return in a new X-Treme X-Men series, also written by Pak.
Marjorie Liu run (2012–2013)
Writer Marjorie Liu and artist Mike Perkins took over the Astonishing X-Men creative team as of issue 48 in March 2012, writing until the series' cancellation in issue 68. Her time on the series marked a more grounded take on the team, focusing more on the relationships of each characters with human reactions and interaction. By the end of her run, Liu's written credits would amount to 21 regular issues and one annual issue, second only to Whedon for most entries written for the title. [19] [20]
Liu's run completely rebooted the series' setting and lineup, which had until this point featured Cyclops and Emma Frost leading the X-Men. Under Liu, the series shifted focus to Wolverine's side as the team returned to New York during the "Regenesis" storyline and following the "Avengers vs. X-Men" storyline. The primary X-Men lineup for the rest of the series consisted of Wolverine, Gambit, Warbird, Northstar, Cecilia Reyes, Iceman, and Karma.
"Northstar" (Issues #48–51)
In the issues illustrated by Mike Perkins, the story primarily focuses on Northstar and Karma. Northstar's arc revolved around his issues with his non-mutant boyfriend Kyle, as both are unsure they can come to a mutual understanding on Northstar's duties as an X-Man and whether Kyle can provide enough emotional support. Northstar proposes marriage to Kyle, but he is at first rebuffed.
The X-Men are soon attacked by the Marauders, though it is revealed that they were under mind-control and were not acting on their own volition. After the attack, Karma soon falls under the control from the same culprit, an unknown business woman. Karma later takes control of the other X-Men, as well as Kyle, who tries to kill himself in front of Northstar. They are each able to break free, but Karma then goes missing. As the team tends to their wounds, Kyle then accepts Northstar's marriage proposal.
"Weaponized" (Issues #52–56 & Astonishing X-Men Annual #1)
During the wedding reception, Wolverine wanders off and finds Karma, only to get attacked by an unseen force. It is then revealed who had been controlling Karma and the Marauders from the beginning - Susan Hatchi, a successful weapons developer who wished to test out new nanotechnology to physically control her victims. Born Da'o Coy Manh, she is Karma's illegitimate half-sister whose mother was killed by their father.
In a later confrontation with the X-Men, Hatchi uses her nanotechnology to seize control of the team and orders them to takeover Madripoor or she will use her technology on New York and kill the population. She wants to not only demonstrate the effectiveness of her weapon but to draw out their father from hiding by publicly using Karma as bait. While she is able to locate her father in Madripoor, the X-Men are able to counteract the technology and defeat her. While the two sisters reach reconciliation, their father takes advantage of their engagement and shoots Hatchi. He is arrested by the police for her murder. After Hatchi's death, Karma inherits her company as the only eligible relative of age and effectively becomes a billionaire.
"Unmasked" and "X-Termination" (Issues #57–68)
Gabriel Hernandez Walta would take over the art duties from Mike Perkins for the remainder of the run, though Amilcar Pinna would draw the two penultimate issues. The final 12 issues would contain shorter arcs, along with the series' only crossover with other X-Men titles.
The initial two issues (issues #57 to #58) focus on Warbird, who travels to Egypt after seeing an artifact in a magazine that turns out to be made by a race the Shi'ar obliterated a thousand years ago.
For the next three issues (issues #59 to #61), the series tied into the "X-Termination" storyline, with the X-Treme X-Men and Age of Apocalypse ongoing titles. Though not officially part of the crossover, issue #59 served as a prelude to the storyline. Issue #60 served as Part 2 of the crossover while issue #61 was Part 5. The storyline focused on the Age of Apocalypse Nightcrawler's attempt to return home, which resulted in the release of three evil beings that destroy anyone they touch. Several casualties resulted, including the AoA's Nightcrawler, Sabretooth, Horror Show, and Fiend, as well as the X-Treme X-Men's Xavier, Kid Nightcrawler, and Hercules. Following the event, Astonishing X-Men would be the sole title of the three to continue publication. [21]
The next arc in the series (issues #62 to #65) featured Iceman, who was corrupted by the Apocalypse seed during X-Termination and sent the world into an ice age.
The next two issues (issues #66 to #67) deal with an alien being that possesses the minds of many New Yorkers. Gambit and Wolverine track the alien down to Indiana, where they enlist the aid of a local human girl who helps discover its origins and intentions.
Astonishing X-Men ended with issue #68 in October 2013, wrapping up many loose ends of the run: Iceman coming to terms with the damage he has dealt, Northstar and Kyle ensuring their future together, and Warbird accepting her role on the X-Men and her home on Earth. Its status as a team book featuring Wolverine and his X-Men team was replaced by a new series by Jason Aaron titled Amazing X-Men in November 2013.
Reception
Whedon's run was a critical success. "Gifted" was given the accolade of Wizard's book of the year, while IGN called the arc "best X-Men run in a decade" and lauded Whedon for flawless character dynamics. [22] Whedon said that while he knew "many people have done cure scenarios before me," he was not familiar with any of those earlier stories at the time he started working on the arc. [23] The "mutant cure" plot of "Gifted" eventually became the basis of the X-Men: The Last Stand .
The third volume of the Astonishing X-Men comic book series has generally been well received with comic sales normally being very high. Whedon's run was nominated for several Eisner Awards. In 2006, the series won the Best Continuing Series and in 2005 and 2006, John Cassaday won Best Artist/Penciller/Inker or Penciller/Inker Team (tied with Frank Quitely for 2005). [24]
However, Joss Whedon's run on Astonishing X-Men was subjected to criticism regarding the delays between the issues. Whedon's initial contract with Marvel Comics was for twelve issues for one year but the final issues were four months late. After a break of several months, the title resumed in February 2006 with the new story arc "Torn." With issue 13, the comic temporarily went from monthly to bimonthly to allow more time for Whedon and Cassaday to finish each issue and avoid further late releases. The book resumed a monthly schedule in September 2006 with issues 16 and 17, but was delayed once again for issue 18. Delays persisted for a variety of reasons, including Cassaday's last-minute assignment to pencil the fifth issue of Fallen Son: The Death of Captain America .
In Wizard #173, Whedon admitted to making mistakes in the second story arc, saying he was so fascinated with the idea of the "new intelligence" that he neglected the action and thus prevented the story from flowing well.
Marjorie Liu's run on Astonishing X-Men received media attention for featuring Marvel Comics' first gay wedding between Northstar and longterm partner Kyle in issue #51. [25] According to Marvel Comics editor-in-chief Axel Alonso, the issue comes as a response to real world's legalization of same sex marriage in New York. [26] Liu was nominated for a GLAAD Media Award in 2013. [27]
