Committee on the Costs of Medical Care

Last updated

The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care (CCMC) was an investigative committee formed in 1927 to study the rising costs of physician and hospital care in the United States. Over its five-year span, the CCMC published dozens of reports studying the American health care system, including studies of Americans' medical costs. In 1932, the CCMC published its final report, Medical Care for the American People, which controversially recommended widespread adoption of health insurance.

Contents

Founding

Ray Lyman Wilbur served as Chairman of the CCMC during its five-year tenure. Ray Lyman Wilbur family photo.jpg
Ray Lyman Wilbur served as Chairman of the CCMC during its five-year tenure.

On April 1, 1925, fifteen delegates at the 1926 American Medical Association (AMA) convention formed a Conference on the Economic Factors Affecting the Organization of Medicine to study the medical economics of the United States. The group became known as the "Committee of Five" due to the dominance of Johns Hopkins Hospital Director Winford Henry Smith, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine Professor Lewellys F. Barker, Brookings Institution economist Walton Hale Hamilton, Yale School of Public Health Professor Charles-Edward Amory Winslow, and health policy analyst Michael M. Davis. After assigning Stanford University President Ray Lyman Wilbur (formerly President of the AMA) to preside over their meeting to prepare recommendations for the 1927 AMA convention, the group decided to form a five-year Committee on the Costs of Medical Care with Wilbur as its chairman. [1]

The CCMC was fully financed through $750,000 in contributions from eight charitable organizations, including the Milbank Memorial Fund, Rockefeller Foundation, Carnegie Foundation, New York Foundation, and Rosenwald Fund. [1]

Findings

Studying the health care expenses of 9,000 American families, the CCMC found that low-income households had similar expenditures, regardless of how many children they had, indicating that families budget a consistent share of their earnings toward medical costs. This finding suggested that for most families, suddenly requiring expensive specialized medical care would lead to financial disaster if they lacked health insurance. Observing that the prevalence of recorded illness increased alongside household income, the CCMC concluded that financial access to the American health care system was offering better diagnostic services to the upper-class. Furthermore, the average expense for hospitalized illnesses also increased alongside household income, reinforcing the idea that the American health care system offered additional treatment to the upper-class. [2]

By 1932, the CCMC had published dozens of reports, many authored in collaboration with other organizations like the AMA and American Dental Association (ADA). [3] Unable to agree on recommendations for its final report, the group summarized its findings in its November 1932 Medical Care for the American People report overseen by associate director of Study Isidore Falk, followed by a series of Minority Reports representing the views of its dissenters. The majority's report recommended that comprehensive medical care should be organized around high-quality hospitals, public health services should be extended to the entire population through dedicated financing and staffing, medical costs should be distributed across the population through insurance and/or taxation, state and local governments should evaluate and coordinate their medical services, and medical professionals should be highly trained. [1]

Under the majority's proposal, cities with at least 15,000 residents should have at least one non-profit community medical center, smaller towns with at least 2,500 residents should have a branch hospital affiliated with the nearest medical center, and rural areas should have a local medical station. Rare diseases would be addressed through traveling clinics. [4]

In comparison, the CCMC's Minority Reports argued that the government should only offer medical care to the impoverished and Armed Forces, though they agreed with the government's role in coordinating public health campaigns. The minority claimed that elevating general practitioners over other health care professionals and eliminating corporate ownership of medical facilities would lower costs. On the other hand, Hamilton and economist Edgar Sydenstricker felt that the majority should have adopted the Bismarck model of financing health care through compulsory insurance. [1]

Reception

The AMA and Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) editor Morris Fishbein endorsed the Minority Reports, framing the majority's proposals as radically imposing a socialist mandate to purchase health insurance, rather than retaining a capitalistic free market of voluntary insurance. [5] The New York Times front-page summary of the CCMC's final report was "Socialized Medicine is Urged in Survey", an interpretation reinforced by The Wall Street Journal , New York Herald Tribune , Boston Evening Transcript and The Washington Star . [1] [6] [7]

While lame duck US President Herbert Hoover praised the CCMC's work ahead of the final report's unveiling at the New York Academy of Medicine's National Conference on Medical Costs, incoming President Franklin D. Roosevelt felt that the political debate over the CCMC's findings would make it impossible to propose health care reforms during his first term. [1] [8] Nonetheless, the 1935 Social Security Act funded grants for states to undertake public health programs, partially embracing the CCMC's recommendations. [1]

