Charter Schools and Their Enemies

Last updated
Charter Schools and Their Enemies
Charter Schools and Their Enemies.jpg
First edition
Author Thomas Sowell
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Subject Education
PublisherBasic Books New York
Publication date
June 30, 2020
Media typePrint (Hardcover and Paperback), and audiobook
Pages276
ISBN 978-1-541-67513-1
OCLC 1137840292
Preceded byDiscrimination and Disparities 

Charter Schools and Their Enemies is a 2020 book by American economist, social theorist and author Thomas Sowell, in which he compares the educational outcomes of school children educated at charter schools with those at conventional public schools. [1] He argues that charter schools on the whole do significantly better in terms of educational outcomes than conventional schools.

Contents

He believes the school system in the United States is in need of reform and makes the case for why the charter school movement is a force for good and how it will help to bring about that reform. It is Sowell's 56th book and was published on his 90th birthday. [2]

Summary

Sowell argues that charter schools are better than conventional schools in numerous ways, but most importantly on educational outcomes. He dispels many claims made about charter schools and tries to demonstrate the need for educational reform in the United States. Sowell dedicates the book to "those children whose futures hang in the balance" as a result of the current state of the education system. [3] [2]

Sowell starts by explaining the current situation with charter schools. He explains that public opinion of charter schools is very divided with some calling it either "a striking success or a 'failed and damaging experiment'". [4] He begins by presenting the case of what he sees as a highly successful school in America; Dunbar High School. He highlights the school because he regards it as an institute that brought huge success for black students in the years 1870 to 1955, which showed that this was possible many years before Brown v. Board of Education , which he has criticised. In these years the school produced the first black federal judge, the first black general, the first black cabinet member, and America's first three black women PhDs. He believes the charter school movement could produce schools as good as Dunbar High but has not yet due to the constant push back against charter schools from teachers unions, politicians, and regulators who want to make charter schools more like traditional schools. The hostility of those critics, Sowell says, is a result of the corrupting influence of money, power, and political advantage, but rarely the best interests of children. [1]

He points out that charter schools have been in high demand by parents ever since they began in the 1990s with long waiting lists and a lottery for available slots. This has happened despite strong political and procedural pressures against them. Sowell argues that the threat to schools comes from the political message of “reform,” which undermines “the urgent task of educating young people in the skills that will determine what kind of future they will have available as adults”. [5] [2]

Sowell presents a great deal of data and statistics comparing the performance of students within charter and public schools. He concludes that charter schools are an effective weapon against an "achievement gap" between white students and black students with the former often doing better than the latter in educational outcomes at normal schools. An example he gives that aims to prove this point is an example of one predominantly-black charter school with an average household income of $49,000 that had higher test scores than wealthier schools with average household incomes some five times higher. [6]

Sowell explains the ways of measuring results, then lays out the latest data and statistics on educational results in charter schools with appropriate comparisons of standard schools. With these statistics, Sowell lays out his central thesis that charter schools have far better educational outcomes for the students that attend them. [7]

Sowell states that charter schools are much more accountable than most typical public schools. This is because while not all charter schools are successful, they can have their charters revoked which cuts off access to public funds. This means that charter schools are incentivised to do better and are accountable to those who are in control of the funding. This, he writes, is not the case with traditional public schools which do not always have their access to public funds cut off if they start to fail. [8]

A notable quotation from Sowell in regards to dangers to education and charter schools was pointed out in a review by the National Review magazine: "What we can do is consider in advance what kind of general principles and specific institutions seem promising. Perhaps the most important of these general principles is that schools exist for the education of children. Schools do not exist to provide iron-clad jobs for teachers, billions of dollars in union dues for teachers unions, monopolies for educational bureaucracies, a guaranteed market for teachers college degrees or a captive audience for indoctrinators". [9]

Reception

Kevin D. Williamson praised the book in National Review, calling it "a bloodbath for Sowell’s intellectual opponents … a neutron bomb in the middle of the school-reform debate.” [9] Charter school advocate Robert Pondiscio agreed and said that the book was a “a metaphorical punch in the nose” for charter school critics and that Sowell “provide[s] ammunition for the fight,” predicting that the book would “embarrass charter critics.” [1] Economists Gary M. Galles and Art Carden, in the Independent Review and the Cato Journal respectively, also wrote positive reviews of the book. [2] [10]

