Baron of the Exchequer

Last updated

The Court of Exchequer
Court of Exchequer, Westminster Hall (Microcosm of London, plate 25) MET DP873998.jpg
Court of Exchequer, Westminster Hall
Composition methodby appointment only
Authorized byConstitutional Monarchy
Number of positions5
Chief Baron of Exchequer

The Barons of the Exchequer, or barones scaccarii, were the judges of the English court known as the Exchequer of Pleas. The Barons consisted of a Chief Baron of the Exchequer and several puisne (inferior) barons. When Robert Shute was appointed second baron in June 1579 the patent declared "he shall be reputed and be of the same order, rank, estimation, dignity and pre-eminence to all intents and purposes as any puisne judge of either of the two other courts." [1] The rise of commercial trade in Elizabethan England occasioned fraudulent application of the Quo minus writ. More taxation demanded staff at the exchequer to sift an increase in the case load causing more widespread litigation cases to come to the court. From the 1580s onwards the Barons of Exchequer were no longer held in such low regard, and more likely to be Serjeants-at-law before qualification. The Inns of Courts began to exclude solicitors, and held posts for judges and barons open equally to barristers. In 1591, Regulations reflected a case in which the Lord Keeper Egerton banned solicitors from seeking cases in the Exchequer.


Together they sat as a court of common law, heard suits in the court of equity, and settled revenue disputes. A puisne baron was styled "Mr Baron X" and the chief baron as "Lord Chief Baron X".

They were originally the same judges as those of the Court of King's Bench, only becoming independent positions after the Exchequer's separation from the curia regis . [2] In the early years of the Exchequer's existence, the Barons were the chief auditors of the accounts of England, a role passed to dedicated auditors during the reign of Edward II. [3] With the Exchequer's expansion during the Tudor era, the Barons became more important; where previously only the Chief Baron had been appointed from the serjeants-at-law, with the other Barons mere barristers, it became practice for all Barons of the Exchequer to be Serjeants. This further increased the Exchequer's standing, since for the first time it put the Exchequer at the same level as the Court of Common Pleas and Court of King's Bench, where all judges were already required to be Serjeants. [4] Prior to the changes of 1533, Serjeants held precedence over barons "sitting in the high court,...of great eminence". Thereafter they held the degree of coif to qualify at the Inns of Court as the senior court at Westminster. [5]

From 1550 to 1579, there was a major distinction between the chief baron and the second, third and fourth puisne barons. The difference was in social status and education. All of the chief barons had been trained as lawyers in the inns of court. With the exception of Henry Bradshaw and Sir Clement Higham, both barristers-at-law, all of the chief barons who served Elizabeth I, had attained the highest and most prestigious rank of a lawyer, serjeant-at-law. By 1841, the equitable jurisdiction was transferred to the Court of Chancery, which deals with pecuniary cases.


By 1272, individuals were nominated to the office of Baron of the Exchequer from time to time: 24 baronial justiciers were appointed by the end of Henry III's reign. From 1278, there were three Barons, with a fourth being appointed in 1296 and a fifth in 1299. By 1308, one of the Barons was recognised as Capitalem Baronem (Chief Baron). Edward I commanded the Exchequer sessions to be held at Hilary term. [6] By the reforms of the reign of King Richard II, barons were not necessarily qualified special pleaders or serjeants; office was in the gift of the king, and barons were not usually permitted to refuse appointment. From then until 1478, it was recognised that there should be four puisne Barons. One was frequently named as Second Baron and rarely appointments were named as Third Baron and Fourth Baron. From then until 1547, the three puisne barons were always appointed to numbered offices, but in 1549, Edward Saxleby as successor to John Darnall was merely appointed as 'one of the Barons of the Exchequer'. However, he and his successors held the office of Cursitor Baron. An additional Baron was appointed in 1604. The number of puisnes generally remained at three until the 19th century, but there was a fourth from 1708 to 1725 due to John Smith having leave of absence to attend to the office of a Baron of the Scottish Exchequer. A fourth puisne baron was appointed in 1830 and a fifth in 1868. [7]

Puisne barons

Cursitor baron

See also

Related Research Articles

The Chief Baron of the Exchequer was the first "baron" of the English Exchequer of Pleas. "In the absence of both the Treasurer of the Exchequer or First Lord of the Treasury, and the Chancellor of the Exchequer, it was he who presided in the equity court and answered the bar i.e. spoke for the court." Practically speaking, he held the most important office of the Exchequer of Pleas.

John Pratt (judge)

Sir John Pratt (1657–1725) was an English judge and politician. He was Lord Chief Justice of England from 15 May 1718 until 2 March 1725. He was appointed as an interim Chancellor of the Exchequer on 2 February 1721 until 3 April 1721.

