Bashkir liberation movement

Last updated

The Bashkir liberation movement is a series of military clashes and uprisings of the Bashkir people against the Russian Empire that colonized Bashkortostan, as well as protests and rallies against the policies of the Russian Federation (in particular, against discrimination of the Bashkir people on national and linguistic grounds).

Contents

Russian Empire

Bashkirs are one of the ancient peoples of Eurasia, formed as a separate ethnos of the Southern Urals in the first millennium AD. [1] After the collapse of the Golden Horde, the territory of modern Bashkortostan was divided between the Kazan and Siberian Khanates and the Nogai Horde. After the fall of Kazan in October 1552, Bashkortostan was conquered the Russian Empire. Since then, a gradual but systematic policy of assimilation and Russification has been pursued towards the Bashkirs. At the same time, Russian entrepreneurs sought to obtain land holdings in the Urals to extract furs and exploit other resources of the region. Ivan the Terrible promised not to touch the lands, religions and customs of the Bashkirs, and also promised them protection and patronage from all enemies. Many Bashkirs therefore considered submission to Moscow as an escape from the ongoing feuds and wars. Nevertheless, once within the Russian state, the Bashkir people faced oppression by Russian landlords and officials, as well as their own feudal lords. With the arrival of the Russian state, mass construction of towns and fortresses, strongholds of colonization, began in Baskhir lands, where servicemen and officials lived. In return for their service, they received land from the Russian government. In addition, the officials increased the amount of tribute collected from the local population. In the 18th-19th centuries Russian settlers began to populate Bashkiria intensively.

Due to discontent of Bashkirs with the Russian policy popular uprisings arose. Eight major uprisings of the Bashkir people took place from the 1600s to the 1800s. [2]

The rebellion of 1662-1664 began because of the violation of fief land rights and tax collectors. The protest was led by large landowners, some of whom renounced their allegiance to Russian and wished to recreate an independent Siberian khanate. Russia struggled to militarily defeat the rebellion, and so conceded some Bashkir demands on land and taxation. [3]

Bashkirs revolted again from 1681-1684 against the forced Christianization of Muslims. The protest was supported by the Kalmyk Khanate, which was also under the protectorate of Russia. Because of this, the Russian government had to abandon the policy of Christianization of Muslims, officially condemned the seizure of Bashkir fiefdoms, and satisfied the demands of the Bashkirs to comply with the terms of Bashkortostan's annexation to Russia. [4]

From 1704-1711 there was a rebellion against the Russian attempt to introduce 72 new taxes, particularly on mosques and mullahs to discourage the practice of Islam. Tsar Peter I also ordered that all mosques built would be on the model of Christian churches, as well as to arrange cemeteries near mosques, and to record marriages and deaths of parishioners to mullahs only in the presence of an Orthodox priest. In addition, the Bashkirs were required to provide 20,000 horses and 4000 soldiers for the Great Northern War against Sweden. At the height of the revolt, the Bashkir nobility renounced Moscow's allegiance. In 1707, the creation of the Bashkir Khanate, bound by vassalage to the Crimean Khanate and the Ottoman Empire, was proclaimed. Hazi Akkuskarov, one of the rebel leaders, was proclaimed Bashkir khan at the council of elders. The Muscovites had to agree to all the Bashkirs' demands in order to stop the rebellion from spreading to other territories. According to some sources, the Bashkirs swore anew to the Russian emperor only in 1725. [5]

The uprising of 1735-1740 was a response to the organization by the Russian authorities of the Orenburg military-political expedition, which aimed to establish colonial orders in Bashkortostan. The punitive expedition of Russian General Rumyantsev during the suppression of the uprising killed, executed or exiled to penal servitude 40,000-60,000 Bashkirs. More than 250 settlements and the main mosque were also burned down. The rebels continued armed guerrilla warfare in the Ural Mountains. After the suppression, many fief lands of the Bashkirs were taken away and given to the servant Meshcheryaks. Some Bashkir historians consider the repressions during 1735-1740 to be the first genocide of the Bashkir people. The American historian Alton Stewart Donnelly estimates that one fourth of the Bashkir population died. [6] [7]

The uprising of 1747 was, like the 1704-1711 rebellion, caused by an increase in taxes. The protest was quickly suppressed. The leaders of the uprising were exiled to eternal servitude in the fortress of Rogervik, other participants were subjected to corporal punishment or exiled outside the region.

