Fishbowl exercise at a 2018 Red/Blue workshop in Wellesley, Mass.
Braver Angels (formerly Better Angels) is a New York-based 501(c)(3) nonprofit dedicated to political depolarization. The organization runs workshops, debates, and other events where "red" (conservative) and "blue" (liberal) participants attempt to better understand one another's positions and discover their shared values.[1][2][3][4]
The organization states that it is the "largest, grassroots, bipartisan organization in America dedicated to reviving the communal spirit of American democracy."[5] As noted by Cavendish, they say that their "method involves bringing politically diverse people together in small groups to listen empathetically to each others’ perspectives."[6]
Founding
David Blankenhorn, a co-founder of Braver Angels, at their 2023 national convention
Braver Angels states that it seeks to build a national movement and, since 2018, it has sponsored conventions for its members across the United States. For its first convention, in June 2018, Braver Angels selected 72 conservative and 72 liberal delegates. The organization reported that over 100 delegates signed "An American Declaration." In their declaration, the signers claim to represent 3,100 members in a call for an end of political polarization and their affirmation of "a shared faith that this land we love will again be touched by the better angels of our nature."[10] The convention had musical performances by Peter Yarrow, Dana LaCroix, and Steve Seskin.[11]
Utah Gov. Spencer Cox at the 2023 national convention of Braver Angels, Gettysburg PA.
The 2019 convention was held in St. Louis, MO. The delegates passed a platform and heard from speakers, including leaders from Black Lives Matter NY and the Tea Party in Cincinnati.[12] The 2020 convention, planned for Charlotte, NC, was cancelled due to the COVID pandemic.
At its July 2023 convention in Gettysburg, PA, a featured speaker was Utah Gov. Spencer Cox, who created the "Disagree Better" initiative of the National Governors Association. Gettysburg was chosen as the site of Lincoln's Gettysburg address, which inspired the organizations original name ("We must not be enemies. … The mystic chords of memory … will yet swell the chorus of the Union when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature."), as co-founder Blankenhorn told journalists.[13] The convention included music and political sketches. A performance by Gangstagrass began with a skit, with co-founder Bill Doherty in a barber's chair getting a haircut by local barber. During the skit, Hawk Newsome of Black Lives Matter, chided the audience for "snickering" he'd heard when he had talked about reparations.[14]
Watch party for the Biden-Trump debate, Braver Angels National Convention, June 27, 2024
The 2024 Braver Angels national convention was held on June 27-29 in Kenosha, WI. The program focused on four issues: "Abortion, Economic Inequality / Economic Growth, Free Speech / Hate Speech, and Immigration." Featured speakers included Jay Bhattacharya, Batya Ungar-Sargon, Jonathan Rauch, and Monica Harris of the Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism.[15] Besides political discussions, the convention schedule includes music and theatre: The New York Theatre Workshop has recruited local youth for a performance.[16] On the first night, Braver Angels had a watch party for the Biden-Trump presidential debate. Braver Angels believes that theirs was the largest debate watch party in the U.S.[17][18]
Workshops and debates
As its main activity, Braver Angels run conversations among Americans with opposing political views. Its flagship discussion format has been the Red/Blue workshops. The Red/Blue workshops are designed to facilitate understanding and conversations between conservative Reds and liberal Blues. Ideally, the number of Red and Blue participants is balanced for each session. The workshop was designed by Braver Angels co-founder, Prof. William Doherty, an expert in family social science at the University of Minnesota, based on therapy methods use in couples counseling.[19] In a chapter for a book published by the American Psychological Association, Doherty "describes the origin and development of Braver Angels, with special attention to the workshops it offers, its initial impact. It connects some key decisions in the outreach of Braver Angels to citizen therapist principles."[19]
Doherty's pilot effort was in December 2016, with weekend workshop in Ohio for 10 Clinton and 10 Trump supporters.[20] The workshop principles are similar to those needed for married clients, as summarized by the WSJ, "Speak for yourself; don’t interpret what’s going on in the other person’s mind. Accept your own contribution to the problem—and that you can only change yourself. Focus on what you have in common: the shared history, goals, aspirations and values."[21]
At Braver Angels workshops and conventions, participants wear red or blue to indicate their political stance as leaning conservative or liberal.