The Chancellor of the Exchequer of Ireland was the head of the Exchequer of Ireland and a member of the Dublin Castle administration under the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland in the Kingdom of Ireland. In early times the title was sometimes given as Chancellor of the Green Wax. In later centuries, when sessions of Parliament had become regular, the Chancellor was invariably an MP in the Irish House of Commons.

John Knyvet

Sir John Knyvet was an English lawyer and administrator. He was Chief Justice of the King's Bench from 1365 to 1372, and Lord Chancellor of England from 1372 to 1377.

Justice of the Kings Bench

Justice of the King's Bench, or Justice of the Queen's Bench during the reign of a female monarch, was a puisne judicial position within the Court of King's Bench, under the Chief Justice. The King's Bench was a court of common law which modern academics argue was founded independently in 1234, having previously been part of the curia regis. The court became a key part of the Westminster courts, along with the Exchequer of Pleas and the Court of Common Pleas ; the latter was deliberately stripped of its jurisdiction by the King's Bench and Exchequer, through the Bill of Middlesex and Writ of Quominus respectively. As a result, the courts jockeyed for power. In 1828 Henry Brougham, a Member of Parliament, complained in Parliament that as long as there were three courts unevenness was inevitable, saying that "It is not in the power of the courts, even if all were monopolies and other restrictions done away, to distribute business equally, as long as suitors are left free to choose their own tribunal", and that there would always be a favourite court, which would therefore attract the best lawyers and judges and entrench its position. The outcome was the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1873, under which all the central courts were made part of a single Supreme Court of Judicature. Eventually the government created a High Court of Justice under Lord Coleridge by an Order in Council of 16 December 1880. At this point, the King's Bench formally ceased to exist.

The Justice of Chester was the chief judicial authority for the county palatine of Chester, from the establishment of the county until the abolition of the Great Sessions in Wales and the palatine judicature in 1830.

Sir Robert Catlyn was an English judge and Chief Justice of the Queen's Bench. He should not be confused with his cousin Richard Catlyn, a politician, who died in 1556.

Roger Hill, of Poundisford Parkin Somerset, was an English judge and Member of Parliament.

The Lord High Treasurer of Ireland was the head of the Exchequer of Ireland, chief financial officer of the Kingdom of Ireland. The designation High was added in 1695.

John Wilde was an English lawyer and politician. As a serjeant-at-law he was referred to as Serjeant Wilde before he was appointed judge. He was a judge, chief baron of the exchequer, and member of the Council of State of the Commonwealth period.

Sir Thomas Raymond or Rayment was a British judge. Born to Robert Raymond, he was educated at a school in Bishop's Stortford before matriculating to Christ's College, Cambridge on 5 April 1643. On 6 February 1645 he joined Gray's Inn, being called to the Bar there on 11 February 1651. In October 1677 he became a Serjeant-at-Law, before being appointed a Baron of the Exchequer on 1 May 1679 and knighted on 26 June. On 7 February 1680 he became a Justice of the Common Pleas, and on 24 April 1680 transferred to the Court of King's Bench. He died on 14 July 1683, leaving behind a set of law reports titled Reports of divers special cases adjudged in the courts of king's bench, common pleas, and exchequer in the reign of King Charles II, which were published in 1696, 1743, 1793 and 1803. His son, Robert Raymond, also later became a judge. Commentators of the time identified him as having "extraordinary servility" and being an "unprincipled judge", with his failure in a witchcraft trial to point out the "irrationality" of the defendants' confessions leading to their death.

Sir Edmund Probyn SL was a British judge.

Sir Edward Atkyns was an English lawyer and politician who sat in the House of Commons in 1660. He was the Chief Baron of the Exchequer from 1686 to 1689.

Sir Richard Broke or Brooke, was an English judge, who served as Chief Baron of the Exchequer.

Baron Sir Thomas Street, MP, KB, JP was an English judge and politician who became a Baron of the Exchequer in 1681. He represented Worcester in the House of Commons between 1659 and 1679. In 1667, he became the Mayor of Worcester, as his father had been before him. In 1677, he became the Chief Justice of Brecknock, Glamorgan and Radnor.

James Reynolds (junior)

Sir James Reynolds (1686–1739) was an English lawyer and politician who sat in the House of Commons from 1717 until 1725 when he was appointed a judge. He was Lord Chief Baron of the Exchequer from 1730 to 1738. He should not be confused with his close relative Sir James Reynolds who was Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas in the same era.

The Record Commissions were a series of six Royal Commissions of Great Britain and the United Kingdom which sat between 1800 and 1837 to inquire into the custody and public accessibility of the state archives. The Commissioners' work paved the way for the establishment of the Public Record Office in 1838. The Commissioners were also responsible for publishing various historical records, including the Statutes of the Realm to 1714 and the Acts of Parliament of Scotland to 1707, as well as a number of important medieval records.