Another uprising of the Bashkir people occurred from 1755-1756, caused by the seizure of the Bashkirs' fief lands, the growth of taxes, attempts to Christianize Muslims, and the perceived arbitrariness of the Orenburg province administration. Mullah Abdulla Aliyev Batyrsha, called on Bashkirs, Tatars, Kazakhs and Uzbeks to "holy war", but only Bashkirs acted en masse. The main rebel forces retreated to Kazakhstan under the onslaught of Russian troops. Moscow authorities used bribery to achieved the extradition of Bashkirs. Of the rebels (50 thousand military men and their families) who were hiding in the Kazakhs, no more than 12-15 thousand returned home. [8]

Pugachev's Rebellion (1773-1775) was the most well-known mass insurgency, led by Salawat Yulayev. It was started by local Cossacks. The Cossacks were joined by Bashkirs, Tatars, Kalmyks, Kazakhs, Chuvash, Ural factory peasants and others. The revolt covered a vast territory, many towns, fortresses and factories were captured. Emelyan Pugachev, who declared himself Emperor Peter III, promised independence to the Bashkirs, so two thirds of the clans came to his side. Yulayev is considered the national hero of Bashkortostan; his symbolic image is on the coat of arms of the Republic of Bashkortostan. [9]

The last major uprising of the Bashkirs took place from 1834-1835, caused by another attempt of the Russian authorities to restrict their rights. As a result of the uprising, the Bashkirs managed to preserve their economic and legal freedom.

The American historian Alton S. Donnelly studied the Tsarist policy adopted after the Bashkirs were incorporated into the Russian Empire and believes that Bashkir uprisings were usually caused by violations by the Russian government of the terms previously agreed upon between the Bashkirs and the Russian authorities. Donnelly concludes that Russia systematically pursued an imperialist policy with consistent infringement of Bashkir interests.

The result of the conquest of Bashkortostan was a significant expansion of the territory and increase in the population of the Russian Empire at the expense of the Bashkirs losing the opportunity to create their own separate nation-state.

Soviet Union

After the February Revolution of 1917, the Bashkir national movement for the establishment of national-territorial autonomy began in the region. In July–August 1917, the I and II All-Bashkir Congresses (kurultais) were held in Orenburg, where it was decided to establish a "democratic republic on national-territorial principles" within federative Russia. The Bashkir Regional Council (shuro) elected by the first and re-elected by the second congresses worked in Orenburg. [10]

In order to consolidate forces, on September 23, 1918, in Ufa was convened the State Meeting, better known as the Ufa Directory, which made a collective decision to transfer supreme power to the All-Russian Provisional Government until the Constituent Assembly was convened. On November 18, 1918, A. V. Kolchak staged a military coup and declared himself Supreme Ruler of Russia and Supreme Commander-in-Chief of Russia's armed forces. Admiral Kolchak did not recognize the autonomy of the Bashkirs. All local governments were asked to declare self-liquidation. Thus, Bashkirs and Cossacks found themselves in a difficult situation. In the conditions of the Kolchakovs' retreat to Siberia, they found themselves without support in the face of the advancing forces of the Red Army. The leaders of the Bashkir autonomy were forced to start negotiations with the Soviets. On February 18, 1919, the Bashkir government and the Bashkir Corps came over to the side of the USSR. On March 20, 1919, the "Agreement of the Russian Workers' and Peasants' Government with the Bashkir Government on the Soviet Autonomy of Bashkiria" was concluded. March 23, 1919 is considered to be the official date of formation of the Bashkir Soviet Republic. [11] [12]

In 1918-1921 mass anti-Bolshevik uprisings of peasants, caused by dissatisfaction with the policy of Soviet power, began. The uprisings were suppressed.

