Big Three (World War II)

Last updated
The Big Three at Tehran Conference. From the left: Soviet leader Joseph Stalin, American President Franklin Roosevelt, and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill Joseph Stalin, Franklin D Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, in Teheran, 1943, edit.jpg
The Big Three at Tehran Conference. From the left: Soviet leader Joseph Stalin, American President Franklin Roosevelt, and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill

Big Three is a term used in the context of World War II to refer to the main powers among the Allies of World War II, and their respective leaders: Franklin D. Roosevelt of the United States, Winston Churchill of the United Kingdom, and Joseph Stalin of the Soviet Union. In 1945, Roosevelt and Churchill were replaced by their successors (Harry S. Truman and Clement Attlee), who are sometimes counted among the Big Three as well.

Contents

Composition of the Big Three

The term is also sometimes used to refer to the three countries, and not just their leaders. [1]

Harry S. Truman and Clement Attlee are also sometimes counted as the members, as "five individual members of the Big Three". They were successors to, respectively, Roosevelt and Churchill; the first of whom died shortly before the war ended, and the second of whom lost the democratic election around that time. [2] [3]

History

The Big Three at Yalta Conference. From the left: British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, American President Franklin Roosevelt, and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin Yalta Conference (Churchill, Roosevelt, Stalin) (B&W).jpg
The Big Three at Yalta Conference. From the left: British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, American President Franklin Roosevelt, and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin
The Big Three at Postdam Conference. From the left: British Prime Minister Clement Attlee, American President Harry S. Truman and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin Potsdam big three.jpg
The Big Three at Postdam Conference. From the left: British Prime Minister Clement Attlee, American President Harry S. Truman and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin

The relation between the Big Three evolved over time, as eventually all three countries became Allies of World War II, with USSR and United States entering the war in 1941, two years after the UK. [2] The three leaders stayed in touch through various means of communication, including personał correspondence [4] . Much of the negotiations between the Big Three was done in person during the two big war-time conferences: the Tehran Conference in November-December 1943 and the Yalta Conference of February 1945; Churchill and Stalin also met shortly after the end of the war during the Potsdam Conference(July-August that year; Roosevelt already passed away in April). [2]

Key topics of negotiations revolved around drawing the post-war spheres of influence between Western Allies and the USSR, major points of contention included the future of Germany and Poland. [2] The leaders of the Big Three saw their alliance as not only the means to win the ongoing war, but also as the means to reform the existing world order. [5]

Initially, Churchill and Roosevelt had the most influence, as the USSR was struggling following the German invasion of the country. This changed around 1944 with the importance of United Kingdom diminishing, and Churchill and the UK were no longer seen as "equals" by the other two partners. The concept of Big Three became less important around the time the world ended, as it became obvious that the two dominant world powers of the new era would be the United States and the Soviet Union. [2] [5]

The partnership of the Big Three succeeded in winning the war and utterly destroying the infrastructure of Nazism, but despite the establishment of the United Nations, failed to establish lasting peace which they aspired to in their public declarations. [5]

Dynamic of the relationship

Within the Big Three, Roosevelt and Churchill were more closer to one another, due to common culture and ideology (as the leading powers among the Western Allies). [6] The British-American relationship during the war was also formalized through treaties such as the Atlantic Charter. [2] The relationship between Stalin and Churchill was the most problematic, as Stalin tended to trust and respect Roosevelt more than Churchill. [6] Nonetheless there was various instances of personal and impersonal communiques between only two leaders, including Roosevelt and Stalin and Churchill and Stalin; in such instances, discussing the third leader "behind his back" was a common occurrence. [2] There were also instances of the two leaders meeting without the third, in person (for example; Churchill met Stalin as early as in 1942 during the Moscow Conference; Roosevelt and Churchill met early in 1945 at Malta Conference). [3]