New York State Commissioner of Health Thomas Parran represented then-New York Governor Roosevelt at the report's unveiling. [8] Winslow presented the majority's recommendations, physician Nathan B. Van Etten explained the minority's recommendations, Barker represented the viewpoint of physicians, and Cornell University President Livingston Farrand expressed the viewpoint of public health officials. [7]

Legacy

On the 25th and 40th anniversaries of the CCMC's final report, Falk published retrospective articles analyzing how the group's recommendations have continued to shape American health care policy. [9] [10] The 2010 Affordable Care Act ultimately embraced the CCMC's emphasis on widespread health insurance through the individual shared responsibility provision, fines fined individuals if they refused to purchase health insurance. [11]

Related Research Articles

Resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) is a schema used to determine how much money medical providers should be paid. It is partially used by Medicare in the United States and by nearly all health maintenance organizations (HMOs).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">American Medical Association</span> Organization

The American Medical Association (AMA) is an American professional association and lobbying group of physicians and medical students. Founded in 1847, it is headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. Membership was 271,660 in 2022.

<i>JAMA</i> Peer-reviewed medical journal published by the American Medical Association

JAMA (The Journal of the American Medical Association) is a peer-reviewed medical journal published 48 times a year by the American Medical Association. It publishes original research, reviews, and editorials covering all aspects of biomedicine. The journal was established in 1883 with Nathan Smith Davis as the founding editor. Kirsten Bibbins-Domingo of the University of California San Francisco became the journal editor-in-chief on July 1, 2022, succeeding Howard Bauchner of Boston University.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Preventive healthcare</span> Prevention of the occurrence of diseases

Preventive healthcare, or prophylaxis, is the application of healthcare measures to prevent diseases. Disease and disability are affected by environmental factors, genetic predisposition, disease agents, and lifestyle choices, and are dynamic processes that begin before individuals realize they are affected. Disease prevention relies on anticipatory actions that can be categorized as primal, primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention.

Against medical advice (AMA), sometimes known as discharge against medical advice (DAMA), is a term used in health care institutions when a patient leaves a hospital against the advice of their doctor. While leaving before a medically specified endpoint may not promote the patient's health above their other values, there is widespread ethical and legal consensus that competent patients are entitled to decline recommended treatment.

<i>Flexner Report</i> 1910 report on medical education

The Flexner Report is a book-length landmark report of medical education in the United States and Canada, written by Abraham Flexner and published in 1910 under the aegis of the Carnegie Foundation. Flexner not only described the state of medical education in North America, but he also gave detailed descriptions of the medical schools that were operating at the time. He provided both criticisms and recommendations for improvements of medical education in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diana Zuckerman</span> American health policy analyst

Diana M. Zuckerman is an American health policy analyst who focuses on the implications of policies for public health and patients' health. She specializes in national health policy, particularly in women's health and the safety and effectiveness of medical products. She is the President of the National Center for Health Research and the Cancer Prevention and Treatment Fund.

Healthcare reform in the United States has a long history. Reforms have often been proposed but have rarely been accomplished. In 2010, landmark reform was passed through two federal statutes: the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), signed March 23, 2010, and the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010, which amended the PPACA and became law on March 30, 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Health insurance coverage in the United States</span>

In the United States, health insurance coverage is provided by several public and private sources. During 2019, the U.S. population overall was approximately 330 million, with 59 million people 65 years of age and over covered by the federal Medicare program. The 273 million non-institutionalized persons under age 65 either obtained their coverage from employer-based or non-employer based sources, or were uninsured. During the year 2019, 89% of the non-institutionalized population had health insurance coverage. Separately, approximately 12 million military personnel received coverage through the Veteran's Administration and Military Health System.

<i>Users Guides to the Medical Literature</i> Book by Gordon Guyatt and Drummond Rennie

The Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature is a series of articles originally published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, later rewritten and compiled in a textbook, now in its third edition. The guides provide practical, clinician-friendly advice on all aspects of evidence-based medicine.

The history of health care reform in the United States has spanned many decades with health care reform having been the subject of political debate since the early part of the 20th century. Recent reforms remain an active political issue. Alternative reform proposals were offered by both of the major candidates in the 2008, 2016, and 2020 presidential elections.

The healthcare reform debate in the United States has been a political issue focusing upon increasing medical coverage, decreasing costs, insurance reform, and the philosophy of its provision, funding, and government involvement.