In a typical format, the workshop starts with each color-coded group identifying the stereotypes of their group. They then share these with the other group.[22] The stereotyping exercise is followed by one or more additional exercises: the fishbowl, where one group does all the talking on a topic, while the other group forms a circle around them to listen; the questions exercise, where mixed Red/Blue groups discuss their answers to questions that had been generated by each (Red or Blue) group; and the "How Can We Contribute" exercise, whereby red- and blue-identified participants are paired up and share in response to a multi-faceted prompt: "What can each of us do individually, what can our side do, and what might both sides do together to promote better understanding of differences and search for common ground?"[23]
By April 2022, the organization had conducted "nearly 1,600 Red/Blue Workshops and 275 structured debates in all 50 states."[22] The debates reportedly were shown to more than 15,000 people, with such speakers as former Ohio Governor Ted Strickland, author Andrew Sullivan, and former House Majority Leader Dick Gephardt.[24]
In addition, Braver Angels offers "Braver Seminars," published works ("Braver Angels Publishing"), and convenes scholars and public intellectuals.[25]
The group also created a "Skills for Bridging the Divide" workshop. In a 2.5 hour format, the workshop aims to convey information about meaningful, non-polarizing discussions, give participants some hands-on practice, and to convince people to do such bridge-building.[26] This training covered three key listening skills -- paraphrasing, clarifying and acknowledging (or agreeing) -- and its speaking skills include pivoting, to introduce a divergent viewpoint, and offering one's own viewpoint, including "I statements" and expressions of concern. The training also cautioned people against pitfalls and counter-productive behavior.[27]
Presentation by the "Trustworthy Elections" team at the 2023 Braver Angels Convention in Gettyburg, PA
In the wake of the 2020 election, Braver Angels conducted 26 "Trustworthy Elections" workshops, guided by a national task force, and issued a report. The report highlighted 3 principles: “Voting should be easy. Cheating should be hard.” “Every citizen should have an equal say in who will govern them; this is done through free and fair elections.” “The American government will fail if candidates refuse to accept any outcome other than victory.” The final report made 26 recommendations in seven areas, including Gerrymandering in the United States, voting access, vote counting, voter identification, and "peaceful transition of power."[28]
Organization
David Blankenhorn is the president of Braver Angels.[7] Prior to Braver Angels, Blankenhorn worked to prevent the legalization of gay marriage; in 2012, he announced that he continues to believe gay marriage is morally wrong, but is in favor of its legalization as a political compromise.[29] John Wood Jr. produces the Braver Angels podcast and YouTube channel. He is a Republican politician in LA county. The board of directors include Blankenhorn, social psychologist and author Jonathan Haidt, and Glenn Stanton of Focus on the Family. [30]
The demographics of Braver Angels participants is mostly white, college educated, and older.[22] While conventions and many workshops are designed for balanced representation, the organization reported that across its 2021 events, self-identified Democrats significantly outnumbered Republicans.[14] In 2022, the organization's expenses were $2.9 million, mainly for "Bridging social divides" and public outreach, with year end net assets of $1.4 million, according to Braver Angels financial statements.[31]
Although Braver Angels does not track their members' religiosity, Christian communities have played a significant role in the organization. For example, in 2018, churches in Florida requested, sponsored, and hosted Braver Angels events. In 2020, "Malice Toward None" was a Braver Angels initiative aimed at reducing partisan animosity within religious communities. (Cavendish 2023, p.13) In advance of its 2024 Convention, the Latter Day Saints Magazine promoted a local conversation series as well as registering delegates for the convention.[32] In addition, an elder of the LDS church was a featured speaker at the 2023 Convention.[33] Sociologist James Cavendish believes that religious groups should use the Braver Angels model, among others, to counter polarization in America and build more robust social relationships, regardless of political antagonism.[6]
The group's website promotes a 50-minute documentary about an early Red/Blue workshop, on April 2017 in Waynesville, Ohio, entitled Better Angels: Reuniting America. It was produced by Peter Yarrow and directed by Jim Brown.[35]
Books published by Braver Angels leaders about depolarizing efforts, including Blankenhorn's In Search of Braver Angels, Guzman's I Never Thought of it That Way: How to Have Fearlessly Curious Conversations in Dangerously Divided Times.[36] (There are also books that highlight Braver Angels, such as Bomey's Bridge builders: bringing people together in a polarized age.[37])
Collaborations
Convention speakers included Erica Manuel of the Institute for Local Government, a collaborating partner with Braver Angels. July 2023
Braver Angels has pursued collaboration with other organizations geared to civic discourse. Notably, it set up the "Braver Network" that lists dozens of organizations who are loosely affiliated. The network is co-chaired by Bridge USA, Institute for Local Government, and StoryCorps. For example, StoryCorps lists the Braver Angels' 1:1 conversations among its One Small Step recommendations.[38]