Glenn Sacks, co-chairman of teachers union United Teachers Los Angeles, argues that the high test scores of charter schools are a result of only top students being allowed into charter schools. He cites former Assistant Secretary of Education Diane Ravitch who claimed that charter schools consist only of "the most motivated students and their families" and a study by professor Gordon Lafer that claimed charter admission policies screen out underperforming students who would be the neediest and most expensive to serve. [11] Sowell argues that these criticisms are either invalid or blown out of proportion relative to the benefits of many charter schools, especially for demographic groups that have typically been underserved by their local school district, such as minority and low income populations. In other words, his book argues that the benefits far outweigh the criticisms, and that these criticisms themselves are often misleading.

Related Research Articles

Education reform is the name given to the goal of changing public education. The meaning and education methods have changed through debates over what content or experiences result in an educated individual or an educated society. Historically, the motivations for reform have not reflected the current needs of society. A consistent theme of reform includes the idea that large systematic changes to educational standards will produce social returns in citizens' health, wealth, and well-being.

A school voucher, also called an education voucher in a voucher system, is a certificate of government funding for students at schools chosen by themselves or their parents. Funding is usually for a particular year, term, or semester. In some countries, states, or local jurisdictions, the voucher can be used to cover or reimburse home schooling expenses. In some countries, vouchers only exist for tuition at private schools.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Sowell</span> American author, economist, and conservative political commentator

Thomas Sowell is an American author, economist, political commentator, social theorist, and senior fellow at the Hoover Institution of Stanford University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Standardized test</span> Test administered and scored in a predetermined, standard manner

A standardized test is a test that is administered and scored in a consistent, or "standard", manner. Standardized tests are designed in such a way that the questions and interpretations are consistent and are administered and scored in a predetermined, standard manner.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charter schools in the United States</span> Primary or secondary education institutions

Charter schools in the United States are primary or secondary education institutions that are funded through taxation and operated by private organizations, rather than local school districts. They do not charge tuition, as they are funded with public tax dollars. Charter schools are subject to fewer rules than traditional state schools. Proponents argue that they are meant to serve underserved communities that wish to have alternatives to their neighborhood school. There are both non-profit and for-profit charter schools, and only non-profit charters can receive donations from private sources. However, there are several ways that non-profit charters can profit.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">No Child Left Behind Act</span> 2002 United States education reform law; repealed 2015

The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB) was a U.S. Act of Congress that reauthorized the Elementary and Secondary Education Act; it included Title I provisions applying to disadvantaged students. It supported standards-based education reform based on the premise that setting high standards and establishing measurable goals could improve individual outcomes in education. The Act required states to develop assessments in basic skills. To receive federal school funding, states had to give these assessments to all students at select grade levels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eric Hanushek</span> American economist

Eric Alan Hanushek is an economist who has written prolifically on public policy with a special emphasis on the economics of education. Since 2000, he has been a Paul and Jean Hanna Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution, an American public policy think tank located at Stanford University in California. He was awarded the Yidan Prize for Education Research in 2021.

<i>Waiting for "Superman"</i> 2010 American film

Waiting for "Superman" is a 2010 American documentary film written and directed by Davis Guggenheim and produced by Lesley Chilcott. The film criticizes the American public education system by following several students as they strive to be accepted into competitive charter schools such as KIPP LA Schools, Harlem Success Academy and Summit Preparatory Charter High School.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Class-size reduction</span>

As an educational reform goal, class size reduction (CSR) aims to increase the number of individualized student-teacher interactions intended to improve student learning. A reform long holding theoretical attraction to many constituencies, some have claimed CSR as the most studied educational reform of the last century. Until recently, interpretations of these studies have often been contentious. Some educational groups like the American Federation of Teachers and National Education Association are in favor of reducing class sizes. Others argue that class size reduction has little effect on student achievement. Many are concerned about the costs of reducing class sizes.

<i>Intellectuals and Society</i> Book by Thomas Sowell

Intellectuals and Society is a non-fiction book by Thomas Sowell. The book was initially published on January 5, 2010 by Basic Books.