In 1936, the Bashkir ASSR was officially denied transformation into a union republic within the USSR. On June 23, 1937, the first Constitution of the Bashkir ASSR was adopted.

The policy of assimilation and Russification was especially purposefully pursued during the years of Soviet power. Russification and forced displacement of the Bashkir language and culture dealt a significant blow to the Bashkirs as a people. The Soviet authorities threw great efforts into eradicating "nationalism" in favor of creating a "Soviet man" without nationality. Nevertheless, the Bashkir national movement began to gain momentum at the turn of the 1980s-90s. In 1988, a group of mainly Bashkir intellectuals (writers and university professors) was formed. Meetings were held clandestinely, often in apartments. The Bashkir People's Center "Ural" was established, standing at the forefront of the struggle to raise the state status of Bashkiria and support the recognition of the status of the state Bashkir language. The Bashkir youth organization "Union of Bashkir Youth" also became a driving force in the struggle for a sovereign Bashkortostan. [13]

Russian Federation

On October 11, 1990, in connection with the adoption of the Declaration of State Sovereignty the republic was transformed into the Bashkir Soviet Socialist Republic - Bashkortostan.

Since March 31, 1992, the Republic of Bashkortostan has been a part of the Russian Federation. In 1993, the Constitution of the Republic was adopted, reflecting many aspirations of the Bashkir people. A year later, the Republic of Bashkortostan and the Russian Federation signed a Federal Agreement on the Delimitation of Powers and Competence, according to which Bashkortostan was granted many republican rights within the Russian Federation. However, when Vladimir Putin came to power, many of the republic's rights were curtailed. The Constitution of Bashkortostan was rewritten under pressure from Moscow, and many articles and clauses were deleted. [14]

The difficult socio-economic situation during Putin's rule led to protest moods in the region. In 2005, thousands of people gathered in the center of Ufa, the capital of Bashkiria, demanding the restoration of social benefits abolished by the new monetization law. They also demanded higher pensions and wages. [15]

In response to the curtailment of constitutional rights and ongoing Russification, Bashkirs formed the nationwide organizations Kuk Bure and Bashkort (2014). These organizations raised the issues of protecting the rights and interests of the Bashkir people, the return of the republic's sovereignty and the 1993 Constitution of Bashkortostan. "Bashkort" held mass public actions in defense of the sovereignty of Bashkortostan, the Bashkir language and culture, and opposed the repression of activists of the Bashkir national movement, which has been ongoing since the election of President V. Putin. [16]

Criminal cases were brought against activists, in particular against the leaders of Kuk Bure and Bashkort, and some participants received prison sentences. In 2020, Bashkort was banned. One of the founders of the organization, Ruslan Gabbasov, was forced to flee Russia and found political asylum in Lithuania. He then formed the Bashkir National Political Center, which coordinates political activities aimed at gaining independence for the Republic of Bashkortostan. The Bashkir National Political Center joined the League of Free Nations, where representatives of national and regional movements of the Russian Federation fight for the independence of their peoples from Russia. [17]

Since 2022, the Bashkirs have been creating an armed underground. The main goals of the struggle are the national independence of Bashkiria, as well as the cessation of Russia's war of conquest with the forced mobilization of Bashkirs into the ranks of its armed forces. [18] [19] [20]

As of October 19, 2022, there were 2,700 people in the ranks of Bashkirs who had announced plans to engage in armed resistance to the Russian Federation. On October 3, partisans set fire to the office of the KPRF party in Salavat. On October 8, a military recruitment office was set on fire in the district center of Arkhangelsky District, 65 kilometers from Ufa. The activists demanded independence of the republic and also opposed the participation of Bashkirs in the war with Ukraine. [21] [22]

Language issue

Today in Bashkortostan there is a policy of reducing the use of the Bashkir language: communication in the Bashkir language is not accepted in any institution, practically all websites of state, municipal, and educational institutions do not allow registration in the Bashkir language.