Clinical peer review, also known as medical peer review is the process by which health care professionals, including those in nursing and pharmacy, evaluate each other's clinical performance. A discipline-specific process may be referenced accordingly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Healthcare in the United States</span>

Healthcare in the United States is largely provided by private sector healthcare facilities, and paid for by a combination of public programs, private insurance, and out-of-pocket payments. The U.S. is the only developed country without a system of universal healthcare, and a significant proportion of its population lacks health insurance. The United States spends more on healthcare than any other country, both in absolute terms and as a percentage of GDP; however, this expenditure does not necessarily translate into better overall health outcomes compared to other developed nations. Coverage varies widely across the population, with certain groups, such as the elderly and low-income individuals, receiving more comprehensive care through government programs such as Medicaid and Medicare.

David M. Eddy is an American physician, mathematician, and healthcare analyst who has done seminal work in mathematical modeling of diseases, clinical practice guidelines, and evidence-based medicine. Four highlights of his career have been summarized by the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences: "more than 25 years ago, Eddy wrote the seminal paper on the role of guidelines in medical decision-making, the first Markov model applied to clinical problems, and the original criteria for coverage decisions; he was the first to use and publish the term 'evidence-based'."

Unnecessary health care is health care provided with a higher volume or cost than is appropriate. In the United States, where health care costs are the highest as a percentage of GDP, overuse was the predominant factor in its expense, accounting for about a third of its health care spending in 2012.

The Specialty Society Relative Value Scale Update Committee or Relative Value Update Committee is a volunteer group of 31 physicians who have made highly influential recommendations on how to value a physician's work when computing health care prices in the United States' public health insurance program Medicare.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Choosing Wisely</span> U.S.-based educational campaign

Choosing Wisely is a United States-based health educational campaign, led by the ABIM Foundation, about unnecessary health care.

Rashi Fein was an American health economist termed "a father of Medicare" in the United States and "an architect of Medicare", was Professor of Economics of Medicine, Emeritus, in the Department of Global Health and Social Medicine at Harvard Medical School, and the author of the book Medical Care, Medical Costs: The Search for a Health Insurance Policy.

Lonnie Robert Bristow is an American physician and former president of the American Medical Association (AMA). In his early career he established a private practice in San Pablo, California, as an internist with a special interest in occupational medicine, and wrote on sickle cell disease and misinformation on sickle cell trait. As the first African American president of the AMA in its 148 year history, he headed the introduction of questions on medical ethics into medical board exams and encouraged education about HIV/AIDS.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Ross, Joseph S. (2002). "The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care and the History of Health Insurance in the United States" (PDF). Einstein Journal of Biology and Medicine . 19: 129–134.
  2. Moser, Whet (28 July 2017). "When America First Realized It Had a Problem With Health-Care Costs". Chicago . Retrieved 2024-09-09.
  3. "The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care Reports". American Journal of Nursing . 32 (12): 1286–1291. December 1932. doi:10.2307/3412780. JSTOR   3412780 via JSTOR.
  4. "The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care Presents Its Final Report". Milbank Quarterly . 11 (1): 21–30. January 1933. doi:10.2307/3347521. JSTOR   3347521 via JSTOR.
  5. "The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care". JAMA . 99 (23): 1950. 1932-12-03. doi:10.1001/jama.1932.02740750052015. ISSN   0002-9955.
  6. "The Report of the Committee on the Costs of Medical Care". JAMA . 99 (24): 2034–2035. 1932-12-10. doi:10.1001/jama.1932.02740760044013. ISSN   0002-9955.
  7. 1 2 "Socialized Medicine is Urged in Survey". The New York Times . 30 November 1932. p. 1. Retrieved 9 September 2024.
  8. 1 2 "Hoover Praises Work of Medical Costs Group; Regrets His Inability to Attend Conference". The New York Times . 28 November 1932. p. 1. Retrieved 8 September 2024.
  9. Falk, Isidore S. (1 August 1958). "The Committee on the Costs of Medical Care—25 Years of Progress". American Journal of Public Health . 48 (8): 979–982. doi:10.2105/AJPH.48.8.979. ISSN   0002-9572. PMC   1551725 . PMID   13559526.
  10. Falk, Isidore S. (March 1973). "Medical Care in the USA: 1932-1972. Problems, Proposals and Programs from the Committee on the Costs of Medical Care to the Committee for National Health Insurance". Milbank Quarterly . 51.
  11. Gore, Thomas B. (April 2013). "A Forgotten Landmark Medical Study from 1932 by the Committee on the Cost of Medical Care". Baylor University Medical Center Proceedings. 26 (2): 142–143. doi:10.1080/08998280.2013.11928937. ISSN   0899-8280. PMC   3603728 . PMID   23543969.