Many historians see the most powerful and successful figure in this relationship, and the winner in the negotiations, arguing that Churchill and Roosevelt were guilty of conceding to his demands too often. [2] [5]

Historiography

The relationship between the Big Three leaders has been a subject of numerous scholarly studies. [5] Monographs on this topic include Robin Edmonds's Big Three: Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin in Peace & War (1991) [5] [7] and Paul Dukes Great Men in the Second World War: The Rise and Fall of the Big Three (2017). [3] [8] [9]

All three leaders have been discussed through, among others, the great man theory, and likely saw themselves as such, believing that they had the power and ability to decide the fate of the world. [2]

The dynamic of the Big Three relationship has been the main theme of the 2015 board game Churchill: Big Three Struggle for Peace by GMT Games. [10] [11] [12]

See also

References

  1. Reynolds, David (1990-07-01). "The 'Big Three' and the division of Europe, 1945–48: An overview". Diplomacy and Statecraft. doi:10.1080/09592299008405788.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Dukes, Paul (2005). "The Rise and Fall of the Big Three" (PDF). History Review (52): 42–47.
  3. 1 2 3 Weinberg, Gerhard L. (2018-11-02). "Great Men in the Second World War: The Rise and Fall of the Big Three". History: Reviews of New Books. 46 (6): 162–163. doi:10.1080/03612759.2018.1510223. ISSN   0361-2759.
  4. Печатнов, В.О. (2009-10-28). "Сталин - Рузвельт - Черчилль: «большая тройка» через призму переписки военных лет" [Stalin—Roosevelt—Churchill: the Big Three through the wartime correspondence]. Вестник МГИМО-Университета. 0 (5(8)). doi:10.24833/2071-8160-2009-5-8-59-69. ISSN   2541-9099. Archived from the original on 2023-11-28.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Kingseed, Cole C. (1992). "Review of The Big Three: Churchill, Roosevelt, and Stalin in Peace and War". Naval War College Review. 45 (2): 129–130. ISSN   0028-1484.
  6. 1 2 Ponomarenko, L. V.; Васильевна, Пономаренко Людмила; Chikrizova, O. S.; Сергеевна, Чикризова Ольга (2015-12-15). "«The Big Three» (J. Stalin, F. Roosevelt, W. Churchill): Allies for the Peace". Vestnik RUDN. International Relations (in Russian). 0 (2): 73–81. ISSN   2313-0679.
  7. Danchev, Alex (1992). "The Big Three: Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin in Peace and War by Robin Edmonds (Book Review)". The Journal of Military History. 56 (3): 517.
  8. Cunningham, Sean P. (2018-09-01). "Great Men in the Second World War: The Rise and Fall of the Big Three. By Paul Dukes. (London and New York, NY: Bloomsbury Press, 2017. Pp. 216. $88.00.)". The Historian. 80 (3): 628–629. doi:10.1111/hisn.12992. ISSN   0018-2370.
  9. Dimitrakis, Panagiotis (2019-10-02). "Great men in the Second World War: the rise and fall of the big three: by Paul Dukes, London, Bloomsbury Academic, 2017, 216 pp., £63.00/£26.09 (hardback/paperback), ISBN 978-1-474-26808-0/978-1-474-26807-3". Diplomacy & Statecraft. 30 (4): 845–846. doi:10.1080/09592296.2019.1666489. ISSN   0959-2296.
  10. Ambrosio, Thomas; Ross, Jonathan (2023-03-15). "Performing the Cold War through the 'The Best Board Game on the Planet': The Ludic Geopolitics of Twilight Struggle". Geopolitics. 28 (2): 846–878. doi:10.1080/14650045.2021.1951251. ISSN   1465-0045.
  11. Thrower, Matt (2019-05-03). "Churchill Review". There Will Be Games. Retrieved 2025-02-19.
  12. Rich, J. Peter; Carey, Steve (2015-08-27). "Churchill—The Game of Strategy". International Churchill Society. Retrieved 2025-02-19.