In 2017, Vladimir Putin said that people should not be forced to learn a language "that is not their mother tongue." There has been controversy over the compulsory study of the Bashkir language at school. [23] [24]

In January 2019, the Advisory Committee of the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities of the Council of Europe criticized Russia for its national policy. The experts expressed concern about "the growing dominance of the Russian language" and at the same time "the lack of effective support for national minority languages". Bashkortostan is illustrative in this respect: in the 2021–2022 academic year, 99% of students in Bashkiria studied their native language. Of these, 68% chose Russian, 21% Bashkir and 9% Tatar. In addition, the native languages of the national republics of the Russian Federation are no longer part of the compulsory school program, unlike the compulsory Russian language. [25]

Moscow has pursued a policy of dismantling or reducing the size of several ethnic groups either by supporting linguistic schisms and cultural diversity within specific communities or by trying to create a super-ethnos to dilute national identities. One notable case involves relations between Bashkirs and Tatars in two Middle Volga republics. The Kremlin has manipulated and highlighted claims by some nationalists in both ethnicities that their populations have been assimilated by the other ethnic group. The primary objective is to divide the two nations, reduce the number of self-identifying Bashkirs,and curtail demands for sovereignty and potential statehood by Bashkortostan. [26]

Eco-activism and environmental protests in Bashkortostan

The corruption of the Moscow authorities and their consumerist policy towards the resources of Bashkortostan became the reason for environmental protests in the republic and the corresponding reaction of the authorities to them. In 2016, civil activist Alexander Veselov, chairman of the Union of Environmentalists of Bashkiria, was attacked in Ufa. The attack took place after he published a special report "Ecology and Ecolokhy in Bashkortostan" analyzing the activities of the Ministry of Ecology of the Russian Federation and exposing the Ministry's falsifications of publicly important information (e.g., on emissions of harmful substances into the atmosphere). [27]

In 2017, a well-known Bashkir public figure, civil activist and journalist Anver Yumagulov was beaten unconscious. [28]

In 2018, the Kushtau mountain (140 km from Ufa) was transferred to Bashkir Soda Company for mining lime, after which the local population protested - in particular, after mass logging began. Local residents consider Kushtau to be part of a single mountain massif with the Toratau and Yuraktau shikhans, which have the status of natural monuments. During two weeks of protests, about 80 activists were detained, and several of them were given administrative arrests. [29]

In August 2020, thousands of protesters organized marches and blocked roads to protect the Kushtau conservation areas. People lined up in a living chain with a huge flag of the republic. The confrontation with law enforcers continued for several days. The protesters, among other things, called for free elections to the regional government, which would have to support the people's demands rather than fulfill the will of the Kremlin. [30] [31]

Active environmental protests continued in 2023: eco-activist Ilsur Irnazarov was fined for organizing a gathering against illegal gold mining, [32] in Bashkortostan there was a people's gathering in defense of the Irandyk Ridge from gold miners. [33] [34]

The growing wave of eco-activism in the republic increasingly resembles citizens' struggle for self-government. [35] The Russian authorities are responding with bans: for example, the Administration of the Tanalyk Village Council of the Khaibullinsky District of Bashkortostan refused to approve a citizens' meeting on the issue of resettlement of local residents in connection with subsoil development. [36]

On January 15, 2024, hundreds of people came to the Baimak court in Bashkortostan to support eco-activist Fail Alsynov, who was charged with incitement to hatred because of his speech at a rally against gold mining. Those who came chanted slogans such as "Freedom to Fail Alsynov!", "Azatlyk!" ("Freedom!"), "Fail, we are with you!" and demanded the resignation of the region's head Radiy Khabirov. On January 17, the day of Alsynov's sentencing, several thousand people came to the courthouse. After learning that the activist was sentenced to four years, the protesters blocked the road, preventing the truck from leaving the courthouse. The protest turned into clashes with law enforcement agencies. The riot police used batons and tear gas cannons. [37] [38]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bashkirs</span> Turkic ethnic group