The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) has sponsored about 200 Brave Angels debates on more than 75 college campuses, on many topics, with support from Braver angels and BridgeUSA.[39] At the local level, Braver Angels developed alliances and interest groups, including a music community, a film club, a book club, technology lab, equality caucus, and faith caucus.[40]
On occasion, media organizations have explicitly supported workshops, such as the USA Today Ohio Network publicizing Braver Angels workshop after the 2020 elections.[41]
In another collaboration, Braver Angels adapted its "Skills for Bridging the Divide" workshop for a national climate advocacy organization. After a pilot run, Braver Angels ran 8 workshops for 403 participants, done online through Zoom. According to an evaluation of this effort, the participants reported that, by large margin, they improved their ability to set a constructive tone, in difficult conversations, and to "listen to people on the other side in a way that they felt heard." However, the evaluation conceded that the demographic of participants was not representative, i.e., older, female, white, and liberal. Furthermore, the study did not examine conversations with political conservatives or those who disputed climate change solution.[26]
Political engagement
Braver Angels defines itself a "nonpartisan group whose mission is to study and strengthen civil society" with a focus on reducing polarization. Within this scope, its "Braver Politics" activities include skill workshops for candidates and elected officials, candidate debates, "neighborhood conversations," and "town halls" with political candidates. It also offers its flagship Red/Blue workships for elected officials or their staff.[42]
For example, Braver Angels ran workshops for mayors in Minnesota, county commissioners in North Carolina, election day officials in New Hampshire, and with 60 members of the U.S. House of Representatives "Problem Solving Caucus."[20]
Braver Angels provides its own certificate for its skills workshops for elected officials.[42]
Scholarship on Braver Angels
Scholars who doubt that Braver Angels can actually reduce polarization include psychologist Peter Coleman. Coleman argues that animosity between groups is stronger than a single workshop can change: "Just meeting with other people, particularly once for a short period of time, is insufficient to changing people's attitudes, habits, the media they watch, the internet that they serve."[22]
Alex Zamalin, author of Against Civility, The Hidden Racism in Our Obsession with Civility, argues that Braver Angels is only looking at civic politeness and thus does not address the power dynamics that are needed for political change.[22]
Out of Braver Angels' workshops, "Red/Blue workshops" have received the most scholarly investigation. The Red/Blue workshops have been characterized as "reciprocal group reflection."[43] Scholarship on Braver Angels has included an examination of its meetings as artistic performances[44] and as comparable to religious teachings, such as those dealing with reconciliation and creating opportunities to "listen attentively and empathetically to [people's] authentic concerns."[6]:7
Scholars have also begun to investigate the effects of Braver Angels on political polarization. One study, which had undergraduate college students participate in Red/Blue workshops, found that "that depolarization is especially effective when it includes both informational and emotional components, such that citizens who are moved to empathize with outgroup members become more likely to internalize new information about them."[43] One study found that Red/Blue workshop participants learned to get along with each other, understand each other's positions, and identify points of common interest, and improved their skills in relating across political differences.[45]
The Braver Angels approach also has been used as a model to compare methodologies for mutual understanding between people from opposing partisan communities, such as "imagined dialogue" as an arts-oriented mode for improving empathy.[46] Hartman et al. cover a variety of other organizations that aim to defuse partisan animosity, including AllSides, BridgeUSA, FairVote, Living Room Conversations, and Public Agenda.[47]
Scholars seek to identify how Braver Angels workshops increase receptivity to conversations with political opponents. In a study of Red/Blue workshop methods, Oliver-Blackburn et al. found that Braver Angels facilitators effectively promoted dialogue by using five strategies: "greetings, acknowledging power differences, enforcing ground rules, listening actively, and providing appreciation for sharing." (p.62) Furthermore, they found that Braver Angels was successful due to three features of Red/Blue workshop design: "(a) Limiting assumptions through perspective-taking, (b) locating shared interests and commonalities, and (c) intentionally structuring the order of the workshop activities." (p.62) Researchers found that a crucial element for perspective-taking and conversations was the agenda order, allowing Blue and Red participants to first meet separately with their own in-group and safely explore their own viewpoints, before trying to listen and attend to people with an opposing perspective.[48]
Related Research Articles
Bohm Dialogue is a freely flowing group conversation in which participants attempt to reach a common understanding, experiencing everyone's point of view fully, equally and nonjudgmentally. This can lead to new and deeper understanding. The purpose is to solve the communication crises that face society, and indeed the whole of human nature and consciousness. It utilizes a theoretical understanding of the way thoughts relate to universal reality. It is named after physicist David Bohm who originally proposed this form of dialogue.