The racial achievement gap in the United States refers to disparities in educational achievement between differing ethnic/racial groups. It manifests itself in a variety of ways: African-American and Hispanic students are more likely to receive lower grades, score lower on standardized tests, drop out of high school, and they are less likely to enter and complete college than whites, while whites score lower than Asian Americans.

Eva Sarah Moskowitz is an American politician and education reform leader, who is the founder and CEO of the Success Academy Charter Schools. A member of the Democratic Party, Moskowitz served on the New York City Council, representing the 4th district on the Upper East Side, from 1999 to 2005. Moskowitz interviewed to be Donald Trump's Secretary of Education, but decided not to pursue the position.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Success Academy Charter Schools</span> School

Success Academy Charter Schools, originally Harlem Success Academy, is a charter school operator in New York City. Eva Moskowitz, a former city council member for the Upper East Side, is its founder and CEO. It has 47 schools in the New York area and 17,000 students.

<i>Inside American Education</i> Book by economist and social theorist Thomas Sowell

Inside American Education: The Decline, The Deception, The Dogmas is a book by economist and social theorist Thomas Sowell that details Sowell's assessment of the state of education in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">School segregation in the United States</span> Racial separation in schools

School segregation in the United States is the separation of students based on their race to the extent that an institution can be racially predominant by black students or white students. Currently more than half of all students in the United States attend school districts with high racial concentrations and about 40% of black students attend schools where 90%-100% of students are non-white. Contemporary school racial segregation is most noticeable in California and New York.

Libertarian perspectives on affirmative action consistently coincide with the way that libertarians view the state as a coercive power. Many libertarians believe that the state should not be used as an instrument of power in enforcing what they call positive discrimination.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Educational inequality in the United States</span>

Unequal access to education in the United States results in unequal outcomes for students. Disparities in academic access among students in the United States are the result of several factors including: government policies, school choice, family wealth, parenting style, implicit bias towards the race or ethnicity of the student, and the resources available to the student and their school. Educational inequality contributes to a number of broader problems in the United States, including income inequality and increasing prison populations. Educational inequalities in the United States are wide-ranging, and many potential solutions have been proposed to mitigate their impacts on students.

Martin Carnoy is an American labour economist and Vida Jacks Professor of Education at the Stanford Graduate School of Education. He is an elected member of the National Academy of Education as well as of the International Academy of Education. Professor Carnoy has graduated nearly 100 PhD students, a record at Stanford University.

<i>Wealth, Poverty and Politics</i>

Wealth, Poverty and Politics: An International Perspective is a book by American economist and social theorist Thomas Sowell. It was originally published by Basic Books in 2015, with an updated version published in 2016. In the work, Sowell argues against the notion that economic equality is solely natural, and examines geographic, cultural, social, and political factors that have contributed to the wealth of groups and nations.

<i>Basic Economics</i> Literary work from 2000 by Thomas Sowell

Basic Economics is a non-fiction book by American economist Thomas Sowell published by Basic Books in 2000. The original subtitle was A Citizen's Guide to the Economy, but from the third edition in 2007 on it was subtitled A Common Sense Guide to the Economy.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Pondiscio, Robert (Fall 2020). "Education Next". Education Next. 20 (4).
  2. 1 2 3 4 Galles, Gary M (Fall 2020). "Charter Schools and Their Enemies Reviewed by Independent". The Independent Review . Retrieved 30 October 2020.
  3. Sowell, Charter Schools… pp. iii
  4. Sowell, Charter Schools… pp. 1
  5. Sowell, Charter Schools… pp. 120
  6. Carden, Art (3 July 2020). "Charters Close The Achievement Gap, Says Thomas Sowell". Forbes. Retrieved 3 October 2020.
  7. Sowell, Charter Schools… pp. 7
  8. Williams, Walter (6 July 2020). "Williams: Charter schools and their enemies" . Retrieved 2 September 2020.
  9. 1 2 D. Williamson, Kevin (9 July 2020). "The Collapsing Case against Charter Schools". National Review .{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  10. Carden, Art (Fall 2020). "Charter Schools and Their Enemies (review)". Cato Journal . Retrieved 2022-09-07.
  11. Sacks, Glenn (2 August 2020). "Thomas Sowell Goes to Bat for Charter Schools".

Thomas Sowell website: https://www.tsowell.com/