The Bashkirs or Bashkurts are a Kipchak-Bulgar Turkic ethnic group indigenous to Russia. They are concentrated in Bashkortostan, a republic of the Russian Federation and in the broader historical region of Badzhgard, which spans both sides of the Ural Mountains, where Eastern Europe meets North Asia. Smaller communities of Bashkirs also live in the Republic of Tatarstan, the oblasts of Perm Krai, Chelyabinsk, Orenburg, Tyumen, Sverdlovsk and Kurgan and other regions in Russia; sizable minorities exist in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ufa</span> Capital of Bashkortostan, Russia

Ufa is the largest city in and the capital of Bashkortostan, Russia. The city lies at the confluence of the Belaya and Ufa rivers, in the centre-north of Bashkortostan, on hills forming the Ufa Plateau to the west of the southern Ural Mountains, with a population of over 1.1 million residents, up to 1.4 million residents in the urban agglomeration. Ufa is the tenth-most populous city in Russia, and the fourth-most populous city in the Volga Federal District.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bashkortostan</span> First-level administrative division of Russia

Bashkortostan, officially the Republic of Bashkortostan, also known as Bashkiria, is a republic of Russia between the Volga and the Ural Mountains in Eastern Europe. The republic borders Perm Krai to the north, Sverdlovsk Oblast to the northeast, Chelyabinsk Oblast to the east, Orenburg Oblast to the south, Tatarstan to the west and Udmurtia to the northwest. It covers 143,600 square kilometres and has a population of 4 million. It is the seventh-most populous federal subject in Russia and the most populous republic. Its capital and largest city is Ufa.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Idel-Ural State</span> 1918 Tatar republic in Kazan and Ufa, Russia

The Idel-Ural State, also known as the Volga-Ural State or Idel-Ural Republic, was an unsuccessful attempt of the autonomy of Tatar peoples that claimed to unite Tatars, Bashkirs, the Chuvash in the turmoil of the Russian Civil War. The republic was proclaimed on 1 March 1918, by a Congress of Muslims from Russia's interior and Siberia, but defeated by Bolsheviks the same month. Idel-Ural means "Volga-Ural" in the Tatar language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sterlitamak</span> City in the Republic of Bashkortostan, Russia

Sterlitamak is the second largest city in the Republic of Bashkortostan, Russia, located on the left bank of the Belaya River, 121 kilometers (75 mi) from Ufa. The city's name comes from the Bashkir language and literally means "mouth of the Sterlya river". According to data released by Bashstat, Sterlitamak had a population of 277,410 at the time of the census. Permanent population of Sterlitamak as of January 1, 2023 amounted to 279,174 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Tatarstan</span> History of the Tatarstan region, Russia

The territory of Tatarstan, a republic of the Russian Federation, was inhabited by different groups during the prehistoric period. The state of Volga Bulgaria grew during the Middle Ages and for a time was subject to the Khazars. The Volga Bulgars became Muslim and incorporated various Turkic peoples to form the modern Volga Tatar ethnic group.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic</span> Autonomous soviet socialist republic of a union republic of the Soviet Union

The Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic, also historically known as Soviet Bashkiria or simply Bashkiria, was an autonomous republic of the Russian SFSR. Currently it is known as Republic of Bashkortostan, a federal subject of Russia. The Bashkir ASSR was the first Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic in the RSFSR.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baymak</span> Town in Bashkortostan, Russia

Baymak is a town in the Republic of Bashkortostan, Russia, located in the upper streams of the Tanalyk River 489 kilometers (304 mi) south of Ufa. Population: 17,710 (2010 Russian census); 17,223 (2002 Census); 15,976 (1989 Soviet census).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flag of Bashkortostan</span> Flag of the Russian republic of Bashkortostan

The flag of the Republic of Bashkortostan, in the Russian Federation, is one of the official symbols of the Republic of Bashkortostan, alongside the coat of arms and the national anthem of Bashkortostan. The flag has three horizontal stripes. From top to bottom, the stripes are teal blue, white, and green. The flag has been used officially as the flag of the Republic of Bashkortostan since 25 February 1992. The white stripe of the flag is charged with a Kurai flower in the center.