Conversation is interactive communication between two or more people. The development of conversational skills and etiquette is an important part of socialization. The development of conversational skills in a new language is a frequent focus of language teaching and learning. Conversation analysis is a branch of sociology which studies the structure and organization of human interaction, with a more specific focus on conversational interaction.
Political polarization is the divergence of political attitudes away from the center, towards ideological extremes. Scholars distinguish between ideological polarization and affective polarization.
Starting with the 2000 United States presidential election, the terms "red state" and "blue state" have referred to U.S. states whose voters vote predominantly for one party—the Republican Party in red states and the Democratic Party in blue states—in presidential and other statewide elections. By contrast, states where the vote fluctuates between the Democratic and Republican candidates are known as "swing states" or "purple states". Examining patterns within states reveals that the reversal of the two parties' geographic bases has happened at the state level, but it is more complicated locally, with urban-rural divides associated with many of the largest changes.
The 2004 United States presidential election was the 55th quadrennial presidential election, held on Tuesday, November 2, 2004. The Republican ticket of incumbent President George W. Bush and his running mate incumbent Vice President Dick Cheney were elected to a second term, defeating the Democratic ticket of John Kerry, a United States senator from Massachusetts and his running mate John Edwards, a United States senator from North Carolina.
A facilitator is a person who helps a group of people to work together better, understand their common objectives, and plan how to achieve these objectives, during meetings or discussions. In doing so, the facilitator remains "neutral", meaning they do not take a particular position in the discussion. Some facilitator tools will try to assist the group in achieving a consensus on any disagreements that preexist or emerge in the meeting so that it has a solid basis for future action.
The term safe space refers to places "intended to be free of bias, conflict, criticism, or potentially threatening actions, ideas, or conversations". The term originated in LGBT culture, but has since expanded to include any place where a marginalized minority can come together to communicate regarding their shared experiences. Safe spaces are most commonly located on university campuses in the western world, but also are at workplaces, as in the case of Nokia.
Reflective listening is a communication strategy used to better understand a speaker's idea by offering your understanding of their idea back to the speaker in order to confirm that the idea has been understood correctly. It is a more specific strategy than general methods of active listening.
Civil discourse is the practice of deliberating about matters of public concern in a way that seeks to expand knowledge and promote understanding. The word "civil" relates directly to civic in the sense of being oriented toward public life, and less directly to civility, in the sense of mere politeness. Discourse is defined as the use of written or spoken communications, similar to having a conversation. Civil discourse includes the practice of deliberating about things that are of concern to society in a way that seeks to help all participants understand each other. It is an essential part of democratic citizenship and is thus a fundamental aspect of freedom of speech, characterized by dialogue that supports the societal good." For civil discourse to truly be effective as a democratic tool, all people need to be heard and share their viewpoints. Civil discourse involves more than just politeness; it involves disagreement without disrespect, seeking common ground, listening beyond preconceptions, and remaining present in dialogues despite deep disagreements. This can help develop better public policies that benefit all people of a society. Members of the U.S. Supreme Court session in 2011 aptly described civil discourse as "robust, honest, frank and constructive dialogue and deliberation that seeks to advance the public interest." Viewpoints are grounded in reason and evidence, adhering to strict guidelines for the appropriate behavior to be practiced. In contrast, uncivil discourse contains direct insults, unwarranted attributions of motive, and open contempt." Civil discourse has its foundation on several key values:
The AARP/Blue Zones Vitality Project is an initiative aimed at improving well-being that began in January 2009 when the city of Albert Lea, Minnesota, launched the initiative with assistance from the United Health Foundation and led by Dan Buettner, author of "The Blue Zones: Lessons for Living Longer From the People Who've Lived the Longest."
David Blankenhorn is an American political activist who is the founder and president of the Institute for American Values and the co-founder of Braver Angels. He is also co-director of The Marriage Opportunity Council and the author of Fatherless America and The Future of Marriage. A noted figure in the campaign against same-sex marriage in the United States, his position changed and he voiced support of legalizing same-sex marriage in June 2012.
National Debate Federation Bangladesh (NDF BD) is one of the largest debate associations in Bangladesh. NDF BD organize National Debate festivals, Medical Debate Festivals, Debate Competition, Debate Workshops, Career and Debate School, Quiz competition and leadership skills development workshops. The main objective of NDF BD is taking debate to the districts and beyond to create social awareness among students on various social, political and economic issues to enhance and facilitate the development of value-based human resources. More than sixty public & private universities, two hundred school & colleges and ten non-educational debating organizations are working in the same platform.