William Skrene was an Irish-born barrister and judge who spent most of his adult life in England, where he became a prominent landowner in Essex. He was a King's Serjeant and a judge of assize in England. He also served briefly as Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer in 1395-7.

Sir Robert Dillon was an Irish judge of the Tudor era who held office as Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas for more than twenty years, despite repeated calls for his removal on the grounds of age and ill-health.


  1. Dugdale, Chronica: series 94; Foss, Judges of England, vol.II, 410.
  2. Thomas (1848) p.3
  3. Thomas (1848) p.9
  4. Guth (2008) p.151
  5. Sir Edward Coke, Preface to Coke's 10th Law Report.
  6. Rotuli Parliamentorum, ii, 442.
  7. Sir John Sainty (comp.) The Judges of England, 1272-1990: a list of the judges of the Superior courts (Selden Society: Supplementary Series 1993, 10), 103-6.
  8. Madox, ii, 28, 320; Calendares Inquisitiones Post Mortem: i, 62.
  9. Calendares Inquisitionem Post Mortem, i, 156.
  10. New Foedera: i, 934; ii, 15, 175, 273, 333; Madox, ii, 58.
  11. left office because he was murdered on the road to Leicester. Madox, ii, 60; Abbreviatio Placitorum Origines, ii, 6, 171.
  12. Nicholas Madox, Writs of the Exchequer: ii, 267-269.; Nisi Foedera, ii, 1005; Foss, The Judges of England, iii, 427.
  13. Parliamentary Writs, ii, P; ii, 527.
  14. Parliamentary Writs, ii, P, ii, 194.
  15. Calendares Rotuli Parliamentorum, 106; Rotuli Origines, ii, 78, 81.
  16. Dugdale, Chronica Series
  17. Abreviatio Placitorum; Rotuli Origines, ii, 91, 261.
  18. Abbreviatio Placitorum; Rotuli Origines, i, 39; ii, 17; Rotuli Parliamentorum, ii, 105.
  19. Walter Dugdale, Origines: 102.
  20. Calendares Rotuli Patentum, 126.
  21. Kalendaris Exchequer: i, 165.
  22. Abbreviatio Placitorum; Rotuli Origenes, ii, 91, 192, 205, 219; Rotuli Parliamentorum, ii, 453.
  23. Abbreviatio Placitorum; Rotuli Origines, ii, 205.
  24. William Devon, Issue Roll: 44 Edw. III., 112, 346; Calendar Inquisition Post Mortem, ii, 315.
  25. Devon, Issue Roll, 133, 209, 256.
  26. Calendares Rotuli Patentum, 189.
  27. Liberate Roll 5 Henry IV (1404); Foss, The Judges of England, vol.III, 135.
  28. Kalendars of the Exchequer, iii, 302; Foss, Judges of England, 88.
  29. "FRAY, John (d.1461), of London and Munden Furnival, Herts.publisher= History of Parliament Online" . Retrieved 21 March 2018.
  30. 1446; Common Pleas record:
  31. 8 Note; Sir William Dugdale: Chronica Series; Calendares Rotuli Patentum: 300, 316.
  32. Collins, Peerage: ii, 444; Plumpton Correspondence: , lxxxiii, 8.
  33. Rotuli Parliamentorum: v, 472, 529; vi, 97; Red Book of Exchequer
  34. Calendar of State Papers, 1509, 263.
  35. Rotuli Patentum, 4 Eliz., p.2; Foss, vol.V, p.534.
  36. The Orlebar Chronicles in Bedfordshire and Northamptonshire, 1553-1733, or the Children of the Manorhouse and their Posterity; by Frederica St. John Orlebar. Pub. Mitchell Hughes and Clarke, London, 1930. Back Matter, page 316 – Orlebar Pedigree: ... Jane, daughter of Robert Shute of Hockington, co. Cambridge (ancestor of Barrington Viscounts (Ireland, c.1720); Baron of the Exchequer 1579).
  37. Baker, J.H. (1984). Order of Serjeants-at-law. Selden Society. pp. 364, 439. ISBN   978-0854232031.
  38. "Edward Henden".
  39. dismissed a suspected Papist.
  40. dismissed a suspected Papist.
  41. dismissed a suspected Papist. Foss, Biographia Juridica, 117-118.
  42. died of a brain haemmorrhage. Gentleman's Magazine: xxxvii, 91.
  43. Dod's Peerage: (1870)
  44. Foss, Judges, vi, 189-190; Historical Manuscript Commission Hatfield, xviii, 195, 219.
  45. Calendar of State Papers Domestic, 1603-10, 613.
  46. TNA, C220/15/8/60.
  47. Luttrell, i, 557.
  48. Parliamentary History: vol.v, 362.