The history of Bashkortostan or Bashkiria covers the region in and around the Southern Urals, historically inhabited by Bashkirs. The region has been known by several names, including al-Bashgird, Bashgirdia, Bascardia, Fiyafi Bashqurt, Pascatir and similar variants. As with previous names, the modern federal subject of Bashkortostan was named after the native Bashkir people.

The Bashkir rebellion was one of the first major insurrection of the Bashkirs in the second half of the 17th century.

The Bashkir Rebellion from 1704 to 1711 was one of the longest in the series of Bashkir rebellions in the 17th and 18th centuries in the Russian Empire. The Bashkir uprisings of 1662–1664, 1681–1684, and 1704-1711 have been treated at length by Soviet and post-Soviet historians as evidence of Bashkiria's gradual incorporation into the empire and of Bashkir resistance to colonial oppression.

The Bashkir rebellion of 1735–1740 refers to a rebellion by the Bashkirs against the Russian Empire. It started in 1735, but was put down by Russian troops in 1740 after a series of heavy clashes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Radiy Khabirov</span> Bashkir politician (born 1964)

Radiy Faritovich Khabirov is a Russian politician and statesman. He is the current Head of the Republic of Bashkortostan since 11 October 2018; he is also the Candidate of Law, Honored Lawyer of the Republic of Bashkortostan. He is a member of United Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jalil Keyekbaev</span> Bashkir linguist and Turkologist

Jalil Giniyatovich Keyekbaev was a Bashkir linguist, Turkologist, doctor of philological sciences (1960), professor (1961), writer and member of the Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic Writers' Union. He is the founder of Bashkir linguistics and of the modern Bashkir school of Ural–Altaic languages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government of Bashkiria</span> Government of Bashkiria between 1917 and 1919

The Bashkir Government was the supreme executive authority of Bashkiria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bashkiria (1917–1919)</span> Short-lived state in Bashkortostan during the Russian Civil War

Bashkiria, also called Bashkortostan, Bashkurdistan, Lesser Bashkiria, or Autonomous Bashkiria, was a short-lived autonomous state which existed from 1917 to 1919, during the Russian Civil War. Aligned with the Russian State, Bashkiria was attacked and later annexed by the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic, leading to its 1919 collapse and succession by the Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Committee of Bashkir Resistance</span> Armed nationalist organization in Bashkortostan

The Committee of Bashkir Resistance is an armed nationalist organization active in the Bashkortostan region of Russia. Its main goal is gaining independence for Bashkortostan. It was founded on 21 September 2022. It is mainly engaged in minor arson attacks on Russian government buildings and police stations.

The 2024 Bashkortostan protests are a series of protests started on 15 January 2024 beginning in the Republic of Bashkortostan, Russia, sparked by the authorities initiating a criminal case against the Bashkir environmental activist Fail Alsynov, who was subsequently sentenced to four years in prison. This led to demonstrations in the town of Baymak, where at least 1,000 Bashkir protesters assembled. The protests resulted in clashes with the riot police, who in response deployed tear gas and batons against the protesters. The protests spread into the regional capital of Ufa on 19 January, where 10 people were arrested in response.

Ruslan Salavatovich Gabbasov is a Bashkir activist, one of the leaders of the Bashkir national movement abroad, founder of the Bashkir National Political Center and Bashkort. Leader and speaker of the Free Nations of Post-Russia Forum.