StoryCorps is an American non-profit organization which aims to record, preserve, and share the stories of Americans from all backgrounds and beliefs. Its mission statement is "to help us believe in each other by illuminating the humanity and possibility in us all—one story at a time". StoryCorps grew out of Sound Portraits Productions as a project founded in 2003 by radio producer David Isay. Its headquarters are located in the Fort Greene neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York.
The Institute for American Values was a New York City think tank focused on family and social issues.
Peter Thomas Coleman is a social psychologist and researcher in the field of conflict resolution and sustainable peace. Coleman is best known for his work on intractable conflicts and applying complexity science.
Mark M. Beckwith was the tenth bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Newark. He is the author of the book Seeing the Unseen: Beyond Prejudices, Paradigms and Party Lines.
Beyond Us & Them is a Los Angeles–based nonprofit organization that trains practitioners in using council to promote wellness and resiliency and utilizes the practice of council to enhance social connection, well being, and restorative justice as well as foster resilient and thriving communities. Beyond Us & Them offers programs and trainings within the social justice, educational, law enforcement and health care systems, and in partnership with businesses and community-based organizations.
Political polarization is a prominent component of politics in the United States. Scholars distinguish between ideological polarization and affective polarization, both of which are apparent in the United States. In the last few decades, the U.S. has experienced a greater surge in ideological polarization and affective polarization than comparable democracies.
Tania Israel is an American psychologist and professor in the Gevirtz Graduate School of Education at the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB). Her research focuses on the development and implementation of interventions to support the mental health and well-being of LGBTQ individuals and communities. Israel has presented about dialogue across political lines and is the author of Beyond Your Bubble: How to Connect Across the Political Divide, Skills and Strategies for Conversations That Work. She is also known for writing song lyrics, memoir, and bisexual haiku.
America in One Room was a 2019 event that assembled the largest representative sample of the American voting electorate in history to discuss polarizing political issues. It utilized a method called deliberative polling, led by Stanford Professors James Fishkin and Larry Diamond of the Center for Deliberative Democracy. The event was funded and operated by Helena, an organization that implements projects to address global challenges.
1 2 3 Cavendish, James (Spring 2023). "Religion as a Resource in an Increasingly Polarized Society". Sociology of Religion. 84 (1): 1–15. doi:10.1093/socrel/srac033.
1 2 Doherty, William J.; Mendenhall, Tai J. (2024). "Braver Angels: Counteracting political polarization". Becoming a citizen therapist: Integrating community problem-solving into your work as a healer. pp.93–111. doi:10.1037/0000378-008. ISBN978-1-4338-3986-3.
↑ "Braver U". Braver Angels. Retrieved June 14, 2024.
1 2 Malow, Beth A., Maryanne Colter, Connie Shortes, Steve E. Saltwick, Bruce W. Morlan, M. Susan Adams, and William J. Doherty. "Bridging the divide on climate solutions: Development, implementation, and evaluation of an online workshop for climate volunteers." The Journal of Climate Change and Health 7 (2022): 100177.
1 2 Baron, Hannah, Robert Blair, Donghyun Danny Choi, Laura Gamboa, Jessica Gottlieb, Amanda Lea Robinson, Steven Rosenzweig, Megan Turnbull, and Emily A. West. "Can Americans depolarize? Assessing the effects of reciprocal group reflection on partisan polarization." (2021).
↑ Fletcher, John. "Braver Angels." Theater and Human Flourishing (2023): 57
↑ Jacobs 2019 as cited in Oliver-Blackburn, Bailey M., and April Chatham-Carpenter. "‘But I don’t know if I want to talk to you’: strategies to foster conversational receptiveness across the United States’ political divide." Journal of Applied Communication Research 51, no. 1 (2023): 55-71.
↑ Dashew, Brian, Karen Doyle Grossman, and Randee Lawrence. "Listening to the voices of dissent: bridging political polarization through imagined dialogue." Reflective Practice 21, no. 6 (2020): 773-785, at p.778
↑ Hartman, Rachel, Will Blakey, Jake Womick, Chris Bail, Eli J. Finkel, Hahrie Han, John Sarrouf et al. "Interventions to reduce partisan animosity." Nature human behaviour 6, no. 9 (2022): 1194-1205.
↑ Oliver-Blackburn, Bailey M., and April Chatham-Carpenter. "‘But I don’t know if I want to talk to you’: strategies to foster conversational receptiveness across the United States’ political divide." Journal of Applied Communication Research 51, no. 1 (2023): 55-71.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