References

  1. "Traditional Communication Routes Of The Bashkirs In The Early Middle Ages".
  2. "Bashkir uprisings: a tradition that gives hope for the dismantling of the Russian Federation".
  3. "Башкирия в составе русского государства. Восстания против гнёта и насилия".(in Russian)
  4. Mehmet, Tepeyurt. Bashkirs between Two Worlds, 1552-1824 (PDF). pp. 75–88.
  5. Charles R. Steinwedel. Threads of Empire: Loyalty and Tsarist Authority in Bashkiria, 1552–1917. Indiana University Press. ISBN   9780253019332.
  6. Алтон С., Доннелли. Завоевание Башкирии Россией 1552-1740 (PDF). pp. 117–159.(in Russian)
  7. "The Bashkir Vanishes?".
  8. "Худайгулов, Тимербулат Султанович Башкирское восстание 1755-1756 гг".(in Russian)
  9. "Pugachev's Rebellion in the Bashkir Lands: 1773-1775".
  10. "Роль Башкортостана в становлении российского федерализма".(in Russian)
  11. Руслан, Габбасов. Записки башкирского националиста. Кук Буре. pp. 15–17.(in Russian)
  12. "Признание Центральной советской властью Башкирской Автономной республики (к 95-летию подписания "Соглашения. . . с Башкирским правительством. . . ")".(in Russian)
  13. "Рост национального самосознания башкир в конце 80-х".(in Russian)
  14. "Lessons from History: Russia's Repression of the Bashkirs".
  15. "RUSSIAN REGIONAL PROTESTS SPREAD TO INGUSHETIA, BASHKORTOSTAN".
  16. Bugajski, Janusz (2022). FAILED STATE A Guide to Russia’s Rupture (PDF). pp. 233–236.
  17. "The Bashkirs, by Askold S. Lozynskyj".
  18. "Bashkirs launch armed underground movement against Russia's war and for national independence".
  19. "Bashkir Separatism Movement Fights Against Russia's War From Within".
  20. "Coming Apart At The Seams? For Russia's Ethnic Minorities, Ukraine War Is A Chance To Press For Independence From Moscow".
  21. ""Это не наша война": башкирские националисты создают вооружённое сопротивление".(in Russian)
  22. "Russia: 'This is not our war': Bashkir nationalists create armed resistance".
  23. "Protesters in Russia's Bashkortostan voice support for Bashkir language in schools".
  24. "Eight Detained At Unsanctioned Protest In Russia's Bashkortostan".
  25. ""Самый проблемный фактор для башкирского языка — система дошкольного и школьного образования"".(in Russian)
  26. Bugajski, Janusz (2022). FAILED STATE A Guide to Russia’s Rupture (PDF). p. 180.
  27. "В Уфе избили местного эколога Александра Веселова".(in Russian)
  28. "В Уфе неизвестными избит гражданский активист Анвер Юмагулов".(in Russian)
  29. "Радий Хабиров заявил об уголовных делах против защитников Куштау".(in Russian)
  30. Bugajski, Janusz (2022). FAILED STATE A Guide to Russia’s Rupture (PDF). p. 203.
  31. "Long live Kushtau mountain and its defenders".
  32. "Баймакский экоактивист Ильсур Ирназаров оштрафован за организацию схода против незаконной золотодобычи".(in Russian)
  33. "В Башкортостане прошел народный сход в защиту хребта Ирандык от золотодобытчиков".(in Russian)
  34. "Russia: Activists in Bashkortostan protest against gold mining fearing for environment and their health".
  35. "5,000 Bashkirs Protest Russian Mining, Putting Putin's Plans To Make Russia Self-Sufficient In Manganese – OpEd".
  36. "Экоактивизм в Башкортостане: головная боль для колониальных властей".(in Russian)
  37. "Thousands In Russia's Bashkortostan Demand Acquittal Of Activist".
  38. "Bashkortostan protests against jail term reach regional capital Ufa".